Hayes Men Don’t Fall Apart
POV: Mason
Eighteen months ago
The argument had been building for weeks, maybe months. I just hadn’t wanted to see it.
“You’re never here anymore!” Sarah’s voice echoed through the kitchen, sharp enough to cut glass. “Even when you’re physically here, your mind is somewhere else.”
I gripped the edge of the kitchen counter, knuckles white against the dark granite. Outside the window, the sun was setting over the mountains, painting the sky in shades of orange and purple.
Instead, all I could focus on was the exhaustion bone deep in my marrow and the way Sarah’s perfectly manicured nails drummed against the marble island.
“My father is dying, Sarah.” The words came out flat, emotionless. I’d said them so many times in the past few months that they’d lost all meaning. “What exactly do you want me to do? Ignore him? Let him waste away while I—what? Take you to dinner? Plan our wedding?”
“I want you to make time for us!” Sarah’s voice cracked, and I looked up to see tears tracking through her makeup. Real tears, I noted distantly. When had I stopped being moved by her tears? “I want the man I agreed to marry back. The one who used to look at me like I mattered.”
“You do matter—”
“Do I?” She laughed, bitter and sharp. “When’s the last time we had a real conversation, Mason? One that wasn’t about ranch schedules or your father’s medication or which one of your brothers is coming home this week? When’s the last time you touched me like you actually wanted me?”
My jaw tightened. She wasn’t wrong. Sarah had fit into my life seamlessly. My mother had practically planned our wedding before I’d even proposed. It had made sense. It had been logical.
It hadn’t been passionate. But I still loved her. It wasn’t my fault that everything was going to shit.
“I’m doing the best I can,” I said quietly. “Between Dad’s hospice care and keeping the ranch running and trying to hold this family together—”
“That’s just it, though.” Sarah’s voice had gone cold now, tears drying as quickly as they’d come. “You’re always holding everyone else together. But what about me? What about us?”
“This isn’t forever. Once Dad—” I couldn’t finish the sentence. Couldn’t say the words out loud. “Once things settle down, we can focus on the wedding. On our life together.”
“Will you, though?” Sarah crossed her arms over her chest, and something in her posture made my stomach drop. This wasn’t the usual argument. This felt different. “Or will there just be another crisis? Another reason why I have to wait? Another excuse for why I’m not your priority?”
“That’s not fair—”
“Fair?” Her voice rose, sharp and cutting. “You want to talk about fair? I’ve been waiting for three years, Mason. Three years of playing second fiddle to your damn sense of duty. When do I get to be first?”
“Sarah, you know the situation—”
“The situation with your dad has been going on for a few months! And before that, it was the expansion. And before that, it was the drought. And before that, it was something else!” She was pacing now, shoes clicking against the hardwood like gunshots. “There’s always something. Always some reason why we have to put our lives on hold.”
“That’s how ranching works. There are always emergencies—”
“I know how ranching works, Mason! I grew up in this world too, remember? But other ranchers manage to have lives. Other men manage to make their relationships a priority.” She stopped pacing, turned to face me fully.
“What do you want me to do?” I shot back. “Abandon my responsibilities?”
“Yes, if you want to still keep the engagement.”
I opened my mouth to argue, to defend myself, but the words died in my throat.
“I thought…” Sarah’s voice broke, and she looked away. “I thought if I was patient enough, if I was understanding enough, eventually you’d… God, I don’t even know. That you’d wake up one day and actually want me. Not just accept me as part of your life plan, but want me.”
“I do want you—”
“No, you don’t.” She laughed, but there was no humor in it. “You want the idea of me. The perfect rancher’s wife who’ll host dinner parties and look good at charity events and give you children who’ll carry on the Hayes legacy.” She met my eyes again. “But you don’t want me. The real me. You don’t even know who I am.”
The accusation hung between us. And the worst part was, I couldn’t refute it. I didn’t know Sarah’s favorite book, or what she dreamed about, or what made her laugh when she was alone.
I knew she liked her coffee with two creams and one sugar. I knew she preferred white wine to red. I knew she wanted three bridesmaids at our wedding.
But did I know her?
“That’s not true,” I said, but even I could hear how weak it sounded.
“Prove it then.” Sarah’s eyes flashed with challenge. “Tell me one thing about me that matters. Not what I do or what I like. Tell me something real.”
I stood there, mind blank, and watched her face crumble.
“That’s what I thought.” She turned away, arms wrapped around herself like she was holding the pieces together. “I’ve been lying to myself for so long. Telling myself it would get better. That once the wedding happened, once we were married, you’d finally let me in. Finally see me as more than just another item on your checklist.”
“Sarah, this isn’t fair. My father is dying—”
“I know!” She whirled back around, and I saw real pain in her eyes now. Raw and bleeding. “I know he’s dying, Mason. And I’ve tried to be supportive. I’ve tried to be understanding. But I’ve also been drowning, and you haven’t noticed because you’re too busy being the perfect son, the perfect rancher, the perfect everything to everyone except me.”
“What do you want me to say?”
“I want you to fight for me!” The words came out as a near shout. “Just once, I want you to fight for us. I want you to prove that I matter more than anything else.”
I stared at her and felt that familiar weight settle over my shoulders. The weight of being a Hayes. Of being the oldest. Being responsible for everything and everyone. “I can’t do that.”
“I know,” she said softly. “That’s why I’ve been seeing someone else.”










