A Grandfather's Love
The Morning Star
Arradwen had been aboard Vingilot for perhaps twenty minutes before she noticed something.
Her grandfather was following her.
She crossed from one side of the deck to the other.
Eärendil followed.
She stopped by the rail.
Eärendil stopped.
Arradwen looked at him.
He looked back innocently.
She moved three paces left.
He moved three paces left.
“Grandfather.”
“Yes?”
“Are you following me?”
“No.”
Arradwen stared.
Eärendil stared back.
“You are.”
“I am walking about my own ship.”
“In precisely whichever direction I happen to be walking.”
“It is not an especially large ship.”
Arradwen narrowed her eyes.
She walked deliberately toward the bow.
Eärendil lasted approximately four seconds.
Then followed.
Arradwen turned around.
“Aha!”
Eärendil stopped.
Caught.
He Knows This Is Ridiculous
The worst thing was that Eärendil knew perfectly well what he was doing.
His granddaughter was fifty-one.
Young by Elven reckoning, certainly, but not an infant.
Arradwen had survived fifty years away from Imladris.
She was a healer.
She had traveled among different peoples.
She had apparently crossed Moria at two.
That particular fact still made Eärendil feel faint.
She rode enormous horses.
She had found Maglor.
She had spent two months gaining his trust.
She had then escorted a profoundly ill ancient Elf across Eriador.
She did not require Grandfather hovering six feet behind her on a ship.
Reasonable thought.
Excellent thought.
Eärendil looked at Arradwen.
His granddaughter.
My granddaughter.
grandfather brain immediately obliterated reason.
Desperately.
Family.
Here.
Alive.
Within reach.
Don’t lose sight of her.
Arradwen watched the entire crisis move across his face.
“Oh.”
Eärendil stiffened.
“What?”
“You’re doing what Ada did.”
“I don’t understand.”
“When I came home after fifty years.”
She smiled.
“He didn’t want to let go of me either.”
Eärendil’s expression crumpled.
Arradwen immediately realized her mistake.
“Oh, Grandfather.”
“My son did that?”
“Barnacle.”
“What?”
“That’s what I called it. He became a barnacle.”
Her grandfather started laughing through suddenly wet eyes.
“A barnacle.”
“Very dignified Lord of Imladris. Completely attached to his youngest daughter.”
Eärendil covered his mouth.
His boy.
His little Elrond had become a father who loved his children so intensely that after one came home from a fifty-year absence, he simply...
held on.
Elwing’s Absence Makes It Harder
And there was another reason.
There was nobody waiting for Eärendil after Arradwen left.
Not anymore.
The reality settled differently now that he had accepted it.
Elwing was no longer the person to whom he brought his deepest feelings.
Perhaps their relationship could someday become something else.
Perhaps not.
But the marriage as Eärendil had understood it was finished.
The Silmaril touched his brow.
He felt almost nothing toward it.
Then Arradwen reached for his hand.
Everything.
That contrast hurt.
She noticed.
“Grandfather?”
He looked down at their joined hands.
“I am learning that I have been lonely for a very long time.”
Arradwen squeezed.
“I know.”
“And now...”
He looked at her helplessly.
“You appear.”
Arradwen smiled.
“Very inconvenient.”
A laugh escaped him.
“Extremely.”
“And now you don’t want me to leave.”
Eärendil’s silence answered.
Arradwen Sets the Boundary
She did not pull away.
That was important.
But neither did she promise never to climb down.
“Grandfather.”
Eärendil looked at her.
“I have to go home.”
He flinched.
Arradwen immediately continued.
“And you will come back.”
His expression changed.
“Yes.”
“Tonight?”
“If my course allows.”
“Tomorrow morning?”
“Yes.”
“Then there’s the answer.”
He frowned.
“What answer?”
Arradwen squeezed his hand.
“We don’t stop separating.”
A pause.
“We practice coming back.”
Eärendil went perfectly still.
Oh.
That was the wound.
Not simply separation.
Permanent separation.
Tuor and Idril.
Elrond and Elros.
Ages.
People disappearing beyond his ability to reach them.
Arradwen wasn’t asking him to stop attachment.
She was giving that attachment a healthier rhythm.
Leave.
Return.
Leave.
Return.
No catastrophe required.
“I climb down,” she explained.
“You continue your voyage.”
“You come back.”
