Extra Dark
Share with your friends
Customize readability

Extra Dark

All Rights Reserved Β©

Summary

Sam is a work-obsessed control freak. But when her friends force her to download the newest dating app -- and actually *go* on a date -- she's stunned by her own primal feelings. He's smart and rugged. Assured and experienced. But despite his perfect image, he's got his own darkness lingering under the surface. And Sam will have to decide whether the heat, the pleasure, and the love story are worth his dangerous past.

Status
Complete
Chapters
41
Rating
4.9 (18 reviews)
Age Rating
18+

Chapter 1

Ggghhh. Gghhhuuhhhhh. Ggghuuuhhuuh.

Shit. I stare at the coffee machine – the $400 β€œinvestment” I’d bought with the intention of using for the next decade – as it gurgles itself to death. The sound is ugly. Loud. But as I try to get it to quiet down by doing the one thing I know how to – pushing every button – my mind sounds off with a different problem.

I’m late.

I glance at the clock on my oven: 4:21pm. I have to be on the east side, across town, by 5:15pm. Even if I leave now, the rush-hour train will take me no less than an hour, all in. But I can’t even leave now, I remind myself. Not with my stupid expensive coffee machine carrying out its own demise.

β€œShit,” I say out loud this time. β€œAnd I need a coffee.”

Ggghhh. Gghhhuuhhhhh. Ggghuuuhhuuh. Gguuuhhuhuuhhh – exasperated by the noise, I turn the machine OFF and yank its handle up. The cylindrical pod, already clearly ravaged by the sharp teeth inside, is sitting there. Still. I lean down, taking a better look… and get a surprise whiff of the ground coffee beans inside. Bitter. Nutty. My whole body tingles.

β€œSHIT,” I say louder, now even more desperate for caffeine.

I lean my weight on the counter and push my face even closer, determined to see every aspect of the pod’s habitat with my own eyes. As I examine it, I can’t help but get frustrated: everything looks like it’s in working order. There’s nothing obviously broken. There’s nothing blatantly sticking out.

Turn it off, turn it on, I think to myself, referencing the extent of my troubleshooting skills. I stall for a second, lulled by the quiet in the air. Just do it, I tell myself. Holding my breath, I turn the machine back on and push the handle all the way back down.

There’s a second of silence. Of possibility. Of… hope…?

GGHHHHUUH. GGGGHHHHUHHHH. GGGHHUUHHHH.

β€œAH,” I leap back, surprised – like an idiot. The sound doesn’t stop on my account.

GGGGHHHHUHHHH. GUHHHUGGUGUUHHH. GHHUUGHGHGUUUUUU –

I jerk the cord out of the socket. Shaky – from the unexpected racket and the 10-hour work day I’d just finished – I catch my breath. With the machine now powered down, the air is calm. The gentle whirr of the heater, a necessity for October on the east coast, is the only discernible noise.

Focus, I order myself. You’re late.

Grabbing my bag and tugging my combat boots on, I promise myself that I’ll deal with the broken machine as soon as I get home. Facing any Friday without the guarantee of morning coffee is a non-starter, but tomorrow isn’t just any Friday – it’s a Friday where the rest of the world, or at least the rest of the country, is off work.

No Starbucks. No cute cafe down the street, my mind ticks off as I lock the door behind me. Your coffee is your problem. You might be unlucky, you might be cursed, but you’re not helpless, I continue – my inner voice harsh as ever.

Fix it.

***

At 5:14pm, I pull the door of The Owl open, eyes scanning the small-but-trendy watering hole. There’s a flock of finance bros at the bar (their pristine suits and manic voices a dead giveaway) and a group of well-off hipsters, likely in advertising, in the middle of the room – but other than that, every table’s filled by demure duos or trios.

No Georgie yet.

Ignoring the tinge of frustration growing inside me – I’d just jogged the two miles from the train to be punctual – I nod at the model-esque hostess who’s approaching me.

