Write a Review

My Boyfriend's Older Brother

All Rights Reserved ©


Serena has always considered herself a "good girl". Getting good grades, never getting on trouble, dating a good boy. She's been dating Corbin for 3 years now, someone who she adores and she believes she'll be with him forever. But when Corbin's older brother comes back from college, Serena is now dealing with someone who definitely likes to break all bounds. Matthew is Corbin's older brother and rival. Always competing with one another, Matthew comes back for 24 days until he has to go back to college. During these 24 days, Matthew has made himself a promise, along with Serena a promise that will alter her life forever.

Romance / Erotica
Victoria Anderson
3.9 5 reviews
Age Rating:

Chapter 1: The Grilled Cheese Sandwich


24 Days Left

“So, what movie do you want to watch?” Corbin asked me.

I heard his question, but I honestly had my mind set on someone else.

Outside, I saw Matthew playing football with his buddies on the front lawn.

Just 2 days ago Matthew had come back from college for a few weeks. I haven’t seen him since he left 6 months ago.

I was ecstatic, to say the least when he left, I couldn’t stand the uptight and entitled asshole. It never made any sense to me how Matthew and Corbin were related. I mean Corbin was so easygoing, so sweet, considerate, and loving to me. While Matthew was a playboy and rude as hell.

I remember the day he left for college, I almost did a backflip due to how happy I was. I had to hide the grin on my face as his mother was bursting into tears as the eldest son left the nest. Corbin felt the same as I did. He despised his older brother, Corbin always felt compared to his brother in a much less way. As if Corbin could never live up to the so-called greatness Matthew left behind.

Ever since Matthew left, poor Corbin has been trying desperately to win his parent’s love and attention, something that I feel awful about. He clearly just wants to show his parents that he is enough and that he does not have to be Matthew.

“Serena?” I heard Corbin ask. This is now the second time he’s addressed me. I turned my head toward him, not looking at the window much longer. “Sorry Corbin, I want to watch a scary movie,” I replied.

I gave him a small smile letting him know that my attention was on him. I wasn’t sure if he knew what I was staring at. But now, my attention was back on my loving boyfriend.

Corbin picked out some B-Movie eventually, and let it play. I didn’t have my mind on the movie much, it tended to stray outside. From the looks of it, you might think I’m admiring or gawking at Matthew Setters, but the truth is, I’m thinking of everything bad that can happen to Corbin and me throughout the next 3-4 weeks while Matthew is here.

Halfway through the movie, Corbin fell asleep, leaving me to my own thoughts. I got bored of the cringey horror movie and eventually figured I’d make myself some food as dinner time was creeping up. I didn’t plan on going home tonight as my mom and dad were at a neighbor’s house for a dinner party.

I left the couch we sat on, went into the kitchen, and started to dig around in the pantries looking for any sort of food that might sound good in this house.

Eventually, my eyes landed on some bread, meaning one thing only. A beautiful grilled cheese sandwich. I grabbed all of my items and began my process. Not just a minute later I heard someone walk into the kitchen. Due to me forgetting who else was here, I ignored the footsteps, only letting myself think that they belonged to Corbin. So I did not turn around.

I soon felt two arms slip around my waist and someone pull me close. At this point in time I did not doubt this to be Corbin. “Do you want one?” I asked him, referring to the sandwich that was now almost ⅓ done on the skillet.

He waited a few seconds before responding, during this time he ran his hands up and down my stomach and chest.

“I’d much rather eat something else,” the man said.

I stopped moving, now realizing that the person wrapped around me, and feeling me up was absolutely not my boyfriend Corbin.

I quickly turned around and only a very few inches from my face was Matthew with a grin on his face.

“I mean if you’re offering something to eat bugs I’ll definitely take you up on it.” he added with a wink.

I pushed him away from me and rolled my eyes, “Do not fucking touch me you creep. What is wrong with you?” I asked him.

He chuckled, “Many things bug, but listen, I’m only going to be back for another 24 days! So I think we should get this show on the road don’t you think?”

What the fuck is he talking about?

“First off asshole, stop calling me ‘bug’. Second off, what show? I have no clue what you are talking about,”

My tone was angry and irritated. I have no interest in whatever game he had going on in his life.

