Chapter 1: First Steps of a New Life
The Boston College campus in late August had a way of making everything feel possible.
That’s what I kept telling myself as I hauled the last plastic bin up the four flights of stairs to my new dorm room. My arms burned. Sweat traced a slow line down my spine, soaking into the thin cotton of my tank top. The air in the stairwell smelled like fresh paint and industrial cleaner, that particular fragrance of institutional optimism.
You made it, Sarah. You actually made it.
The room itself was small, two twin beds shoved against opposite walls with just enough space between them for a shared desk and a mini-fridge that hummed like it was already exhausted.
I dropped the bin beside my bed and pushed a loose wave of cherry-red hair back from my face. The climb had left strands sticking to my cheeks and neck, and I caught sight of myself in the darkened window for just a second. My green eyes looked brighter against my flushed cheeks and cherry-red hair, and despite my rumpled appearance, I couldn’t help smiling at my reflection.
My roommate hadn’t arrived yet. Her side sat empty, bare mattress and a stripped-down bulletin board, while my stuff was already colonizing every available surface: clothes spilling from my duffel, my keyboard case propped in the corner, a framed photo of Mom and Dad on the windowsill.
I’d spent the last three years making sure this moment would happen. Every document, every form, every official record listed me as female. Sarah Foster. The name felt right on my tongue, tasted like something I’d earned rather than something I’d been given.
At five foot four, with soft curves and a face that people usually read as sweet before they knew anything else about me, I’d worked hard to make my reflection feel like home. The red hair helped. It was impossible to ignore and impossible not to love.
The surgeries, the hormones, the endless waiting for letters and signatures and legal stamps of approval. I’d turned eighteen early in my senior year, giving me time to finish the last of my surgeries and recover before college. Mom and Dad had been there through everything, covering every expense and making sure I had everything I needed. All of it funneled into this one irreducible fact: I was here, and no one knew anything except what I chose to show them.
That was the plan, anyway.
I’d learned early that being stealth wasn’t just about paperwork. It was about the way I stood, the pitch of my laugh, the stories I told and the ones I buried. It was about knowing which restroom to use without checking over my shoulder, which locker room conversations to avoid, which moments to slip away before anyone got too curious. I had a whole atlas of small evasions, and I’d memorized every route.
My phone buzzed on the mattress. Mom.
Made it to the hotel. Dad’s already snoring. Call us tonight if you can. We’re proud of you.
I typed back a quick love you and set the phone face-down. The afternoon sun angled through the blinds, striping the floor in gold and shadow. Outside, someone was blasting music from a car window, some bass-heavy pop song that made the walls vibrate. The whole building hummed with noise and movement and the particular chaos of people starting over.
I pulled my keyboard from its case and set it on the desk, running my fingers over the keys without pressing down. Music had been my anchor through all of it, the one place where I didn’t have to explain or justify or prove anything. The notes just were. They didn’t care what was underneath my clothes or what my birth certificate used to say.
Theater was different. Theater asked you to be seen.
I’d been involved in theater and choir throughout high school, spending countless afternoons rehearsing scenes, learning songs, and preparing for performances. I’d also participated in community theater, which gave me opportunities to work with more experienced performers and tackle productions beyond what my high school could offer. Choir had helped me develop my singing voice, while theater had taught me how to step into a character’s life and make an audience believe in it. I’d loved both enough that choosing theater as my major and music as my minor had felt like the most natural decision in the world.
That was the risk, I guess. The deliberate exposure. I’d chosen it anyway, because standing on a stage and becoming someone else felt like the closest thing to honesty I’d ever known. You could hide in plain sight when the lights were bright enough.
A knock at the door made me jump.
“Yo, anyone in there?”
I crossed the room and opened it to find a girl with a laundry basket balanced on her hip, dark curly hair pulled back in a messy ponytail. She had the kind of smile that took up her whole face.
“I’m Mandy. Your roommate, apparently. God, this stairwell is brutal, right?”
“Sarah.” I stepped back to let her in. “Yeah, I think I lost a lung somewhere around the third floor.”
She laughed and dropped the basket on the empty bed. “Okay, so, quick disclaimer, I snore. Like, apparently it’s really bad. My sister said it sounds like a lawnmower having a crisis. So if you need earplugs, I won’t be offended.”
“Noted.”
“And I’m a morning person. Like, disgustingly. I’ll try to be quiet, but I make no promises.”
