Thorns and Ivy: The Magical Tale of Petunia Evans
Share with your friends
Customize readability

Thorns and Ivy: The Magical Tale of Petunia Evans

dorowa

Summary

A lifelong Muggle woman consumed by regret—over a sister stolen by magic, a world that shut her out, and a lifetime of cruelty masking broken longing—dies at last, only to wake back in her ten-year-old self. But this time, when the acceptance letter for Hogwarts arrives for Lily Evans, a second, impossible envelope appears: one addressed to Petunia. Granted a second chance she never dared wish for, Petunia Evans must confront her jealousy, rewrite her choices, and walk through the gates of Hogwarts alongside her sister… even if it means facing the magic she once swore to hate.

Genre
Fantasy
Author
dorowa
Status
7mo ago
Chapters
3
Rating
n/a
Age Rating
13+

live again

I am Petunia Evans.

My nails are always trimmed to perfect shortness, edges filed smooth—no dirt beneath them, no ragged cuticles out of place. Every morning, Mother irons my cotton dresses until the fabric lies flat and crisp, like a newly opened book, no matter how I dash up the stairs or hunch over my desk for hours, lost in stories. I eat my meals at the exact same time each day, finish every sprout and carrot without a complaint, and speak only when spoken to—my voice soft, polite, never loud, never disruptive. To the neighbors on our quiet Cokeworth street, to our village primary school teachers, I am the model of a well-behaved girl: quiet, diligent, unassuming, the kind who never causes trouble and follows every rule to the letter.

Most evenings, Mother would gather Lily and me on the weathered garden bench, her arms loosely around us as sunlight filtered through the apple tree at the end of the yard, painting golden streaks across the grass. She’d talk of our futures with a warm, fond smile, her voice soft with maternal pride. “You two are the finest girls in town,” she’d say, pressing a gentle kiss to my head, then brushing a strand of unruly red hair from Lily’s forehead. “Lily, you’re bright and bold, cheerful and brave—no one in this world won’t adore you. And Petunia, you’re quiet and clever, so hardworking; you’ll do extraordinary things one day, I just know it. Maybe you’ll write novels, dear—beautiful, timeless books people will hold close to their hearts.”

I believed every word. I clung to that promise like a lifeline, an anchor to the ordinary, perfect life I dreamed of. I saved every copper penny from running errands for Mrs. Pollett at the corner store—forgoing lemon drops, colorful hair ribbons, the pretty paper dolls I ached for—until I had enough to walk to the shabby, dusty bookstore on the edge of town. The brass bell above the door jingled as I stepped inside, and I ran my finger over the leather-bound notebooks on the top shelf until I found one: small, deep blue, with crisp blank pages and a tiny silver clasp. I bought it with trembling hands, tucked it safely into my schoolbag, and that night, I wrote my name on the first page in neat, looping script: Petunia Evans, Future Novelist. It was the start of everything I thought I wanted.

For a little while, life was fair, equal, unbroken. We were two inseparable sisters, sharing a cozy bedroom, walking to school hand in hand, laughing at the same silly jokes, dreaming of the same quiet, happy future. We’d stay up late whispering about our first dances, first jobs, the nice, ordinary boys we’d marry, the little families we’d build. But that fragile peace shattered the day the strange, impossible things began happening to Lily.

It started small—so subtle I tried to pass it off as a trick of the light, or childish imagination. A wilted daisy on our windowsill blooming bright pink when Lily hummed a lullaby to it. A pencil rolling across her desk without her so much as glancing at it, as if pushed by an invisible hand. A windowpane trembling violently when she cried after a cruel boy teased her for her fiery red hair and quick temper. But the incidents grew bolder, more frequent—impossible to ignore. One afternoon, I watched Lily stand in the garden, close her eyes, and make a cluster of red roses float three feet off the ground, their petals swaying in a wind that didn’t blow. I also noticed a thin, quiet boy from the rough end of town—Severus Snape, the neighbors whispered, judgmental tones thick in the air—lingering at the edge of our garden, watching Lily with wide, curious, almost reverent eyes.

