We Shouldn't Be This

All Rights Reserved ©

Summary

Nova Sinclair arrives at Blackthorne Academy with two secrets: She doesn’t know who her father is. And her mother’s death was never an accident. Hidden behind polished manners and inherited wealth, Nova is haunted by fragmented memories of whispered phone calls, locked doors, and a journal filled with clues that never made sense until Blackthorne. The deeper she digs into the academy’s history, the more those clues begin to align with something far darker than she ever imagined. Cassian Vale is the last person she should cross paths with. Cold. Arrogant. Untouchable. And the son of the most powerful man tied to Blackthorne’s past. From their first collision, they become enemies drawn into a quiet war of sharp words and buried tension. But when Cassian catches Nova uncovering truths that could destroy his family, he isn’t sure if he should stop her… or protect her. Because the truth they’re circling binds their families in secrets, betrayal, and a love that never should have existed. And the closer Nova gets to uncovering who her mother really was… The more dangerous it becomes to fall for the boy she was always meant to hate.

Status
Complete
Chapters
32
Rating
5.0 14 reviews
Age Rating
18+

Prologue

Genevieve & Alaric

Genevieve always knew love was dangerous.

She just never imagined it would cost her everything.

The university at night was quieter than it should have been. Stone arches swallowed sound.

Lanterns burned low along the paths. The world felt paused like it was holding its breath for them.

Genevieve stood beneath the shadow of the old clock tower, fingers curled tight around the strap of her bag.

Her heart beat too loudly in her chest. She had told herself she wouldn’t come again.

Yet here she was.

“Waiting for me?”

His voice melted through the dark like warm smoke.

Alaric Vale stepped into the light with the kind of ease that came from knowing the world had always made room for him. His coat was perfectly pressed.

His smile was calm. Dangerous. The heir of a powerful name, walking through the night like consequence had never learned his address.

She should have walked away.

“You shouldn’t be here,” Genevieve said instead. “Someone could see you.”

His gaze moved over her like he already owned every secret she carried.

“They always see what I allow them to see.”

That was the problem.

She had been brilliant. At the top of her class. Careful. Untouchable.

Until him.

They met in a lecture hall full of ambition and silent rivalry. He had asked one question... soft, calculated and she had answered.

From that moment, the lines of her life had begun to blur.

Late-night debates turned into private meetings. Private meetings into stolen kisses. Stolen kisses into dreams she never should have allowed herself to have.

“You promised,” she whispered. “You said this would end.”

Alaric stepped closer. Close enough that the cold night no longer reached her skin.

“I said it would change.”

His words were smooth. Too smooth. And yet her heart leaned toward them like they were truth.

“What about my future?” she asked. “What about everything I’m risking for you?”

For a moment... just a moment his expression shifted. Something like hesitation flickered behind his control.

Then it vanished.

“Trust me, Genevieve.”

She hated how much she wanted to.

By the time the scandal erupted, it happened fast. Too fast. Faces that once smiled turned away.

Whispers followed her through hallways like ghosts. Doors closed. Professors looked through her as if she had already been erased.

And Alaric?

He never stood beside her when the storm came.

Her expulsion was written in neat, official language. Dispassionate. Final.

She packed her life into one suitcase.

As she walked away from the university gates, heart broken and name stained, Genevieve finally understood the truth:

Some men don’t just break hearts.

They rewrite destinies.

And years later long after the truth was buried beneath wealth, silence, and legacy...

That love would rise again in blood.

Next Chapter