β€œShould be under Georgie Henderson,” I greet her, watching her long finger tap the iPad on the stand. When she looks up again, she’s glancing across the room, at a table by the wall. I can make out a jacket on a chair. A bag – or something bag-like – on the surface.

β€œI think she’s –”

β€œSAAAAAAM!”

I, along with the whole bar’s happy hour population, turn to face the sing-song scream. At the other side of the room, by the hallway to the restrooms, stands Georgie: 5’2 and platinum blonde, embodying the kind of no-fucks confidence that makes it clear some people really are just born with it. I can’t help but laugh – my frustration dissolving.

β€œSorry, sorry,” she wraps her sweater-enclosed arms around me as soon as I’m within reach. β€œI walked from work and thought I was gonna pee myself. We’re here.” I follow her as she travels back to our table, grabbing the tote (I was right) off her place setting.

β€œYou just left your bag?”

β€œNo, I didn’t just leave my bag,” Georgie responds, crossing her legs. β€œI left my book bag. You know, the bag I use to take new books from the office home with me on the foundation’s dime,” she smiles. Georgie works at a nonprofit, doing some mixture of marketing and event planning. While the pay is shit – her forever-boyfriend fronts most of their living expenses – the perks, like library access and sports tickets, make up for it.

β€œWhat are you reading now?” I ask, leaning over to grab the tote off the seat beside her.

She flicks my hand away. β€œNo. Absolutely not.”

β€œWhat?”

β€œThat’s not why we’re here.”

β€œWhy are we here, George?” I ask, genuinely curious. Because – while we are happy hour aficionados – we’re not usually bougie enough to brave the Financial District on a Thursday.

Her blue eyes stare back at me. β€œYou’ve been here for almost a year, Sam.”

β€œWhat do you mean, here? Home?”

β€œYes, home,” she rolls her eyes. β€œJesse is fine now, he’s in school. Your grandma’s at the nursing home, getting taken care of. You built your business. You got your new place –”

β€œGeorgie, I feel like I’m listening to some deranged biography on tape.”

β€œYou’re not dating.”

I stare back at her, unable to hide my surprise. β€œI’m not… dating?”

β€œYou’re not dating,” she repeats. β€œYou refuse to get on the apps. You won’t let us set you up with anyone. You’re not flirting in public, you’re not up to anything weird in private, you’re not getting laid,” she ramps up the volume as she builds her case.

β€œGeorgie.” I interrupt her, pointedly glancing at the tables around us. Then I focus back on her. β€œYou don’t even know that. I could be –”

β€œWhat? You could be living some secret double life where you’re not working until 10pm every night? Where you’re not calling me on a Saturday at dinnertime to talk about what’s changed in the Cinnamon Toast Crunch recipe?”

β€œThat was one time.”

β€œSam, we’re 24. You have to be putting yourself out there. You don’t have to want marriage, a family, all of that, but you do have to have fun. I can see it in your face. You’re not having fun.”

My hand flits to my cheek. β€œThat’s why you wanted me here? So you could chastise me for not flirting with a sufficient number of suitors?”

She gives me one of her looks. β€œNo,” she counters, holding my gaze. β€œI wanted you here because there’s this brand new app that Meg – I work with her, remember?” I nod, vaguely recalling an artsy-looking woman in her early 30s. Georgie continues. β€œThat Meg just told me about. It’s in its trial phase, invite-only. And get this. It’s already been live in New York and LA, but it just opened its doors to a third city. Ours.”

β€œGeorgie…” I start, but she’s already blowing past my hesitation. Her finger scrolls for something on her phone as she keeps talking.

β€œApparently the co-founder went to school with Meg here, and she was adamant this city was its next release spot before they go global.” She finds what she’s looking for, turning the phone to face me. I read the single white word on the black screen.

β€œLocale?”

β€œLocale. The premise is you don’t get a name or any identifying information, you just get the people who are less than two miles away from you. Their photos, their prompt answers. That’s it.”