“I’m more of a night owl, so we’ll probably balance out.”
She grinned and started unpacking, her movements quick and efficient. Within ten minutes, her side of the room had transformed: fairy lights, a tapestry of some indie band I didn’t recognize, a collection of succulents arranged on the windowsill. She talked the entire time, a steady stream of observations about the campus, the orientation schedule, the cute guy she’d seen in the elevator.
“So what’s your major?” she asked, shaking out a wrinkled poster.
“Theater, with a music minor.”
“Oh, nice. I’m doing psych, but I’m thinking about adding a minor in procrastination. I’m really good at it.”
We spent the next hour getting the room into some semblance of order, then headed down to the dining hall for the welcome dinner. The line stretched halfway across the quad, hundreds of freshmen clutching plastic trays and looking varying degrees of terrified and excited. I spotted a few people from my orientation group, waved at a girl named Priya who’d sat next to me during the campus tour.
The food was exactly what I expected: mediocre pasta, overcooked vegetables, a salad bar that looked like it had been picked over by locusts. Mandy and I found a table near the windows and ate while she scrolled through her phone, occasionally reading out texts from her sister.
“She says if I don’t join at least three clubs, she’s disowning me. Which is fair, honestly. I need structure or I just kind of... dissolve.”
“What clubs are you thinking?”
“Maybe the film society? Or the newspaper. Something where I can be nosy and call it work.”
I laughed. “That’s a solid strategy.”
* * *
The next few days blurred into a rhythm of orientation sessions and icebreaker activities. I sat through presentations about academic integrity and campus safety, learned the fastest route from my dorm to the arts building, and started memorizing faces in the crowd. There were the usual clusters: athletes in their team gear, theater kids already performing even when no one was watching, international students navigating the culture shock with varying degrees of grace.
I kept my head down and my story straight. Sarah Foster, from a small town in Connecticut, daughter of two accountants, here to study theater and music. It was close enough to the truth that I didn’t have to work hard to remember it.
Mom called that evening while I was sitting on my bed, looking through the orientation materials scattered around me.
“Hey, sweetheart! How’s everything going?”
“Good, Mom. Really good, actually.”
“Are you settling in okay? How’s your roommate?”
“Mandy’s great. She talks a lot, but she’s really nice. I think we’re going to get along.”
“That’s wonderful, honey. Your father’s right here. Hang on.”
I heard some rustling, followed by Dad’s voice.
“Hey, pumpkin! How’s my favorite college girl?”
I laughed. “I’m your only college girl, Dad.”
“Doesn’t make you any less my favorite.”
“How’s the dorm?” he asked. “Everything working like it’s supposed to?”
“So far. It’s small, but I like it. And I finally got my keyboard set up.”
“Good. You need anything, you let us know. Money, supplies, whatever. Don’t go without something because you’re worried about asking.”
“Dad, you’ve already done more than enough.”
“Sarah, sweetheart.” Mom’s voice came through again. “You know we don’t see it that way.”
I looked down at the blanket beneath me, running my fingers along a loose thread.
They’d never hesitated when it came to helping me transition. The appointments, the hormones, the surgeries, all the expenses that had seemed impossible when we’d first started talking about them. Mom and Dad had taken care of everything, even when it meant putting things they wanted for themselves on hold. I’d offered to pay them back someday, but Dad had just laughed and told me that being my parents wasn’t a loan.
“I know,” I said softly. “I just really appreciate everything you’ve done for me.”
“And we’d do it all again,” Dad said. “Every bit of it.”
Mom agreed. “We love you, Sarah. All we’ve ever wanted is for you to be happy.”
“I am happy, Mom.”
And I meant it. Sitting there in my own dorm room, with classes about to start and an entire future waiting for me, I felt happier than I could remember being.
“Good,” Dad said. “Now, don’t spend all your time studying. Make some friends, have some fun, maybe find yourself a nice boyfriend.”
“Dad!”
“What? I’m just saying!”
Mom laughed. “Ignore him, sweetheart. You enjoy yourself, and call us whenever you feel like talking, okay?”
“I will. Love you both.”
“Love you too, honey,” Mom said.
“Love you, pumpkin,” Dad added. “And remember, we’re only a phone call away.”
When we hung up, I sat there smiling at my phone for a moment. I missed them already, but knowing they were there whenever I needed them made being away from home a little easier.
I set my phone on the nightstand and went back to sorting through my orientation materials, feeling more excited than ever about what the coming semester might bring.
