Customize readability
Aa

The Devil You Choose

All Rights Reserved ©

Summary

She’s promised to a man who never wanted her. He’s the man who could destroy her reputation — and her world. When Natalia Kensington crosses paths with Logan Walker, she steps over the invisible line that divides her pristine life from his chaos. And once she does, she’s never the same.

Status
Complete
Chapters
31
Rating
5.0 2 reviews
Age Rating
18+

Chapter 1

The dress fit perfectly.

Of course it did. Everything in Natalia Kensington’s life was tailored to perfection — the silk, the smile, the script.

She stood in front of her vanity, smoothing invisible wrinkles from the champagne fabric. Her reflection stared back at her — flawless makeup, pearls, soft curls, the kind of woman her mother had spent twenty-four years molding like porcelain.

She should have felt beautiful.

She felt bored.

Her phone buzzed. Wyatt.

No apology. No explanation. Just another text from the man she was supposed to marry in four months.

Natalia stared at the message until the words blurred. Then she dropped the phone onto the marble counter and exhaled through her nose. Slowly. Controlled.

Because that’s what Kensingtons did — they controlled.

Wyatt Clarke had been her fiancé for eight months. They’d been “a match made in heaven,” or so the society pages said. His father ran one of the largest investment firms in the Midwest; hers chaired the board of a global real estate empire.

Their engagement hadn’t been a love story — it had been strategy.

He was handsome in a polished, empty way — sharp jaw, crisp suits, the kind of smile that looked great in photos but never reached his eyes. He talked about quarterly returns and political connections over dinner, never about dreams or feelings or anything that made him sound human.

Their parents called it a power union. Natalia called it a merger she never agreed to.

At first, she’d tried to convince herself it could work. That love could come later. That maybe duty mattered more than passion.

But every time Wyatt brushed a kiss against her cheek like an obligation, every time he dismissed her opinions as “cute,” something inside her cracked a little more.

He didn’t love her.

And the truth she hated most — she didn’t love him either.

She walked into the living room, where the skyline glittered through the floor-to-ceiling windows of the Kensington penthouse. Chicago’s city lights blinked below, cold and distant.

The clock on the wall read 7:42 p.m.

She was supposed to be sitting across from Wyatt at a private booth in La Mer, pretending not to notice him checking his phone between courses. Instead, she stood here alone, in a dress that suddenly felt too tight, in a life that didn’t fit anymore.

She could hear her mother’s voice in her head, calm and commanding:

You were born to be a Kensington. Don’t embarrass us by wanting things that don’t matter.

What didn’t matter, apparently, was happiness.

Natalia’s fingers itched. She wanted to throw her phone, scream, do something reckless. Something real.

Instead, she reached for her clutch and her coat.

If Wyatt could skip out on their plans, so could she.

“Where to, Miss Kensington?” the driver asked when she slid into the backseat of the town car.

She hesitated. She could go home. She could order takeout, put on her robe, and scroll through engagement party inspo like a good fiancée.

But something in her — something wild and quiet that had been buried under pearls and expectations — whispered, No.

“Take me somewhere…different.”

The driver blinked in the rearview mirror. “Different, ma’am?”

“Yes. Somewhere people don’t know my name.”

He looked hesitant but nodded. Ten minutes later, the car slowed in front of a place that looked nothing like the glittering restaurants she was used to. Neon lights buzzed faintly above the door, the sign half burned out. The Pit Stop.

Natalia stared at it.

Oil-stained sidewalk. A crowd of leather jackets smoking outside.

It reeked of everything she’d been warned to avoid.

Perfect.

She paid the driver and stepped out before she could change her mind.

Inside, the air was thick with smoke and the low hum of classic rock. Laughter spilled from a pool table in the corner, and the bartender raised a brow when she approached.

“Uh…wine list?” she asked, instantly regretting it.

He smirked. “We’ve got beer or whiskey, sweetheart.”

She swallowed. “Whiskey, then.”

The liquid burned her throat, but she didn’t wince. Instead, she leaned against the bar and let herself watch for once. People here were loud, messy, alive. No one cared about etiquette or last names.

And for the first time in her life, Natalia felt invisible.

Liberated.

Her phone buzzed again. Wyatt, probably.

She ignored it.

Then she felt it — the weight of a stare.

Across the room, a man leaned against the wall, half in shadow. Dark hair, broad shoulders, tanned skin dusted with oil and hard work. Tattoos snaked down his forearms, visible where his rolled-up sleeves ended. He didn’t look like the kind of man who asked for permission.

His eyes found hers, slow and deliberate.

He smiled — not polite, not practiced, just dangerous.

And Natalia’s pulse jumped.

She looked away, but not before she saw him push off the wall and start toward her.

Every instinct told her to leave.

But she didn’t move.

Because for the first time in years, she wasn’t playing a part.

She was about to live one.

The whiskey burned less the second time.

Maybe because she was starting to like the sting.

Natalia swirled the amber liquid in her glass, eyes fixed on the ice as it cracked and shifted. Around her, laughter and shouts blurred into background noise — a soundtrack of freedom she didn’t understand but wanted to.

