A Good Night for Bad Decisions
It’s Friday night and here I am in the middle of a loud bar, playing third wheel.
I sigh and run a hand through my hair as I look at my best friend Sam out there on the dance floor with Leon, her latest conquest. I take another swig of my beer, which has gone lukewarm and flat in the hot, crowded room. I eye the bar counter with envy, but I don’t want to get up and risk losing these rare seats.
The band is playing some Irish folk music and Sam and Leon are pretending to Riverdance. They look like idiots, but at least they’re happy idiots.
A guy walks up to me. I already clocked him from the other side of the room where he was eying me. I’ve tried to show my resting bitch face, but I guess he either can’t read it or chose to ignore it. Both suck.
“Hey, pretty lady, you come here often?” he asks. I blink at him. “Wow. Does that line actually work?” He grins, apparently mistaking my disbelief for encouragement. “Depends. Is it working on you?” I take a deep breath, swallowing my frustration at his inability to process what I’m trying to give him. I think I know how this will end.
“Not even a little,” I say calmly, almost bored. He laughs, then glances at the empty space across from me. “Mind if I sit?” I try to dissuade him. “Actually, I—” Too late. He’s already sliding into the booth. Fantastic.
“So, what’s your name?” I take another sip of my increasingly tragic beer. “Not interested.” He chuckles. “That’s an unusual name.” “And yet, remarkably easy to remember.” I say with something that sounds like ice in my voice. He still doesn’t seem to get it.
Across the room, Sam catches my eye. Her grin widens as she takes in my predicament. Instead of rescuing me, the traitor gives me an enthusiastic thumbs-up. I’m going to kill her.
I turn back to the guy across from me and take a deep breath. I’m done with him, with this situation and with pretending to want to play nice any longer. “Look, I know. Pretty girl, all alone at a loud bar, drink almost empty.” I start and I see him nod. Idiot.
“But what you don’t know is that I’m actually enjoying myself. Or at least I was, until you decided to conduct a hostage situation in my booth.” He laughs, leaning back against the worn leather seat like I’ve just told him the funniest joke he’s heard all night. “Feisty. I like that.”
Of course he does. “That’s wonderful,” I reply, sarcasm dripping from my voice now as I plaster on the fakest smile I can muster. “Unfortunately, your approval wasn’t something I was looking for.” My smile drops instantly.
“Come on, sweetheart. I’m just trying to be friendly.” He says and I can feel my hand clench into a fist. “And I’m trying to be left alone. See? We both have dreams.” His smile finally falters for half a second before returning with renewed determination. “You’re a tough one, aren’t you?”
I stare at him, trying to gauge if he’s intoxicated enough yet that he won’t see my swinging fist coming towards his face.
It’s genuinely fascinating how some men can interpret a woman telling them to leave as an invitation to try harder. Somewhere in the evolutionary process, something has gone terribly wrong.
“Listen,” I say, setting my beer down. “I’m sure you’re a perfectly adequate human being,” lie, “but I’m not interested. So, unless you’re planning on buying this booth from the establishment, I’d appreciate having it back.”
He looks at me for a moment, then shakes his head with a disbelieving laugh. “Jesus. You don’t have to be such a bitch about it.” Ah. There it is.
The transformation from charming stranger to wounded asshole. A classic. Practically deserves its own nature documentary. “You’re right,” I say sweetly. “I could’ve been much nicer. Unfortunately, you seem to have mistaken my politeness for a negotiation.”
He opens his mouth, presumably to deliver another dazzling contribution to modern discourse, but a voice cuts through the noise from somewhere beside our table.
“Everything alright here?”
It’s a man’s voice. Deep, calm, and carrying just enough authority to make the guy across from me turn his head. I look up. He’s tall. That’s my first observation.
Broad shoulders beneath a dark blue crewneck sweater, dark hair that looks like someone has run their fingers through it a few times, and a face that’s unfairly attractive for someone who has apparently just wandered into my evening.
He isn’t looking at me, though. He’s looking at my unwanted guest.
“Yeah, man,” the guy says, his tone immediately changing. “We’re just talking.” The newcomer nods once. “Good.” Then he looks at me. And simply smiles a genuine smile. “Sorry to interrupt.” He extends his hand. “I’m Nate.”
I glance down at his hand. Well… That’s unexpected. Apparently, somewhere in Boston, a man still remembers how introductions work. I take his hand. “Angie.” His grip is warm and firm, and he gives my hand a brief, perfectly normal shake before letting go. No lingering. No weird thumb stroking. Another pleasant surprise.
“Nice to meet you, Angie,” he says. “Likewise.” The guy across from me looks between us. “Seriously? You’re gonna talk to him?”