β€œIt sounds like every other attempt at a dating app,” I sigh at her. β€œTrying to be edgy and special, but just as hopeless as the rest.” Her unblinking expression tells me my take is not the right one.

β€œYou’re gonna try it.”

β€œGeorgie –”

β€œSam. How long have we been friends?”

I look back at her.

β€œA really fucking long time,” she answers for herself. β€œI love you to death, I want you to live the fullest life you can possibly live. And right now, you’re not cutting it.”

β€œThat’s a messed up thing to say –”

β€œStop being a pussy,” she taps her phone screen, still facing me on the table. β€œI’m sending you the access code when Meg gets it to me later,” she continues. β€œYou’re downloading the app. Now…” Her eyes dart around for a server. When she clocks him – taking the hipster table’s order – she immediately pivots her plan and waves down the hostess.

β€œYeah?” The doll-eyed girl appears.

β€œCool if we order with you?”

β€œUh –”

Georgie doesn’t wait for the answer. β€œWe’ll do the barolo,” she taps the bottle list, pretending to be someone who spent a semester abroad (instead of someone who grew up with a high-functioning alcoholic father).

β€œThe full bottle?”

β€œThe full bottle,” her megawatt smile radiates. β€œWe’re celebrating.”

β€œWe’re not celebrating,” I roll my eyes at her as the hostess pads away. β€œI’ll think about it, but I’m not just downloading another stupid app to placate –”

β€œWe’re not celebrating you,” she laughs. β€œWe’re celebrating me.”

I wait to see if she’s joking, but when her smile maintains its wattage and her nose scrunches the way it always does when she has something to confess, I re-focus. β€œDid you get a promotion again? I thought they just threw one at you a month ago. You’ve got to be the most celebrated humanitarian event planner to ever –”

β€œI told Johnny next year is the year,” she interrupts.

I gasp. Johnny – Georgie’s boyfriend since college – has been trying to lock her down ever since they celebrated their first anniversary: six years ago. While she obviously loves the guy to death, she’s had no interest in welcoming the government into their relationship.

Until… well, now, I guess.

β€œYou’re getting engaged?!” I whisper-yell, as shocked about her change of heart as I am about us being adult enough to even be having this conversation.

β€œIt won’t be until the new year, January at the earliest,” she explains. β€œBut I told him as soon as New Years passes, I’m fair game.”

I take in my best friend. I’ve watched her cry her eyes out after 8th grade formal, eat her way through a dozen cinnamon rolls on a dare, and streak – butt naked – before accepting every job from 17 on. (β€œIt brings me good luck,” she’d laugh as she’d run.) I’ve seen her through every milestone, through every heartbreak and laugh-so-hard-she-cries attack, and now, I’m seeing her here. Seeing her eyes twinkle. Seeing her overflow with excitement (even though she hides the hopeless romantic part of herself like a pro to everyone else).

β€œYou’re getting engaged,” I repeat, the weight of it hitting me. She grabs my hand over the table, as solemn as I’ve ever seen her.

β€œSam,” she says, β€œwe’re getting engaged.”

***

We’re getting engaged.

Georgie’s words kept replaying through my head as I made my way home. They kept replaying as I made a pit stop at an all-purpose store to buy an ultra-cheap coffee machine, and they kept replaying as I set it up on the counter, next to its fancier cousin.

We’re getting engaged.

Now I’m sitting on a barstool at the kitchen island, stuffing the last pretzel in the bag – smothered in hummus – into my mouth. I’m tipsy, but more importantly, I can’t stop thinking about everything Georgie told me. About the timeline she’d given Johnny. About the certainty in her voice.

There are only two things I’m certain about at 24, I say to myself as I let my feet walk me back over to the fridge. I’ll do whatever I can to make it professionally, and…

I pull open the fridge door.

…I’ll never have enough food in the fridge.

I scan the shelves. Olives. Cherry tomatoes. Hot sauce bottles. Leftover fries. With a sigh, I grab the styrofoam container of fries – real classy, Sam – and carry it back to the island. As I proceed with my dip-in-hummus method, I use my other hand to open my phone’s calendar, running through tomorrow’s schedule.

