V1 Chapter 1: The Silence Between Arguments
The classroom clock ticked softly, but to Elvar, the sound was louder than it should’ve been. First day at Ramord School—a school far bigger than the one he left behind. Yet in his eyes, all schools felt the same: places where voices were mocked before they even had the chance to grow.
His steps down the corridor were light, yet firm. A high-collared black jacket covered part of his face, and a thin chain necklace peeked from underneath. His sling bag was a little worn, but he didn’t care. He just wanted to get through this final year without too much noise.
A few students looked his way. New faces always stirred curiosity. But Elvar was used to ignoring stares—observation mattered more than involvement.
“New kid, huh?”
A cheerful voice broke through his thoughts. A girl with a bright smile approached him. Her hair was tied high, and her posture suggested someone used to being in charge.
“I’m Dira, class president. What’s your name?”
“Elvar,” he replied briefly.
“Quiet type, huh?”
Dira let out a small laugh, patting his shoulder before walking away.
“If you need anything, just ask me, okay!”
Elvar merely nodded. Small talk was never his strength. He made his way to the seat furthest back, by the window, and sat down without a word. That kind of spot was his favorite—shielded from the spotlight, but with a wide view of everything.
The first lesson began. The teacher spoke about material and expectations for graduation. But Elvar’s attention was only half there. He was more focused on observing his classmates—figuring out who was truly interested, and who was just there to tick boxes.
At home, opinions weren’t appreciated. He grew up in a family where silence meant obedience, and questions were seen as defiance. That’s why he thought more than he spoke.
Until one day, at his old school, his thoughts exploded. And that’s what brought him here.
⸻
During break, Elvar left the class. He climbed the stairs to the school’s rooftop, hoping it would be quiet enough to calm his thoughts. And it was. No one else was there.
He sat on a rusted bench, gazing at the cloudy sky above Gabrela City. The afternoon air was cool.
“You’re not from around here, are you?”
A voice came from behind. Elvar turned to find a girl standing there, hands tucked in the pockets of her blazer. Shoulder-length hair, eyes sharp but not judgmental. There was a calmness in the way she stood—like someone who knew exactly what she was doing.
“I’m Elvar,” he said flatly.
“Aeryn,” she replied, walking closer. She sat on another bench, keeping her distance, but close enough to talk.
A few minutes passed in silence. But it wasn’t awkward silence—it was the kind that asked quietly, Do we need words right now?
Aeryn spoke first. “In Ms. Laila’s class earlier, you answered that philosophy question from a pretty unique perspective.”
Elvar raised an eyebrow. “I just said people obey too easily without knowing where rules come from.”
“That’s not a typical answer.”
“To me, it is.”
Aeryn smiled. “You think like someone who debates.”
Elvar turned his face away. “I just think. Doesn’t mean I want to speak in front of a crowd.”
Aeryn’s gaze remained steady. She studied him for a moment, then said softly, “Sometimes, the things you keep inside… gain more meaning when you dare to say them out loud.”
Her words lingered in the air. Elvar didn’t respond. But for the first time since arriving, his thoughts didn’t feel so alone.
⸻
The next day, a notice was pinned to the school’s main bulletin board:
“Debate Team Tryouts – One Slot Available!”
Aeryn stood in front of it. Most students only gave it a passing glance. But she stood still, staring, as if weighing something within herself.
Someone walked past behind her. Someone in a black jacket, carrying a sling bag.
His eyes faced forward—but for a moment, they met hers.
Aeryn gave a small smile.
She had found her candidate.
⸻
Aeryn walked down the hallway of Ramord School with measured steps. Her eyes scanned the announcements pinned to the large board—though only one truly caught her attention: Debate Team Tryouts – One Slot Available!
For most, it was just another extracurricular activity. But not for Aeryn.
She was born into a family of law. Her father—a senior prosecutor, known for his unyielding principles. Her mother—a dressmaker, soft-spoken and creative, the only person who ever made Aeryn feel unjudged.
