Not Vanilla

All Rights Reserved ©

The Sleepover - Part 2

Panice was written all over my face when I heard Carla’s footsteps and Chase immediately picked up my clothes and handed it over to me.

“Quick. Hide under the sink,” He whispered and rushed outside the kitchen to see Carla and stall her as much as possible. I could hear some whispers by the time I got dressed and hid under the sink.

“She went home after I caught her with the booze. Why are you spoiling her, Carla? Do you have any idea how much trouble you could get into?” I heard Chase scolding her which was amusing to me because he definitely didn’t send me home. In fact, he sent me straight to heaven with that intense orgasm. I also realised that I was still here which means I still get to fuck him.

I had no idea what this means or this is a one time thing but I wanted to lose my virginity to him and I was sure that I would have absolutely no regrets about it. I was waiting patiently for him to put his hands and mouth all over my body before he could lose interest in me.

Fuck, I was sounding like a slut but I didn’t care. It was Chase and with the amount of crush I have for him, I would have done literally anything for him look at me. Now that I have him, I just wanted to show how much I like him.

“Are you coming outside or not?” I heard Chase’s voice from up and came back to the present. I took a peek at him below and found him, grinning back at me with an amusing look on his eyes. He looked unbelievably adorable and I still couldn’t believe that he wanted me.

Yup, definitely worth it.

“What about Carla?” I asked with a shy glance as I came outside and he pulled me closer to him without wasting another second.

“Upstairs. She thinks I sent you home. I hope... that’s fine with you.” He whispered, pausing a little as his fingers trailed down my neck. At this point, I was fine with anything that amazing mouth of his would say.

I simply nodded in agreement and a small smirk crept on his face. He took my hand and guided me towards his room and shut the door behind me as soon as I walked inside. I didn’t even have a moment to look at his room as he slammed his lips on mine with so much hunger and desire that made me feel instantly wet.

“Chase..” I moaned as he pushed his cock against my bottom and I had this weird ache in my pussy to have him inside me. He started to undress me again until I was standing in just my panties.

“Perfection.” He groaned, pushing me on to the bed and he stood in front of me, taking his own sweet time to look at me. I had never been more exposed in my life so I tried to cover my body, feeling shy but he held my hands, stopping me and looked straight into my eyes. I swear, everything around me disappeared at that moment and all I could see was him.

“Don’t hid yourself from me. I want to worship every inch of you, Emma.” He mumbled, looking at my body again hungrily and I must have resembled a tomato by now with the amount of times I was blushing because of him.

“I...umm..this is my first time.” I said it out loud finally, hoping that he would not freak out but to my surprise, he just smiled and kissed my lips softly.

“You really thought I did not know that? I know everything and I notice every single thing about you, Emma.” He added, taking me by shock completely.

What in the world?

“Oh...” I was unable to form a proper sentence as he was affecting me both physically and mentally.

“You were not the only one with a secret crush, Em.”

No way!

Nope, not gonna believe it.

He is probably trying to get in my pants by saying stuff like this so I decided to put him out of his misery.

“Chase, you don’t have to say these things. I want you as much as you want me so have to convince me or anything..” I trailed off, feeling embarrassed about the fact that I was literally asking him to fuck me even if he didn’t like me.

What is wrong with me?!

“What?” He lifted himself a bit and met my eyes with a confused look on his face.

“You know, the crush and everything. I mean, it’s okay. You don’t have to make up things,” I let out a nervous chuckle, still very much aware of the fact that we were both almost naked.

“Is it so hard for you to believe that I actually like you?” he asked, shaking his head and I was still not convinced.


“Well, sucks for you because I like you, Emma. Not the best timing and everything but I want you to know it.i want to show you how much I like you.” He replied, looking serious as fuck and I didn’t know what to respond. I was still very much confused by this whole thing so I decided to calm down my body first.

“Just fuck me before I go crazy, Chase.” I whined, making him laugh out loud and he kissed me hard, his hands travelling south towards my pussy.

