We Were Supposed to Be Strangers
Share with your friends
Customize readability

We Were Supposed to Be Strangers

This story contains themes of: assault, attempted rape, cheating, domestic violence, drug use overdose, racism, sexual assault abuse, torture, violent death, explicit imagery

All Rights Reserved ©

Summary

Angelina D'Amato was twenty-three and pregnant when Vincenzo went to prison. Twenty-three and terrified that the life he chose would swallow their daughter he didn't know about whole before she even took her first breath. So she had to make a choice. Walk away or watch everything burn. She chose to walk away. Seven years later, 1995 NYC, she's an undercover NYPD agent with a new face and a singular focus. She's to infiltrate the Castellano crime family and take down their Consigliere. The job is dangerous. The target is deadly. And when she sits across from Vincenzo Vitale for the first time as "Marianna Marino," she realizes the worst part isn't the risk of being killed. It's that he still looks at her like she's the only person in the room. Vincenzo Vitale spent seven years building an empire on the ashes of everything he lost. Prison taught him control. Power taught him patience. Being Consigliere taught him that sentiment gets you killed. Angelina broke him, but he had moved on. He turned off his emotions and let the dark mafioso life consume his soul. There was no more room for heartbreak, and he'd learned to live in the dark until she became the light he didn't want. When the blonde woman walked into his world, something about her unravels him in ways he can't explain. She's too smart for her own good. Too familiar in moments that shouldn't feel familiar at all. He tells himself it's attraction or chemistry and nothing more. Until Vincenzo is hit with the realization that she is not some ordinary blonde, but the woman he used to love. Love doesn't always give you a choice. Sometimes it just gives you a reckoning and the knowledge that some people were never meant to be strangers, no matter how hard you tried to make them disappear.

Status
9mo ago
Chapters
20
Rating
n/a
Age Rating
18+

Chapter 1: Glass & Gilt

The city wore evening like a mink thrown over bare shoulders: brazen and a little cold. Midtown climbed the sky in mirrored teeth as the town car slid up to Rockefeller Plaza, and Angelina watched her reflection fracture across the tinted glass. Six months deep and the legend still fit like a second skin, but some nights, when the light hit wrong, she could see the seams.

Marianna Marino, she reminded herself. You’re Marianna tonight. You’re always Marianna.

The Rainbow Room’s chandeliers burned like captured constellations forty floors above, and every man stepping out onto the carpet pretended he’d hung them there himself.

Angelina was all black silk dress. The fabric clung to her elegantly, but shaped her dangerously. The slit the way up her thigh was like an inviting trap, but her blue eyes gleamed with control while her blonde hair cascaded down her back like a golden waterfall.

Carlo “Charmer” Vitelli offered his arm the moment her first, lethally sharp heel touched pavement. “Stellina, you’re trouble.”

She slid in close, eyes laughing, her voice like smooth velvet laced with polished Brooklyn warmth. “Only the good kind, yeah? The kind you brag about in confession.”

He grinned, delighted. “Capisce. Then tonight, you’re my miracle.”

“Miracles ain’t free,” she murmured, brushing his lapel smooth. “You want charm, you feed me first.”

Inside, the Rainbow Room turned above Manhattan like a slow gold clock. She moved the way a seasoned hostess moves, someone who’d learned hospitality at her mother’s table, where every guest was treated like family whether you trusted them or not. Cheek-kisses, wrist-touches, a laugh that rang like a spoon on crystal.

“Auguri, Judge,” to a rope-shouldered man with a tan too deep for February.

“Mrs. Ferraro, you look like a Valentino sketch,” to a councilman’s wife whose smile doubled under the compliment.

To the maître d’: “Do me a solid, tesoro: two seats by the north windows? My guy promised me the view.”

Carlo watched her work the floor, pride softening his features. “Look at you,” he said under the band’s “Summer Wind,” “givin’ lessons.”

She bumped his shoulder. “Please. I’m just sayin’ hello like my ma taught me.”

Except Ma never taught me how to smile at killers, she thought. That I learned on my own.

