Fate Found Us Twice

All Rights Reserved ©

Summary

They met once. In the quiet after chaos. In the space between who they were and who they were supposed to become. And for a moment… it felt like fate. Then he was gone. Years later, Aria has built a life out of safe choices and steady routines. Until fate brings him back. The boy from the night she never forgot. The feeling she was never able to replace. And now, standing on opposite sides of the same city, they’re forced to face the truth: Some people aren’t meant to be just a memory.

Status
Ongoing
Chapters
10
Rating
n/a
Age Rating
16+

Chapter 1

The music lived in my bones.

It always had.

It wasn’t just something I heard—it was something I felt. The bass rolled through the floor and up my legs, into my chest, syncing with my heartbeat until I couldn’t tell where it ended and I began.

I laughed, spinning with my friends in the middle of the living room, my drink sloshing dangerously in my hand as someone grabbed my wrist and pulled me back into the chaos.

This—this was my favourite part.

The letting go.

The way nothing else mattered for a few hours. No expectations. No plans. No pressure to have my whole life figured out before I’d even lived it.

Just music. Movement. Freedom.

“Aria, don’t break that!” someone yelled over the noise as I threw my head back laughing.

“No promises!” I shot back, already spinning away, my steps a little too loose, a little too unsteady.

I bumped into someone, laughed it off, then stumbled sideways, my hip knocking lightly into the wall as I tried to catch my balance.

“Woah—okay, maybe a little promises,” I muttered to myself, grinning anyway.

The music pulled me again before I could think, dragging me back into it as I spun too fast, my arm swinging out and barely missing a framed painting on the wall.

“Shit—” I laughed breathlessly, steadying it before it could fall. “You’re fine, you’re fine.”

I took another reckless sip, the alcohol burning just enough to make everything feel warmer, lighter.

Tonight wasn’t just any party.

It was the end.

Graduation.

The last night of being this version of ourselves before everything shifted into something bigger, scarier… permanent.

And if there was ever a night to feel everything all at once—

It was this one.

I let the music take over again, closing my eyes for a second as I moved with it, lost in the rhythm, in the heat, in the moment.

This is what I loved.

Not the party itself. The feeling. The way I could disappear into it.

Forget everything else.

Be… just me.

But even the best moments blur eventually.

The room started to feel too full. Too loud. Too much all at once.

I slipped away from my friends, weaving through bodies until I reached the back door and pushed it open.

Cool air hit my skin instantly.

I exhaled, stepping outside, the quiet wrapping around me like a reset button.

The music still pulsed faintly behind me, but out here it felt distant. Softer.

Manageable.

I walked a little further from the house, heels crunching against gravel, tilting my head up toward the night sky.

Just for a second.

Just to breathe.

“Escaping?”

The voice came from my left.

Low. Calm.

Like it belonged to the quiet.

I turned—and everything stilled.

He was leaning against the fence, half-shadowed by the soft glow spilling from the house behind us. Dark hair, slightly messy like he’d run his hands through it too many times. His posture was relaxed, but there was something about him that wasn’t.

Something… aware.

His eyes met mine.

And held.

It was subtle.

But something shifted inside me.

“Something like that,” I said, my voice softer now, like the night had pulled it down with everything else.

The corner of his mouth lifted slightly.

“Yeah,” he said. “I get that.”

I found myself stepping closer without thinking about it.

“I love it in there,” I admitted, glancing back toward the house. “The music, the chaos… it’s just—” I let out a small laugh. “—a lot.”

He watched me like he was actually listening.

Not just waiting for his turn to speak.

“Yeah,” he said again, quieter this time. “It is.”

Silence settled between us.

But it wasn’t awkward.

It felt… easy.

Natural.

“I’m Marcus.”

Of course he was.

The name fit him too well.

“Aria.”

He repeated it under his breath, like he was testing how it felt.

“Aria.”

The way he said it made my chest tighten in a way I didn’t understand.

“Feels weird, doesn’t it?” I said after a second, letting out a soft breath as I glanced back toward the house. “Like… that’s it. School’s over. We’re just… done.”

He followed my gaze, nodding slightly. “Yeah. No more showing up because you have to.”

“No more pretending you know what you’re doing,” I added with a small laugh.

He huffed out a quiet laugh beside me. “Speak for yourself. I’ve been pretending for years.”

I smiled at that, relaxing a little more, the alcohol settling into something softer now, less dizzying, more warm.

“Same,” I admitted. “I think tonight’s the first time I’ve actually stopped thinking about what comes next.”

He glanced at me again, something unreadable in his expression. “And?”

I tilted my head slightly, letting the night air brush over my skin. “And it’s kind of nice.”