I turn back toward him. “Well, he did manage to introduce himself without calling me sweetheart. It’s a compelling opening argument.”
Nate’s mouth twitches. “That’s a pretty low bar,” he observes. “You’d be amazed how many people trip over it.” This time he laughs, a genuine, low sound that somehow manages to reach me over the music.
The other guy slides out of the booth with an irritated scoff. “Whatever. Have fun with that one, buddy.” Nate watches him leave before turning back to me. “Well,” he says, “that seemed pleasant.” I nod, my face serious. “Absolutely delightful. I’m thinking of inviting him to Thanksgiving.” The corner of his mouth moves again.
“Bit early to introduce him to the family, don’t you think?” He plays along. “Oh, no. My brother would love him.”
He takes a second, eyes narrowing. “Really?” I laugh now. “God, no. He’d probably throw him through a window.” Nate laughs again. And damn it, I find myself smiling.
He glances toward the now-empty seat across from me, then back at my face. “Would you mind if I joined you for a minute? Or are you enjoying your solitude?” I raise an eyebrow. “You’re actually asking?“. He shrugs. “It’s generally considered polite.”
“Apparently you’re an endangered species.”
“So I’ve been told.”
I study him for a moment. There’s something vaguely familiar about his face, though I can’t quite place it. Maybe I’ve seen him around Boston. Maybe he just has one of those faces.
Either way, he hasn’t annoyed me yet. Which, given how this evening is going, is practically a miracle. I gesture toward the empty seat. “Go ahead.” He slides into the booth, leaving a comfortable amount of space between us.
“Can I get you another drink?” he asks, nodding toward my glass. I glance at the sad remains of my beer. “Are you offering because you’re hoping to get something out of it?” I ask, testing how he will respond.
“No,” he answers without hesitation. “I’m offering because that beer looks like it’s been through something traumatic.” I look down at the glass. Then back at him. “You’re not wrong.”
“What are you drinking?” He asks. My mouth is quicker than my brain. “At this point? Regret.” He grins. “Any particular brand?” I laugh before I can stop myself.
And across the dance floor, Sam chooses that exact moment to look in our direction. Her eyes widen. Then she grabs Leon’s arm and points directly at our booth. Oh, for fuck’s sake. I can practically see the wedding invitations forming in her head.
Nate follows my gaze. “Friends of yours?” “Unfortunately.” He looks toward the dance floor, where Sam has now started waving at me with the subtlety of an airport ground marshal.
“She seems enthusiastic.” He says politely. I laugh again. “That’s one word for it” He looks at me now, small smile on his gorgeous face. “Should I be worried?” I turn back to him, considering the question. “That depends.” He raises his eyebrow at that. “On?” “How fast you can run.” His grin widens. “Pretty fast, actually.” “Good. You might survive meeting her,” I say and I throw him a wink.
And for the first time all evening, I find myself genuinely hoping Sam stays on that dance floor just a little longer.
“A draught beer is fine,” I say, deciding that I will let this gorgeous man buy me a drink, as I quickly finish the sad leftovers in my glass. “But please don’t spike it.” I joke, with an undertone of seriousness.
Nate’s smile softens slightly, though his eyes remain amused. “How about I bring you a sealed bottle instead?”
I tilt my head, appreciating his suggestion. “I said draught.” “You did.” He stands, raising his hands in surrender. “Then you’re welcome to supervise the entire operation,” he says, gesturing his hands towards the bar.
“Tempting, but I’m guarding these seats with my life.”
“Understandable. Prime real estate.”
He glances toward the crowded bar before looking back at me.
“Tell you what. I’ll ask the bartender to pour it in front of me, and you can decide whether you trust my charming personality.” I think about this suggestion for a second. “That’s a rather ambitious sales pitch.” His eyes twinkle. “I’m an optimist.”
I eye him for a second, narrowing my gaze. He’s interesting. I like it.
I get up out of the booth and I put my jacket on the table, as well as Sam’s. Hopefully that keeps people away just long enough that it will still be here when we get back.
“I hope you can understand that I don’t want to take any unnecessary risks, Nate. If that is even your name.” Nate chuckles, stepping aside to let me out of the booth. “Perfectly reasonable. And for the record, it is my name.” “Convenient.” He chuckles again. “I can show you my driver’s license, if that helps.”
I glance up at him, trying to keep my face serious, but I’m not entirely succeeding. “You offer identification to every woman you meet?” “Only the ones who accuse me of having an elaborate fake identity.”