-8am, call with Scott.

-10am, feedback meeting with Paul and team.

-1-3pm, work session with Matteo.

-4pm, check-in with Analise.

Of course it’s a holiday Friday for everyone else and an oh-so-stuffed marathon for me, I roll my eyes inwardly. But even as I think that, I know I’m grateful for the busyness.

It’s taken me 11 months to build my client list – international client list, I correct – from scratch, and while being a one-woman show has been exhausting, it’s also been thrilling. Gratifying.

But still… lonely. As much as I hate to admit it, I know Georgie was right about my social life. Sure, I’m a constant at our bi-weekly girls nights, and sure, I go to the movies with Jesse – my little brother – every Sunday, but for a 24-year-old who used to close out the bar scene of New York City on a regular basis, I’ve slipped a long way down.

Did I really call her about Cinnamon Toast Crunch on a Saturday night? I shake my head, perturbed by my own behavior.

Before I can stop it, my finger swipes me out of the calendar and into the app store. I dip another fry into hummus, the second wave of embarrassment revving a sense of morbid curiosity up inside me.

Georgie had sent me the access code as soon as I got home, so I could gain entry if I wanted to. And Georgie had said that it was exclusive, with Meg’s friend – the co-founder – only letting in people she could personally vouch for.

I type an β€œL” into the search bar. Then an β€œO.” Then a β€œC.” As relevant hits populate the search, I see the same modern-white-font-on-black-background logo I saw at the bar.

LOCALE.

I click the app name, my thumb hovering over the download button. Half of me feels pulled in by the promise of something new, but the other half feels reluctant – doubtful that this new gamified version of online dating will be anything but more of the same.

Before I can make a decision, my phone starts vibrating. Dramatically.

---- β€œINCOMING CALL: SCOTT LUTE.” ----

Damn it, I think to myself, wiping the hummus off my fingers and forcing the carefree wine haze out of my mind. I press the green button, letting the voice of Scott – one of my very first clients – into the privacy of my home.

β€œSam?” He says as soon as I answer.

β€œHey Scott,” I match his serious tone. β€œWhat’s going on?”

β€œSorry to bug you. We’ve got a situation. The pitch we’re rolling with tomorrow –”

β€œFor the new firm?”

β€œRight, we just got our hands on some final numbers. I’d plug-n-play them myself if they didn’t change the narrative…”

β€œBut they are different from the predictions,” I finish for him, realizing what he’s saying. The presentation I’d spent the past four weeks working on was now obsolete. In order for it to match up with the evidence, it’d have to be redone.

β€œI wouldn’t ask if it wasn’t critical,” Scott says, the urgency clear.

β€œWhat time’s the meeting?” I ask, my eyes darting to the oven clock. 11:14pm.

β€œWe’re there at 3."

β€œI can jump into it now,” I tell him, walking over to my desk. The severity of the situation isn’t lost on me: Scott’s company, a maker of gaming software, has been on a mission to help parents gain more control over kids’ video gaming. It’s secured a good amount of funding since its founding two years ago, but Scott has big ideas – and big ideas need bigger pockets.

Tomorrow’s meeting with a new VC firm might be enough to get him what he needs, so to lock down the investors, we’ve been working on a new – more personal – pitch. But that pitch needs to be grounded in reality to get us anywhere. β€œDid you forward me the numbers?”

β€œYeah,” Scott exhales. β€œAre you serious? You can do it?”

I’m already seated, pulling my laptop open. β€œScott, we’ve been working on this for a month. We’re not about to throw our hands up now.” I enter the shared file then open my inbox, finding the email with the updated metrics. β€œLet’s keep our 8am on the docket. I don’t think these numbers will take me more than six hours to implement into the existing big picture, but either way, I’ll have the rejigged version ready by then.”

β€œYou’re a lifesaver. You understand that? Triple your rate for however long this takes you.”

β€œGet some sleep, Scott,” I respond, my brain already immersed in the task at hand. β€œWe need you sharp.”

