Beauty in Blackmail

All Rights Reserved ©

Summary

They were never meant to be husband and wife. She was never meant to stand at that altar. And he was never meant to fall for a lie. When Isobel vanishes on the morning of her arranged mafia wedding, her quiet stepsister Mila is paid to take her place—just long enough to say the vows and disappear. But nothing is simple with Hugo Castellani, the cold, calculating head of the Castellani crime dynasty. He knows something is wrong with the woman in white… and he becomes obsessed with discovering why. Mila carries scars she never asked for and secrets she never chose. She steps into Hugo’s world expecting brutality—but instead finds a man who protects what’s his with terrifying devotion. A man who sees her fear, her strength, her fire… and refuses to let her slip away. And Hugo learns that Mila isn’t fragile. She isn’t helpless. She knows how to defend herself against the darkness she was raised in. He doesn’t shield her because she is a woman. He shields her because she is his woman. Arranged or not. Deceived or not. Blackmailed by fate or by choice. Bound by a lie, trapped in a marriage built on secrets, they find love in the one place nobody expected— in each other. She was his. And he was hers. Long before either of them dared to admit it.

Genre
Romance
Author
Mila
Status
Ongoing
Chapters
2
Rating
n/a
Age Rating
18+

Chapter 1 — Lies in Silk

Mila Hart had always known life could be cruel.

She just never realized cruelty could wear lipstick the color of fresh blood.

Isobel lounged on the ivory chaise like a queen punishing a servant, her wedding gown spilling around her like a cloud of lies. The silk shimmered beneath the golden morning light—a dress worth more than everything Mila owned in her entire life.

Mila, stop trembling,” Isobel said, voice sharp as the diamonds hanging from her ears. “You look pathetic when you shake.”

Mila swallowed hard. The scent of roses—Isobel’s perfume—hung in the air, making her throat tighten. She was allergic to roses, but that never mattered in this house. Nothing about Mila ever mattered.

Except now.

Now she mattered more than she wished she did.

Sit,” Isobel ordered, pointing to the stool beside her. “We don’t have time.”

Mila obeyed because there had never been another option. Her palms were cold, her breath unsteady. She tucked a strand of her dark hair behind her ear, trying not to let Isobel see the fear in her eyes.

Isobel leaned in.

Her voice dropped.

Her smile sharpened.

You’re going to marry Hugo Castellani for me.”

The world tilted.

Sound disappeared.

Blood rushed in Mila’s ears.

“I—Isobel, I can’t—”

You will.” Isobel’s tone was impatient, as if she were discussing a simple errand. “Hugo won’t notice. You look enough like me from a distance, and the veil will cover most of your face.”

Mila shook her head, dark waves falling around her shoulders. “No. No, I can’t. I could never—”

Isobel sighed dramatically, then picked up her phone and waved it in front of Mila’s face.

Think carefully before you say no.”

On the screen was a photo.

Her brother.

Noah.

Sleeping in his hospital bed, frail and hooked to machines that kept him breathing.

Machines Mila couldn’t afford.

Isobel tapped the screen.

“I told the hospital to hold off on today’s treatment. They’re waiting for my call.”

Air left Mila’s lungs in a shudder.

You wouldn’t…,” she whispered.

Isobel’s voice was ice wrapped in silk.

I would. And I have. Let me put this in simple terms for you, sister. You marry Hugo Castellani in my place,” she said, lifting Mila’s chin with a manicured finger, “or Noah dies.

Mila’s entire body went numb.

Not again.

Not another punishment.

Not someone else taking from her because she had no power.

Isobel stood and paced the room, her dress rustling like whispers of betrayal.The vow ceremony takes ten minutes. Ten. Afterward, you find an excuse to leave, I disappear, and the Castellanis won’t realize they were tricked until it’s too late.”

Mila tried to breathe.

I’ll be killed,” she said softly.

No,” Isobel said,you’ll be useful. A pawn. A little fake bride they won’t look at twice. Hugo doesn’t care who stands there—he only cares about sealing the alliance.”

Mila flinched.

Because Hugo Castellani wasn’t a man.

He was a dark reputation wrapped in perfect suits, a name spoken like a warning.

He was storms and shadows and whispered violence.