I laugh, shaking my head as we weave through the crowd. “Well, Nate, you’re handling this remarkably well.” He leans closer so I can hear him over the music. “Something tells me you’re worth a little interrogation.”
Oh. That was smooth. Annoyingly smooth.
I eye him again, how the confidence just seems to roll off him. Must be nice to navigate the world that way. When we reach the bar, he orders a draught beer and a double scotch for himself. Before I can say anything, he’s already put thirty bucks in the bartender’s hand.
“Keep the change.”
I sigh. Damn, he’s a good tipper.
I take my beer and thankfully, the booth is still empty. We both sit down and I look at Sam for a second, still happily being a dancing idiot. “Your friend seems to be having a good time,” Nate observes, following my gaze. “She’s easily entertained. Give her a handsome man and questionable music, and she’s set for the evening.” It’s a quality I envy sometimes.
“And you?” I turn back to him. “I’m considerably more difficult to impress.” “I gathered that.”
He takes a sip of his scotch, looking entirely too pleased with himself. “So, Angie, besides interrogating strangers and guarding booths, what do you do?”
I smile into my beer, considering his question. “Well, I recently graduated. Sports psychology. Just finished my master’s, actually.” I leave out the Harvard bit. No need to brag.
His eyebrows rise. “Harvard?” I just nod. “Impressive.” “Thanks,” I shrug, suddenly feeling a little self-conscious. “I’m still figuring out what comes next. I’ve spent so long studying that having to make actual grown-up decisions feels mildly terrifying.”
He smiles. “What made you choose sports psychology?” I glance down at my glass, then back at him. “My family loves hockey. I got infected, except I have the athleticism of a panda. So this way I can still feel close to them, but in my own way.” I actually surprise myself with my honest answer.
Nate laughs at the panda comment. “I won’t offend you by asking you those macho questions to make you prove you actually like hockey.” “Good call.” I smile, genuinely. He is definitely ticking my boxes right now.
“So, what about you?” I ask, leaning back against the booth. “What do you do when you’re not rescuing women from socially challenged men?” He grins. “Is that what I did?” I shrug again, small smile on my face. “Don’t let it go to your head. I had the situation under control.”
“Never doubted it.” And he seems to mean it. Dammit.
He takes a sip of his scotch before he answers. “I travel a lot for work. Weird hours, weekends, that sort of thing.” “That’s impressively vague,” I challenge. “Occupational hazard.”
I narrow my eyes playfully. “You’re not secretly married, are you?” He laughs and shakes his head. “No wife. No girlfriend. No secret family in Connecticut.”
His vague answer annoys me a little, also because I still feel like I’ve seen his face somewhere. But I let it slide. His charm makes up for it. For now at least.
“So what are your expectations for tonight?” he suddenly asks, and I hesitate at his question. It is both earnest and a little assuming, and I find it utterly confusing and intriguing at the same time.
“I actually have no expectations for the night. I came here to support Sam in her pursuit of Leon over there. And I was hoping the music would be good, which it is, and the beer would be cold, which it is. I am perfectly content being a third wheel tonight,” I say with an honest smile.
Nate studies me for a moment, a small smile playing at the corners of his mouth. “That’s a pretty good answer.”
“Was there a wrong one?” “No.” He chuckles. “I just wanted to know if you were waiting for someone, hoping to meet someone, or genuinely enjoying your evening.”
“And?”
“And now I know.”
I raise an eyebrow. “You’re being mysterious again.” “Am I?” He says, looking straight at me. “You’re developing a habit.” He leans forward slightly, resting his forearms on the table. “Well, for what it’s worth, I wasn’t expecting to meet someone interesting tonight either.”
I feel an entirely inconvenient flutter in my stomach. “Careful, Nate. That almost sounded like flirting.” He smiles, holding my gaze. “It was.” “You’re good at it,” I say, watching him carefully. For the first time, his confidence seems to falter. Just a fraction. His smile turns almost bashful before he recovers. “Well, that depends.” He says, and I don’t entirely believe him. I just don’t know if I care, and that is what surprises me.
“On what?” I ask. “On whether it’s working.”
I take a slow sip of my beer, deliberately making him wait. “Jury’s still out.” He laughs, shaking his head. “Tough crowd.”
“Extremely.” I nod, unable to keep the smile off my face. “Guess I’ll have to try harder.”
“Or,” I suggest, leaning forward slightly, “you could just be yourself.” Something shifts in his expression at that. His smile softens. “Yeah,” he says quietly. “I think I’d like that.”
“Okay, Nate who is now going to be himself. If you’re not going to tell me what you do, will you tell me what you do for fun?” I ask.
