Not Vanilla

All Rights Reserved ©

Nerd Guy X Hot Girl

"Kathy, why are you so obsessed with that nerdy guy?" My friend, Betty gave me a look of annoyance and went back to fixing her eyelashes. We were hanging out at out regular bar and I was able to get every single guy's attention in the room except one.

Noah Carter!

He works at the bar, handling the accounts and also helps the DJ with technical difficulties sometimes. No matter how provocatively I dress, he wouldn't bat an eyelash in my direction. At first I thought he was playing hard to get but then I realised that he wasn't paying attention to any girl in the bar.

"How could he not drool over this?" I muttered, gesturing towards my body and gulped my drink, feeling a little tipsy immediately. I could see him chatting with the DJ at the corner of the bar.

He was not the regular type of guy I usually go for but there was something unique about him that made me want him more with every passing day. He was wearing a loose button down shirt which was tucked inside his dress pants and his thick mop of curly hair was all messed up over his head. I could see a hint of stubble on his jawline which made me drool more.

"How could you drool over that? He is tall and lanky and for heaven's sake, he is wearing glasses." She gasped in a dramatic tone, making me roll my eyes.

"I find it sexy." I winked while she shook her head in disapproval.

"You are weird. Anyway, I'm going to dance. Join me when you are done drooling over Mr.Nerdy over there." She added and stood up from her seat to leave. I watched her walk away and noticed that she found a guy to dance with immediately while I let out a soft sigh.

What could I do to get him to notice me?

I stood up from my seat and ruffled up my hair a bit. I pushed my boobs up and walked towards the DJ.

"Hey, Mike." I gave him a seductive smile and he immediately stopped talking with Noah and gave me his undivided attention.

"Well, hello there, sexy!"

I controlled myself from rolling my eyes and continued to flirt with him, hoping to get Noah's attention.

"How is it going, tonight? Big crowd, huh,"

"Yeah, it's packed for a Thursday night. You having a good time?"

"Ummm...yeah sure. Just having a couple of drinks with my friend," I quickly glanced at Noah to find his head stuck to his phone.

What the fuck?

I was getting really angry now.

I know he was single and he was straight. What could possibly be the reason that is stopping him from giving me a glance? It's not like I'm out of his league.

"I'll be in my office, man. Call me if you need anything." He patted Mike's shoulders and started to walk away.

That is it.

"You've got to be kidding me." I spat out angrily and followed him as he made his way towards his office which was located at the further end of the bar.

I entered his office and locked the door behind me, making him turn around with a confused look. He opened his mouth and his eyes went wide in shock and surprise.

"Ehhh....I'm sorry, miss but you are not allowed in here. If you are looking for the restroom, it's to the left." He gave me a polite smile and went to sit down behind his desk.


"It's Noah right? Noah Carter!" I started, walking towards his desk slowly and I could see beads of sweat appearing on his forehead. He was not even looking at me but I could sense that he was affected by my presence.

"Look at me, Noah." I placed my hand on his desk, startling him in the process and he finally looked at me through his glasses, his Adam's apple gobbling up and down his throat.

He was nervous.

I smirked, biting my lips and trailed my eyes all over his body.

"I don't think you understand, Ms, Donovan." He replied, trying so hard to stare at my boobs that were spilling out of my tight bodycon dress.

"You know my name which means you have noticed me. Intresting......let me ask you something, are you gay, Noah?"

He shook his head.

"Are you in a relationship?" I asked just to make sure I wasn't ruining anyone's life.

He shook his head again.

I was in the clear.

"Don't you want to fuck me then?"

He shook his head and just like that my confidence was broken into a million pieces.


I felt so embarrassed and wanted to get out of that place as soon as possible. I've never been this humiliated and I felt so bad that I was about to almost force myself on a guy.

"I--I'm so sorry. I should go," I mumbled and was about to walk away but the next thing that came out of his mouth blew me away.

"I can't fuck you because I'm in love with you."


"Say what?"

"I--I've never been with any woman, Ms. Donovan and I know the probability of us being a couple is unlikely. I also know why you want to sleep with me," he paused and I remained frozen in my spot unable to believe what he was saying.

"I want to make love to you only if you like me and not because I seem like a another challenge to you," He gave me a sad smile, adjusting his specs and continued.

"And I know for sure that I'm not going to rock your world or anything. I mean, look at me so why waste your ti--" I stopped him from speaking anymore by placing a finger on his lips. He stopped breathing for a second and looked straight into my eyes, making me swallow hard in excitement and anticipation.

" talk too much." I whispered, backing him up against his seat and made him sit down.

"I admit that at first I was intrigued because you didn't even give me a second glance but as days went by, I realised that I was really attracted to you and I want you, Noah."

"Why me?" He let out a small chuckle and it was a valid question.

"I guess it's because you never looked at me like there was nothing more to me than just my body." I whispered, scrunching my dress upwards and sat on top of his lap, placing both my legs beside his thighs.