For a moment, neither of us said anything.

Then I pushed off the fence lightly, stepping past him, nodding toward the darker stretch beyond the yard.

“Walk with me?” I said, more casual than I felt.

His answer came without hesitation.

“Yeah.”

We didn’t go back inside.

Not once.

The air was cooler out here, softer. It brushed against my skin, calming the heat that had built under it, carrying the faint scent of damp earth and leaves. Gravel shifted under my heels, then gave way to softer ground as we stepped off the path and into the trees.

It got quieter with every step.

Not empty—just… different.

Alive in a quieter way. The rustle of leaves overhead. The distant hum of insects. The sound of our breathing, a little uneven from the alcohol and the walk.

I became hyper-aware of him beside me.

The space between us.

Close, but not touching.

Like we were both aware of it without every saying anything.

There was a small clearing just beyond the edge of the yard, the grass uneven and slightly damp. Moonlight filtered through the trees, just enough to see the outline of him when I turned my head.

We stopped there.

Neither of us said anything at first.

Then I sank down into the grass, tucking my legs beneath me, my fingers brushing over the cool blades like I needed something to ground me.

He sat beside me—not too close, not too far.

And then… we talked.

Not the surface-level, party kind of talking.

The real kind.

The kind that slips out when you don’t feel like you’re being judged. When the world feels far enough away that honesty doesn’t feel dangerous.

Words came easier than they should have.

I told him things I didn’t usually say out loud—about how everyone kept asking what I was going to do next, like I was supposed to have a perfectly mapped-out plan already. About how every option felt too permanent. Too final.

About how I was scared of choosing wrong and waking up one day stuck in a life that didn’t feel like mine.

I laughed it off at first, like I always did.

But it didn’t come out the same way.

Not here.

Not with him.

Because he wasn’t interrupting.

Wasn’t brushing it off.

Wasn’t trying to fix it.

He was just… listening.

Really listening.

And somehow that made everything feel heavier and lighter at the same time.

“You ever feel like everyone else got a map,” I said quietly, my fingers twisting into the grass, grounding myself in something real, “and you’re just… guessing your way through it?”

Marcus let out a quiet breath beside me.

“Yeah,” he said. “All the time.”

I let out a small, surprised laugh. “That makes me feel slightly less insane.”

He glanced over at me, the corner of his mouth lifting. “Only slightly?”

“Don’t push it,” I said, nudging his shoulder lightly with mine before I could overthink it. “I’ve spent the last six months pretending I have a five-year plan.”

“Do you?” he asked.

I shook my head, looking back out into the trees. “No. I have like… vague ideas and a lot of panic.”

He huffed out a quiet laugh. “That’s more honest than most people.”

“What about you?” I asked, turning back to him. “You got the map?”

There was a beat. Just long enough to feel real.

“Not really,” he admitted. “I just got better at making it look like I do.”

I studied him for a second, something about that answer settling somewhere deeper than it should have.

“You don’t seem like someone who fakes things,” I said.

His gaze held mine a fraction longer than it had before. “Everyone fakes something.”

“Yeah,” I murmured. “I guess that’s true.”

Silence stretched between us again, but it felt different now. Heavier. Warmer.

“Can I tell you something kind of dumb?” I asked.

He shifted slightly toward me. “Yeah.”

“I thought tonight was going to feel bigger,” I admitted. “Like this huge, life-changing moment. And instead it just feels like…” I hesitated, searching for the right word. “Like everything’s about to start and I have no idea how to catch up to it.”

He didn’t laugh.

Didn’t brush it off.

“Maybe you’re not supposed to catch up,” he said quietly. “Maybe you just… go with it.”

I let that sit for a second, my fingers stilling in the grass.

“That sounds a lot easier than it is,” I said.

“Yeah,” he agreed. “But it’s probably the only way it works.”

I looked at him then.

Really looked.

And something about the way he said it—so simple, so honest—made my chest ache a little.

Most people would’ve brushed it off.

Pretended.

He didn’t.

He just… understood.

We laughed after that.

Talked about stupid things.

Shared things we probably shouldn’t have.

And somewhere along the way, the distance between us disappeared.

I didn’t notice when it happened.

Just that suddenly—

He was closer. Too close.

My breath caught as my eyes dropped to his lips—perfectly shaped, the kind you notice without meaning to. I swallowed, a sudden, reckless thought flashing through me—how easy it would be to close the space between us, how much I wanted to know what they felt like against mine.

Marcus didn’t move away. Almost like he had the same thought.

“Aria,” he said softly.

Like a warning.

Or maybe a question.

I didn’t answer.

Didn’t think.

I just leaned in.

And everything after that felt like falling.