“Oh, don’t worry, I’ll keep calling you that. It’s my nickname for you. And come on, you know, sex? Hookup? Lay? Fuck? Like a serious bug, you can’t tell me you’ve never wanted to hook up with me? Hmmm? I’ve been watching you for years, bug, I’ve always had my eyes on you. You really have no clue how much I missed you while I was gone. You were the thing I wanted to see most when I got back. I did hope my dipshit of a brother and you broke up, I mean since he wouldn’t be as upset if I fucked you, but it is what it is.”

What in the fuck?

Sleep with him? Fuck no!

“You must be joking, right? Like I would ever sleep with someone as horrible as you are,” I told him.

I played my sandwich and started to try and walk out of the kitchen, but clearly, Matthew had other plans. He grabbed my plate of food and sat it back on the counter near the stove. Forcing me to walk back over to go and get it. During this time, it allowed him to block me into the corner cabinet. I glared at him the second he did this action.

His words and actions towards me were truly pissing me off beyond all belief.

I truly could not understand what he wanted. Why was he acting like this? There was no reason for it. He has never acted like this before toward me. Not that he and I really ever spoke a whole bunch previous to these encounters.

It was always a big deal between Matthew and Corbin. They hated each other. They never got along. But, I never really had much conversation with Matthew. Which was why it was so confusing to me why all of this was happening. He needed to get away from me.

“Matthew, I do not know what you want. But I need you to leave me alone. I don’t know what the fuck is going on with you, but you’re acting so strange. So again, get away from me. Figure something else out rather than sitting here and annoying me. Your brother is in the next room. Why do you want anything to do with me?” I asked him.

He stood there for a few seconds, maybe thinking about what to say. The perfect thing to say?

“ Listen, you’re fucking stunning. and I’ve missed you very much. I haven’t seen you in quite a while. I’ve always hated not seeing you. I’ve admired you for years. You’re something that I’ve never really encountered. Most girls just throw themselves at me. The thing is, you’re completely different. Why, though? You’re sitting there with my brother, something I will also never understand. How could you go for somebody like him? He’s completely out of your league. you’re gorgeous, and he’s basic.” Matthew replied.

“ I don’t even know what you’re even talking about. You’re just fucking jealous. Maybe you’re sick and tired of all the whores that you deal with. How about you go find someone and leave me alone? Because I’m not going to sit here and have this conversation with you. I love your brother, and I am sure as hell not going to sleep with you. So back off!”

I tried to push him out of my way, to make it past him. But he didn’t let me. I was still cornered in the inside of the cabinets. He wasn’t hurting me, nor was he making me insanely uncomfortable. If he did, then I knew he would have walked away. He was playing games with me. And I knew that.

I continued to stare at him. I needed to get back into the living room. Where Corbin was. Just me and him. Not this fucking sociopath. “Matthew, seriously. Move out of the way.”

He chuckled, “ I’ll move if you kiss me.”

“No, fuck off,” I snapped at him. I pushed him once more, but he didn’t budge. He didn’t move one inch. Not even half.

“ You’re not going to move me. Come on, you and I both know there’s always been tension between me and you. You cannot deny that. You can sit there and say you’re this good girl all you want. But I know you’re not. You settled. You shouldn’t have decided to be with my brother. He’s boring as fuck, and honestly, you need someone like me.”

“No I don’t. I’m telling you I don’t. I don’t want to be with somebody who sits there and fucks a thousand girls. Not that you’re even my type anyways.”

“ I haven’t fucked a thousand girls. There’s a lot that you don’t know about me. You should get to know me. I think you would like what you would find. In more ways than one.” he said with a smirk.

Fucking gross moron.

“Listen, I’m telling you right now I’m not kissing you. Back off. I have no interest in you. I’m dating your brother, what is wrong with you? Why are you sitting here doing this? Is something legitimately wrong with you?” I asked him.

It’s no longer pure irritation inside of my body, I think it was getting to the point that I was just finding all of this extremely amusing. But truthfully, why was he acting like this? There was no point to it. Never in the few years that I have been dating Corbin has he ever done anything like this? He never really even spoke to me before. Don’t get me wrong, we have had a few conversations. None of them were amazingly awesome, or deep or anything like that. But it came down to the point right now that he was acting super weird.

Something that was not normal. Can I have no clue? The main thing that was going inside of my mind was wondering if he was just messing around. If he had a darker motive for this. Maybe he was trying to see if I would actually cheat on Corbin.

“Matthew, move!”

But he didn’t budge. Instead, he started to lean closer into me.

