The Boy Who Wasn't Mine
Share with your friends
Customize readability

The Boy Who Wasn't Mine

All Rights Reserved ©

Story Notes

♡ Welcome toThe Boy Who Wasn’t Mine♡

This is an original teen romance filled with fake dating, jealousy, friendship, heartbreak, secrets, and a very slow-burn love triangle.

Expect messy feelings, unexpected moments, and characters who don’t always make the right choices.

New chapters coming soon! 💜

I hope you enjoy reading as much as I enjoy writing it. Don’t forget to vote, comment, and let me know who you’re rooting for!

Summary

Mia Carter has loved Ethan Brooks for years. He’s her best friend’s brother, the boy who always makes her heart race, and the person she secretly believes she’ll never have. So when Ethan starts dating someone else, Mia is left completely heartbroken. Then Adrian Brooks makes her an unexpected offer. Fake date him. The plan is supposed to be simple: make Ethan jealous, protect Mia’s pride, and end the arrangement before anyone catches real feelings. But Adrian isn't the cold, arrogant brother Mia thought he was. He notices the little things. He remembers everything she says. And somehow, pretending to be his girlfriend starts feeling a little too real. Mia thought she was trying to make one brother fall for her. She never expected to fall for the other. And when Ethan finally starts looking at her differently, Mia has to choose between the boy she always wanted and the boy she never saw coming. Because sometimes the person you spend years dreaming about isn't the person your heart actually needs.

Status
Complete
Chapters
12
Rating
n/a
Age Rating
16+

The Boy I Never Had

There are some things you keep to yourself because saying them out loud makes them real.

For me, that thing was Ethan Brooks.

I had been in love with him for three years.

Not the dramatic, movie kind of love.

At least, that’s what I told myself.

It was the little things.

The way he smiled when he saw me in the hallway.

The way he always stole fries from my lunch.

The way he remembered that I hated tomatoes but somehow forgot every homework assignment he was supposed to turn in.

And the worst part?

He was my best friend’s brother.

“Lena!” I called, running across the school parking lot.

She turned around, laughing. “Finally! I’ve been waiting for you for ten minutes.”

“I had to finish something.”

“You mean you were staring at Ethan again?”

I froze.

She grinned.

“I wasn’t staring.”

“You were.”

“I was looking.”

“That’s the same thing.”

I rolled my eyes and pushed her shoulder.

Then I saw him.

Ethan was standing near his car with a few friends, laughing about something. His dark hair was messy from the wind, and he had that stupid smile that had been ruining my life since freshman year.

Then his eyes met mine.

He smiled.

My heart immediately forgot how to behave.

“See?” Lena whispered.

“See what?”

“Your face.”

“My face is normal.”

“Your face looks like you just won the lottery.”

Before I could answer, Ethan walked over.

“Hey, Mia.”

“Hey.”

One word.

That was all I managed.

He looked at me for a second before smiling. “You coming over tonight?”

I blinked. “Tonight?”

“Mom’s making dinner.”

Lena groaned. “She practically lives with us anyway.”

I laughed.

“Sure,” I said. “I’ll come.”

Ethan smiled again.

And for a few seconds, everything felt perfect.

Until a girl walked over and slipped her hand into his.

She was beautiful.

Blonde hair. Perfect smile. Confident.

Ethan turned toward her.

“Oh, Mia, this is Chloe.”

Chloe smiled at me.

“Hi.”

“Hi.”

Then Ethan looked at Chloe.

And the way he looked at her was different.

Softer.

Like she was the only person in the parking lot.

My stomach dropped.

Lena noticed.

“Mia...”

“I’m fine.”

I wasn’t.

Not even close.

That evening, I sat across from Ethan at the Brooks family’s dinner table, pretending everything was normal.

Then Ethan cleared his throat.

“I actually have something to tell everyone.”

My fork stopped halfway to my mouth.

Lena looked up.

Adrian, Ethan’s older brother, leaned back in his chair.

“What?”

Ethan smiled.

“Chloe and I are officially together.”

The room erupted in congratulations.

Everyone smiled.

Everyone except me.

And Adrian.

His eyes met mine from across the table.

He didn’t say anything.

He just looked at me like he knew.

Like he could see every broken piece I was desperately trying to hide.

I looked away.

Because sometimes the hardest thing isn’t losing someone.

It’s realizing you never had them in the first place.

Let Talesbymoonlight know what you thought about this chapter!

Further Recommendations

The Alpha's Exiled Mate (ON HOLD)

Catherineb83: Story good just would have liked her not to wear a mask

Read Now
Bear Shifter Secrets

tatianne Ingrid: Adorei cada capitulo! parabens

Read Now
The zatorian

lunaartsoul___: I loved the way your story unfolds. The emotional depth and structure made it feel very engaging, almost cinematic at times.I’m someone who enjoys both reading and visual storytelling, and your work really stood out to me. If you’re open to chatting about creative ideas someday, I’d love that.

Read Now
My Blacksmith Savior

apolloavr04: I love it. It's a great story.

Read Now
Going For The Goalie

S.TYTECA: I really enjoyed reading this book! The story was engaging and kept me interested throughout. There were a few minor spelling errors here and there, and some parts felt a little drawn out for my personal taste, but that’s purely subjective. Overall, it was a lovely read, and I genuinely enjoyed the ...

Read Now
Ruthless Lord

susiebear2012: Realy enjoyed this so looking forward to more.great story line hope they can achieve getting away from the kings burden. Truly amazing well written well done.

Read Now
Hit and Run

ZaraPearl: I truly love the story, very intersting and lovely.Sebastian is a great character and yoda ..., all of it , though I expected more at the endingi5 would've been great

Read Now
Rebuilding After Betrayal

Lynne: Very enjoyable short story good characters and they all found love n honesty.

Read Now
The Easter Bunny

Talia Kendrick : Honestly I love the book. Here is how I feel about each character: Detective Kayla is an Idiot, I can't stand this lady and I feel so bad for braelyn and Phoenix because after everything they have been through it makes me angry that they have to go through this again. Sure Phoenix doesn't know about...

Read Now