She could still feel that man’s gaze from earlier, lingering in the back of her mind. It was ridiculous how much it had affected her. A look shouldn’t feel like that. Like someone had peeled back every layer of her polished composure and seen straight into the restless woman underneath.

She told herself he was gone. That he was probably just another drunk with too much confidence and not enough sense.

Then a low voice brushed her ear.

“Didn’t think they served royalty here.”

Natalia’s heart stuttered. She turned — and there he was.

Closer now. Taller than she expected. The dim lights picked up the steel glint of a chain around his neck, the sharp angle of his jaw. His eyes were a deep, stormy gray — amused, assessing.

“I’m sorry?” she said, keeping her tone cool.

He gestured to her dress, her posture, the pearl earrings that didn’t belong anywhere near this place.

“You don’t exactly blend in, princess.”

She felt heat rise to her cheeks — part embarrassment, part something else. “I wasn’t aware there was a dress code.”

“There’s not,” he said, leaning one elbow on the bar. “But you walked in here like you owned it. That gets attention.”

Natalia forced a small smile. “And you? Do you usually hit on strangers who look out of place?”

He grinned, lazy and slow, like he had all the time in the world. “Only when they look like you.”

Her chest tightened. She should’ve laughed it off, turned away, texted Wyatt, done anything but engage.

But there was something magnetic about him — something raw that drew her in like gravity.

He nodded at her glass. “What are you drinking?”

“Whiskey.”

“Good start.”

“You say that like it’s a test.”

He chuckled, low and rough. “Maybe it is. You passed.”

Natalia arched a brow. “Do I win something?”

“Depends what you’re playing for.”

The words sent a spark straight through her stomach. She looked away, trying to hide the faint tremor in her breath.

He watched her — not the way men at galas did, with polished lust and polite restraint. No, this was hungrier. Curious. Like he wanted to see how far she’d go if no one was watching.

“What’s your name?” she asked, surprising herself.

“Logan.”

Just Logan. No last name, no pretense.

“Natalia,” she said after a beat.

“I know,” he replied, smirking. “You’ve got that Kensington look.”

Her spine straightened. “You know who I am?”

“Everyone in this city knows who you are.” He took a sip of his drink, eyes never leaving hers. “The golden girl. Engaged to Clarke Industries’ heir. The kind of woman who doesn’t belong anywhere near a place like this.”

The way he said it — half mocking, half admiring — made her pulse jump again.

“So why are you here, golden girl?”

She hesitated. “Maybe I just wanted a drink.”

He laughed under his breath. “Nah. Women like you don’t end up here by accident. You came looking for something.”

She hated that he was right.

“I told you,” she said lightly, “just a drink.”

He leaned in, close enough for her to smell smoke and leather and something sinfully male. “If that’s all you wanted, you’d have left already.”

Her throat tightened.

“You’re making a lot of assumptions,” she managed.

“Maybe.” He smiled, a slow, dangerous curve. “You can tell me I’m wrong if you want. But I don’t think you will.”

Her heart hammered. She wanted to walk away — she should — but his nearness was intoxicating.

And God, when was the last time someone had looked at her like this? Not like an accessory, or a business deal, but like a woman.

“Your fiancé wouldn’t like this,” Logan said softly, almost to himself.

Natalia’s eyes snapped to his. “You don’t know him.”

He shrugged. “Don’t have to. I can tell by the way you say it.”

A flicker of shame and irritation flashed through her chest. “You think you’ve got me all figured out?”

He grinned. “Not yet. But I’d like to.”

Her breath caught.

That was her cue to leave. It should’ve been. But instead, she found herself standing there, her fingers brushing the condensation on her glass, stalling.

Because the truth was, for the first time in a long time, she didn’t feel numb.

“Wyatt stood me up for dinner…again,” Natalia found herself admitting.

Why had she said that? She didn’t know Logan and yet here he was, listening to her like what she said actually mattered. Like she was more than just something to show off at social functions.

“Yeah, bet he’s got a real good excuse too. But, right now, I’m looking at what he’s got to lose sitting all alone in a bar,” Logan said, watching her as he shrugged. “If I were him, I wouldn’t let you out of my sight. Especially around a guy like me.”

Natalia found herself giving a small smile and glancing away as heat crept up her neck. It was crazy how a complete stranger could say something that stripped her of all her walls, her carefully curated public facade.

Logan finally straightened, tossing a few bills on the bar. “Enjoy your drink, princess.”

And just like that, he turned and walked away, disappearing into the crowd.

Natalia stood frozen, watching the spot where he’d been.

Her pulse still hadn’t slowed.

When her phone buzzed — Wyatt’s name lighting up the screen — she didn’t answer.

By the time Natalia stepped out into the night, the city air had cooled, crisp against her flushed skin. The noise of the bar still hummed faintly behind her — laughter, clinking glasses, that song playing on the jukebox she didn’t know but couldn’t stop hearing in her head.

Her heels clicked on the cracked sidewalk as she walked toward the waiting car. The driver straightened when he saw her, but she waved him off for a moment, leaning against the door as she drew in a deep breath.

