The Devil's Cutlass
Share with your friends
Customize readability

The Devil's Cutlass

StumboOnTheGo

All Rights Reserved ©

Story Notes

This is a piece for Strange Offering's Monthly Creative Prompts for July being PIRATES:


(You can find Strange Offerings at www.facebook.com/groups/strangeofferings)


Reader’s Notes: The Devil’s Cutlass

Setting & Tone: A dark, nautical-gothic horror set in the 18th century on the high seas. Expect an oppressive, slow-burn atmosphere where the ocean itself feels like a graveyard.

The Inspiration: A dark twist on classic maritime folklore and ghost ship legends. Instead of searching for hidden cursed treasure, the treasure is the curse—and it arrives disguised as a helpless survivor.

Themes to Watch For:

False Hope & Desperation: How greed and hunger can blind men to obvious danger.

The Cyclical Nature of Evil: Pay close attention to the logbook—history isn’t just repeating itself; it’s a trap reset time and time again.

Inversion of the “Lucky Charm”: Exploring how something that seems like divine intervention can actually be a predatory lure.

Content Warning: Features eerie psychological horror, subtle body horror, maritime violence, and tense supernatural encounters.

Summary

"Even the monsters of the deep know when a thing is dead twice over."For weeks, The Devil’s Cutlass drifted in a dead calm—its crew starving on rot and thin broth, its sails held together by thread and desperate prayers. Then the horizon broke. A shattered Spanish galleon, ripped open as if by giant shears, sat upon a sea as flat and black as glass. No fire, no smoke—only a dark, iron blade driven deep into the deckhouse door, and a shivering thirteen-year-old boy clinging to the wreckage. His name was Niklaus. The moment he stepped aboard, our fortunes inverted. An unnatural gale filled our canvas, directing our heading without a chart. French prizes fell into our lap without a fight. Chests overflowed with silver dollars. The crew cheered the "Little Admiral" who brought us luck. They didn't see the silver turning gray and dull in the firelight. They didn't see how the birds fled our wake, or how the boy’s shadow remained dead-still while the lanterns swayed. Now, trapped in a choking fog off the Hispaniola shoals, the truth is laid bare. The boy was never a survivor. He was an anglerfish—and we were just foolish enough to bite the bait.

Status
Complete
Chapters
9
Rating
n/a
Age Rating
16+

Chapter 1

“The Devil’s Cutlass”

By: Matt Stumbo

Too long it had been since this crew had a meal that wasn’t gruel best served as chum in those dark waters. Even longer still since we had a true haul that made this sea life worth the salt we endured. I, the Quartermaster of The Devil’s Cutlass, had sworn to assist my captain with righting this wrong. But the more blank sunsets I came across with nothing to show for it, the more it dried up my will to see this thing through. Captain Brahm’s eyes weren’t as sharp as they once were, and I could tell the crew was starting to whisper amongst themselves. I didn’t dare speak the words out loud, but just as we navigated those treacherous waters, I stepped carefully upon the deck all the same… a deck that had become even harder to traverse upon the choppy seas. The hull was overrun by bloody barnacles, and the sails were thinned-out patchwork held together by the threaded back hair of The Cook Barnaby himself. The man could cook his arse off, but one could say with confidence that his cooking was the only comfort we had left against the chilling nights.

In those darker times, I suppose it was best to count our blessings for a quiet moment to think upon… But aye, as they say, there’s always a calm before the storm…

It was just past eight bells when the horizon finally broke its cruel silence. Master Thomas Frye was at the rail, his brass spyglass glued to his eye, squinting through a bank of fog that had no right bein’ there on a summer evening.

“Wreckage!” Frye’s voice cracked, dry as a sun-bleached plank. “Dead ahead, Quartermaster. Shattered timbers... and she’s a big one.”

Captain Brahm emerged from his cabin before the echo of Frye’s shout could die down. He didn’t walk so much as cascade down the steps, his coat flapping like a crow’s wings, a desperate, manic hunger in his clouded eyes. It was the first time I’d seen him move with life in a month.

As The Devil’s Cutlass drifted closer into the mist, the water grew unnaturally still, the choppy waves dying down into a flat, black sheet of glass. There she lay. A massive Spanish galleon, ripped open from stem to stern as if a colossal pair of shears had snipped her in two. No smoke. No fire. Just the hollow, weeping sound of water sloshing through broken ribs of oak.

“Barnaby! Cross! Get the longboat cleared!” Brahm bellowed, his hand trembling as he pointed a ring-heavy finger at the floating graveyard. “There’s gold in those bellies, boys, or I’ll see us all hang from the yards before Sunday!”

I watched the shattered hull draw near, a cold prickle of sweat breaking out under my wool waistcoat. My eyes didn’t fix on the floating crates or the spilled cargo. They fixed on the captain’s quarters of the ruined vessel, where a heavy, dark iron naval blade was driven so deep into the deckhouse door it looked like it was holding the wood together.

And there, clinging to a splintered spar right beneath that blade, was the boy. No older than thirteen, old enough to hold a flintlock and hold his own in a scrap, but there was also a frailty about him. He looked like a wet rag doll tangled in the rigging, his pale skin shivering against the dark wood of the spar.

