When We Were Infinite

All Rights Reserved ©

Summary

Maya Chen has twenty-three years, two duffel bags, and a one-way ticket to Denver. She's running from a cancelled wedding, a suffocating hometown, and everyone's expectations of who she should be. She doesn't expect to meet Levi—the wandering musician with secrets in his smile and a guitar on his back. He was supposed to go to Nashville. She was supposed to disappear. Instead, they collide in a new city where neither of them belongs. What starts as coffee and late-night conversations becomes something neither can walk away from. But Maya came to Denver to learn how to stand still, and Levi's always been someone who runs. When his dreams pull him to LA and hers root her in Colorado, they face an impossible choice: follow love or follow yourself? This is a story about brave beginnings, messy endings, and finding home in the last place you expected. It's about the people who change us, the places that save us, and learning that sometimes the bravest thing you can do is stay. Perfect for fans of Emily Henry and Taylor Jenkins Reid—a heart-wrenching, hopeful love story about what we leave behind and what we finally keep. Your Denver is waiting. Are you brave enough to find it?

Status
Complete
Chapters
1
Rating
n/a
Age Rating
18+

A Story of Love, Loss, and Fresh Starts

The thing about leaving everything behind is that you never really leave it all.

Maya stood in the parking lot of the Greyhound station, her entire life compressed into two duffel bags and a backpack that cut into her shoulders. Twenty-three years old, and this was it. Everything she owned could fit in the overhead compartment. Her phone buzzed. Mom. She declined the call for the fourth time that morning.

The bus to Denver would leave in seven minutes. She’d never been to Denver. Didn’t know a single person there. That was exactly the point.

“You running from something or toward something?”

Maya turned. The guy looked about her age, maybe a little older, with dark hair that fell into his eyes and a smile that seemed like it knew secrets. He wore a faded denim jacket despite the August heat.

“Does it matter?” she asked.

“Probably not.” He shifted the guitar case on his back. “I’m Levi.”

“Maya.”

“Well, Maya, I hope Denver’s ready for you.”

She almost smiled. “You heading there too?”

“Nashville, actually. Though I’ll probably end up wherever the bus breaks down.” He said it like a joke, but something in his voice felt heavy, like he meant it more than he was letting on.

The bus driver called for boarding.

“Good luck with whatever you’re running from,” Levi said, already turning away.

“You too,” Maya called after him.

She didn’t expect to see him again. That was the whole point of running—you didn’t see anyone again.

Denver was overwhelming in the way only a new city could be. Maya found a room in a shared house in Capitol Hill, started waitressing at a breakfast place called The Griddle, and tried very hard not to think about the life she’d left in Ohio.

Three weeks in, she was wiping down tables when someone slid into the booth by the window.

“Small world.”

She looked up. Levi.

“I thought you were going to Nashville,” Maya said, the dishrag frozen in her hand.

“I was. Then the transmission gave out in Kansas, and I figured the universe was telling me something.” He grinned. “Turns out Denver has open mic nights too.”

Against her better judgment, Maya sat down. “You’re a musician.”

“Trying to be. Right now, I’m mostly a guy who plays guitar at coffee shops for tips.” He leaned back. “What about you? What does someone run to Denver for?”

“Fresh start.”

“From?”

“Everything.” The word came out harder than she meant it.

Levi didn’t push. That was the first thing she liked about him—he understood the weight of not asking.

“There’s an open mic tonight at The Clockwork,” he said instead. “You should come.”

“I don’t really do crowds.”

“You work at a restaurant.”

“That’s different. I’m invisible there.”

“Maybe that’s the problem,” Levi said quietly.

She went. She told herself she wouldn’t, but at nine PM she found herself walking into The Clockwork, a bar that smelled like beer and possibility. Levi was on stage, just him and his guitar, playing something that sounded like heartbreak felt. His voice was rough around the edges in a way that made you lean in closer.

Maya ordered a whiskey she couldn’t afford and listened.

When he finished, he found her at the bar. “You came.”

“Don’t let it go to your head.”

“Too late.” But he was smiling, and she realized she was too.

They talked until last call. About everything and nothing. He told her about growing up in a small town in Montana where everyone knew everyone, and he’d felt like he was suffocating. She told him about her mom, who loved her so much it felt like drowning. About her ex-fiancé, Tyler, who’d been perfect on paper and completely wrong in reality.