He started to breath heavily and gripped the arm rest tightly. I smiled at his innocence and slowly removed his glasses. He looked so damn cute and that's when I realised how green his eyes were. They were so beautiful and I felt myself getting lost in those gorgeous orbs.

Holy Fuck!

I really liked this guy.

"Do you want me to continue?" I asked, looking down at his lips and he nodded.

"Only if you are attracted to me as you say," he whispered and I smirked, grabbing his place and kissed him. He placed his hands on my hips and kissed me back slowly as if he was afraid to hurt me. I smiled against his lips and started to grind my ass against his now erect cock.

"Woah!" He gasped, pulling back a little and I started to unbutton his shirt.

"You have no idea how long I wanted to do this," I moaned in pleasure and he just smiled at me.

"Me too. Literally."

I laughed at his response and continued to trailed my hands down his chest.

"God, you are so beautiful."

"Unzip me," I commanded him and he did as I said, his eyes capturing every inch of my body with hunger and desire. I pushed my dress down till my waist and guided his hands towards my breasts.

"Shit!" He groaned in pleasure as he squeezed my boobs and I threw my head back, feeling my pussy getting wetter. I removed my bra and lifted myself to remove my panties as well.

"Do you want to know how wet I am, Noah?" I asked, kissing his neck while his hands automatically gripped my thighs. I felt like my entire body was on fire and wanted nothing but him inside me right now. He started to press my boobs with one hand, planting wet kisses all over it.

"Tonight is about you." I stopped him and started to unbuckle his pants.

"I apologise in advance if I'm no good, Kathy." He added and I smiled at his mention of my name.

"You are adorable," I shook my head and pulled out his cock which was surprisingly huge and thick.

"Wow, you have been hiding this from the world all this time." I stated in a seductive tone and rubbed the length of his cock with my palm. He hissed in pleasure and bit his lips to hold back his moans.

"You like that, Noah?" I asked in a sweet voice, batting my eyelashes and he ran his fingers through his curly hair, letting out a low growl.

"I bet you like this," I winked and bent down to take him in his mouth. He held my shoulders and automatically guided me further down as I took his full length in my mouth. I still couldn't believe he was a virgin and felt glad that I was the one who was spoiling him. For some reason, it felt special and I wanted him all to myself.

"Kathy!" He grunted and pushed me back a little.

"I can't hold longer," he stated and I wiped my lips with my fingers.

"Are you ready?" I asked and he gulped, hesitating for a moment.

"Umm... I...I don't have a condom." He scratched the back of his head, looking cute as fuck and I lifted myself and guided his cock inside my wet aching core.

"Doesn't matter. I'm on the pill." I replied and sunk into his cock, squeezing my eyes shut.

"Jesus Christ!" He held my hips tightly as my pussy clenched against his cock. Fuck, he felt so amazing and I burried my face in the crook of his neck as I started to ride him. He smelled like mint and whisky.

Addictive as hell.

"This feels amazing, Noah." I spoke against his skin as he hugged me tightly, kissing the nape of my neck. I smiled at that simple action and pulled back to look at him. He looked at me like nothing else mattered and I pulled him closer to my chest.

He was indeed in love with me.

And this felt so intimate and amazing.

"Fuck, I'm going to come, Noah!" I screamed in pleasure as I continued to pump his cock and he took my nipples between his teeth, rolling his tongue all over my erect buds.

And he says this is his first time, damn!

I found my release within seconds as he released his seeds inside me. We both held each other for a while catching our breath and I finally looked into his eyes.

"Wish I had done this sooner," he smiled, showing his dimples and I grinned widely, feeling satisfied both physically and mentally.

"I'm glad I was your first," I whispered, running my fingers against his jaw which had a hint of stubble and I could see his face turning a deep shade of red.

"Well, if a hot girl like you had noticed me earlier and found me attractive then you wouldn't have been my first," he teased me and I rolled my eyes at his goofiness.

"Did you like it?" I asked feeling shy all of a sudden and he raised his eyebrows.

"Do you even have to ask? Seriously, the best sex of my life so far." I laughed so hard and he just kept staring at me with a small smile playing at the corner of his lips.

"Thank you so much." He let out a soft sigh and I kissed him again before standing up. Once I was all dressed up, I turned around to face him. He was buttoning up his shirt and wasn't looking at me.

"So, it's okay if I call you tomorrow, right?" I asked as I took his card from the table and leaned against his desk. He gave me a confused look.

"You didn't think this was a one time thing, did you?"

"I don't get you."

"I thought you were in love with me," I let out a small gasp and his eyes went wide in shock and realisation.

"Of course I am but...wait, you mean--"

"Hope you are free after 6 tomorrow. I want to take you out on a date." I smirked and made my way towards the door, leaving him speechless.

Continue Reading Next Chapter

About Us

Inkitt is the world’s first reader-powered publisher, providing a platform to discover hidden talents and turn them into globally successful authors. Write captivating stories, read enchanting novels, and we’ll publish the books our readers love most on our sister app, GALATEA and other formats.