Zara tensed at the slight invasion, her body going rigid.
Above her, Nathaniel swore loudly, his eyes dark with passion. When she looked at him, Zara saw the concentration on his face, the effort it took him to go slow with her.
“Fuck, Zara. You’re so damn tight.”
A fresh wave pulsed through her core and she felt her body’s juices on her inner thigh. Part of her was embarrassed and still a bit unsure of how exactly she should proceed. How she could make this good for him too.
But Nathaniel took that thought away from her.
He pulled out completely and sat back on his heels. Zara panicked, sitting up and already beginning to bring her legs together.
“I’m-I’m sorry. I don’t know why-”
Nathaniel groaned and shut her up with a kiss, his hands going to her knees and pushing them apart.
Falling back on the bed, Zara hugged him to her, tracing the muscles in his back with her fingers. His skin was warm and inviting and she wanted to taste him with her tongue.
She moaned when he slipped a hand between her legs and covered her slit with a finger. Zara tensed up again, but he didn’t stop or go slow.
Tracing the seam of her mouth with the tip of his tongue, Nathaniel kissed her almost languidly, the brush of his erection against her thigh the only opposition to that notion.
When she needed a breath, Zara turned her head away, but that didn’t stop him. Leaning down, he kissed her neck, beginning with small, soft kisses. All the while, he gently probed her entrance, slipping his finger in for a moment before pulling it out, going slightly deeper each time.
“You have nothing to be sorry about, Zara.“, he murmured against her skin, his voice thick, sucking on the spot where her neck met her shoulder.
She tilted her head further, giving him better access. His breath made goosebumps rise on her skin. The feel of him against her was enough to make her even wetter and she heard the groan Nathaniel suppressed against her chest when his finger slid in all the way.
Zara felt the sharp pain when he tried to move in further and a small gasp escaped her mouth.
Nathaniel’s head jerked up and there was worry etched on his features.
“Damn it, I don’t want to hurt you.“, he cursed even as he slowly slid his finger out of her.
He leaned down and kissed her forehead. There was just a second of respite and then his thumb was on her clit and Zara’s back arched off the bed.
“I want you to come for me.“, Nathaniel growled in her ear, his thumb tracing slow, lazy circles on and around her clit. Zara held on tight to him, her moans growing louder when he slid his finger back into her entrance.
Underneath her fingers, she felt Nathaniel’s body go impossibly hard and tensed. But he didn’t relent.
Leaning in and forcing her to look at him, he kissed her mouth once and then twice, his tongue flicking against hers hard and fast.
She turned away and buried her face in his neck, scraping her teeth against his skin, spreading her legs even wider, feeling the sweet pressure building up in her lower abdomen.
Nathaniel swore when she licked his neck, her moans turning to whimpers when his thumb sped up slightly and he slipped another finger into her. Zara grabbed the headboard with one hand, her fingers searching for purchase.
The tension was building in her core and her body ached for release. Beside her, Nathaniel groaned and caught her hand that was now fisting the sheets and placed it at the back of his neck.
“Show me what I make you feel, Zara.“, he growled. “Don’t hold back. I want you to let go, baby.”
Then his mouth was on her breast, his teeth nipping at the flesh surrounding her nipple. The pressure became unbearable.
Nathaniel’s fingers worked her walls, pushing in deep and staying still for a long torturous moment, before pulling out and repeating the motion again and again. Her core clenched down on his digits, every pulse releasing fresh wetness till she felt drenched.
“I can’t hold back any longer, Zara.“, he groaned, biting down on her nipple.
It was the desperation in his voice that sent her over the edge.
Her body clamped down on his fingers and she screamed out his name.
Then suddenly his fingers were gone, and Zara had only a moment’s warning before Nathaniel plunged into her entrance, now slick with her own juices. There was a sharp pain when he tore through her resistance, but it paled just a bit with the onslaught of the pleasure that coursed through her limbs in waves. She felt his lips cover hers in a demanding kiss and then he was moving, his cock stretching her till she felt so full she had to bite back a shout of joy.
He groaned each time he had to pull out of her, only to push in harder, till he was completely sheathed. Zara brought her knees toward her chest and then hooked them around his waist, her heels digging into the muscles of his ass.