Debate was never her desire. It was inheritance. An invisible pressure that had grown with her since childhood. Every word had to be logical, every opinion defendable. “Losing isn’t about losing,” her father once said, “it’s about losing face.”
And so, Aeryn was shaped—sharp, efficient, rarely misstepping. But sometimes, she wondered… Was any of this truly hers? Or simply obedience, wrapped in ambition?
Today, her thoughts wandered in a direction they rarely took.
Because someone had drawn her attention yesterday.
Someone named Elvar.
⸻
On the other side of the school, Elvar sat again in his usual corner seat.
He slowly rolled the cuff of his jacket, occasionally glancing out the window at the brooding sky.
Without warning, someone took the seat beside him.
“Yo, you’re the new kid, right?”
The voice belonged to Brian.
His hair was messy, his expression relaxed, but his mouth seemed to have a mind of its own.
“I’m Brian. We’re almost graduating, but man, you showed up at an interesting time.” He grinned, then continued uninvited, “Saw Aeryn checking you out earlier. That girl’s stiff as hell, but she’s killer in debate. Her folks are lawyers or something—I forget.”
Elvar glanced sideways. “So?”
Brian shrugged. “Dunno. Just weird, y’know? She never gives a damn about anyone. But you? She waited for you to speak yesterday on the rooftop.”
Elvar exhaled quietly. He didn’t like being in the spotlight. Especially not because of Aeryn. She was everything he avoided—spotlights, pressure, expectations.
⸻
Days passed. The announcement for tryouts loomed closer.
Aeryn began appearing in unexpected places—the library, empty hallways, even the back garden where Elvar often hid away.
“I know you think a lot,” she said one afternoon when they bumped into each other by accident. “But sometimes, thinking alone isn’t enough.”
“And you talk like everyone needs to hear what you think,” Elvar replied.
Aeryn went quiet for a moment.
But not offended.
She smiled.
“You know? My dad once told me, debate isn’t about who’s the loudest. It’s about who knows when to stay silent.”
“Nice words. But do you really believe them?”
Aeryn didn’t answer.
Because truthfully… she wasn’t sure.
⸻
Back home, Elvar’s living room was far from peaceful.
His father sat on the couch, still wearing his work shirt even though it was late.
“When you transfer schools, don’t just be a bystander. A man should have a voice,” he said.
Elvar stared at the floor.
In this house, a voice wasn’t for expressing your truth. It was a weapon—proof that you weren’t weak.
“There’s a debate tryout at school,” his mother offered gently. “Maybe Elvar could give it a try.”
The room chilled.
His father scoffed.
“If it’s just for show, don’t bother. The real world’s harsher than a mouth war.”
Elvar rose and walked out. Not in anger. Just… knowing. There would be no discussion.
In this house, debates belonged to one voice only.
⸻
The next morning, the announcement board was crowded with names.
The list of debate tryout participants had been posted.
Elvar’s name wasn’t there.
But something gnawed at his mind all day.
Not the competition.
Not even Aeryn.
Something deeper whispered—You should’ve spoken. Just this once. Not only thought. Not only stayed silent.
That evening, Elvar found a folded note tucked into his desk drawer. The handwriting was neat and deliberate.
“Sometimes we don’t join because we fear losing. But the worst kind of loss is not knowing what we could’ve won.”
No name.
But he knew exactly who it was from.
⸻
Elsewhere in the hallway, Aeryn was rereading her debate material. Her hands were busy, but her mind drifted. She wasn’t the type to remember someone’s face for too long.
But Elvar…
He wasn’t ordinary.
Not because of his calm gaze or the small chain he always kept hidden under his collar. But because of that look in his eyes— The kind that carried too many words, yet chose silence.
And to Aeryn, silence was the most powerful opinion of all.
⸻
The day of the tryouts had finally arrived.
The small hall at the southern wing of Ramord School was filled with rows of plastic chairs and a single whiteboard. At the far end of the room, three debate advisors sat behind a long table, looking more like judges at a courtroom than club mentors.