“I left two weeks before the wedding,” Maya said, the whiskey making her honest. “Everyone called me selfish. Maybe they were right.”

“Or maybe you were brave,” Levi said.

“I don’t feel brave. I feel like I ruined everything.”

“Everything was already ruined if you had to run.”

They walked back toward her house, the Denver night cool and infinite around them. At her door, Levi stopped.

“Can I see you again?”

“This seems like a bad idea,” Maya said.

“The best things usually are.”

It started slowly. Coffee on Tuesday mornings before her shift. Late-night texts when neither could sleep. Him teaching her guitar chords on his secondhand acoustic, her hands fumbling over strings while he laughed and adjusted her fingers.

“You’re terrible at this,” he said.

“I know.”

“It’s kind of endearing.”

“Shut up.”

But she was smiling, and he was close enough that she could count his eyelashes, and then somehow they were kissing, and it felt like the first real breath she’d taken in years.

“Bad idea,” she whispered against his mouth.

“The worst,” he agreed, and kissed her again.

They became inseparable in the way you can only be when you’re both running from something. They explored Denver like tourists—Red Rocks at sunrise, dive bars in Five Points, late-night diners where they were the only customers. Levi played anywhere that would let him. Maya started going to every show, became the girl in the front who knew all the words, even though he’d just written them. He wrote a song about her. Called it “Parking Lot Girl.”

“That’s terrible,” she said when he played it for her.

“You love it.”

She did. She loved all of it. She loved him, though she hadn’t said it yet, because saying it made it real, and real things could be lost.

Four months in, Maya’s mom showed up at The Griddle. Maya saw her through the window and felt her whole chest tighten. Patricia Chen looked smaller than she remembered, older, wearing the blue cardigan Maya had bought her for Christmas two years ago. She almost ran. Then her mom looked up, and their eyes met, and Maya knew she couldn’t.

“Hi, baby,” her mom said when Maya stepped outside.

“How did you find me?”

“You used your credit card. I’ve been tracking the charges.” Patricia twisted her hands. “I just wanted to make sure you were okay.”

“I’m okay.”

“Are you?”

Maya wanted to lie. Instead, she said, “I’m trying to be.”

They sat on the curb, right there on Colfax Avenue, and her mom cried.

“I thought I was losing you,” Patricia said. “You just disappeared.”

“I couldn’t breathe there anymore, Mom. Everything was about Tyler, the wedding, and being who everyone expected. I couldn’t do it.”

“I just want you to be happy.”

“I know. But your version of happy was killing me.”

It was the most honest they’d been in years. Maybe ever.

Her mom stayed in Denver for two days. Met Levi, who charmed her despite himself. Saw Maya’s tiny room, her new life, the person she was trying to become.

“He’s good for you,” Patricia said at the airport. “I can see it.”

“You’re not mad?”

“I’m terrified. But you’re smiling again. You haven’t smiled like this in years.” She hugged Maya tight. “Be careful with your heart.”

“I will.”

But she knew she wouldn’t. Her heart was already gone.

Winter came. Levi got a regular Thursday slot at a better venue. Maya got promoted to shift manager. They moved in together, a studio apartment in Baker that barely fit a bed and his guitar collection. It should have been perfect. But Levi started getting restless. Maya could see it in the way he stared out the window, the way his fingers moved even when he wasn’t playing.

“What is it?” she asked one night, both of them tangled in sheets that smelled like them.

“Nothing.”

“Levi.”

He sighed. “I got an email. A producer in LA heard one of my recordings. Wants to meet.”

Maya’s heart dropped. “That’s amazing.”

“Is it?”

“Of course it is. This is what you want.”

“I don’t know what I want anymore.” He turned to face her. “I came to Denver to figure myself out. Then I found you, and suddenly everything got complicated.”

“Love’s supposed to be complicated.”

“You love me?”

She hadn’t meant to say it. “Yeah. I do.”

“I love you too.” He said it as it hurt. “That’s the problem.”

He went to LA for the meeting. Came back three days later, quiet and distant.

“How was it?” Maya asked.

“Good. Really good. They want to sign me.”

“Levi, that’s incredible!”

“I’d have to move. To Los Angeles. They want me in the studio full-time.”

There it was. The thing they’d both been avoiding.

“When?”

“End of the month.”