“I climb up.”
“You go home again.”
“Yes.”
Eärendil’s eyes filled.
“And one day you may not be able to come?”
Arradwen did not lie.
“One day.”
His expression broke.
“But that is not today.”
No catastrophizing across eternity.
Today first.
Apparently Arradwen had learned something from rehabilitating Maglor.
“Today you’re here.”
“Yes.”
“And when I leave?”
“I go downstairs and annoy Ada.”
Eärendil laughed.
“And Maglor.”
“Yes.”
“And meet your siblings.”
“Yes.”
“And practice medicine.”
“Yes.”
“And perhaps wear the dress Arwen has been trying to put me in.”
Arradwen looked horrified.
“Absolutely not.”
“That answer was very fast.”
“Grandfather, don’t you start.”
He laughed harder.
Grandfather Discovers Hair Kisses
Arradwen sat beside him near the rail.
Eventually her head came to rest against his shoulder.
Eärendil froze.
Again.
Every ordinary gesture still felt miraculous.
He carefully rested his cheek against her hair.
Then kissed the top of her head.
Arradwen made a small contented noise.
Eärendil’s heart nearly stopped.
He did it again.
Arradwen smiled.
“Oh.”
“What?”
“Ada does that.”
His eyes filled immediately.
Of course.
“Hair kisses?”
“Yes.”
Eärendil tried to laugh.
It emerged suspiciously wet.
“So I missed thousands of years only to independently develop the same habit.”
“Apparently it’s hereditary.”
Eärendil kissed her hair again.
Arradwen leaned closer.
Grandfather brain:
🥹❤️
Rational mind made no effort to intervene.
Then Arradwen Says Something Dangerous
“I’ll bring Ada up sometime.”
Eärendil stopped breathing.
Arradwen felt it.
Slowly looked up.
“Grandfather?”
“You could?”
Oh.
Arradwen immediately understood what she’d just offered.
A meeting.
Eärendil and Elrond.
Not star and worshipper.
Not distant father and grieving son.
Father and son.
After Ages.
“I’d have to ask Ada.”
Eärendil nodded quickly.
“Of course.”
“And see whether Grandfather-Starship-Tree climbing is something his nervous system can tolerate.”
“I understand.”
“And you cannot ambush him.”
“Never.”
That came out so emphatically Arradwen believed him.
“He gets to choose.”
“Yes.”
Then Eärendil’s voice became tiny.
“Do you think he might?”
Arradwen touched his cheek.
“Yes.”
No promise about when.
Just possibility.
That was enough to make him cry again.
The Attachment Finds a Healthier Shape
Eventually Arradwen stood.
Eärendil immediately stood too.
She looked at him.
He looked sheepish.
“I have to return.”
“I know.”
He took one breath.
Then another.
Did not grab her.
Good.
Arradwen smiled.
“Grandfather?”
“Yes?”
“Forehead kiss.”
That he could do.
He cupped her face and kissed her forehead carefully.
Arradwen hugged him.
Eärendil held her tightly.
Not indefinitely.
Just enough.
Then released her first.
That was difficult.
And important.
Arradwen noticed.
Her smile softened.
“Good Grandfather.”
His eyes closed.
Those two words nearly destroyed him.
When he opened them again:
“You’ll be careful climbing?”
“Yes.”
“You’ll tell Elrond where you’ve been?”
“...Eventually.”
“Arradwen.”
She stared.
There it was.
Parent voice.
Already.
“Fine.”
“And eat breakfast.”
“Grandfather!”
Eärendil smiled.
Apparently this family’s primary love language really was feeding people.
Arradwen climbed down.
Halfway, she looked up.
Eärendil was still at the rail.
Watching.
She waved.
He waved back.
Then instead of remaining there until she disappeared entirely, Eärendil did something much harder.
He turned back toward the helm.
Arradwen saw.
Her chest warmed.
She continued downward.
No Sea-longing.
No terror.
No abandonment.
Just the knowledge:
Grandfather will come back.
And aboard Vingilot, Eärendil repeated the lesson to himself.
She went home.
Not away.
There was a difference.
A vast one.
For a lonely mariner relearning attachment after Ages, that distinction was going to take time.
But Eärendil had time.
And now, astonishingly, he also had a granddaughter who intended to keep climbing trees until he learned it.