“ I’m not going to force you into anything. I’m not that type of person. But, we’re not done with this. I know what’s inside of you. As I said earlier. You are not who you think you are. You have a much darker entity inside of you and I know that! I don’t really understand why you’re dating my brother, it truly makes no sense to me. But I’m going to bring out the true you. Because whether you want to admit it or not, you’ve always been interested in me. And I’ve seen it, and I’m here to reciprocate it.” he said to me. He started to back away and begin his way out of the kitchen.

But I wasn’t going to let him off that easily. There was no reason for him to act like this. Because the thing was, he was completely wrong. He knew nothing about me, he knew nothing about how I acted or what I believed.

I was not the bad girl that he was thinking that I was. I had no interest in sleeping with him. Kissing him, anything. “Matthew, don’t you leave! you don’t get to just do all that shit, and then walk away without any reasoning. what the fuck is wrong with you? You sit there and leave for months and, to go out to college, and before that, you don’t even ever talk to me. All you do is bring your whores around and act like you’re this big bad wolf, but clearly, you’re not. So I want to know, what is going on with you? So now all of a sudden you show a little bit of interest in me?”

He looked at me with a small smile on his face, “Listen, I’ve always shown interest in you. It’s not my fault you’ve never noticed. I’ve been watching you for years since I’ve said before, now I’m finally just taking my shot. That’s all.”

I expected him to leave the kitchen. Leave this conversation, but instead, he proved me wrong. He started walking closer to me again. Once again, he backed me into the corner. I stared up at him, wondering what he was going to do next. The small smile still stayed on his face. not moving.

“Come on, Serena, bug, I know you’re into me. I’m not going to sit there and go after somebody that I know is not. You can sit there and act like a good girl, act like you give a shit about Corbin, act like you give a shit about your relationship. But the truth is, I know that’s not you. You sit there and hide your true self behind the wall that you’ve built. Because listen, I used to do the same thing. I would sit there and think that all these girls were going to solve my problems. But they weren’t. They never did. All of them were fake, all of them were stupid as fuck, but you’re not that, you’re something else. That’s why I’m interested in you. and if it makes you feel better, I’m honestly not just after the sex with you. Don’t get me wrong, I’m very interested in that. But that’s not the only thing.”

The more he talked, the more he confused me. “ Then what do you want? What is your main motive?”

“My main motive? It’s to show you who you truly are. Because you don’t belong with my brother. He’s a boring, basic, vanilla type of guy. He’s going to get married to a girl, who’s exactly like him. Because the thing is if you honestly sit there and marry him, your relationship is going to go down the drain very quickly. You are going to have kids with him, something that both of you want. But he’s going to pressure you into everything. And you’re going to sit there and agree, eventually to the point that you have an affair. Destroying your entire family. I know that’s far out there, but I’m pretty sure it’s the truth. Because you are not meant to be tied down. Especially not anywhere near close in age. So I think you should have some fun. With me..”

Now, for the actual time, he walked out of the kitchen. Leaving me alone. Still, I couldn’t understand what the hell just happened.

Continue Reading Next Chapter
Further Recommendations

Natasha: I love the stories, very exhilarating. Made me wish that some of these stories was me

Anna: This book was amazing. The mother is a nut

Angwaro Jok: I loved that it talked about one couple

Bam.jk8338: Estuvo bien redactado y bien explicito, eso me gustó

gruenwedelchristin: This is one good story . One of the best that I have read in a long time … the cast of characters are love able, fun, and well rounded … the story lines moves along well and it captivates the audience .

Alina: J adore a quand la suite

annalaville: This is a great novel, such wonderful romance it is worth reading, just want to read more and more this is great.

Tamara: Mir gefällt die Geschichte

annemirl56: Toller Schreibstil wie immer und sehr erotisch 😘😘muss auch dabei sein, sonst istces langweilig 😘

More Recommendations

Shakeicha Young: Omg what a story!!

Amy Grindle: This book is hot from the beginning. Teacher with student is an amazing story line that never gets old.

Leticia: Esto es épico, la historia detrás, Y todo! Enserio Amo este trabajo, la creadora enserio es súper talentosaaa!!<3

Sheila: A good book I will read it further as it is finished

LaQuiche: Amazing for this slow build up to be so satisfying! Definitely a guilty pleasure!

About Us

Inkitt is the world’s first reader-powered publisher, providing a platform to discover hidden talents and turn them into globally successful authors. Write captivating stories, read enchanting novels, and we’ll publish the books our readers love most on our sister app, GALATEA and other formats.