* * *
The first day of classes arrived with a cool morning that made me glad I’d brought a hoodie. I walked to the arts building with my earbuds in, some Chopin nocturne playing low enough that I could still hear the conversations of students hurrying past me.
The building itself was old, brick and ivy, with creaking floors and rehearsal rooms that smelled like dust and rosin.
Acting 101 met in a black box theater on the ground floor. I got there early, claimed a seat near the back, and watched the other students trickle in. There was the usual mix: confident kids who’d done theater in high school, shy ones who sat with their shoulders hunched, a few who looked like they’d wandered in by mistake.
And then there was Jesse.
He came in with a group of guys, laughing at something one of them had said. Tall and broad-shouldered, with dark hair that curled slightly at the ends and the kind of easy smile that made you want to know the joke, he moved through the room like he’d already decided he belonged there. He was wearing a faded band T-shirt and jeans with a hole in one knee.
I didn’t stare. I was good at not staring.
Professor Delgado started the class with the usual syllabus review, then launched into an improv exercise that had half the room dying of embarrassment within the first ten minutes. I volunteered when she called for pairs, mostly because I’d rather control my own humiliation than have it thrust upon me.
“Good,” she said after our scene ended. “You’ve got instincts. Don’t lose them.”
The hour passed quickly. When we broke for the day, I gathered my things and headed for the door, already mentally mapping out the rest of my schedule.
“Hey, Sarah, right?”
I turned. Jesse was beside me, messenger bag slung across his chest, hands shoved in his pockets.
“Yeah. Jesse, right?”
“Guilty.” He fell into step beside me as we headed down the hallway. “You were good in there. The improv thing. You actually listened instead of just waiting for your turn to talk.”
“Thanks. I’ve had practice.”
“Community theater?”
“Something like that.”
His gaze flicked briefly to my hair before returning to my face. “Also, for the record, you’ve got unfairly great hair.”
I laughed. “That’s a new one.”
We pushed through the double doors into the mild September air. The quad was full of students moving between buildings, bikes weaving through foot traffic, someone handing out flyers for a comedy show. I could smell coffee from the cart near the library, mixing with the fresh scent of grass and the faint promise of autumn.
“Where you headed?” he asked.
“Music theory. You?”
“Same, actually. Well, not the same class, but the same building. I’m doing the theater major too, but I’m thinking about a minor in film.”
We walked together, the conversation drifting between light topics: favorite directors, the best places to eat off campus, whether the campus coffee was actually good or just convenient. He had this way of asking questions that felt genuine, not like he was just filling silence. By the time we reached the music building, I’d learned he was from Chicago, had a younger sister, and had spent the summer working at a movie theater where he’d watched the same blockbuster seventeen times.
“I can recite the entire thing from memory,” he said. “It’s a curse.”
“I’m sure that’ll come in handy someday.”
“It already has. Impressed my sister’s friends at a party. I was the life of the event.”
I laughed before I could stop myself. “I’m sure they were thrilled.”
We paused outside the door to my classroom. He was supposed to keep going to the end of the hall, but he lingered, shifting his weight like he was deciding something.
“Hey, so, a bunch of us are getting together to study for Delgado’s class next week. Nothing formal, just hanging out in the lounge. You should come.”
“Maybe. I’ll see how my schedule looks.”
“Cool. Cool, cool.” He nodded a few times, then seemed to realize he was still standing there. “Okay, well. See you around, Sarah.”
“See you.”
He turned and walked away, and I watched him go for exactly two seconds before catching myself. Don’t.
* * *
The weeks that followed settled into something like a routine. Classes, homework, the occasional dorm event that Mandy dragged me to, more dinners in the dining hall where we complained about the food and made plans we’d probably never follow through on. My music theory class was harder than I’d expected, all those Roman numerals and figured bass lines that made my head spin. I spent most evenings in the practice rooms, working through my keyboard exercises until my fingers cramped.
One of the biggest events during those first few weeks was auditioning for the theater department’s fall production of Legally Blonde: The Musical. I’d loved the show for years, and when I saw the audition announcement, I knew I had to try. I spent several evenings practicing my audition song, sometimes staying in the music building long after I’d finished everything else. My music background gave me confidence in my singing, but I knew that wouldn’t guarantee anything. There were talented students in the department, including upperclassmen who’d already performed in several productions.
