Chapter 1 — The Case Nobody Could Solve
Rain tapped softly against the windows of the police headquarters.
Inspector Adrian Vale sat behind his desk, reading the same case file he had read dozens of times.
Fourteen months had passed since the murder of Elias Hart.
Fourteen months, and the police still had no killer.
Adrian closed the file.
There were no fingerprints that led anywhere.
No weapon had been recovered.
No witness had seen the murder.
And the four people closest to Elias had all been investigated.
None of them could be connected to the crime.
That was why the case had gone cold.
A knock came at the door.
"Come in."
A man entered and sat across from Adrian.
He was the investigator Adrian had requested for the case.
Unlike an ordinary investigator, he had a strange ability.
He could see fragments of a dead person's memories.
Not every memory.
Not whenever he wanted.
Usually, he needed to touch something that had belonged to the dead person. Even then, what he saw was unpredictable. Sometimes it was only a few seconds. Sometimes it was nothing at all.
But when the memories came, they were real.
Adrian pushed the case file toward him.
"This is Elias Hart."
The investigator opened the file.
A photograph showed a young man standing beside a river.
"Elias was twenty-nine," Adrian continued. "He worked as an architectural photographer. Fourteen months ago, he was found dead inside Warehouse 17."
The investigator looked at the photograph.
"Any suspects?"
"Four people were questioned."
Adrian turned the file around.
"Mara Hart, his sister. Jonas Reed, his business partner. Lena Morris, his former girlfriend. Daniel Cross, his neighbour."
"Why weren't any of them charged?"
"Because we couldn't prove any of them were involved."
Adrian pointed to each statement.
"Mara was at home with her daughter."
"Jonas was at his office."
"Lena was having dinner with friends."
"Daniel was at the hospital visiting his mother."
The investigator read the statements carefully.
"So all four had alibis."
"Yes."
"Are the alibis reliable?"
"Reliable enough that we couldn't break them."
The investigator looked at Elias's photograph again.
"Then what am I supposed to find?"
Adrian took a small evidence bag from his drawer.
Inside was a brass key.
The number 17 had been scratched into it.
"This was found in Elias's apartment last week."
The investigator looked at it.
"Was it his?"
"We don't know."
"Where does it belong?"
"We don't know that either."
The investigator held out his hand.
Adrian gave him the evidence bag.
He stared at the key for several seconds.
Then he removed it from the bag.
The moment his fingers touched the metal, the room disappeared.
He was somewhere else.
A narrow hallway.
A yellow light above him.
Elias was standing in front of a wooden table.
He placed the brass key on it.
He looked nervous.
Then someone spoke from somewhere behind him.
"You shouldn't have come."
The memory ended.
The investigator opened his eyes.
He was back in Adrian's office.
Adrian was watching him.
"What did you see?"
"Elias."
"What was he doing?"
"He put this key on a table."
"Where?"
"I don't know."
"Did you see the person who spoke?"
"No."
"Could you hear the voice clearly?"
"Yes."
"What did they say?"
The investigator looked at the key.
"You shouldn't have come."
He repeated the words.
Adrian wrote them down.
"Anything else?"
"No."
Adrian nodded.
"Then let's go to Warehouse 17."
---
The warehouse stood near the river, surrounded by old industrial buildings.
It had been empty since the murder.
Adrian unlocked the entrance.
Inside, the building was quiet.
The investigator walked slowly behind him.
"This is where Elias was found?"
"Yes."
They entered a small room at the back.
There was an old wooden table near the window.
Two chairs stood beside it.
Adrian pointed toward the floor.
"Elias was found here."
The investigator looked around.
Nothing immediately stood out.
He walked toward the table.
"Was this table here when the police arrived?"
"Yes."
He touched it.
Nothing happened.
No memory.
He waited a moment.
Still nothing.
"Sometimes it doesn't work," Adrian said.
"I know."
The investigator moved toward the first chair.
He touched it.
Nothing.
Then he touched the second.
A memory came.
Elias was sitting in the chair.
He was looking at the door.
His hands were tense.
Someone entered the room.
The investigator couldn't see the person's face.
Elias stood.
"You came."
The other person said something, but the memory became distorted.
The investigator saw Elias reach for something on the table.
Then the memory disappeared.
He pulled his hand away from the chair.
"What did you see?" Adrian asked.
"Elias was sitting here."
He pointed to the chair.
"He was waiting for someone."
"Did you see who?"
"No. Their face wasn't visible."
"Did Elias know them?"
"I think so."
"Why?"
"Because he wasn't surprised when they entered."
Adrian looked at the two chairs.
"So there really was another person here."
"Yes."
They examined the room again.
Adrian opened his old crime-scene report.
"According to the original report, Elias was alone when he was last seen."
The investigator looked at him.
"That's impossible."
"Why?"
"I saw him waiting for someone."
Adrian didn't argue.
Instead, he looked through the photographs taken on the night of the murder.
One photograph showed the two chairs.
The investigator studied it.
"Wait."
"What?"
He pointed.
"The second chair."
Adrian looked closely.
In the photograph, the chair was beside the table.
But in the room, it was several feet away.
Adrian frowned.
"Maybe the police moved it."
"They would have recorded that."
Adrian checked the report.
"No record."
The investigator looked at the chair.
"Then someone moved it before the police arrived."
Adrian was silent.
That changed something.
If someone had moved the chair before the police arrived, then the original crime scene was not exactly as they had believed.
But that still didn't tell them who had moved it.
It could have been Elias.
It could have been the person he was meeting.
It could even have happened before either of them entered the room.
There was no way to know yet.
Adrian turned another page.
"Elias was last seen at 10:21 p.m."
"By whom?"
"A shopkeeper near the river."
"And when was he believed to have died?"
"Between 10:30 and 10:45."
The investigator looked toward the window.
"Then we need to know what happened during those twenty-four minutes."
Adrian nodded.
"That's the part nobody has been able to explain."
The investigator looked at Elias's photograph again.
He had seen only two fragments of Elias's memories.
A key.
A room.
A meeting with someone whose face he couldn't see.
None of it revealed the killer.
And perhaps that was the most frustrating part.
They had a dead man.
Four innocent-looking people.
A missing twenty-four minutes.
And a memory that had shown them someone else was in the room.
But it had not shown them who.
Adrian closed the file.
"We start with everyone again."
The investigator looked at the four names.
Mara.
Jonas.
Lena.
Daniel.
At first glance, none of them looked like a killer.
But the investigator had learned something from working with the dead.
Memories could show what happened.
They couldn't always explain why it happened.
And sometimes, the most important part of a murder was the part a memory refused to show.