And she—

She was a girl with wild berry tea stains on her fingers, a girl who painted to escape, a girl with cigarette burn scars hidden beneath her blouse. A girl who had been taught her whole life to obey.

Mila.” Isobel’s voice softened, but the cruelty remained beneath.You want Noah alive, don’t you?”

A tear slipped down Mila’s cheek.

Her brother.

The only person who had never hurt her.

The only person who had held her on nights when the burns were new, whispering that one day they would escape.

Yes, she wanted him alive.

More than anything.

Isobel’s lips twitched in triumph.Good. Now stand up.”

Mila did.

Isobel grabbed the wedding dress—white silk, decadent lace, jeweled bodice—and thrust it into Mila’s arms. The fabric was cold, heavy, suffocating.

Put it on. Now.”

Mila’s hands shook. “Can’t I think about this? Even for a moment—”

“No.” Isobel’s eyes glinted. “Time’s up. If you don’t walk down that aisle in the next two minutes, Hugo Castellani will come looking. And trust me… you want to avoid that.”

Mila pressed the dress to her chest.

It felt like holding a blade.

Beautiful, sharp, and meant to cut.

Isobel stepped closer, her breath brushing Mila’s cheek.Do this for Noah. Or live with his death.”

Her voice was soft, almost tender, and it broke something inside Mila.

Because she wasn’t choosing to be brave.

She wasn’t choosing to be a hero.

She was being forced into a silk cage.

And still—

she nodded.

She had no choice.

Good girl,Isobel said, stroking Mila’s cheek with a false affection that made her skin crawl. When this is over, you’ll go back to being invisible. Just the way you like it.”

But something inside Mila whispered a warning:

Nothing about this would end quietly.

Nothing about Hugo Castellani was safe.

And nothing about wearing another woman’s name would let her stay invisible.

Still, she stepped behind the screen and pulled the wedding gown over her trembling body. The fabric slid against her skin like a lie whispered in the dark.

When she emerged, Isobel’s eyes widened.

Mila looked…

beautiful.

Haunting.

Broken in a way no silk could hide.

Her brown eyes—soft, warm, shaped by years of quiet suffering—glimmered with unshed tears. Her hair, long and dark, spilled over her shoulders like shadowed silk. Her lips trembled, not with vanity, but with the weight of the betrayal she was about to carry down the aisle.

For the first time, Isobel looked almost startled.Perfect,” she murmured.Absolutely perfect.”

Mila felt sick. Her stomach twisted. Her scars burned beneath the lace.

Isobel pressed a veil into her hands.

Remember,” she whispered,this is just a role. You walk in, say the vows, and walk out.”

But Mila knew better.

Nothing about this day—

nothing about this dress—

nothing about this lie—

would let her walk away clean.

As she followed Isobel out of the room, the world outside glittered with chandeliers and laughter, a celebration built on the bones of truth.

And somewhere across the estate, waiting at the altar, stood Hugo Castellani.

The man she’d lie to.

The man she’d marry.

The man who would become her greatest danger.

Mila closed her eyes.

All for Noah. All for love.

All for a lie in silk.

CHAPTER ONE — Lies in Silk (Hugo’s POV)

Isobel might think she got away… but I have eyes everywhere.”

The cathedral was suffocating.

Gold-leaf ceilings, stained-glass saints watching from above, a thousand candles flickering like trembling witnesses. The Castellani wedding was supposed to be a spectacle—an alliance sealed in vows and bloodless diplomacy. Hugo had accepted it as such. A transaction. A necessity. Nothing more.

He stood at the altar in a tailored black suit, expression carved from marble, hands behind his back, the picture of mafia royalty. Around him, guests whispered, shifting in their seats, anticipating a union between two powerful families.

But Hugo felt nothing.

Not excitement.

Not nerves.

Not hope.

He hadn’t felt much of anything in years—not since the accident.

Marriage to Isobel Hart was simply business. A political arrangement. She was vain, spoiled, sharp-tongued, and careless—but she was predictable. And predictable was safe.

He could manage predictable.

The orchestra began a soft, ceremonial swell. The doors at the end of the cathedral creaked open.

Hugo exhaled, bored already.

Then he saw her.

The breath left his lungs.

A bride stepped into the light.