I’d set my sights on Elle Woods, although I knew landing the lead as a freshman was a long shot. My initial audition went well enough to earn me a callback, which was encouraging until I walked into the room and saw the competition. One of the juniors had an incredible voice and the kind of stage presence that made it difficult to look anywhere else. I gave my best performance, but I wasn’t particularly surprised when she was cast as Elle.
What did surprise me was seeing my name beside Vivienne Kensington on the cast list. I’d read for the character during callbacks, but I hadn’t expected to land such a substantial role. I stood there staring at the announcement for a moment, making absolutely sure I wasn’t imagining it. Vivienne wasn’t exactly the sweet, approachable type, which made the prospect of playing her even more exciting. I’d have to work at portraying someone so different from myself, and I was looking forward to the challenge.
Jesse had auditioned too, and he’d landed Warner Huntington III. Apparently, the directors thought his natural charm suited the character, although Jesse insisted he was offended by the implication that he could convincingly play someone so shallow. I told him I wasn’t entirely sure it required much acting on his part, which earned me an exaggerated look of betrayal.
The funniest part was realizing that Vivienne and Warner were a couple in the show. Jesse seemed particularly pleased about that, pointing out that we’d be spending quite a bit of time together during rehearsals. I pretended the thought didn’t make my stomach flutter.
Rehearsals started soon afterward, adding another commitment to an already busy schedule. Between learning music, working through scenes, and getting to know the rest of the cast, I was beginning to understand just how demanding college theater could be. But every time I walked into rehearsal, I felt a little more certain that I’d chosen the right place to be.
Jesse showed up everywhere. We ended up in the same study group, the same late-night coffee runs, the same conversations that stretched past midnight over text. He was easy to be around, funny without trying too hard, and he had this way of looking at me that made me feel like I was the only person in the room.
It was dangerous. I knew it was dangerous.
But I kept answering his texts anyway.
By mid-October, we’d settled into a friendship that felt more solid than anything I’d had before. He’d introduced me to his friends, a rotating cast of theater kids and film nerds who adopted me as one of their own. I’d started eating lunch with them, sitting through their debates about whether the latest Marvel movie was actually good or just loud. It was normal. It was easy. It was terrifying in ways I tried not to think about.
He doesn’t know, I reminded myself every time he smiled at me. And he never will.
* * *
The assignment was simple enough: read a scene from a contemporary play, analyze it, and present our findings to the class. Jesse and I ended up in the same group, which meant we were supposed to meet outside of class to work on it. Mandy had plans to spend the evening studying at the library, so I offered to let him come over.
It seemed perfectly reasonable when I suggested it. We’d been spending time together for weeks, and working on an assignment was hardly an excuse to get nervous. Still, the thought of having him alone in my room made me reconsider just how reasonable I’d been.
Mandy had already left for the library when Jesse knocked on my door. I’d spent the previous fifteen minutes straightening things that didn’t need straightening, including the books on my desk and the blanket folded at the foot of my bed.
I opened the door to find him standing in the hallway, laptop tucked under one arm and a backpack slung over his shoulder.
“Hey,” he said, smiling. “Hope I’m not early.”
“Right on time, actually. Come in.”
He stepped inside, glancing around the room while I closed the door behind him.
“Nice place. I like what you’ve done with it.”
“It’s a dorm room, Jesse. There isn’t much to work with.”
“Sure, but you’ve managed to make it look like someone actually lives here. Mine still looks like a storage closet with beds.”
I laughed and gestured toward the desk. “We can work over there. I’ve got a copy of the script.”
“Perfect. I’ve got my notes too.”
He pulled out the desk chair while I sat on the edge of my bed with my laptop. He turned the chair toward me so we could both see the screen, and I did my best to ignore how different it felt having him here instead of meeting somewhere on campus.
We worked through the scene together, comparing notes, arguing about interpretation. The script was a two-hander, the kind of play where everyone talks around the real subject and says everything except what they mean. The characters circled each other, all that unspoken tension just beneath the surface.
“This is the part that gets me,” Jesse said, pointing to a line near the end. “He says he doesn’t care, but then he does this whole monologue about all the things he remembers. That’s not someone who doesn’t care.”
“Maybe he’s lying to himself. Maybe he thinks if he says it out loud enough, it’ll be true.”
“Or maybe he just can’t say the real thing.”
I looked up from my notes and caught him watching me. Something shifted in the air, a subtle change in pressure. He glanced away first, back to the screen.
