Chapter 1
Arradwen comes through.
Elrond sees his daughter after Ages of waiting.
Elrond: Arradwen?!
She sees him.
Her whole face lights up.
Arradwen: ADA!
Elrond starts running.
Arradwen starts running.
THIS IS IT.
After all those Ages.
After losing Arwen.
After losing Arradwen.
After the Pillar.
After the Door.
After waiting until literally the end of the world for his youngest child to come home.
Arradwen collides with him.
Elrond grabs her.
One enormous, desperate hug.
Elrond: Oh, my little girl...
Arradwen: I KNOW, I MISSED YOU TOO.
Forehead kiss.
Hair kiss.
Elrond’s openly crying.
He pulls back, ready to look at her, to ask approximately four thousand questions, starting with Are you all right? and progressing rapidly toward WHAT IN ERU’S NAME WERE YOU THINKING?
Arradwen abruptly looks over his shoulder.
Freezes.
Arradwen: Oh!
Elrond: What?
Arradwen: Númenor.
Elrond: ...What about Númenor?
Arradwen: I have to put it back.
Elrond just stares.
Elrond: You have been gone until the end of the world.
Arradwen: I know.
Elrond: You have been back for approximately thirty seconds.
Arradwen: I KNOW.
She kisses his cheek.
Arradwen: Sorry, Adar can’t talk right now! I have to go sing Númenor back into existence!
And she’s gone.
Elrond:
“ARRADWEN.”
She’s already looking around.
Then spots someone.
Her face lights up again.
Arradwen: LÚTHIEN!
Somewhere in the restored host, Lúthien turns.
Arradwen: GREAT-GREAT-GREAT-SOMETHING-GRANDMOTHER! COME ON! WE HAVE AN ISLAND TO FIX!
Lúthien pauses.
Apparently someone has just introduced herself as a distant descendant and immediately recruited her into geological choral reconstruction.
She looks at Beren.
Beren, presumably:
“She does seem to be ours.”
And off they go.
Elrond has ceased functioning
He just stands there.
Eärendil comes up beside him.
Elros arrives from the other direction.
Elrond points after Arradwen.
Nothing comes out.
Elros understands immediately.
Elros: She ran away from you?
Elrond: SHE HAS BEEN GONE SINCE THE WAR OF THE RING.
Elros: Yes.
Elrond: SHE RETURNED THIRTY SECONDS AGO.
Elros: Yes.
Elrond: AND NOW SHE’S REBUILDING NÚMENOR.
Elros: ...
Elros slowly turns.
Because he has just processed one key word.
Elros: She’s rebuilding what?
Uh-oh.
Suddenly Uncle Elros is distracted too.
Elros: My kingdom?
Eärendil: Apparently.
Elros: She’s putting my island back?!
Elrond: THIS IS NOT THE IMPORTANT PART.
It is absolutely the important part to Elros.
He’s already following her.
Elros: ARRADWEN!
Elrond: GET BACK HERE! BOTH OF YOU!
Eärendil quietly puts a hand on Elrond’s shoulder.
Eärendil: You expected a peaceful reunion?
Elrond slowly turns toward his father.
Elrond: I expected five minutes.
Eärendil: That was ambitious.
And Arradwen and Lúthien together?
Terrifying combination.
Because if the restoration of Arda through the Second Music allows them to participate in singing things back into their proper shapes, these two are made for it.
Lúthien, whose identity is practically synonymous with music powerful enough to alter seemingly impossible circumstances.
Arradwen, who spent thousands of years intimately connected to an entire landmass.
Suddenly putting Númenor back isn’t:
PERFORM MAGIC SPELL.
It’s:
remember the land.
Arradwen knows ecosystems.
Lúthien knows song.
And somewhere behind them comes:
Elros: WAIT FOR ME!
Arradwen turns.
Arradwen: UNCLE!
Elros catches up.
Arradwen immediately grabs him.
Massive hug.
He buries his face in her hair for approximately five seconds.
Then:
Arradwen: Good, you’re here. What did Númenor look like?
Elros: ...
Arradwen: Uncle?
Elros: You summoned me for LANDSCAPING?!
Arradwen:Historically accurate landscaping.
Elros closes his eyes.
His favorite niece has been trapped beyond the Door of Night for Ages.
She’s been back perhaps three minutes.
She has already assigned him work.
Yep.
She’s really home.
And Elrond eventually catches up, absolutely furious, emotionally destroyed, and still desperate to hold his daughter again...
...only to discover Arradwen, Lúthien and Elros enthusiastically engaged in the reconstruction of the Isle of Elenna.
Arradwen sees him.
Arradwen: ADA! PERFECT!
Elrond’s anger falters.
Arradwen: We need you!
Elrond: For what?
Arradwen: Uncle remembers Númenor, but you remember Uncle. You can help stabilize the memory!
