Customize readability
Aa

THE GIRL THEY BOTH WANTED

Summary

Maya Carter has never been the kind of girl people notice. Quiet, responsible, and burdened with more than most her age, she’s used to staying invisible—focused on school and taking care of her younger siblings. The last thing she wants is attention. But everything changes the moment Jayden Cole walks into her life. Mysterious, confident, and dangerously unpredictable, Jayden is the kind of boy everyone talks about but no one truly understands. When he singles Maya out, the quiet life she’s built begins to unravel. Suddenly, she’s the center of whispers, rumors, and unwanted attention. And she’s not the only one watching. Ethan Blake—her loyal best friend—has always been her safe place, the one person she can rely on when everything else falls apart. But as Maya is pulled deeper into Jayden’s world, Ethan begins to see her in a way he never allowed himself to before. Caught between the boy who feels like home and the one who feels like a storm, Maya finds herself trapped in a dangerous emotional tug-of-war. But the real threat comes from someone who refuses to be ignored. Vanessa Reed is used to getting what she wants—and she’s not about to let Maya take it. What begins as subtle jealousy quickly turns into calculated cruelty, as Vanessa sets her sights on destroying Maya’s reputation and pushing her out of the picture entirely. As rumors spread and lines are crossed, Maya’s world begins to collapse under pressure. Trust becomes fragile. Friendships are tested. And the truth behind certain actions proves more complicated than it seems. What started as a simple glance turns into obsession. What felt like attention turns into control. And what seemed like love begins to blur into something far more dangerous. Now, Maya must decide who she can trust—and who she’s willing to lose. Because in a world where everyone is watching, one wrong step could cost her everything. And this time, walking away might not be an option.

Status
5mo ago
Chapters
4
Rating
n/a
Age Rating
16+

Chapter 1

Maya Carter woke up before the sun.

Not because she wanted to—but because she had to.

The room was still dark, the air heavy with the quiet breathing of her younger siblings. For a moment, she just lay there, staring at the cracked ceiling, letting the silence sit on her chest.

Then reality returned.

Bills. School. Responsibilities.

Life.

She sighed softly and slipped out of bed.

The cold floor greeted her bare feet as she moved carefully, so she wouldn’t wake them. In the small kitchen, she tied her hair into a loose bun and got to work.

Water on the stove. Bread on the table.

Routine.

Always the same.

“Maya…?” a sleepy voice called from behind.

She turned slightly and smiled. “You’re awake already?”

Her little sister rubbed her eyes. “I had a bad dream.”

Maya’s expression softened immediately. She knelt down and pulled her into a hug.

“It’s okay,” she whispered. “I’m here.”

And she meant it.

She was always there.

—

By the time the sun finally rose, the house was no longer quiet.

“Eat your food before it gets cold!” Maya called, tying her shoelace quickly.

Her younger brother groaned. “I don’t want to go to school today.”

Maya gave him a look. “You said that yesterday. And the day before.”

He grinned. “Maybe I just don’t like school.”

“Too bad,” she replied, grabbing her bag. “Because school likes you.”

He laughed.

Moments like this… they made everything feel lighter.

Even if it didn’t last.

—

The walk to school was longer than usual.

Or maybe it just felt that way.

Students gathered in groups, laughing, gossiping, living freely—like the world wasn’t heavy on their shoulders.

Maya walked past them quietly.

Invisible.

Just the way she preferred it.

Or at least… that’s what she told herself.

As she stepped through the school gate, a sudden shift in atmosphere made her slow down.

Something felt… off.

Different.

Her eyes lifted—

And that’s when she saw him.

Leaning casually against a car like he owned not just it—but everything around him.

Tall. Calm. Watching.

His presence alone drew attention.

Girls whispered.

Boys stayed alert.

But he wasn’t looking at them.

He was looking at her.

Maya’s steps faltered.

For a second—just a second—the world went completely silent.

Their eyes locked.

And something about the way he looked at her…

It wasn’t normal.

It wasn’t curiosity.

It wasn’t admiration.

It was something deeper.

Something… dangerous.

Maya quickly looked away and continued walking, her heart beating faster than it should.

She didn’t know why.

She didn’t know who he was.

But one thing was certain—

That wasn’t the last time their paths would cross.

—

“Hey, Maya!”

She turned to see Ethan jogging toward her, slightly out of breath.

“You walked past me like I offended you or something,” he said.

Maya smiled faintly. “I didn’t even see you.”

Ethan raised an eyebrow. “That’s new. You always see everything.”

She hesitated.

Not everything.

“Are you okay?” he asked, studying her face.

“Yeah,” she replied quickly. “Just tired.”

Ethan didn’t look convinced, but he let it go.

“Come on,” he said. “Let’s get to class before they mark us late again.”

As they walked side by side, Maya couldn’t help herself.

She glanced back.

Just once.

And there he was.

Still standing there.

Still watching.

And this time…

He smiled.

—

Let AmaNyamewaa16 know what you thought about this chapter!
Love this

0

Love this

Funny

0

Funny

Spicy

0

Spicy

Suspenseful

0

Suspenseful

Emotional

0

Emotional

Profound

0

Profound

Heartwarming

0

Heartwarming

Shocking

0

Shocking

Good Writing

0

Good Writing

Compelling Plot

0

Compelling Plot

Great Character

0

Great Character

Strong Dialog

0

Strong Dialog

Further Recommendations

The Easter Bunny

Mia: Really nice story

Read Now
SECRET BILLIONAIRE

Jkind12: Very enjoyable!

Read Now
Bear Roberts

Fah🖤🖤dah: Great chemistry, an interesting plot, and characters you can’t help but get attached to. I really enjoyed this story! ❤️‍🔥

Read Now
Half-Claimed

Saraa: Hey! I really enjoyed your story. It made me wonder how you actually write. Are you someone who plans everything in advance, or do you discover the story as the chapters unfold?

Read Now
Alpha’s Claim

Read4Free16: Devotion, strength and trust all in creating a wonderful read

Read Now
Bloodlines

Marie: Very well written and a full story without hundreds of excess words or narrative... totally 😉

Read Now
Exile in Flames

NOVELHOLIC: Honestly, I did NOT expect this book to be this good. 😭❤️It was only **18 chapters** and honestly, I went into it thinking, “Okay, this will be a quick little read.” Boy, was I WRONG. 😭😭I finished it in like **30 minutes**, but somehow this short little book managed to pack in so much depth, emot...

Read Now