The assignment had started simply enough: paper trails and permits, a bureaucratic maze Carlo’s people couldn’t navigate without leaving fingerprints. The Aureum nightclub was two signatures from shutdown when she’d breezed in with a leather folder and a smile that made inspectors forget why they’d come in the first place.

“You’re short a floor-load letter, and the railing height reads wrong,” she’d told the sweating manager, voice velvet-warm. “But I got a guy at DOB who hates mess. We bring cannoli, we fix the mess.”

By the time the inspector arrived, she’d staged a tidy miracle: corrected plans, fresh affidavit, a polite route to compliance pending. Carlo had watched from the bar, sipping Campari, clocking the way the inspector lowered his voice when she touched his elbow.

Afterward, on the curb, he’d offered her his lighter. “You always make federal problems look like coffee stains?”

She’d taken a drag, mouth curving. “Only when the shirts are expensive.”

From there it became late-night contract clinics and daytime drives in a town car that smelled like cedar and money. Carlo learned her rhythms; she learned his tells. When he was nervous, he rolled his cufflink. When he lied, his left eye smiled a breath too slow. He treated her like a queen in public: chairs pulled, doors opened, the gentle palm at her back that said mine.

She let him believe it. That was the job.

What Lieutenant DeLuca’s briefing hadn’t prepared her for, what no amount of tactical training could brace her against, was the name buried halfway down the hierarchy chart.

Vincenzo “Vice” Vitale — Consigliere.

She’d been standing in her kitchen when she opened that file. Coffee going cold in her hand. The words had blurred, then sharpened, then blurred again.

Vinny. Fucking... Vinny.

Not the boy who’d loved her in the dark. Not the man she’d left behind in a prison cell with their daughter growing inside her. This was something else. Something polished and dangerous and untouchable.

Of course he’d climbed. Of course he’d become this.

She’d left him with nothing, and he’d built an empire on the bones of it.

And now she had to stand in the same room and pretend she’d never known his name.

Tonight, she tucked herself under Carlo’s arm, warm and public, and let the room see exactly what they expected: a beautiful woman who knew how to make powerful men feel even more powerful.

They made rounds.

Marco “The Bookie” Romano laughed so hard at her quip about “accountants with rosaries” that he slapped the table.

Frankie “No Nose” Bellini kissed both her cheeks and called her fortuna.

Dominic “Ice” Vescari appraised her like she was a well-cut stone and said nothing at all, which meant he was paying attention.

Rocco “Rock” Manzetti lifted his glass and she answered with a wink that said I see you, paesà.

Anthony “Silk” Castellano drifted past with a cadre of enforcers, and the room bent subtly in his wake. She filed the geometry of power the way a painter studies light. Donna Castellano floated through a knot of donors in columnar silk, her smile cool and assessing when it met Angelina’s.

Two women. Same room. Different wars.

Carlo leaned close. “You’re a natural, Anna.”

“Nah,” she said, straightening his tie with careful fingers. “I just remember names. And I let people be shiny.” She squeezed his hand. “Now be shiny, amore.”

Babbeo, she thought. Sweet, stupid fool.

Carlo didn’t know how many hours she’d spent memorizing faces, names, family trees, business fronts. He didn’t know about the dead drops or the wire recordings or the way she scrubbed herself raw in the shower some nights, trying to wash Marianna off her skin.

He didn’t know that every smile cost her something.

This was her debut in their eyes: the beautiful blonde Carlo couldn’t stop talking about. Tonight she had to be more than believable. She had to be inevitable. A woman these men would protect because she made their world feel warmer, softer, like they were something other than what they were.

She was good at that. Making monsters feel human.

Near the windows, the skyline broke open: rivers like molten pewter, bridges strung with stars. Carlo turned her to face him, thumbs resting at her waist as though there were already music playing.

“After the handshakes,” he said, “we dance.”

She tapped his chin with a manicured finger, her voice dropping to silk. “And after the dance?”

“We eat.”

“And?”

“We behave.” But the sinful curve of his mouth told her otherwise.