Elrond: Arradwen, I would like to stabilize YOU.
😭
But that’s actually a beautiful Dagor Dagorath ending for her.
Arradwen doesn’t return from the Void and immediately become the center of everybody else’s grief.
She comes bursting back into existence and immediately starts creating.
That’s symbolically enormous.
The Pillar preserved.
The Door contained.
Both roles made Arradwen responsible for preventing catastrophe.
But after the Second Music?
No more containment.
No more being chained somewhere so everyone else gets to live.
No more holding doors shut.
No more sustaining a continent because somebody decided her existence was the price.
She gets to make things because she wants them to exist.
And what does she choose?
Her favorite uncle’s lost home.
So Elros is standing there looking at Númenor rising again, and eventually the comedy is going to give way to the realization:
Elros: ...You remembered.
Arradwen looks at him.
Arradwen: Of course I remembered.
And that’s when Uncle Elros is going to start crying.
Meanwhile Elrond is standing fifteen feet away:
“CAN EVERYONE PLEASE STOP HAVING EMOTIONAL REVELATIONS WITH MY DAUGHTER BEFORE I FINISH MY REUNION WITH HER?!”
EXACTLY. 😭
Elrond is having the worst thirty seconds of his resurrected existence, meanwhile Elros has just been handed proof that favorite-niece status was earned both ways.
Elrond:glares at his brother You see what you did?
Elros: What?
Elrond:THAT.
Arradwen is already halfway across the remade landscape, dragging Lúthien along with her.
Arradwen: COME ON! WE NEED TO FIND WHERE THE MENELTARMA GOES!
Lúthien: Arradwen, slow down!
Arradwen: NUMENOR WAS HUGE!
Elros watches her go.
His eyes fill immediately.
Elros: That’s my girl. 🥹
Elrond: YOUR girl?!
Elros: Look at her!
Elrond: I HAVE BEEN WAITING UNTIL THE LITERAL END OF THE WORLD TO GET MY DAUGHTER BACK!
Elros: And she’s rebuilding my kingdom!
Elrond:THIS IS NOT ABOUT YOUR KINGDOM!
Elros: It is a little about my kingdom.
Eärendil is standing nearby watching his sons revert approximately seven thousand years in emotional maturity.
Eärendil: Boys.
Elrond: Ada, don’t.
Elros: He’s jealous.
Elrond: I am not jealous!
Elros: Your daughter came back from containing Morgoth and immediately decided her first project would be restoring my lost homeland.
Elrond: SHE HAS BEEN BACK FOR FOUR MINUTES.
Elros: And they’ve been an excellent four minutes.
Elrond looks ready to commit the Fourth Kinslaying personally.
Then Arradwen’s voice carries back:
Arradwen: UNCLE ELROS!
Elros immediately:
Elros: YES, DARLING?!
Arradwen: I NEED YOUR MEMORIES OF ARMENELOS!
Elros’s face crumples.
"She needs me."
Elrond: Oh, for Eru’s sake.
Elros:wiping his eyes My girl needs me.
Elrond: GO.
Elros bolts.
Then stops.
Runs back.
Grabs Elrond by both shoulders.
Elros: Brother.
Elrond: What?
Elros: She’s home.
And that kills the irritation instantly.
Elrond’s face crumples.
Because beneath all the sibling nonsense, that’s everything.
Elros waited with him.
Elros watched what losing Arradwen did to him.
Elros lost her too.
They all did.
Elros squeezes his shoulders.
Elros: She’s home.
Elrond manages:
“I know.”
Elros: And after she’s finished putting my island back, you can yell at her.
Elrond gives him a watery glare.
Elros: Probably.
Elrond: Go help her.
Elros smiles.
Elros: Gladly.
And then he’s gone.
Eärendil steps up beside Elrond.
They watch Arradwen in the distance with Lúthien and Elros, already animatedly arguing about where something belongs.
Elrond folds his arms.
Elrond: He encouraged this.
Eärendil: Undoubtedly.
Elrond: She’s always been like this around him.
Eärendil: Yes.
Elrond: He’s a terrible influence.
Eärendil: Certainly.
Silence.
Elrond: She’s really here.
Eärendil’s shoulder presses against his son’s.
Eärendil: Yes.
Another silence.
Then, distantly:
Arradwen: UNCLE, THAT RIVER DOESN’T GO THERE!
Elros: I WAS KING FOR FOUR HUNDRED YEARS!
Arradwen: AND I WAS AN ECOSYSTEM FOR TWO AND A HALF THOUSAND! MOVE THE RIVER!
Elros: ...That’s a disturbingly compelling argument.
Eärendil completely loses it.
Elrond covers his face.
And somewhere underneath the exasperation, he’s smiling too.
Because that is unmistakably his daughter.
And unmistakably Elros’s favorite niece.