“Bring us alongside!” Brahm barked, his boots already sloshing through the bilge water in the bottom of the longboat as Cross and Barnaby pulled hard on the oars.

The closer we rowed, the more the hair on my arms stood on end. The air around this wreck didn’t smell like salt and sea; it smelled like the bottom of an old well… stagnant, cold, and heavy with the scent of wet copper. The rest of the men were eyein’ the loose barrels of flour and rum bobbing in the water, their greedy minds already spending the coin they hadn’t found yet. But my eyes stayed glued to that deckhouse door.

And that blade.

“Grab the lad,” Brahm ordered as the longboat bumped against the groaning timber of the Spanish galleon. Redmond “The Butcher” Cross reached out with a hand the size of a smoked ham, hoisting the shivering boy over the gunwale with a single, effortless grunt.

The kid collapsed into the bottom of the boat, a puddle of freezing water spreading from his clothes. He didn’t cry. He didn’t beg. He just looked up through a curtain of damp, dark hair, his wide eyes fixing straight onto Captain Brahm.

“M-my name is Niklaus, sir,” the boy whispered, his teeth chattering so hard I thought they’d snap. “The storm... it took the rest of ’em. I’m all that’s left.”

“You’re safe now, boy,” Brahm said, his voice softer than I’d heard it in years. He threw his own heavy woolen coat over the lad’s shoulders.

While Brahm played the savior, I stepped out of the longboat and onto the slick, tilted deck of the ruined ship. The silence here was thick enough to choke on. I walked past a row of shattered cannon ports straight to the captain’s quarters, my boots crunching on loose glass.

I stopped in front of the heavy oak door. Up close, the naval blade didn’t look like any cutlass I’d ever seen in a prize haul. The iron was midnight-black, etched with faint, jagged grooves that ran all the way down to the guard, and it was buried three inches deep into the wood. Right where the blade pierced the oak, the wood had turned a sickly, rotted gray, as if the steel itself was poisoning the timber.

I wrapped my leather-gloved hand around the hilt and, with a good hard tug, pulled. My Arthurian dreams came alive as I yanked the blade from its wooden prison. A strong smell of sulfur captured my senses, and my eyes got lost in the strange, rhythmic vibrations coming off the dark metal in my hand.

With the blade freed, the heavy, rotted oak door groaned and swung inward on its cracked hinges, revealing the pitch-black maw of the captain’s cabin. The stench of wet copper and stale rot rolled out into my face, making me gag. I took a half-step inside, the water sloshing up to my shins. There, slumped over a sodden mahogany desk, were the gaunt remains of the Spanish captain, his bony fingers still frozen in a death-grip around a thick, leather-bound book. The cover was water-logged, stamped with a golden crest that had gone entirely black.

A survival instinct I couldn’t explain screamed at me to drop it, but my hands moved on their own. I pried the dead man’s fingers loose and stuffed the heavy Spanish logbook down into the canvas sack at my hip.

As I slipped further into the captain’s quarters looking for anything else of worth, Captain Brahm’s bellowing voice pulled me back.

“Mr. Gideon! We have our heading!”

As I exited the captain’s quarters, I noticed the boy staring up at my captain with a mix of admiration and something else that didn’t sit right with me. As I started back toward the longboat that Cross and Barnaby were loading up with their treasured bounty, I turned back to notice the stern of the wrecked ship. The name La Santa Gracia was etched in gold that shone bright for a moment, as if begging for my attention.

Continue reading in the app

Scan the code to open this book in the Inkitt app and keep reading on your phone.

Let StumboOnTheGo know what you thought about this chapter!

Further Recommendations

Crowned in Blood: Fated to the enemy

alan: The difference between the past tense (Simple Past) and the pro tense (Past Progressive / Past Continuous) lies in whether the action is viewed as a finished, single event or as an ongoing activity in progress

Read Now
Mystic Wolf

Teresa: The book is well done, brilliant in fact! Z

Read Now
Bear Shifter Secrets

tatianne Ingrid: Adorei cada capitulo! parabens

Read Now
The Full Moon Breeding Club

Susan Morris: This is a fantastic romance story! The writing, the timing, the flow, the characters were all great. I love the story because it involved a “process” I had not read about before in shifter romance and was well thought out and applied to this story. Cheers to the author!

Read Now
Ruthless Lord

susiebear2012: Realy enjoyed this so looking forward to more.great story line hope they can achieve getting away from the kings burden. Truly amazing well written well done.

Read Now
The Cursed Alpha's Fifth Luna

karen cridland: Good character construction and fluid writing style.

Read Now
The Iron Crown

Danielle_Anderson: Kira's training yard and her mirror feel like two different women, and the gap between them is where this opening does its best work. The clean arc of the sword, the shock running up through her wrists, the bright singing moment when only the blade exists, all of that is undone by the practiced soft...

Read Now
The Moon's Weapon : the cursed mate [ MOVING TO GALATEA]

Cynthia Foley: Loved every second of this story. Highly recommend!!!

Read Now
The Luna Trials

Denver: Loved this story. Very well written with great characterisation and storytelling. It was a compelling read. Will definitely read more by this author, as I like their style of writing. I can't wait to see how it develops further in the story of Elijah.

Read Now