​The Mystery of the Middle Stall
Share with your friends
Customize readability

​The Mystery of the Middle Stall

All Rights Reserved ©

Story Notes

​"This story is based on a real event that happened during my last days of school in 12th Commerce. The hallway you see on the cover is my actual school! I wanted to write this because the 'mystery' of that locked door turned our whole school day into a comedy-thriller, and I hope you enjoy the chaos as much as we did."

Summary

"What happens when the Principal and the entire Science department are defeated by a broken bathroom door? A comedy of errors in the girls' washroom."

Genre
Thriller
Author
Athrva
Status
9mo ago
Chapters
2
Rating
5.0 (1 review)
Age Rating
13+

Chapter 1

The school felt like a graveyard with a bell. It was the final week of the term, and with only a handful of us in the classroom, the empty hallways echoed every whisper. But the boredom ended the moment two of my classmates practically fell through the door, their faces pale.

"Someone is in the middle stall," one gasped. "We’ve been knocking for ten minutes. It’s locked from the inside, but... they won't answer."

The word 'Suicide' traveled through the room like a spark in a dry forest. Within minutes, the 'quiet' atmosphere vanished. Our lady teacher didn't just knock; she called for reinforcements. Suddenly, the girls' washroom—a place usually off-limits to any 'Sir'—became a high-stakes investigation site.

The Principal was there, looking deeply uncomfortable standing next to the sanitary bins. Behind him were the Science HOD and the 10th-grade teachers, all staring at the wooden door of the middle stall. It was a classic 'Impossible Crime'—the metal stopper was visibly slid into the bolt, but when the Science teacher squinted through the tiny gap in the door frame, he turned to the Principal and whispered, "Sir, there’s no one in there. But the stopper is closed."

I stood at the back, leaning against the cold tile wall. While my classmates were biting their nails and whispering about tragedies, I was actually enjoying the show. It was comedy gold to see the Science teacher trying to use "physics" and "vibrations" to explain how a door could lock itself.

In the middle of this high-tension 'crime scene,' the door to the washroom swung open. Two girls from the upper floor walked in, probably just wanting to check their hair. They stopped dead. Their eyes went wide as they saw the Principal, three 'Sirs,' and a crowd of students gathered around a toilet. Without a single word, they turned on their heels and bolted back up the stairs, probably convinced the faculty had finally lost their minds.

Just as the Principal was about to order someone to break the door down, the school cleaner walked in with a dripping mop. He looked at the crowd of important men with a bored expression.

"Sir, why are you all in here?" he asked, completely unimpressed.

"The door is locked from the inside!" the Science teacher exclaimed. "How is this possible? There's no space to reach over or under to slide the stopper!"

The cleaner sighed, reached out, and gave the door a very specific, sharp kick near the bottom hinge. With a loud clack, the vibration caused the loose, heavy stopper to slide backward out of the bolt. The door swung open to reveal... a completely empty, broken toilet.

"The flush is broken," the cleaner muttered, pushing his mop into the stall. "The door doesn't stay shut on its own, so I just slam it hard from the outside. The vibration makes the stopper slide into the lock so no one uses the broken toilet. I didn't think it would take a whole faculty meeting to figure that out."

The 'Sirs' stood in silence, defeated by a loose bolt and a well-placed kick, while I tried my best not to laugh out loud.


The End

Thank you so much for reading! This was a wild, true story from my school days, and I’m so glad I could share the "mystery" with you.

What did you think? I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments—did you guess the cleaner was the "mastermind" behind the lock?

Want more? I’m considering writing a follow-up chapter from the perspective of the two girls who ran away. Let me know if you’d be interested in reading that!

© imaginememories, 2026. All rights reserved.

"Follow my profile for more relatable school stories and 'impossible' mysteries!"

Let Athrva know what you thought about this chapter!

Further Recommendations

Home for the Holidays

May06: this is so entertaining

Read Now
Wild In Vegas (Original-Unedited)

CrimsonMabel: I really enjoyed your story! Sydney’s personality, the Vegas setting, and the chemistry between the characters feel very cinematic. I think this would look amazing as a comic/webtoon with proper character designs and illustrations. I actually got some ideas on how your story could be visually adapte...

Read Now
Rules of Fatals

Ingibabes511: Loved it. Thank you for an unusual read that was beautifully put together. Every tick box was covered somewhere within the story. Your way of creating a world that felt as if it could actually exist is breathtaking, where the descriptions brought it to life. Thank you again 🥰💜

Read Now
The Lycan King's Second Chance

Sherry: It is not fair to the reader when the Author does not finish the book. It would be nice to have an appropriate ending to let us know what happens to Atlas' mate, her father, and herself. Does she learn to use all of her powers?

Read Now
Until You’re Mine

𝑨𝒍𝒆𝒙𝒂𝒏𝒅𝒓𝒂 𝑫𝒓𝒆𝒆𝒓: What caught my attention about Until You’re Mine was how quickly an ordinary dating-app encounter became something unsettling. There’s an immediate sense that Gabrielle and Dane are approaching their match with very different intentions, and that makes even their early exchanges feel loaded.Dane’s p...

Read Now
Ashes & Lace

VeronicaLee92: Please please tell us your going to continue this story!!!!! Im so invested 😍 i would love to know what their future holds!!! Loved the twists and turns of the story line! This was such a good read!!

Read Now
Heated Circuits

emmylee.p.: I absolutely loved this read, funny and emotional, loved the characters so much.

Read Now
Pining for You | Red Logde Hearts - Book One

Jeanne: Loved this story from the beginning.The humor, the characters. Really liked the fact that Noah's perspective was very prominent.Just a sweet love story.Thank you!

Read Now
Red Velvet - Part 1: Prey

michele: Totally grabs you right away and then takes you for an amazing, hot, spicy, wild ride. Edge of your seat. Absolutely loved it!!!

Read Now