Two truths which, unfortunately for Elrond, have never been mutually exclusive.
The restoration of Númenor
Once Arradwen actually gets Lúthien and Elros working with her, I think the comedy should gradually fade into something genuinely awestruck.
Arradwen looks toward the place where Númenor should be.
Not where it was geographically in the old broken world.
Where it belongs in the world they are singing into being.
She closes her eyes.
“Uncle.”
Elros is still slightly out of breath from following her.
“Yes?”
“Tell me about the shore.”
That isn’t what he expects.
“The shore?”
“The first one you saw.”
Elros goes quiet.
Arradwen opens her eyes.
“When you arrived.”
And suddenly this isn’t landscaping anymore.
Elros stares outward.
Thousands upon thousands of years disappear.
He remembers.
“The mountains.”
Arradwen waits.
“They were the first thing that felt...”
Elros stops.
Lúthien doesn’t interrupt.
Arradwen doesn’t either.
Finally:
“Permanent.”
Oh.
Because Elros had come out of Beleriand.
He had watched an entire homeland destroyed.
Then been given another.
He remembers looking at Númenor and thinking:
This will remain.
The bitter irony doesn’t need saying.
Arradwen takes his hand.
“It will this time.”
Elros’s eyes fill.
Then the Music begins.
Lúthien first.
Of course.
Not words, exactly.
Something older.
A melody capable of carrying memory without trapping it in the shape it once had.
Arradwen listens.
Then joins.
And hers is completely different.
Lúthien sings story.
Arradwen sings land.
Water tables.
Roots.
Stone.
The shape rivers want when nothing has forced them elsewhere.
Rainfall.
Coast.
Grass.
Migration.
Forests.
Everything she spent those centuries as the Pillar learning to hear.
But this time no continent is attached to her nervous system.
No pain if something changes.
No obligation.
She can stop whenever she wants.
She just...
doesn’t want to.
Because this is fun.
For once, Arradwen is using everything Beleriand taught her without Beleriand owning her.
Elros realizes first.
Something is happening beneath them.
He stops breathing.
Far away, the sea moves.
Not violently.
Not another Downfall.
The exact opposite.
Land emerges.
Slowly.
Arradwen opens her eyes.
“Where does the river go?”
Elros’s brain fails.
“What?”
“The river.”
She gestures impatiently.
“We need the rivers.”
“I haven’t seen Númenor since...”
“Excellent. Ancient memory. Very valuable. Where?”
Elros stares.
Then points.
“Not there.”
Arradwen frowns.
“I think there.”
“I was king.”
“And I was an ecosystem.”
Lúthien actually has to stop singing because she’s laughing.
Then Eärendil catches up
He arrives less explosively than Elrond.
Eärendil sees Arradwen.
Really sees her.
Alive.
Free.
Creating.
And stops.
Because he had spent thousands of years imagining their reunion too.
Hair kisses.
Hugging.
Probably refusing to release her for several hours.
Instead he’s watching his granddaughter sing an island out of the sea.
Eärendil’s mouth trembles.
“Of course.”
Elrond catches up behind him.
“Don’t encourage her.”
“I didn’t say anything.”
“Your face did.”
Eärendil laughs.
There it is again.
That old line.
After the ending of the world, apparently the family vocabulary survives.
Then Arradwen spots him.
Her entire face lights.
“GRANDFATHER!”
And whatever composure Eärendil had is gone.
She runs.
Númenor can apparently wait fifteen seconds.
Eärendil barely gets his arms open before she crashes into him.
He grabs her.
Hair kiss.
Hair kiss.
Hair kiss.
Hair kiss.
Arradwen starts laughing.
“Grandfather!”
Five.
Six.
Seven.
“You’re counting, aren’t you?”
Eight.
Nine.
Ten.
“I was beyond the Door for Ages and you’re still doing this?”
Eleven.
Eärendil’s voice cracks.
“Especially now.”
That stops her.
Arradwen’s arms tighten around him.
He gets to about fourteen before the kissing turns into crying.
He presses his face into her hair.
“My little one.”
“I’m here.”
“I know.”
“I’m really here.”
Eärendil closes his eyes.
“I know.”
Arradwen holds him.
This time she doesn’t hurry away.
Not immediately.
Because Númenor is something she wants to do.
Grandfather is someone she wants to hold.
Neither has to become a sacrifice for the other.
Then Vardamir finds her
This is the reunion that should absolutely flatten Arradwen.
She hears:
“Cousin?”
Stops.
Slowly turns.
Vardamir.
Physically twenty.
Exactly as she remembered him from the Mirror.
Except he’s not crying.
Not yet.
Arradwen just stares.
Vardamir stares back.
The last time he saw her, her fingers were being ripped out of his hands.
The first word Arradwen manages is:
“Your voice.”