“Sure.” He smiles. “I like cooking, actually.” I raise my eyebrows. “Cooking?” “Don’t sound so surprised.” I raise my hands a little as I lean back in an unspoken apology. “I’m just adjusting my expectations. You look more like a protein-shake-and-grilled-chicken kind of guy.” He laughs. “I make a mean lasagna, for your information.”
That grabs my interest. “That is a bold claim,” I say. “I can back it up.” No arrogance on his face, just quiet confidence. “Noted. Anything else?” He nods. “Live music, spending time with friends. I like getting outdoors when I can. And I’m embarrassingly competitive with games.”
I grin. “Oh, that’s unfortunate.” “Why?” He asks. “Because I don’t believe in letting people win.” His eyes brighten. “Neither do I.”
I hold his stare and neither of us is backing down, immediately putting our words into practice. I can feel a tingling sensation low in my belly that I haven’t had in quite some time. Still, neither of us blinks.
Suddenly Sam comes crashing at our table, happy energy, completely aware of the moment she just interrupted. “ANGIE!”
I nearly jump out of my skin as Sam practically launches herself into the booth beside me. “Jesus Christ, Samantha!” “What?” she asks innocently, her cheeks flushed from dancing. “Can’t a girl come say hello to her best friend?” “Not when she’s apparently auditioning to be a human cannonball.”
She ignores me entirely, turning her attention to Nate. “Oh, hello.” Nate laughs, looking thoroughly entertained.
“Hi. I’m Nate,” he says, extending his hand again. “Sam.” She shakes it. Her eyes immediately dart toward me. Oh, I know that look.
“So, Nate,” she begins brightly, “how do you two know each other?” “We met about twenty minutes ago,” he answers. “Really?” Sam turns to me, her grin widening. “And you haven’t scared him off yet?” I shrug, trying to play it cool. “I’m working on it.”
Nate chuckles. “She’s been very welcoming, actually.” Sam bursts out laughing. “Oh, I like you.”
“Sam,” I warn. “What? I’m being friendly!” She yells a little too loud for her to be making a genuine argument. “You’re being nosy,” I say with a smirk on my face. “I can multitask,” she says before she leans closer to me, lowering her voice to what she apparently believes is a whisper. “He’s ridiculously hot.” I close my eyes as I feel my cheeks flush crimson. Dear God, please open a hole in the floor for me to disappear into.
“I’m sitting right here,” Nate points out, laughing. “I know!” Sam beams at him. “That’s why I said it.” I bury my face in my hands.
And just like that, my peaceful Friday evening has officially become a circus.
“Hi, Leon,” he introduces himself to Nate as he slides into the booth next to him, handing Sam a fresh drink, some kind of fruity cocktail she likes.
“Nate.” He shakes Leon’s hand, shifting to make room. “Hope we’re not interrupting anything,” Leon says, glancing between us. “Nothing whatsoever,” I answer.
“She means yes,” Sam supplies helpfully, taking an enthusiastic sip of her cocktail. “Sam, I swear to God.” I try to threaten, but it feels completely empty. “What? I’m supporting your social development.”
Nate laughs into his scotch. Leon looks amused. “You two always like this?” “Since we were sixteen,” I tell him. “Unfortunately, nobody’s managed to house-train her.”
“Love you too, bitch.” Sam blows me a kiss. I roll my eyes, but I’m smiling. Under the table, Nate’s knee brushes mine. Neither of us moves away.
“So Leon and I were just talking. We’re both hungry. Wanna come for tacos, Angie? You can come too.” She grins at Nate. Honestly, I could kiss her right now. I wasn’t ready for this conversation to end, but I wasn’t just gonna throw myself at him either.
“Yeah, I could eat,” I say, not trying to expect too much from Nate at this point. He’s a free man, he can do what he likes.
Nate looks at me before answering, which earns him another imaginary gold star. “Tacos sound great,” he says. “If you don’t mind the company.” “Not at all!” Sam practically sings.
I take a sip of my beer to hide my smile. “Excellent,” Leon announces. “Because I’m starving.” “You’re always starving,” Sam tells him with a kiss. “You’ve known me for a while, and that’s what you’ve learned?” “And so much more.” She flirts, deepening the kiss.
Nate chuckles, then turns toward me. “Just so we’re clear, I’m coming for the tacos.” “Obviously.” I say. “Your company is merely an added bonus.” I raise an eyebrow. “Careful. I might start charging.” He leans a little closer. “Would another beer cover it?”
I laugh. “You’re going to have to do better than that.” His eyes hold mine for a moment. “I was hoping you’d say that.”
Oh. This man is trouble.
And the worst part?
I might actually enjoy finding out just how much.