“If I behave now,” she murmured, leaning close enough that her breath warmed his jaw, “then misbehave with me later. Deal?”

“Deal.” His grin widened. “This is why I said you’re trouble.”

She laughed—Marianna’s laugh, bright and easy—and let him spin her toward the glass.

The band slid into “The Best Is Yet to Come,” and New York turned beneath their feet like a record. For a moment, she let herself feel it: the music, the light, the illusion of safety.

Then she felt it.

That old, animal awareness. The way air goes still before a storm.

A pocket of space quieted across the room. Heads turned with a subtle deference that didn’t need to be announced. Men who rarely stepped aside stepped aside.

Her pulse kicked once, hard, before she forced it down.

Don’t look. Don’t look yet.

But her body knew before her eyes confirmed it.

He stood near the north windows, backlit by the city he’d conquered. Taller than memory. Sharper. The boy she’d loved had been all restless energy and reckless charm. This man was composed, controlled in a way that made the room recalibrate by instinct alone.

Vincenzo Vitale.

Vice.

Donna Castellano’s hand rested in the crook of his elbow, elegant and possessive. He was laughing at something Anthony Silk had said: that low, genuine laugh she used to pull from him in the dark when it was just them and the city lights and promises they’d both believed.

Her chest tightened.

Six months of preparation. Six months of watching him from across rooms, memorizing the new lines in his face, the way power had settled into his shoulders like a well-tailored suit. Six months of being so careful not to let him see her, really see her.

But tonight was different.

Tonight, Marianna Marino would have to stand close enough to shake his hand. To meet his eyes. To smile and charm and perform while every cell in her body screamed recognition.

Tonight she would stand three feet from the father of her child and pretend she didn’t know the exact shade of hazel in his eyes when the light hit them just right.

You can do this, she told herself. You’ve done harder.

That was a lie. Nothing had ever been harder than this.

Carlo’s voice pulled her back. “Come on, stellina.” His palm settled warm at her spine, thumb tracing that lazy circle she knew so well: possessive, practiced. “Tonight we’re rubbin’ elbows, capisce? Smile, take a bow. You’re my lucky charm. ’Member that.”

She turned into him, letting her smile bloom slow and easy. “How could I forget? You remind me every five minutes.”

“’Cause it’s true.”

“Then let’s go be lucky together.”

With her hand laced through his arm, Carlo guided her forward: toward the north windows, toward the skyline, toward the center of the turning room.

Toward Vincenzo Vitale.

She painted Marianna’s smile across her face and let it hold.

The legend didn’t shake.

Not yet.

Let LunarCosmos know what you thought about this chapter!

Chapter Notes

Hey there, beautiful souls!

Welcome toWe Were Supposed to Be Strangers.This is my very first story here on Wattpad, and honestly? I’m equal parts terrified and excited to share this with you. If you’re here, you probably searched for something dark, dangerous, and deliciously complicated. Good news: you found it.

This is for the girls who root for morally gray men in expensive suits. For the readers who live for that “he doesn’t know my secret” angst and the inevitable moment. This is for the girlies who want to do something bad, know it’s a bad idea, but do it anyway. It’s also for the readers who are here for everything when it all comes crashing down. If you’ve ever looked at a mafia romance and thought,“But what if she had a secret baby AND was undercover to take him down?“, then babe, grab your wine or coffee, get cozy, and let’s ruin our lives together.

Fair warning:Angelina and Vinny’s story isn’t a fluffy rom-com. It’s messy. It’s painful. It’s the kind of love that leaves scars. But that’s the best kind, right?

What You’re Getting Into:

Tropes:

Mafia Romance

Undercover Agent

Secret Baby

Second Chance Romance

Forbidden Love

Enemies to Lovers

Exes

Forced Proximity

Touch Her and Die energy

Morally Gray MMC (he’s a whole consigliere, what did you expect?)