After a few more rounds of thank you’s, he hangs up. I adjust myself in my chair and start typing.

It might take me all night, but this adrenaline rush is incomparable, I think to myself, Georgie’s engagement, the new dating app, and the Cinnamon Toast Crunch embarrassment all leaving my mind. If I get it done, I’ll make $3k while everyone else is sleeping.

Come on, Sam, I order myself. Get. It. Done.

Next Chapter

Let Lola Jay know what you thought about this chapter!

Becky_Columnist
Becky_Columnist

I'm already loving it 😍 I've been looking for a strong and independent female lead

3 years
Bennettkick
Bennettkick

Hi Lolaβ€―Jay,

I just finished reading your story Extra Dark and I loved it so much. Your writing blends raw emotional realism with a haunting undercurrent of personal darkness, and I kept picturing how visually stunning that could be in comic or manga form, .

I really loved the opening scene in Chapterβ€―1, where Sam battles her malfunctioning coffee machine at 4:21β€―pm, the clattering noise amplifying her stress. When she finally slams the machine off, the sudden silence, her exasperated sigh, and the whirlwind of thoughts about being late, it’s humor and high-pressure anxiety captured in visceral detail. That internal tension and the comedic beat would translate so well into a sequential visual sequence, panel by panel, emphasizing the chaotic sounds and Sam’s expressions,Β  .

Another moment that stood out is the dynamic between Sam and her friend Georgie at the bar. As Georgie delivers that candid β€œyou’re not having fun” speech, the contrast between Sam’s worn-down exhaustion and Georgie’s energetic intensity creates a compelling emotional visual contrast. The moment Georgie reveals she’s engaged, and Sam’s stunned, half-laughing reaction,offers perfect emotional beats for a comic: strong character-driven visuals with shifting tones from caring confrontation to surprise and reflection, .

I’m a commissioned artist, and I’d love to draw Extra Dark as a comic or manga. No pressure, just genuine enthusiasm. I think your ability to capture emotional complexity and everyday intensity would really shine in visual form.

You can check out some of my recent work on my DeviantArt (Username – Ev3Verse). If you're interested, please message me on Discord (Username – bennett_lol) so we can explore bringing your story to life visually. I'll be thrilled to hear from you!

Regards,
Bennett.

a year

Further Recommendations

Begin Again

Christina: Really loving the night in shining armor

Read Now
Strangers in the Storm

mymy_260204 : Amazing! Absolutely beautiful!!! I never write reviews, but this story, the plot, and the message behind it! Beautifully hought through - Honestly, so talented.😍😍

Read Now
Lemon

Sherry: Love the writing and story. Couldn’t put it down.

Read Now
One Simple Word

nicolasandiford: Wow I really enjoyed this book, the plot was full of interesting characters and great details. The story had many positives and was truly great, the characters were very interesting and had some great comical one liners. This book would appeal to a vast audience of different ages and was really writ...

Read Now
The Neighbor

Barney: I like the characters and I also like how they were described. I’m also I’m love with the chemistry between them

Read Now
Loving Paige

Andrea: Such a masterfully written story. I was hanging on to every word. The roller coaster of emotions I felt was palpable . Beau and Blair just had my whole heart and soul and their journey together was beautiful.

Read Now
Deviant Desires

Susan Cassimatis: Interesting plot, as well as characters. Held my interest unlike most! Will probably read again and recommend

Read Now
Undecided

Victoria Herzog: "Undecided" delves into the complex and often controversial territory of professor-student relationships with a strikingly original approach. While the storyline does not shy away from the stereotypical issues inherent in such narrativesβ€”age gaps, power imbalances, and societal scrutinyβ€”it deftly re...

Read Now
During The Thunderstorm | Natural Disaster #1

Dimitra Dal: It's fresh and exquisite! Really nice story. It doesn't have magical characters wearwolfs or vampires. It is a real life story of love! Really nice and refreshing! I loved it.

Read Now