She could still feel him.

The gravelly tone of his voice. The way his eyes had lingered when she pretended not to care.

The way her pulse had jumped when he said princess.

It was ridiculous. He was a stranger — rough, dangerous, entirely wrong. Everything her world had told her to stay away from.

And yet…

She told herself the warmth flooding her veins was just the whiskey. That the dizzy, restless energy inside her had nothing to do with the man who’d looked at her like he already knew how to ruin her.

She almost believed it.

The penthouse was quiet when she got home. Too quiet.

The kind of quiet that filled the expensive air with absence.

Wyatt was exactly where she expected him to be — sprawled on the couch, laptop open, the city lights reflecting off his cufflinks. He didn’t look up right away.

“There you are.” His voice was even, controlled. “Didn’t you get my message?”

“I did.” She hung her coat carefully, the pearls at her throat suddenly feeling like a noose.

“I tried calling,” he said, closing his laptop. “Twice.”

“I was out,” she said simply.

He blinked at her, a hint of disbelief in his perfectly symmetrical features. “Out where?”

“Just…out.”

His jaw flexed. “You went somewhere alone?”

She nodded, meeting his eyes with quiet defiance.

Wyatt laughed — that polished, humorless sound that had always grated at her nerves. “You’re serious? Natalia, do you have any idea how that looks?”

Her fingers tightened on her clutch. “To who? You weren’t there.”

“That’s not the point,” he snapped, rising from the couch. “You can’t just wander around the city unaccompanied. You’re not some—” He caught himself, smoothing his tone. “You’re not like other women, Natalia. You’re a Kensington. People notice when you make choices that don’t…fit the image.”

There it was again. The image.

The holy scripture of their lives.

“Maybe I don’t care what they notice,” she said softly.

His brow furrowed, as if the concept were foreign. “You should.”

He stepped closer, lowering his voice to that practiced, patronizing calm. “I know things have been stressful with the wedding, but let’s try to remember what this is all for, alright? Our families have expectations. This—” He gestured vaguely between them. “This is bigger than feelings or moods.”

Feelings. Moods.

As if she were a child acting out instead of a woman barely holding her sanity together.

She wanted to scream. Instead, she smiled that perfect Kensington smile — the one that didn’t reach her eyes — and nodded. “You’re right, Wyatt.”

“Good.” He kissed her cheek absently, already glancing back toward his laptop. “You look tired. Maybe get some rest.”

She stood there a moment after he left the room, the echo of his words clinging to the air.

Get some rest.

Remember what this is all for.

She walked into the bedroom, unhooked her earrings, and caught sight of herself in the mirror — the woman who’d laughed softly over a whiskey glass less than an hour ago looked like a stranger now.

The diamond ring on her finger glinted under the lamplight.

She stared at it, then whispered under her breath,

“I wish I’d stayed.”

Because for one fleeting moment, in that dingy bar with that dangerous man and his crooked smile, she hadn’t felt like a Kensington.

She’d just felt alive.

Let RHeide0608 know what you thought about this chapter!
Love this

7

Love this

Funny

0

Funny

Spicy

0

Spicy

Suspenseful

1

Suspenseful

Emotional

0

Emotional

Profound

2

Profound

Heartwarming

0

Heartwarming

Shocking

0

Shocking

Good Writing

1

Good Writing

Compelling Plot

0

Compelling Plot

Great Character

0

Great Character

Strong Dialog

0

Strong Dialog

Further Recommendations

 Mehrfach zurückgewiesene Gefährtin

Silvia: Sehr schön geschrieben, mit Spannung von Anfang bis Ende. Tolle Geschichte .

Read Now
Ein Kuss für den CEO

phelix21: Gesucht, leichte Kost für zwischendurchGefunden, viel Wahrheit in jedem Kapitel!Jedes Kapitel mit einem Tagebucheintrag zu beenden ist ein schöner schreibtechnischer Kniff.

Read Now
Luna de Verano - Die Gefährtin des Alphas (Band 1)

C.: Ich habe so oft herzhaft gelacht. Was für eine tolle Geschichte. So schön geschrieben. So schön, flüssig lesbar. Ich lieb‘s. Mir tun die Herren in der Geschichte fast leid, die Frauen sind reine Naturgewalten. Lustig, verschmitzt, offen, direkt. So schön. Danke für diese Geschichte und das wir sie l...

Read Now
Ruthless Lord

Ock: romance captivante. Hâte de lire la suite

Read Now
Stripped Shadows

Pfefferwinz: Richtig gut geschrieben und spannend bis zum Schluss.Ich kann es nur absolut empfehlen und bin auch schon bei der Fortsetzung, ... soweit wie sie eben schon fertig gestellt ist. Ich bin sehr gespannt was noch kommt ♥️Danke für die Bereicherung meiner Freizeit. Für mich der perfekte Ausgleich zumArbe...

Read Now
SECRET BILLIONAIRE

Janet: Very heart warning, shows what a kindness will be rewarded. Good reading.

Read Now
Silver's Second Chance

natstarr: Druid? That’s so interesting. Love these little surprises you give

Read Now
The Devil You Choose