Content Warnings & Trigger Warnings:

Please take care of yourself, loves. This story contains:

⚠️Violence & Crime:This is a mafia story—expect guns, violence, organized crime, morally questionable decisions, and blood

⚠️Sexual Content:Mature/explicit scenes (this is an 18+ story)

⚠️Strong Language:These characters curse like the New Yorkers they are

⚠️Emotional Angst:Heartbreak, betrayal, complicated relationships, secrets, and lies

⚠️Pregnancy/Secret Baby:Off-page pregnancy in backstory, child character present

⚠️Themes of Abandonment:Character left in prison, estrangement, family trauma

⚠️Morally Gray Characters:No one here is a saint (and we love them for it)

⚠️Mentions of Domestic Violence:Mentions and flashbacks of past abuse

⚠️Violence Against Minors (backstory):Reference to a character committing assault as a child

⚠️Racism & Racial Slurs:To maintain realism, some characters (particularly within the crime family) use racist language and hold prejudiced views. This reflects the reality of organized crime in 1995 NYC, not the author’s beliefs. These moments are not glorified.

⚠️Sexual Assault:References to and/or depictions of non-consensual situations. Reader discretion is strongly advised.

If any of these are difficult for you, please prioritize your well-being. Your mental health matters more than any story. 💙

A Few Notes:

Setting:1995 New York City—before cell phones, before social media, when secrets could actually stay secret. Expect landlines, pagers, and all that nostalgic ’90s goodness.

POV:3rd person dual POV

Update Schedule: I plan on posting Mondays, Wednesdays & Fridays.

Let’s Be Friends:I LIVE for your comments. Yell at me when Vinny does something stupid. Cry with me when Angelina’s heart breaks. Ship these disaster humans with your whole chest. This is a judgment-free zone where we can all be feral about fictional Italians together.

Disclaimer:

This is a work of fiction. Any resemblance to actual persons (living or dead), places, or events is purely coincidental. The Castellano crime family is entirely made up—please don’t come for me, actual mob families.

All rights reserved. Please don’t copy, reproduce, or distribute this work without permission. I worked really hard on this, and Vinny will personally have words with anyone who steals it. (Kidding. Mostly.)

Okay, the story you came here for is waiting below.

Buckle up, besties. It’s about to getcomplicated.

xoxo,Lunar Cosmos🌙✨

P.S. - If you enjoy this story, votes and comments make my entire day (week? month? year?). And if you really love it, add it to your reading list so you don’t miss updates.

Further Recommendations

Velvet Triggers

Vivian: So what happen to the mile. Love the story but stull unfinished know got 2nd book when will it be out . Love age gap

Read Now
The Biker (Book 1)

Kandy-Writes: Literally so hooked on this! My wifi went out mid-read for two whole hours and I had to restart everything and I mean everything on a different device vro and I was stressed because I needed to know what happened next lol. Made it to chapter 19 and Dante and Victoria’s banter and slow burn are top t...

Read Now
Three Desires

Jacque: This book is an emotional rollercoaster and I loved the ride.I was & am "all in"

Read Now
Sangue e Inchiostro (Blood and Ink)

Palo London: A story of great depth & well written with imagery to make you feel as if you were there...witnessing everything first hand.

Read Now
The De La Cruz Return

Portia Cassim: Absolutely amazing. Just shows never think you are better.Lerenzo is absolutely great. The love he shows for his family is priceless.All the characters just fit. I love Dean. You need to somehow soundproof those rooms. HR needs to step in not only provide the raise.Leo is just the best. Mia buying a...

Read Now
Mafia's Pet: His Dangerous Obsession (Edited)

Rain_55: This is definitely one of the best books I've read here. It literally kept me in suspense and a whirlwind of emotions from the first page to the last. Kudos to the author, keep it up 👌😍🍀

Read Now
His Contract wife

Jacqueline: Good reading

Read Now
The Ruin of Us

Susan Morris: Is this the ending?? with Dante blocking her?? OR will there be a sequel? If this is the ending, I did not like it. I loved the plot, the intrigue, the characters, but not the stooping point of the book.

Read Now
The Fourth Offer

Daphne : Love the suspense, the anticipation, boundaries and the romance

Read Now