His palms were on either side of her head and his biceps bulged as he kept up the rhythm, his eyes focused on her face. Zara smiled in ecstasy when he tilted his hips just slightly and increased the pace of his strokes.
Their bodies were covered with a slight sheen of sweat. After three more strokes, Nathaniel tensed and then pushed into her hard, just once.
Then his body shuddered as he came, his head dropping to her neck, his breathing harsh and ragged. He crushed her in his arms, hugging her so tight she couldn’t breathe.
“I love you.“, he murmured into her skin, kissing her softly before nuzzling her there.
Zara couldn’t wipe the grin from her face.
When he pushed himself onto his elbows and looked down at her, she was still smiling. He chuckled when he saw that.
“Did I hurt you too bad?“, he pushed the hair from her forehead gently, sweeping it behind her ear.
She shook her head, the smile turning even wider.
Nathaniel laughed, “I love you so much.“, he repeated, kissing her nose and then her mouth, before suddenly moving lower and kissing the tip of one nipple.
Zara gasped and grabbed his head, her grip on his hips turning tight.
“Mmm... I think I’m already ready for round two.“, he husked out, his grin turning predatory.
Zara giggled when his hands crept up her sides, his thumbs grazing the undersides of her breasts.
“Nathaniel, don’t!“, she laughed, when he bent lower and kissed her belly button, slipping his tongue inside it and then slowly tracing a circle around it.
When his lips reached her hipbone, Zara hurriedly sat up, pulling his head up to her and taking his lips.
Her heart soared when Nathaniel moaned into her mouth, his fingers gripping her waist. She sucked his lower lip lightly and traced her tongue across it, reaching forward and pressing her breasts to his chest. The feel of the dusting of hair on his pectorals made her nipples tighten again. But the soreness between her legs stopped her from taking it further.
When she pulled away and opened her eyes, Nathaniel had his closed. He moved toward her and kissed her cheek, then the side of her face and her forehead.
His breathing had turned heavy once more, but he didn’t take it further, choosing to let his hands roam idly over her body.
“Hold still.“, he whispered in her ear, as he slowly pulled out of her.
Zara looked down and saw the stain of red on the condom and flushed with self-consciousness. She began to move back but Nathaniel stopped her. Hooking a finger underneath her chin, he raised it, making her look at him.
“What?“, he said.
She shook her head. “It’s nothing.”
He didn’t seem to believe her.
“Don’t move.“, he said thickly, as he slipped off the bed, taking the condom off as he went into the bathroom. Zara heard the water running and a few seconds later, he came out with a washcloth.
He gave her a serious look before he sat down next to her, spread out her legs and reached out with the washcloth toward the junction of her thighs.
“I can do it, Nathaniel-“, she tried to pry the cloth out of his hands.
He caught both her hands and brought them to his lips. “I’ll tie you up if I have to, sweetheart.“, he said without smiling.
Zara bit her tongue and shut up, letting him reach between them and wipe off the slight blood and the wetness on her skin.
He was careful and gentle, taking care not to hurt her or cause her any discomfort.
When he was done, he disappeared into the bathroom for a few moments. Zara took the time to gather the sheets around her, her body feeling sore, but deliciously so.
Nathaniel came back to her, slipping in between the covers and pulling her against his body, her back to his front. Then he gently laid them both down and kissed her neck.
“I’m going to text Matt to come in later.“, he said between kisses.
Zara leaned back further into him, stretching her arm over her neck to sink her fingers into his hair.
When she tugged at it lightly, he sighed and laughed.
“What?“, she asked, turning to face him.
He slid his hand over her stomach and then let it travel upward. He cupped the weight of her breast in his palm and Zara sighed out loud in satisfaction. “I’m tempted to get you on all fours right now and fuck you from behind.“, he growled in her ear, his fingers tweaking her nipple.
Zara leaned into him and bit her lip when she felt his cock grow hard near her butt.
“Then why don’t you do it?“, she whispered, the soreness already forgotten.
Nathaniel groaned and pulled her even closer, tucking her in the crook of his shoulder.
“You’re sore, Zara. Not today.“, he nipped her earlobe.
Tucking the sheets around them, he kissed the top of her head and squeezed her gently.
“Sweet dreams.“, he whispered.
Zara laid her hand on his forearm and closed her eyes. When sleep came, she dreamed of him.
A/N:- Vote and Comment, guys! ❤️