The participants’ names were projected on a screen.
Aeryn sat in the front row, eyes locked forward, her fingers playing with the tip of her pen—like always.
She was used to being on stage.
Used to being ready.
What she wasn’t used to… was the subtle quickening of her heartbeat.
Because… Elvar was there.
⸻
A few days earlier, just after the last class ended, Elvar had walked into the student council room and submitted his debate application form with a neutral expression.
“You signed up after all?”
Brian’s voice called from the hallway as he passed by.
Elvar gave a small nod.
Brian exclaimed, “Whoa, the world must be ending. The quiet guy joining debate—wild!”
Meanwhile, Aeryn, who was reading near the staircase, glanced up for a second—pretending not to care.
But behind that composed face, a spark flickered.
Curiosity, maybe.
Or… a kind of concern.
⸻
Back in the hall, the room grew denser.
Each participant was called to draw a number.
Elvar got the last spot.
He didn’t mind.
In fact, he preferred it that way—silent, watching first.
Brian slouched at the back, unsure whether he was part of the tryout or just the noisiest spectator there.
“You know,” he whispered to Cecila—the shy girl sitting next to him—“rumor is Elvar used to go to a school full of fights. That’s why he’s all quiet now—scared his words might start something.”
Cecila gave a small smile and scribbled something in her notes.
She didn’t say much.
But the way she observed… it was clear she had her own thoughts.
⸻
The first contestant stepped up. Then the second. Third.
Aeryn was sixth.
She opened her argument with clarity—structured, steady, convincing. As always, she appeared flawless.
One of the judges commented,
“Your argument is solid, but a bit too textbook. Add some emotional weight—it could make all the difference.”
Aeryn frowned slightly.
She wasn’t used to being asked to “feel”.
Round after round continued. Some participants were visibly nervous.
Some overconfident.
Brian eventually had his turn—but his speech veered into the bizarre.
“The point is… it depends how you see reality. Politically, socially, and… uh, astrologically?”
Silence.
Even Cecila looked down in embarrassment.
Brian came down the stage with a grin.
“Well, hey. At least I showed up!”
⸻
Then… it was Elvar’s turn.
He stood.
His eyes swept across the room.
Silence.
His heart pounded, but his face remained calm.
The debate topic:
“Does academic ranking support a student’s holistic development?”
He inhaled deeply.
Then began.
“If development means learning how to think, to feel, and to understand one’s limits… then the ranking system fails from the start.”
His voice wasn’t loud, nor trembling.
But there was something in his tone that made the room still.
“Ranking puts numbers above growth.
It equalizes heads that clearly carry different contents.
And when someone doesn’t make the top ten,
it’s not their process that’s questioned— it’s their resilience that’s punished.”
A few teachers exchanged glances.
Aeryn… sat frozen.
Elvar looked directly at the judges.
“I’m not here to win.
I’m here because I once sat in my own house,
looked at my report card,
and was told I had failed as a child.”
Silence.
“I want to speak because I believe debate isn’t about
who’s best at speaking—but who dares to say what’s hardest to express.”
⸻
After stepping down, Elvar didn’t return to his seat.
He walked out of the hall—
back to the garden behind the school.
Only that place felt quiet enough
after everything he had just let out.
Minutes passed.
Then Aeryn followed.
She stood there for a while, saying nothing.
Just watching Elvar with his back to the setting sun.
“You’re… not who I thought you were,” she said at last.
Elvar turned slightly.
“And who did you think I was?”
“Quiet. Distant.
But turns out… you’ve just been carrying too much.”
She didn’t smile.
Didn’t flatter. But in her eyes—there was respect.
“Elvar,” she said softly, “if you make the team, don’t stop here. Sometimes… people like you are exactly what debate needs.
Not the loudest,
but the ones who carry something worth hearing.”
Elvar didn’t respond.
But for the first time, he looked Aeryn in the eye.
And for the first time… Aeryn wasn’t searching for an argument.
She was seeing a person.
⸻