“Anyway. I think we’ve got enough for the presentation.”
“Yeah. Probably.”
We finished the rest of the assignment quickly, falling back into the comfortable rhythm of collaboration. By the time we were done, the sun had set and the room had darkened into that particular twilight that made everything feel softer.
“I’m starving,” Jesse said, closing his laptop. “Any chance you’ve got something to eat?”
“I’ve got ramen. Unless you want to order something.”
“Ramen sounds perfect.”
I got up and retrieved two cups from the small collection of snacks I’d brought from home, then filled the electric kettle on my desk. Jesse leaned back in his chair, watching me.
“Very impressive,” he said. “A full-service dining establishment.”
“Five stars. Just don’t expect table service.”
He laughed while I waited for the water to boil. There was something nice about having him here, the way he seemed completely comfortable in my space. We’d gotten close enough over the past few weeks that quiet wasn’t awkward anymore.
I handed Jesse his ramen and settled back onto my bed with my own cup.
“So,” he said, looking over at me, “what’s your deal?”
“My deal?”
“Yeah. Like, where do you come from? What’s your story?”
I wrapped my hands around the cup, letting the heat seep into my palms. “Nothing interesting. Small town, boring childhood, parents who love me. The usual.”
“Come on, there’s got to be more to it than that.”
I shrugged. “I’m a pretty boring person, Jesse.”
“I don’t believe that.”
He moved from the desk chair to sit on the floor beside my bed, leaning back against the mattress with his legs stretched out in front of him. The lamplight caught the line of his jaw, the faint shadow of stubble he hadn’t bothered to shave.
“What about you?” I asked. “What’s your deal?”
“Party of four, middle child, perpetually overlooked. I discovered acting because it was the only way to get attention.”
“That’s kind of sad.”
“It’s fine. I’ve made peace with it.” He grinned. “Plus, I’m very charming, so it all worked out.”
We talked for another hour, the conversation drifting from families to favorite movies to the things we wanted out of life. Jesse told me he’d wanted to become a professional actor for as long as he could remember, preferably in film or television, although he wouldn’t turn down Broadway if the opportunity came along.
“I figure I’ve got the looks for it,” he said with a grin. “Now I just have to convince someone I can actually act.”
I laughed. “At least you’re modest.”
“Hey, I know what I look like. Doesn’t mean I think I’m better than anybody else.”
There was something refreshing about his confidence. He knew he was attractive, and he wasn’t going to pretend otherwise, but he didn’t seem particularly impressed with himself either. He was just comfortable with who he was.
He told me about the actors he admired and the kinds of roles he hoped to play someday. I told him about music, how it was the only thing that made sense when everything else was noise.
“You should play for me some time,” he said.
“Maybe. If you’re lucky.”
“I’m very lucky. It’s one of my defining traits.”
I finished my ramen and set the cup on the desk. The room had grown warmer, or maybe that was just the effect of sitting in one place for too long. He stretched his arms overhead, and his hoodie rode up, exposing a strip of stomach. I looked away.
“You okay?” he asked.
“Yeah. Just tired.”
“We can call it a night if you want. I should probably get back to my dorm anyway.”
I should have agreed. I should have walked him to the door, wished him goodnight, and spent the rest of the evening pretending I hadn’t been thinking about kissing him for weeks. Instead, I found myself wishing he’d stay a little longer.
“I’m fine,” I said instead.
He watched me for a moment, then got to his feet. “You’ve got an electric kettle, right? Mind if I make some tea?”
“Go ahead. The kettle’s on the desk, and the tea bags are beside it.”
“Want some?”
“Sure.”
I stayed on the bed while he filled the kettle and rummaged through my collection of tea bags, eventually holding up two different flavors for my approval. I pointed to one, and he grinned before dropping the bags into our mugs.
A few minutes later, he handed me my tea and settled beside me on the bed. We talked for a while longer, sipping our drinks and trading jokes about our professors. When we’d finished, Jesse got up to put our mugs on the desk.
I stood to stretch my legs, and as he turned back toward me, we found ourselves standing unexpectedly close. His hand brushed mine, and when I looked up, his eyes were already on me.
Neither of us moved away.
The air between us went still, thick with something unspoken. His eyes met mine and held, and for a second I couldn’t breathe.
“Sarah,” he said, voice lower than before.
“Yeah?”
“I don’t know how to say this.”
“Say what?”
