Chapter 1
I noticed her in fifth standard.
We were both new to the school.
She was usually late. She would arrive after assembly had started and quietly find a place to sit by herself.
I noticed because I was doing almost the same thing.
One morning, I saw her sitting alone.
She looked up.
Our eyes met for a second.
She looked away.
I don’t know why I remembered that.
There were plenty of new students. Plenty of girls. I was already making friends easily, and people seemed to know me quite quickly.
But I noticed her.
Maybe because she wasn’t trying to be noticed.
One day during assembly, I went up to her and said hello.
We talked for a little while.
It was ordinary.
At least, it should have been.
Later, we were preparing for the annual function. I needed female singers for a qawwali performance.
She could sing.
I asked her to join.
She said no.
I insisted.
She still hesitated.
For some reason, I didn’t want to take no for an answer.
Eventually, she agreed.
I was happy about it, although I never told her why.
Then came the day of the function.
She was in her costume.
I saw her.
And for some reason, I didn’t know how to behave.
There were people everywhere. Friends. Teachers. Students.
I suddenly became conscious of myself.
She came toward me.
Maybe she wanted to talk.
Maybe she wanted to show me her costume.
Instead of saying hello, I looked away.
I even made a face.
The moment passed.
I thought nothing of it afterward.
I didn’t know that she would remember it.
I didn’t know that, for her, that was the moment everything changed.
Years passed.
By eighth standard, I saw her again during Sports Day.
I was playing kabaddi.
Whenever I scored, I found myself looking in her direction.
I don’t know when that habit started.
Maybe I wanted to know if she had seen me.
Maybe I wanted her to see me.
Whenever our eyes met, she seemed uncomfortable.
Eventually, she walked away.
I wondered why.
I didn’t realize that she had already decided I was someone she didn’t need to care about.
In ninth standard, she brought her instrument to school.
She played beautifully.
I asked her to come and sit near my bench.
She refused.
I laughed it off.
She had changed.
Or maybe I had simply never understood her.
She didn’t give me the kind of attention other people did.
And strangely, I noticed that.
There were always people around me.
Girls who wanted to talk to me.
People who wanted to be my friends.
I was used to attention.
But she?
She could look straight through me.
And somehow, that made me want to bother her even more.
So I teased her.
Sometimes during games.
Sometimes just because I could.
There were so many people I could have chosen.
Yet somehow, I kept choosing her.
I didn’t have an explanation.
I just liked seeing her react.
One day she cried in class.
I noticed immediately.
I asked,
“Why were you crying?”
And then I laughed.
I don’t know why.
Maybe I was uncomfortable.
Maybe I didn’t know what to say when someone was actually upset.
She looked at me as though I had proved something she already believed about me.
That I was rude.
That I was proud.
I wanted to explain.
I didn’t.
In tenth standard, I saw her at tuition.
I hadn’t expected her to be there.
The moment I noticed her, I asked,
“Are you changing batch?”
It was an ordinary question.
But I remember being strangely happy to see her.
She probably didn’t realize that.
Eventually, I left the tuition.
Another moment passed.
Another conversation that never became anything.
By twelfth standard, we had known each other for years.
And yet I still didn’t know what she thought of me.
Maybe she disliked me.
Maybe she remembered fifth standard.
Maybe she thought I was arrogant.
Maybe she simply didn’t care.
I couldn’t tell.
So I teased her again.
I challenged her to make eye contact.
It was easy to say.
I thought she would look away.
She didn’t.
She looked directly at me.
And suddenly, I couldn’t hold her gaze.
I looked away first.
For a moment, I felt ridiculous.
I had started the challenge.
She had accepted it.
And somehow, I was the one who lost.
She probably wondered why.
I wondered too.
After school, she moved away.
Life changed.
We had jobs, different places, different people.
One day I messaged her, joking about the keys.
It was nothing important.
At least, that’s what I told myself.
Then came the school reunion.
I saw her again.
Older now.
Different.
And yet somehow exactly the same person I remembered sitting alone in fifth standard.
I asked if she was coming to the function.
I don’t know whether I asked everyone.
Maybe I did.
Maybe I didn’t.
She probably wondered about that too.
She always seemed to wonder about me.
And I always seemed to wonder about her.
There was something unfinished between us.
Not a relationship.
Not a love story.
Not even a confession.
Just years of small moments.
A glance.
A joke.
A song.
A game.
A question.
A girl walking away.
A boy pretending not to care.
And perhaps that was the strangest part.
I had met hundreds of people.
I had forgotten most of them.
But somehow, I kept remembering her.
The girl who never chased me.
The girl who stopped giving me importance.
The girl I kept teasing even when there were so many others around.
The girl whose attention I seemed to want without ever admitting that I wanted it.
Maybe I liked her.
Maybe I didn’t know what liking someone meant back then.
Maybe I was simply curious.
Maybe I liked the fact that she was different.
Or maybe I had been trying, in my own immature way, to get back something I had carelessly pushed away in fifth standard.
I will never know.
And neither will she.
Because I never told her.
And she never asked.
Some stories don’t end with two people falling in love.
Some stories end with two people growing up...
and carrying the same unanswered question in opposite directions.
I sometimes wonder whether she ever understood why I kept choosing her.
Perhaps she thought it meant nothing.
Perhaps she was right.
Or perhaps
for reasons I never learned to explain
she was the girl I kept looking for.