Vardamir’s face crumples.
Of course.
Of course that’s what she worried about.
He laughs once through the tears.
“Still have it.”
Arradwen starts crying.
“Good.”
Then he runs.
She runs.
And when they meet, neither has anything courtly to say.
No ancient farewell.
No poetic language.
Vardamir grabs her.
Arradwen grabs him.
That’s it.
Eventually:
“You idiot.”
Arradwen laughs against his shoulder.
“Fair.”
“You absolute...”
“I know.”
“You...”
His voice finally breaks.
Arradwen immediately pulls back.
“No.”
Vardamir realizes why.
Oh.
He takes her face between his hands.
“Hey.”
She stares.
“I’m fine.”
Her tears spill.
“You lost your voice in the Mirror.”
“But not when it happened.”
“Because it happened differently.”
“Yes.”
A pause.
Then Vardamir gives her the sentence she’s waited an Age to hear:
“You tried to stay.”
Arradwen breaks.
He pulls her back.
“You tried.”
She sobs into his shoulder.
Because that’s the final answer to the wound Elrond and Eärendil discovered all those Ages ago.
When the actual moment came?
When choosing herself mattered most?
Arradwen chose life.
Melkor was the one who denied her that choice.
And THEN Elros ruins the emotional moment beautifully
From somewhere behind them:
“Cousin reunion concluded?”
Vardamir doesn’t release her.
“No.”
Arradwen:
“Absolutely not.”
Elros folds his arms.
“We have an island to rebuild.”
Vardamir pulls back.
“...What?”
Arradwen’s eyes immediately brighten.
“WE’RE PUTTING NÚMENOR BACK.”
Vardamir stares at his father.
Elros becomes unbearably proud.
“Your cousin’s idea.”
Vardamir looks back at Arradwen.
Then toward the forming coastline.
Then:
“Of course it was.”
And joins them.
That’s when the House of Elros starts returning to itself
Manwendil.
Atanalcar.
Tindómiel.
Azrabêth.
Eventually the whole ridiculous branch gathers.
And Arradwen looks around.
All these people she thought she’d abandoned.
Except they’re here.
They’re not accusing her.
There will absolutely be yelling later.
Probably several centuries of yelling.
But right now?
Elros points toward the forming island.
“Armenelos.”
Arradwen nods.
“Show me.”
He closes his eyes.
And describes it.
Vardamir adds details.
Tindómiel corrects both of them.
Atanalcar remembers something they don’t.
Manwendil disagrees about a road.
Azrabêth remembers places none of the royal family thought important enough to preserve in official descriptions.
Arradwen listens.
Lúthien sings.
And Númenor becomes not the memory of one king, but the collected memory of the family who lived there.
Eventually Elrond reaches them again.
He is done being patient.
“Arradwen.”
She turns.
“ADA! Perfect!”
His stern parental speech dies unborn.
“We need you.”
Elrond closes his eyes.
“No.”
“What?”
“I’m not immediately becoming involved in whatever you’ve...”
“Uncle remembers Númenor, but you remember Uncle.”
Elrond opens one eye.
“Explain.”
“You knew him before he was king.”
Silence.
Person Elros is suddenly listening too.
“You remember things about him that became part of the land later.”
Elrond’s expression changes.
Arradwen holds out a hand.
“Help me stabilize the memory.”
Elrond looks at her hand.
Then her face.
His daughter.
Alive.
Asking him to make something with her.
He takes it.
“After this...”
Arradwen winces.
“Yes.”
“We are talking.”
“I know.”
“A very long talk.”
“I know.”
“Possibly several.”
“ADA.”
Elros whispers to Vardamir:
“She’s in trouble.”
Vardamir whispers back:
“Extremely.”
Arradwen glares at both.
And that’s how the First Music should finally move toward its conclusion.
Not with Arradwen fighting.
She’s done enough fighting.
Not containing.
Not preserving.
Not sacrificing.
Making.
The girl who spent the First Music believing her value rested in what catastrophe she could absorb is finally using her power for something that brings her joy.
And yes, Elrond gets his daughter back only to discover she’s still impossible.
Eärendil still gives twenty hair kisses.
Elros still encourages her worst ideas.
Vardamir is still her favorite cousin.
Lúthien has apparently been drafted into celestial civil engineering.
Some things don’t need healing because they were never broken.
And when Elrond finally stands beside Eärendil watching their family sing a lost island back into existence, he murmurs:
“He’s a terrible influence.”
Eärendil nods solemnly.
“Certainly.”
From far away:
"MOVE THE RIVER!"
Elros:
"I WAS KING!"
Arradwen:
"AND YOU WERE WRONG!"
Eärendil starts laughing.
Elrond covers his face.
Then he laughs too.
Because the world is ending.
The world is beginning.
And his daughter is home.