He laughed, a quiet exhale that didn’t quite reach his eyes. “Never mind. Forget it.”
“No, tell me.”
He turned to face me fully, and now we were standing close enough that I could feel the warmth radiating off his skin. He smelled like soap and something faintly woodsy, and his eyes were dark in the dim light of the room.
“I like you,” he said. “Like, more than just friends. And I’ve been trying to ignore it because I didn’t want to make things weird, but I keep thinking about you. All the time. And I don’t know if you feel the same way, and if you don’t, that’s fine, I’ll get over it, but I just...”
He trailed off. His hands hung at his sides, fingers flexing like he was trying not to reach for me.
The words sat between us, waiting.
I could have deflected. I could have made a joke, changed the subject, escaped into the safe territory of friendship. That was the smart move. That was the move that kept everything intact.
But I was tired of being smart.
“I like you too,” I said.
His expression shifted, surprise and relief and something else, something warmer. His dark brown eyes searched mine, as though he needed to be absolutely certain he’d heard me correctly.
“Yeah?”
“Yeah.”
He stepped closer, and now there was barely any space between us. I could see the flecks of gold in his irises, the small scar on his chin I’d never noticed before. His hand came up, slow and careful, and cupped my cheek.
“Tell me if I’m reading this wrong,” he said.
“You’re not.”
He kissed me.
It started gentle, his lips brushing against mine like he was asking a question. I answered by leaning in, letting my eyes close, letting my hands find the front of his hoodie. He made a sound low in his throat, something between a sigh and a groan, and deepened the kiss.
His mouth was warm, insistent without being rushed. He tasted like the tea he’d been drinking, all faint sweetness and heat. And his hands moved from my face to my shoulders, sliding down my arms, pulling me closer until there was no space left between us.
I hadn’t been kissed like this in a long time. Maybe ever. There was something about the way he held me, the way he kept pulling back just enough to look at my face before diving back in, that made me feel seen.
That was the dangerous part. The part where being seen meant being exposed.
But his hands were at my waist now, and his mouth had moved to my jaw, my neck, and I couldn’t think about consequences when his lips were doing that.
“You have no idea,” he murmured against my skin, “how long I’ve wanted to do this.”
“Show me, then.”
He pulled back just far enough to look at me, a question in his eyes. I answered by taking his hand and pressing it to my chest, letting him feel the rapid flutter of my heartbeat underneath his palm.
He kissed me again, harder this time, his tongue sliding against mine while he walked me backward toward the bed. My knees hit the edge of the mattress and I sat down, pulling him with me.
We lay there tangled together, his weight pressing me into the pillows, the heat between us building with every touch. His hand found the hem of my shirt and hovered there, waiting for permission.
“Yes,” I said, and his fingers slipped underneath.
The first touch of his skin against mine sent a shiver down my spine. He traced the curve of my waist, the ridge of my ribs, the sensitive skin just below my breasts. I arched into him, wanting more, and he obliged, his thumb brushing over the thin fabric of my bra.
“You’re beautiful,” he said. “God, Sarah, you’re so...”
He didn’t finish the sentence. He kissed me instead, and his hands kept moving, exploring, learning the shape of me.
I’d spent years making sure nobody would ever have a reason to question who I was. Every surgery, every appointment, every dollar had brought me closer to the life I’d wanted. There was nothing about being with Jesse that should have frightened me, and yet I couldn’t quite silence the fear that somehow, some way, he’d discover the one thing I’d promised myself nobody at college would ever know.
But his hands didn’t wander where I feared they would. He stayed above my waist, paying attention to the places I gave him access to, reading my responses like a script he was memorizing. When I pulled him closer, he came. When I let out a small gasp, he did it again.
“Tell me what you like,” he whispered.
“This. Keep doing this.”
He smiled against my mouth. “I can do that.”
The kissing deepened, grew more urgent. His hips settled against mine, and I could feel him through the layers of clothing, the hard length of him pressing into my thigh. He shifted, and I felt the heat of it, the weight of his arousal, and part of me wanted to let go, to let whatever was going to happen, happen.
But another part, the part that had spent years building walls, hesitated.
Not yet, I thought. Not like this.
I pulled back just enough to look at him. His eyes were dark, pupils blown wide, breath coming faster than usual. He looked like he wanted to devour me.
“I don’t want to stop,” he said.
“I don’t want you to.”
“I mean it. I’ve been thinking about this since the day we met.”