“Lily, stop this at once!” I snapped, my voice sharper than I meant it to be, my hands clenched into fists at my sides to hide their trembling. I marched over, grabbed her wrist roughly, and pulled her away from the floating flowers, my heart pounding with a primal, unnameable panic. “This is nonsense—foolish superstition, silly tricks! It’s not normal. If Mother or Father sees you, they’ll be terrified. People will call you a freak, whisper about our family, and we’ll be outcasts in this town.”

Lily’s bright emerald eyes filled with hot tears, her lower lip trembling like a scared kitten that’d been harshly scolded. “But Tuney, I can’t help it,” she whispered, her voice small and broken, thick with confusion and fear. “It’s real. The flowers listen to me, objects move when I’m upset or angry. I’m not doing it on purpose. Severus says it’s magic… that I’m a witch.”

The word hung between us—heavy, foreign, terrifying. Magic. I recoiled, scowling to mask my fear. “Don’t talk such ridiculous things,” I said, my voice softening a little but still firm, refusing to believe her. “There’s no such thing as magic. It’s all in your head. Now come inside, before someone sees you and starts talking.”

I softened, just for a moment, brushing her messy red hair away from her tear-streaked face. I loved Lily more than anything—more than my neatly pressed dresses, more than my precious blue notebook, more than the quiet order and normalcy I craved. But fear coiled in my chest like a cold, tight snake, a knot that tightened with every impossible thing Lily did. I feared she’d become someone I no longer recognized—foreign, strange, separated from me forever. I feared the villagers’ judgment, their stares and whispers. But most of all, I feared she’d walk into a world permanently closed to me—that I’d be left behind, trapped in the dull, monotonous ordinary, while she stepped into a world of wonder and light I could never reach.

Then the letter came.

At dawn, a small tawny barn owl landed at our bedroom window, its talons clutching a sealed envelope. The wax seal was embossed with a crest I’d never seen: a lion, an eagle, a badger, a snake, surrounding a large letter H. Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, the envelope read in elegant, looping script, addressed to Lily Evans.

Mother and Father wept with joy when they read it, pulling Lily into a tight, suffocating embrace—cooing over her, calling their little girl a miracle, their special witch. Overnight, I became invisible, a ghost in my own home. My perfect grades, my quiet diligence, my dream of becoming a novelist—none of it mattered anymore. I was just the ordinary one, the plain, unremarkable daughter, the leftover child with no magic, no special gifts, nothing to set me apart. Jealousy burned in me—hot, bitter, corrosive—a feeling I hated but couldn’t quash, no matter how hard I tried. I didn’t hate Lily, not truly; I loved her with every fiber of my being. But I envied her, more fiercely than I could bear—envied her magic, the world opening up to her, the chance to be more than ordinary.

That night, while Lily slept soundly, I crept to her window, where the tawny owl perched quietly on the sill. I begged the bird in a trembling, desperate whisper, tying a crumpled letter to its leg. It was addressed to Albus Dumbledore, Hogwarts’ Headmaster—the man who held the key to the world I craved. My handwriting was neat but shaky, every line filled with humble, broken pleading: Dear Professor Dumbledore, I am Petunia Evans, Lily’s elder sister. I beg you, please let me come to Hogwarts too. I want to learn magic, I want to stay with Lily, I don’t want to be left behind. Please give me a chance.

The owl returned two days later with a short, polite but unyielding note, in the same elegant script as the acceptance letter.

I am sorry, Miss Evans. Hogwarts is a school for young people with innate magical ability, and it is clear you possess no such talent. I wish you well in your ordinary life.

I sent one letter. Then ten. Then twenty. I lost count of the nights I stayed up late, writing by candlelight, tears staining the pages, begging for a chance I knew I didn’t deserve. But every reply was the same: polite, final, unyielding. You have no magic. Each rejection was a knife to my heart, slowly snuffing out every last spark of hope I had.