But she did not move like Isobel.

She did not look like Isobel.

This woman—

This woman was something else entirely.

Her silhouette was trembling beneath layers of silk, delicate yet haunting. The gown clung to her frame like moonlight captured in fabric. Her hands were small, fingers curled tightly around the bouquet.

Her walk was hesitant.

Her shoulders drawn in.

Her head bowed, as if she carried a secret that could crush her.

A strange heat twisted in Hugo’s chest—sharp, unexpected.

His pulse kicked up.

Why?

This wasn’t Isobel.

He knew it instantly.

Isobel Hart walked like she owned every room she entered.

This woman walked like she hoped no one would notice her.

Isobel’s perfume was roses—suffocating and sweet.

This woman smelled faintly of something softer… wild berries, perhaps. Something real.

Hugo’s jaw tensed.

What the hell is this?

She reached the halfway point of the aisle, still hidden behind her veil. The music swelled, the guests sighed in admiration, oblivious to the shift in the air.

But Hugo noticed everything.

Her height was slightly shorter.

Her posture different.

Her hands… too gentle, too unsure.

Her breath unsteady beneath the lace.

A stranger.

A bride he did not choose.

And yet—

his body reacted to her.

Heat curled low in his stomach.

Arousal.

Interest.

Possessive tension he had no intention of feeling.

For the first time in a long time, Hugo Castellani felt alive.

By the time she reached him, his heartbeat was no longer steady. He extended his hand slowly, masking the storm beneath his skin.

Her fingers slipped into his.

Soft. Cold. Trembling.

Not Isobel.

Not even close.

Hugo leaned in—subtle, intimate, threatening.

The cathedral watched, believing it to be devotion. They didn’t hear the warning in his voice.

“Your perfume is different.”

The bride froze.

Her shoulders went rigid.

She didn’t answer.

Hugo allowed a slow, razor-edged smile to touch his lips.

It’s bold of you to think I wouldn’t notice.”

Still nothing.

Her pulse hammered against his palm.

Fear.

She was terrified.

And for reasons he couldn’t name, that fear slid down his spine like warm smoke.

Intriguing.

Addicting.

Dangerous.

But he kept his composure, turning her gently toward the priest.

The ceremony began.

Every vow spoken felt like a game.

Every second, he studied her.

The tremor in her fingers.

The way her breath hitched when he touched her hand.

The way she kept her face down, hiding beneath the veil.

When the priest finally said, “Lift the veil,” Hugo felt the entire cathedral exhale.

But he did not rush.

He lifted the veil slowly.

Deliberately.

Like unwrapping something forbidden.

And then—

God.

Her face.

She was breathtaking.

Not polished like Isobel.

Not arrogant.

Not hardened.

This girl—this stranger—had eyes that carried storms of their own. Brown with flecks of gold, wide with fear, framed by dark lashes. Her lips were soft and trembling. Her skin glowed against the white silk, fragile yet striking.

An innocent wearing a guilty dress.

For a split second, Hugo forgot to breathe.

This wasn’t just a switch.

This wasn’t just a lie.

This was an insult.

A provocation.

A challenge.

But instead of anger, a strange hunger took its place.

His bride—fake or not—was exquisite.

Too exquisite to let walk away.

So he leaned forward, his mouth brushing the shell of her ear, his voice soft enough that only she could hear.

Isobel might think she got away,” he whispered, “but I have eyes everywhere.”

Her body shuddered.

Good.

She understood.

He tilted her chin gently, forcing her to look at him.

Those terrified golden-flecked eyes met his, and something inside him tightened painfully.

She wasn’t Isobel.

She wasn’t meant to be his.

But in that moment, Hugo Castellani made a silent decision.

She would be.

He took her hand again, firmer this time.

When he spoke his vow, it rang through the cathedral like a vow made in blood.

“I do.”

He felt her breath catch.

The priest turned to Mila—though no one knew her name yet.

And do you—”

Her voice came out barely above a whisper.

…I do.”

And with those words—

with that trembling surrender—

she belonged to him.

Not because she was the bride he expected.

Not because of the alliance.

Not because of duty.

But because the moment he looked into her eyes, Hugo knew:

He wasn’t letting her go.

Not now.

Not ever.