Instinctively Yours
Share with your friends
Customize readability

Instinctively Yours

All Rights Reserved ©

Summary

Noah Bennett never expected to find a half-frozen stranger buried in the snow outside his apartment. He certainly didn't expect that stranger to be a werewolf. After rescuing the mysterious Micah, Noah's quiet life in New York is turned upside down. Between hidden ears and tails, disastrous attempts at fitting into human society, and a roommate who somehow manages to be both intimidating and impossibly adorable, everyday life becomes wonderfully chaotic. Somewhere between shared meals, late-night conversations, and countless near disasters, Noah begins to fall for the one person he never imagined could change his world. There's just one problem. Micah is hiding the truth. As the future chief of a werewolf pack hidden deep within the legendary Devil's Triangle, he was never meant to leave home... and he was certainly never meant to fall in love with a human. When Micah's family crashes into Noah's life, a nationwide manhunt begins, and the existence of werewolves threatens to become humanity's greatest discovery. Forced into hiding together, Noah and Micah must navigate dangerous instincts, impossible traditions, and feelings neither of them knows how to confess before the worlds they've always known collide. But some secrets are older than either of them realizes. Because the storms surrounding the Devil's Triangle aren't simply protecting the werewolves. They're hiding the truth about how their world began. Filled with slow-burn romance, laugh-out-loud comedy, found family, aching yearning, ancient mysteries, and heart-stopping adventure, Instinctively Yours is a story about choosing love over fear, challenging traditions thousands of years old, and discovering that sometimes the impossible is where home has been waiting all along.

Status
4mo ago
Chapters
49
Rating
n/a
Age Rating
16+

Prologue

Hi everyone! 💙

This is my first ever story. I actually started writing it about six months ago, but I never finished it and ended up abandoning it for a while. Recently, I’ve been revising the chapters and giving the story a fresh start, so I hope you’ll enjoy the journey with me!

The first part of the story is mostly a slice-of-life romance with plenty of cute moments. Then, somewhere along the way, everything descends into organized chaos.

A quick content note: this story isn’t heavily explicit, though it does contain some suggestive and romantic scenes. Later chapters also explore horror themes and darker content, so I’d recommend it for readers around 14–15+.

Feel free to leave comments and let me know what age rating you think fits best once you’ve read more of the story!

Anyway, have fun, and thanks for giving my story a chance! :)

—

They called it the Devil’s Triangle, a cursed stretch of sea where compasses spun madly and ships vanished without a trace.

To humans, it was a mystery.

To the werewolves who lived beneath its fog, it was sanctuary.

For thousands of years, the pack had survived there: fishermen, sailors, and villagers bound to the tides. Hidden beneath shifting mist and restless waves, they built a world the surface was never meant to find.

The storms that rolled through the Triangle were not accidents. Neither were the disappearances. They were warnings, illusions created by their ancestors, who had once fled a world that hunted them.

The fog became their shield.

The sea became their law.

And the Triangle became their home.

But every home had rules.

Children were raised with salt in their veins and tradition carved into their bones. They were taught one truth before anything else:

The ocean gives, but it also takes.

And those who dared betray it... never returned.

—

“Mick! Hurry up or your father’s gonna leave you!”

“Be there in a second, Mom!”

Micah burst out of his room, a hat far too big on his head and a small toy fishing rod clutched in his hand. His grin stretched wide, his tail flicking with excitement.

His mother, a blonde woman in her mid-thirties, smiled warmly as she watched him. “I can’t believe you’re eight already,” she said, ruffling his hair. “Feels like just yesterday you were fresh from the crib. No matter how old you get, you’ll always be my baby.”

“Mom! I’m not a baby anymore! And I have to go!”

“Alright, alright. Have fun.”

“Okay!”

Micah darted out into the warm summer air.

The breeze carried a strong taste of salt, sharp, familiar, almost comforting. He sprinted past the village at the edge of the shore, where houses were built from driftwood and salvaged ship timber. No two looked the same, as if each family had shaped their home from whatever the sea decided to give back.

The smell of drying fish filled the air, fresh and homey.

Old Ben was asleep in his rocking chair as usual, still pretending to watch the harbor. Next, he passed by two men in their late twenties, known as the Knot Brothers, arguing over who could tie a knot better.

“Your knot is too loose. Try my way.”

“Pftt. Please. I’ve been tying knots since before you knew how to transform.”

“I think it’s the other way around.”

A breeze whipped through Micah’s dark hair, drying the sticky salt on his skin.

“Micah, I thought you’d sleep till winter!” a fisherman walking by called.

Micah laughed and yelled back, “I would never on my birthday!”

He was practically vibrating with excitement as he passed by an elder’s house. He ran his hands over an old plank, taken from the sacred oak tree. An old woman pinched his cheeks before he could leave.

“Happy birthday, little fish!”

“I’m not little anymore. I’m a big boy!” Micah puffed up his little chest, his tail swaying with pride.