After that, I built a thick, impenetrable wall around myself—a wall of harsh words, cold disdain, bitter cruelty. I pretended to despise magic with every bone in my body, to loathe anything unusual, to call wizards freaks and their world a dark, dangerous nightmare. I mocked Lily’s excited Hogwarts stories, turned away in disgust when she showed me her small accidental magic, snapped at her cruelly every time she mentioned the wizarding world. I wrapped my fragile, broken heart in cruelty, my deep, unfulfilled longing in burning disgust—convinced that if I hated magic enough, the searing pain of being excluded would fade. It never did. I pushed Lily away with every cruel word, even as I ached to hold her close and never let go. I watched her grow brighter, more alive, more wonderful, while I withered in my ordinary life—trapped in the future I’d once wanted, now a gilded cage.

I lived that empty, hollow life for decades. I married Vernon Dursley—a loud, brutish, narrow-minded man who hated anything out of the ordinary, a man who fit perfectly into the mundane, safe world I’d resigned myself to. I had a son, Dudley—a spoiled, selfish boy who knew nothing of magic and cared only for his own comfort. I grew old, my hair turning white, my face lined with wrinkles, living a quiet, uneventful life in our prim, boring house. Vernon died a few years before me, peaceful in his sleep. Dudley grew up, married a plain, ordinary woman, and had two spoiled children of his own. To the outside world, I had a perfect, respectable, ordinary life. But inside, I was empty—consumed by a regret so deep it ached to my bones.

Every single day, I thought of Lily. Her bright emerald eyes, her wild red hair, the magic she’d tried so hard to share with me. Dumbledore’s polite rejections, the countless letters I’d sent, the hope I’d lost forever. I regretted every harsh word, every time I’d pushed her away, every moment I’d let jealousy and fear come between us. I regretted never telling her how much I loved her, how much I’d wanted to stay by her side, how much I’d craved the world she’d been given. I regretted being ordinary, being left behind, being forever locked out of the magical world that had taken my sister from me.

I took my last breath in that quiet, empty house, my heart heavy with a lifetime of unspoken regret and sorrow, and closed my eyes, ready to fade into nothingness.

When I opened them again, sunlight streamed through the window of my childhood bedroom in Cokeworth, gilding the pages of my long-forgotten blue notebook on the desk. I heard Lily’s laughter floating up from the garden below—bright, carefree, full of the innocent joy I remembered so well. I lifted my hands—small, smooth, unwrinkled: ten-year-old hands, perfect and clean, free of the lines of a long, empty life.

I was ten years old again, back in the little house where I’d grown up—back before the letter, before the rejections, before the unbridgeable rift between my sister and me tore us apart forever.

Let dorowa know what you thought about this chapter!

Further Recommendations

Mystic Wolf

Teresa: The book is well done, brilliant in fact! Z

Read Now
To Catch a Ghost, Part 1

Wendy Salvo: I really liked this story but now that I’ve read all three I wanted to come back with a thought, the forward on this story talks about a reverse harem and not having to choose, but there isn’t any choice, or thought of a harem until the moment she connects with them, there is only foreshadowing of o...

Read Now
The Grumpy Next Door

mmurphy1008: This book had my attention from the very first chapter! It has romance and humor and just enough tension to keep it moving along. Can’t wait to read more from this author.

Read Now
Ruthless Lord

susiebear2012: Realy enjoyed this so looking forward to more.great story line hope they can achieve getting away from the kings burden. Truly amazing well written well done.

Read Now
The Orc's Pet

Glenda Holmes: Good read!

Read Now
Light at the End of the Track

Sonya: This was a lovely gripping and emotional storywith a brilliant ending

Read Now
The Mate he couldn't have

glendinningjune: Sdfgg ghiiio dghjk sdfgh tuition xxvhh gvhhn gvvhj ghj joking hbvcfh jkkkbv fccgh hhh dccg wfgbv yvffv invest unvvgh

Read Now
Married by Fate

starx_1413: Honestly, what a read!! I absolutely loved this story. The plot was so interesting, and those plot twists? I WAS NOT EXPECTING THEM AT ALL!! Just when I thought I had figured things out, the story managed to surprise me all over again.One of my favourite things has to be the chemistry between the ch...

Read Now
Bear Roberts

user-za6B61FpQY: While I felt like this wasn't a realistic situation on meeting someone; I realky like how their relationship develops!

Read Now