The Black Coffee
My name is Alyssa Lemmon.
If you had asked me that morning whether I believed in fate, I would have laughed in your face. Fate doesn’t pay rent, doesn’t finish a manuscript when the deadline is closing in, and doesn’t save struggling writers from editors who love the phrase, “We really like your work, but—”
I hated that “but.” Hated it enough that I spent the whole cold, rainy walk to work thinking about exactly two things: coffee, and five uninterrupted minutes of silence before the day could start asking anything else of me.
That was when I noticed the coffee shop. It looked new, though I couldn’t for the life of me remember what had been there before — some nail salon, maybe, or a dry cleaner, the kind of place you walk past a hundred times without really seeing. Warm light spilled through the large windows onto the wet sidewalk, soft music drifted out every time the door opened, and even from the street I could smell fresh coffee, rich and dark, cutting through the smell of rain on concrete.
I checked the time. Just enough of a window before work to make this detour worth it.
The bell above the door chimed as I stepped inside, shaking a little of the rain off my sleeve. The place was almost empty — two students hunched over textbooks by the window, a man frowning at his laptop in the corner, the espresso machine hissing somewhere behind the counter. Behind it stood a barista. He looked up and smiled, and for some reason I had the strange, immediate feeling that he’d been expecting me.
Ridiculous. I didn’t even know this place existed ten minutes ago.
“Good morning,” he said.
“Morning.”
“What can I get for you?”
“A large black coffee.”
He reached for a cup. “No sugar?”
I blinked, caught slightly off guard by how sure he sounded, like he already knew the answer before I gave it. “Right.”
“Name?”
“Alyssa.”
He wrote it on the cup in neat, unhurried letters. “Good choice, Alyssa.” Then he turned toward the machine, and steam rose between us like a curtain closing.
He was tall, dark-haired, with a voice that had an easy warmth to it — the kind that made small talk feel less like a transaction. A small black name tag on his apron read Theron. Nothing extraordinary. Just an ordinary guy making ordinary coffee on an ordinary Tuesday.
I pulled out my phone and checked my email out of habit, already bracing for it. The message about my manuscript was still sitting there, unread, bold and accusing. Perfect. Plenty of time to let that ruin my mood later, once I’d at least had caffeine in me.
“Alyssa.”
I looked up. Theron was holding out my coffee, my name written neatly across the side in his same steady hand. “Thank you.” I reached for it, and our fingers touched.
Just for a moment.
And suddenly—
Laughter. Rain. City lights smeared gold and red across wet pavement.
“You know you’re adorable, right?” Theron’s voice, but different — softer, closer, aimed only at me. His smile. His hand wrapped around mine like it belonged there.
Then a restaurant glowing with candlelight, the kind of low golden light that makes everyone look a little bit in love. Text messages before bed that made me smile at my phone like an idiot. A first date, then a second, then a third. Long conversations that ran past midnight and into the kind of tired laughter that comes from being up too late with someone you don’t want to stop talking to. Walks through the city with no destination. His laugh. His eyes. The way he looked at me in the in-between moments, when he thought I wasn’t paying attention and didn’t know I’d catch it anyway.
A week. One perfect week, compressed into something that felt like it lasted a lifetime and no time at all.
And then—
A woman’s voice, sharp and confused, cutting through all of it like a blade. “Wait... that’s your girlfriend?”
Silence. Too much silence. I watched Theron’s expression change in real time, watched guilt bloom behind his eyes before he even opened his mouth.
“Alyssa, wait.”
The restaurant was gone. Rain poured down in sheets while cars rushed past, headlights smearing across my vision. My chest hurt in a way that felt too specific to be imagined, a real ache where something had just been taken out of it.
“Alyssa!”
“Don’t.”
“I can explain.”
“Don’t.”
I walked faster, but his voice kept following me down the street, getting smaller and smaller until it wasn’t a voice at all anymore, just an echo—
“Alyssa!”
“Alyssa?”
I blinked, and the coffee shop rushed back in all at once — the smell of coffee, the low music, the warmth of the room after the cold outside. The cup was still between our hands, exactly where it had been, and Theron was still standing on the other side of the counter, exactly as he had been a second ago. My heart was pounding so hard it actually hurt, a fast, frightened rhythm that had no business existing in a quiet coffee shop on a Tuesday morning. For a moment, I genuinely couldn’t breathe.
What was that?
The feeling started slipping away almost immediately, the way a dream dissolves the second you try to describe it out loud. Hot coffee splashed against the lid as my hand trembled slightly, and only fragments stayed behind. Rain. A restaurant. A heart breaking cleanly in half. Theron shouting my name down a wet street that didn’t exist five minutes ago.
It couldn’t have been real. I must have just zoned out — people did that, especially exhausted, over-caffeinated writers running on four hours of sleep and a manuscript that wouldn’t stop haunting them. People daydreamed. People imagined things. They didn’t live an entire week, a whole relationship, inside the space of a single heartbeat, standing at a counter with their hand still touching someone else’s.
I took the cup fully into my hand, grounding myself in the ordinary weight of it.
“By the way...” Theron smiled, and every detail of that smile was exactly the same as the one from the memory that couldn’t have happened. “If this isn’t too forward, would you let me buy you coffee after work sometime?”
Something tightened in my chest, fast and instinctive. I didn’t know why, and I definitely didn’t understand what had just happened to me in the four seconds our fingers had touched — but every instinct I had screamed the same single answer, loud and immediate.
No.
His smile faltered slightly. “No?”
“I’m sorry.” I forced a polite smile back, the professional kind I used on writers whose work I had to reject. “I’m running late.”
I turned and headed for the door before he could say anything else. Cold air hit my face the moment I stepped back outside, sharp and clean after the warmth of the shop, and I let it clear my head a little. Behind me was the coffee shop, its windows still glowing gold against the grey morning. Ahead of me was Other World Publishing, waiting with its usual quota of manuscripts and disappointments. Somewhere deep inside, a strange, unplaceable feeling remained — as if I had just narrowly avoided something important, or maybe, somehow, already lost it.
At the time, I had no idea it was only the first touch.










