Holly Hamilton

Twenty-something maths graduate. C-drama enthusiast. Fantasy nerd. Hopeless romantic (especially the tragic kind). ♥️♥️♥️ LPTF updated Wednesdays. B&B updated once LPTF complete.

Overall Rating
Plot
Writing Style
Grammar Punctuation

Good!

I wonder what happened to Ava! I imagine it'll probably come out in the next few chapters. The pacing was good, not too quick and not too slow. One thing I would look at is the telling at the beginning of chapter 1. You do tell us quite a lot of background information about Ava and some bits about her uncle. I think it would be better if you started straight into the immediate moment and let those bits come out through the dialogue. I would also have a closer look at punctuation with commas and fullstops in places. Sometimes they're missing or a comma is used instead of a fullstop. And finally, I would also check that you are using present at all times in the immediate moment (except for referring to events prior to the story), as there are a few thatslip into past.

But overall a very good start! Keep it up :)

Read the story now
Overall Rating
Plot
Writing Style
Grammar Punctuation

A Good Start!

I feel so sorry for the situation that Emma is - her stepfather is a horrible, horrible man and I hope she manages to find a way out.

Read the story now
Overall Rating
Plot
Writing Style
Grammar Punctuation

Strong Lead!

Really enjoying Ares's character so far and how determined she is to kill those who killed her father! She also stands up for herself no matter if it's the Colonel or other women looking down on her. I also really like the way that Skip contrasted her strong personality and the dynamic between them :)

Read the story now
Overall Rating
Plot
Writing Style
Grammar Punctuation

Solid Start!

The lore in this world is very interesting, in that the elemental magic is tied to specific "sources" located in Alterdam. I also liked the mention of war here and there, it shows that eventually these chapters will be leading up to something important. I also would like to know why Lea's eyes are golden even though she is a blue and can control water, and I expect that will be a major plot point.

For the most part, SPaG (spelling, grammar & punctuation) seems of good quality aside from the odd typo here and there (which happen to us all) and the odd tense switch. An example of this is: "she'll be left alone in this place" which should be "she would be left alone in this place" (will - present future, would - past future -- if that makes sense?) Another was "she had recently got those bangs after she got the envelope and elixir." I would instead recommend: "she had recently gotten these bangs after getting the envelope and elixir". Another thing with punctuation is to just watch with the fullstops at the end of dialogue. I think it was in chapter 2 where a list of names is read out. They should be punctuated like this: "Aliah Bell." There are other instances where some fullstops are missing, too.

The Hogwarts references made me chuckle. One thing I was wondering is if going to Alterdam us as simple as closing her eyes and picking it, how come she never tried to go there beforehand? Especially because she was dying to as a kid?

Overall this is a solid start to a story and I'm sure you have lots of things up your sleeve in regards to the war and her golden eyes :)

Read the story now

No reading lists yet

No badges received yet

About Us:

Inkitt is the world’s first reader-powered book publisher, offering an online community for talented authors and book lovers. Write captivating stories, read enchanting novels, and we’ll publish the books you love the most based on crowd wisdom.