“Then stop thinking.”
He kissed me again, and his hands moved lower, skating past my waist, over the denim of my jeans. His fingers found the button and hovered there, a wordless question.
I should have stopped him. I knew the script, knew what came next, knew that this was the boundary I’d sworn I wouldn’t cross with anyone who didn’t know the truth.
But the truth was complicated. The truth was a story I didn’t want to tell. And right now, with his lips on my neck and his body pressed against mine and his hands so close to the place I’d been guarding for years, I didn’t want complicated.
I wanted him.
“Jesse,” I said, and my voice came out rougher than I meant it to.
He stilled immediately, pulling back to look at me. “Yeah?”
“I want this. I just...”
I didn’t know how to finish the sentence. I wanted him, probably more than I’d wanted anyone before, but letting someone this close was unfamiliar territory. I’d spent so long protecting my privacy that opening myself up to another person, even someone I trusted, frightened me more than I wanted to admit.
I wasn’t ready to let those fears control everything, though. I wanted to experience this, to be a girl falling for a boy without worrying about anything beyond the two of us.
“I want you,” I said. “But we have to go slow.”
He nodded, understanding softening his expression. “Okay. We go slow.”
His hands withdrew from my jeans, but they didn’t go far. He traced the line of my hip instead, the curve of my waist, the sensitive skin at the small of my back. And then his lips found mine again, and for a while, there was nothing but the slow dance of our mouths and the steady rhythm of our breathing and the heat building between us like water coming to a boil.
We stayed like that for a long time, learning each other one touch at a time. He explored every inch of me he was allowed to touch, and I found myself responding in ways I hadn’t expected. My body arched into him, wanting more, and when he pressed his thigh between my legs, I gasped.
“Good?” he asked.
“Very.”
He smiled, that slow, easy smile that made my stomach flip. “I want to make you feel good. I want to make you feel so fucking good, Sarah.”
His hand found my breast, squeezing gently, his thumb finding the hard point of my nipple. I moaned into his mouth, and he swallowed the sound, kissing me deeper.
Then his lips began to move lower.
He kissed my neck, my collarbone, the hollow of my throat. His hands pushed my shirt up, and he pressed his mouth to the flat plane of my stomach, learning the taste of my skin.
“Is this okay?” he asked, pausing at the edge of my ribcage.
“Yes.”
He peeled my shirt over my head, and I was suddenly exposed, lying beneath him in just my bra and jeans. His eyes traveled over me, and for a moment, I was terrified. But what I saw in his face wasn’t confusion.
It was hunger.
“Fuck,” he said quietly. “You’re gorgeous.”
He leaned down and kissed me again, and his hands found the clasp of my bra, unhooking it with a flick that would have impressed me if I’d had the capacity to be impressed. He pulled it away, and then his mouth was on my breast, hot and wet, his tongue circling my nipple.
I arched off the bed, a sound escaping me that didn’t sound like my voice. He sucked harder, and my fingers tangled in his hair, holding him to me.
“Jesse, oh god.”
He hummed against my skin, and the vibration shot straight to my core. My hips bucked against his, and he groaned in response, grinding back against me.
“You’re so responsive,” he murmured, switching to my other breast. “I love it. I love the sounds you make.”
I should have been embarrassed. I should have felt exposed. But all I felt was alive, every nerve ending lit up like a Christmas tree, my body finally getting what it had been craving for longer than I’d realized.
He kissed a path down my stomach, his fingers hooking into my belt loops. “Can I?”
I knew what he was asking. And I knew what I had to say.
“Not yet,” I whispered. “Not this time. But I want... I want to feel you.”
His brow furrowed. “I’m not sure what you mean.”
I reached down and pressed my hand against the bulge in his jeans, feeling the heat and the weight of him through the fabric.
“Oh,” he said.
“Yeah.”
“I thought you said slow.”
“I said go slow. I didn’t say stop.”
Something shifted in his expression. The hesitancy melted away, replaced by raw want. He leaned down and kissed me, and I felt his hands at his own belt, heard the clink of metal as he undid his jeans.
He didn’t undress completely. He just pulled them down enough to free himself, and then he took my hand and guided it to his cock.
He was thick and warm, the skin smooth as polished stone. I wrapped my fingers around him, feeling the weight of him, the way he twitched at my touch.
“Fuck,” he breathed. “Your hands are so soft.”