Three weeks. They had three weeks.

“Come with me,” Levi said suddenly.

“What?”

“Come to LA. We’ll both start fresh. Together.”

Maya felt the words like a fist. “I just got here.”

“I know, but—”

“You want me to run again? To leave what I’ve built here?”

“I’m not asking you to run. I’m asking you to come with me.”

“It’s the same thing,” Maya said, and she could hear her voice breaking. “I can’t keep running, Levi. I ran from Ohio. I can’t run from Denver, too.”

“So what are you saying?”

“I’m saying I need to stay. I need to prove to myself I can build something that lasts.”

“What about us?”

“I don’t know.” The tears came then. “I don’t know.”

They tried to make it work. Long distance, they said. People do it all the time. But LA changed him. Or maybe it just revealed who he’d always been—someone who needed movement, needed change, needed the next thing always on the horizon. The calls got shorter. The visits got rarer.

Six months in, Maya knew it was over before he said the words.

“I met someone,” Levi said over FaceTime. He couldn’t even look at her.

Maya should have been devastated. Instead, she just felt tired.

“Okay.”

“Okay?”

“I mean, it’s not okay. But I understand.” She did. She really did. “You need someone who can run with you. I need to learn how to stand still.”

“I loved you,” he said.

“I know. I loved you too.”

Past tense. Both of them.

After they hung up, Maya cried. Then she got up, went to work, came home, and kept living.

A year passed. Then another. Maya became the person she’d moved to Denver to find. She got her own apartment, a nice one in Wash Park. Started taking classes at community college. Made friends who didn’t know Tyler, didn’t know Ohio, only knew this version of her. She stopped checking Levi’s Instagram. Stopped wondering what if.

On her twenty-sixth birthday, she went back to The Clockwork. Different bands now, different faces, but the same smell of beer and possibility.

“Is this seat taken?”

Maya looked up. The woman was pretty, with short dark hair and kind eyes.

“It’s all yours.”

“I’m Sara.”

“Maya.”

They talked through three bands. Sara was a nurse, new to Denver, recently divorced. She made Maya laugh in a way she hadn’t in months.

“Can I buy you a drink?” Sara asked.

“Yeah,” Maya said. “I’d like that.”

It wasn’t the same as it had been with Levi. It was quieter, steadier, less like running and more like finding your feet. Three months later, when Sara asked if Maya wanted to move in together, Maya said yes without hesitating.

The thing about leaving everything behind is that you take yourself with you. Maya understood that now. She’d run from Ohio, from Tyler, from her mom’s expectations. She’d found Levi and lost him. Found Denver and kept it. Found herself somewhere in between.

On a warm September morning, she got a text from an unknown number.

Hey. It’s Levi. I’m playing at Red Rocks next month. Sold out show. Wanted you to know. You’re the reason any of this happened.

Maya stared at the message for a long time. Then she smiled and deleted it. She didn’t need to go back to that.

Sara was in the kitchen making coffee, humming off-key, and Maya’s mom was visiting next week, and she had a shift at the restaurant where she was now assistant manager, and her psych midterm was on Thursday. Her life was full. Not perfect, but real. Built, not run to.

“Coffee’s ready,” Sara called.

“Coming,” Maya said.

And she meant it.

YOUR TURN

What are you running from? What are you running toward?

We all have a Denver waiting for us—that place where we finally learn to stand still. Share this story with someone who needs to hear it. Tag someone who’s searching for their own fresh start.

Because the truth is, the best stories aren’t about perfect endings. They’re about brave beginnings.

Drop a comment: What’s your Denver? Where’s the place you finally felt like yourself?

Let’s build something beautiful together—one share, one story, one brave choice at a time.

#WhenWeWereInfinite #FreshStart #BraveNotPerfect

If you loved this story, please:

❤️ LIKE this story to show your support💬 COMMENT below with your thoughts - I read every single one!🔄 SHARE with friends who need to read this⭐ LEAVE A REVIEW on Inkitt to help this story reach more readers

Your engagement helps this story rank higher on the Inkitt app and reach people who need it most. Every like, comment, share, and review makes a difference in growing our reading community!

Thank you for being part of this journey. Your support means everything! 📚✨

#WhenWeWereInfinite #FreshStart #BraveNotPerfect #InkittStories #ContemporaryRomance #BookLovers