“Such a demanding little thing. I love that are wet for me already,” he whispered against my lips as he dipped his fingers in my silky wetness and I shuddered in delight.

“Oh my God..” I cried out in pleasure as he twisted his fingers coiled inside me and I couldn’t hold it any longer. I wanted him so badly. He removed my panties and pulled out his cock as well. My eyes almost bulged out of it’s socket when I saw the size of his massive junk.

Sweet Lord! I was positive that it wasn’t going to fit in me.

“Are you sure about this?” he asked with so much restraint and I nodded my head, giving him my full consent. He pulled out a condom from his bedside drawer and wore it on his cock before placing the tip of it on my pussy.

“The pain will be over soon and please stop me if you feel uncomfortable, okay?” he asked with concern evident in his eyes and I smiled, pulling him closer to kiss him. My heart was swelling with happiness because I’ve always dreamt of this and now, it was actually happening. It was even better that my imagination.

He pushed himself slowly inside me and I could feel my pussy clench around his cock. The pain was there and I squeezed my eyes shut as he pushed himself with full force without any warning.

“Is it in?” I asked, breathing heavily and he chuckled, resting his forehead against mine.

“Yeah, all in but the best is yet to come,” He winked because once the pain disappeared, he slowly started to push in and out of me all the while his eyes not leaving mine.

“You feel so fucking good,” he groaned, gripping my waist tightly and I was started to feel the pleasure as he increased his pace and started to ride my pussy.

Holy Fuck!

“Jesus Christ! I don’t think I can hold it any longer.” He grunted and started to go faster. I was also on the edge and could feel the pressure build inside my body. I was so close. He squeezed my boobs with his free hand, pinching my nipples and I arched back in both pain and pleasure. I was getting addicted to his touch despite being obsessed with him already.

“Fucking hell...” He kissed my lips again and we both moaned against each other’s lips as we found out release. He fell back on the bed, trying to catch his breath while I was trying to process and relive the whole moment.

It was phenomenal and definitely way better than how I imagined my first time to be but what if this was also my last time with him?

“That was amazing, Chase.” I whispered, shyly and turned to my side to find him already staring at me intensely.

“The best sex of my life so far,” he grinned widely and I blushed again for the millionth time that day. I had no idea what to do next. Was I supposed to leave or stay the night or ask him what the hell he meant by having a crush on me as well?

I was so confused so I decided to do the sensible thing. I got up from the bed and picked up my clothes before disappearing inside his bathroom. Once I cleaned up myself, I looked at reflection in the mirror and took a deep breath to calm down my nerves.

I just fucked this guy. Why the hell am I still nervous to be around him?

I walked outside and found him still lying on the bed. He looked at me as soon as I came out of his bathroom and I was still unable to look straight into his eyes.

“Umm..I guess I’ll leave now. I’ll collect my things from Carla tomorrow.” I spoke, looking at my hands and was about to walk towards the door.

“Woah! Where the hell are you going?”

I froze in my spot and turned around to look at him. Did he want me to spend the night? I mean, I would love it but I was still nervous around this guy so I didn’t want to assume anything and make a fool out of myself.


“We still have to discuss the whole crush thing. Get that sexy ass of yours back in the bed. You are not going anywhere.” He smirked, balancing his weight on his elbows and I didn’t say anything even then.

“Please tell me you are joking. You can’t have a crush on me, Chase.” I laughed and turned around to walk away. I felt his presence behind me before I saw his hand on the door knob. He was standing so close, still very much naked and I was having a hard time to breath properly.


I breathed out as I turned around and I fixed my eyes on his face, making sure that I was not looking anywhere beyond it.

“How many times do I have to fuck you until you believe me?” he asked, making me gasp a little and he pulled me closer by my waist, making sure that I could feel his cock already hard for me.

Continue Reading Next Chapter

About Us

Inkitt is the world’s first reader-powered publisher, providing a platform to discover hidden talents and turn them into globally successful authors. Write captivating stories, read enchanting novels, and we’ll publish the books our readers love most on our sister app, GALATEA and other formats.