I stroked him slowly, learning the shape of him, the way his breath caught each time I found a particularly sensitive spot. His eyes fluttered closed, and his head dropped to my shoulder.
“Am I doing okay?” I asked.
“You’re doing incredible. Don’t stop.”
I didn’t. I kept stroking, faster now, watching his face change, watching the tension build in his jaw. His hips began to move in rhythm with my hand, small shallow thrusts that pressed him into my palm.
“Sarah, I’m not going to last long if you keep doing that.”
“Then don’t.”
He groaned and kissed me, messy and urgent, his tongue sliding against mine. “You’re going to be the death of me.”
“What a way to go.”
He laughed, then gasped as I twisted my wrist just so. “Okay, okay, fuck. Wait.”
“For what?”
He looked at me, and even in the dim light of the room, I could see the raw want in his eyes. “I want you to be part of this. I want to feel you come.”
I hadn’t expected that. “Jesse, I...”
“Just your hand. Or mine. I want to see what you look like when you fall apart.”
The offer hung in the air between us. I could have said no. I probably should have. But the ache between my legs had become impossible to ignore, and the idea of him touching me, even just the way he was asking, was more than I could resist.
“Okay,” I whispered.
He kissed me, slow and deep. “Tell me if you change your mind.”
“I won’t.”
He shifted, his weight pressing me into the mattress, and his hand slid down the front of my jeans. His fingers found the damp heat between my legs, and I heard his breath catch.
“Jesus, Sarah. You’re soaking.”
“Shut up.”
“Not a chance. This is the hottest thing I’ve ever felt.”
His fingers moved in slow circles, learning the shape of me, finding the spots that made me gasp. I clung to him, my nails digging into his shoulders.
“And you’re tight,” he murmured. “God, I can feel how tight you are.”
I bit my lip to keep from crying out. His fingers pressed in deeper, curling at just the right angle, and I saw stars.
“Right there,” I said. “Don’t stop.”
“I won’t. I’ve got you.”
He kept touching me, his thumb tracing circles while his fingers moved inside me, and I felt the pressure building in my core, slow and inevitable.
“Jesse, I’m close.”
“Let go. I want to see it.”
He leaned down and sucked my nipple into his mouth, and that was it. The pressure broke, and I came with a cry, my body clenching around his fingers, my hips bucking off the bed.
He worked me through it, drawing it out, not stopping until I pushed his hand away, oversensitive and breathless. He pulled back to look at me, and the expression on his face was something between awe and hunger.
“You’re so beautiful when you come.”
I laughed, shaky and breathless. “Shut up.”
“Never.”
He kissed me, long and slow, and his hips pressed against my thigh. I could still feel him, hard and wanting, and I reached for him again.
“I haven’t finished with you yet,” I said.
“Sarah, you don’t have to...”
“I want to.”
His eyes searched mine. Whatever he found there must have satisfied him, because he nodded, and I wrapped my hand around him again.
He was slick with precum, and the slide of my palm made him groan low in his throat. I watched his face as I worked him, watched the way his brow furrowed, the way his lips parted, the way his hips stuttered when I found the right rhythm.
“That’s it,” I whispered. “Fuck my hand, Jesse.”
“Jesus Christ.”
He thrust into my grip, the wet sounds of skin-on-skin filling the small room. His breathing grew ragged, his movements more urgent.
“I’m close,” he warned. “Where do you want it?”
“On me. On my tits.”
“Fuck. Fuck, Sarah.”
He pulled back, and I let go as he jerked himself the rest of the way, and then he was coming, thick ropes of heat splashing across my chest, my stomach, my breasts. I watched his face as he rode it out, watched the way his whole body shuddered with release.
He collapsed beside me, breathing hard. For a long moment, neither of us spoke.
Then he laughed. “Holy shit.”
I laughed too, giddy and light. “Yeah.”
He found a towel and cleaned me up, then pulled me into his arms. We lay tangled together, his heartbeat slow against my ear.
“So,” he said.
“So.”
“I’m really glad I kissed you.”
I smiled against his chest. “Me too.”
We drifted for a while, somewhere between sleep and waking. The room had gone dark, and I could hear music from somewhere down the hall, something soft and acoustic.
Then his hand moved lower again, and I felt a fresh spark of heat.
Again? Already?
The thought barely had time to register before his fingers were sliding through the slick heat between my thighs, and I realized he wasn’t finished with me.
He wasn’t even close.