She laughed, the corners of her eyes crinkling. “Your family should come over today, dear. My son caught a seven-foot-long sea viper!”

Micah’s eyes went wide with delight. “Really? That sounds so good!”

“A special treat for you!”

Micah bounced on his heels, pumping his fist in the air. “Okay, bye, Grandma Mae!”

So, Micah continued on his trip to his father. The sun shone brightly in the sky as a group of kids holding wooden swords passed by him.

“Micah! We’re playing pirates later! Join us!” a red-haired werewolf called out.

“I’ll be there soon!”

Micah sped up his pace, finally leaving the village and reaching the bustling docks filled with fishermen getting ready for their trips. Each one of them touched the water before stepping into their boats.

He never knew why they did that. He never asked questions because it was tradition.

Ahead, his father stood beside a canoe, studying it like it had personally offended him.

Two fishermen stopped to tease him gently.

“Don’t drop your father overboard today.”

“I won’t.”

“Nah, the chief’s too heavy for that.”

All the nearby fishermen started laughing together, and even the chief joined in. Micah sprinted over to him.

“Hi, Dad!” Micah called, his voice bright with excitement.

“My boy!” his father’s resonant voice carried across the shore.

Micah ran to him and was lifted high into the air with ease before being set back down.

“Ready for your first fishing trip, boy?”

“Yes!”

Together, they pushed the canoe into the shallow water. It resisted at first, then slid forward with a reluctant scrape before floating properly.

“Today,” his father said proudly, climbing in, “you’re getting a VIP lesson from yours truly.”

Micah’s eyes sparkled. “Okay... so like this?”

His father chuckled, his eyes full of pride. “You’re already getting the hang of it. Making me proud already.”

They fished in silence, broken only by waves and the occasional instruction.

Then—

“Dad! I think I caught something!”

Micah pulled hard on the line, eyes wide with triumph. A small fish flopped onto the canoe floor.

“Amazing! But you need to—”

Before he could finish, it wriggled free and splashed back into the sea.

“Aww, man...”

His father let out a booming laugh. “Don’t worry, son. First time. I was worse than you.”

Micah leaned back, staring at the endless horizon. Then he spoke in a much quieter and more curious voice.

“Hey, Dad?”

“Yes, son?”

“What happens if we keep rowing... past the border?”

The air changed.

His father looked out toward the distant fog line where sea and sky blurred together. When he spoke again, his voice was almost solemn, as if he were remembering something painful.

“Son... we never go past the border.”

Micah frowned, tilting his head to the side. “Why not?”

“Because humans are dangerous.”

A pause.

“But what if—”

“Remember this,” his father interrupted, more serious now. “The ocean gives, but it also takes. Never forget that.”

Then, just as quickly, the moment softened again. He ruffled Micah’s hair.

Micah blinked, then smiled.

“So... if I give the ocean a piece of candy, will it give me a gazillion more?”

His father let out a full laugh. “No. That’s not what I meant...”

—

I never understood what he meant.

Not until that day.

My nineteenth birthday.

Let ˚₊‧꒰აMidnightPalace໒꒱ ‧₊˚ know what you thought about this chapter!

Further Recommendations

To Catch a Ghost, Part 1

Wendy Salvo: I really liked this story but now that I’ve read all three I wanted to come back with a thought, the forward on this story talks about a reverse harem and not having to choose, but there isn’t any choice, or thought of a harem until the moment she connects with them, there is only foreshadowing of o...

Read Now
Ruthless Lord

susiebear2012: Realy enjoyed this so looking forward to more.great story line hope they can achieve getting away from the kings burden. Truly amazing well written well done.

Read Now
Hit and Run

ZaraPearl: I truly love the story, very intersting and lovely.Sebastian is a great character and yoda ..., all of it , though I expected more at the endingi5 would've been great

Read Now
Rebuilding After Betrayal

Lynne: Very enjoyable short story good characters and they all found love n honesty.

Read Now
The Rewrite

MHReader: The story has a great plot and moves along nicely. There are a few grammatical errors but these do not detract from the flow of reading.

Read Now
Silver's Second Chance

April: Reading this one time was not enough, I love rereading this story. I love how strong and independent silver is. 💗💗

Read Now
The Mate he couldn't have

glendinningjune: Sdfgg ghiiio dghjk sdfgh tuition xxvhh gvhhn gvvhj ghj joking hbvcfh jkkkbv fccgh hhh dccg wfgbv yvffv invest unvvgh

Read Now
Married by Fate

starx_1413: Honestly, what a read!! I absolutely loved this story. The plot was so interesting, and those plot twists? I WAS NOT EXPECTING THEM AT ALL!! Just when I thought I had figured things out, the story managed to surprise me all over again.One of my favourite things has to be the chemistry between the ch...

Read Now
Bear Roberts

user-za6B61FpQY: While I felt like this wasn't a realistic situation on meeting someone; I realky like how their relationship develops!

Read Now