Chapter 1 — A Question Worth Asking
Olive spotted Ethan outside the biology building, finishing a conversation with a woman in a red bicycle helmet.
He saw her approaching and lifted the two coffees balanced in one hand.
“Hey. I got yours.”
The woman glanced over.
“I should go. Good luck with the presentation.”
“Thanks. See you around.”
He turned to Olive as the woman wheeled her bike away.
“Hi.”
“Hi.”
He leaned down to kiss her, careful to hold the coffees away from them. His hair brushed her forehead. It was still a little damp, the light brown waves already escaping whatever he had done to them that morning.
She caught his wrist before he could step back and kissed him once more. He had left her apartment in a hurry that morning, calling goodbye while she was still brushing her teeth. This was better.
Up close, she could see the tiny shaving cut beneath his jaw.
“You’re bleeding.”
“Was bleeding.”
She tilted his chin toward the light.
“You’ll survive.”
“Good. Big day.”
He looked good, too, and knew it. Blue shirt, dark jeans, clean sneakers. He had pushed his sleeves up on the walk over, exposing the watch his parents had given him when his paper was accepted.
She particularly liked that shirt. He had worn it on their second date, when she had spent a distracting portion of dinner wondering whether he was going to kiss her afterward. He had. She had made sure there was a third date.
Olive straightened the folded edge of one sleeve.
“You nervous?”
“A little.” He shifted his laptop beneath his arm. “Ask me again in ten minutes and I’ll have convinced myself I’m incredible.”
“Text me when you’re done.”
“Oh, you’re getting the full recap. Probably with reenactments.”
He handed her a coffee.
She took a sip.
Plain latte.
For a moment, she looked through the opening in the lid, as though the pumpkin spice might be somewhere farther down.
“What?”
She glanced up. “Nothing. Thank you.”
“You’re welcome.”
They started toward the entrance together.
She had been ordering pumpkin spice since it had returned to the menu. Ethan had even stolen a sip last week and complained that it tasted like a candle. She considered reminding him, but he was already checking the time, his thumb tapping against the side of his cup.
He had a presentation to worry about. She could get the coffee she wanted tomorrow. Still, she had been looking forward to that first sip.
She drank some more. It was warm, and she hadn’t had coffee yet.
“Ben wants to have people over Friday,” he said. “Are you free?”
“Probably. At yours?”
“His place this time. Apparently he bought a grill.”
“Does he know how to use it?”
“We’ll find out.”
“Should we eat before?”
“I would.”
She laughed.
Ethan had been easy to be around from the beginning. He talked to people without rehearsing an opening, made plans without turning them into complicated negotiations. Olive had come from Canada to Stanford on a visa. During her first weeks there, Ethan had invited her to lunch with a few friends and shifted his chair to make space for her when she arrived.
He had kept inviting her.
Eventually, she had stopped feeling like a guest.
Olive had built a life she liked before she met him. She could spend an evening alone without needing to fill it.
Still, she remembered their first Thanksgiving together: his mother calling from the kitchen to ask whether Olive liked sweet potatoes, Ethan answering that she could ask Olive herself, and then passing over his phone.
No careful conversation about whether she had somewhere else to go.
They had simply made room.
She had thought about that call afterward more than she had told him. His mother had wanted to know what she liked to eat. Such an ordinary question, asked with the assumption that Olive would be there to eat it. She had finished the conversation and stayed beside Ethan on the sofa, her leg resting against his, reluctant to get up.
“Mom asked about you yesterday,” he said, as though he had followed her there.
“How is she?”
“Good. She wants the picture from Sunday. The one where Dad’s actually looking at the camera.”
“I sent it to you.”
“Right. Okay. Send it again?”
She looked at him.
“Please?”
“I’ll send it to her.”
“See? This is why you’re the favorite.”
He opened the door for her, and she ducked beneath his arm.
Inside, he slowed beside the elevators.
“Wait. I have news.”
Something in his face made her stop.
“Seattle?”
He nodded, smiling now.
“They want me out there next Thursday.”
“Ethan! Why didn’t you start with that?”
“I was getting to it.”
She put a hand on his chest and kissed him.
He was grinning when she stepped back.
“Do that again. I’ve been very impressive.”
She laughed and kissed his cheek.
“When did they email?”
“This morning. Two-day visit. Meet the team, see the facilities, dinner with the director.” He watched her take it in. “It’s happening.”
“I know.”
For months, the possibility had been there in the background: a position he wanted, a city neither of them knew well. Now someone had chosen dates.
She wanted to ask a dozen questions. Who would interview him? Had they mentioned a start date? How long would they give him to decide? She knew what getting this far meant to him, though, and for another moment she wanted to enjoy the expression on his face.
“You should come,” he said.
“To the interview?”
“No, after. Fly up Friday. We could stay the weekend.”
She adjusted the strap of her bag, freeing a strand of hair caught beneath it.
“I’d have to look at my schedule.”
“Come on. We haven’t gone anywhere in ages.”
“I want to. Let me check what I can move.”
“Okay.” He touched her waist. “Think about it.”
“I will.”
An elevator opened, and he glanced toward it.
“Go,” she said. “Good luck.”
“Dinner tonight?”
“Yes. I’ll text you after class.”
He stepped inside, holding the door with his hand.
“Which class?”
“The Whitmore seminar.”
“Oh, right.” He nodded. “Tell me how it goes.”
By the time Olive found the lecture hall, most of the lower rows were occupied.
She paused in the doorway to take off her jacket. The walk across campus had left her warm beneath her cream sweater, and she could feel a strand of hair sticking to the back of her neck.
There was an empty seat on the aisle, four rows up. She took it, setting her bag between her white sneakers and folding her dark green jacket over her lap.
Her phone lit up as she pulled out her notebook.
Anh: Has it started?
Olive: Not yet.
Anh: Good. Time for one deeply unhelpful piece of information.
Anh: Malcolm says someone cried in this class last year.
Olive: Did Malcolm take this class?
Anh: No. I have already raised concerns about his sources.
Olive smiled.
Olive: Very useful. Thank him for me.
Anh: Text me afterward. I want your version before he starts embellishing.
She silenced her phone.
At the front of the room, a man was connecting a laptop to the projector. He straightened, and she recognized him.
Dr. Adam Carlsen.
Well. That was unexpected.
She knew his face, of course. It was difficult to miss him around the department, and Ethan had once pointed him out with the solemnity of someone identifying a dangerous animal. She had assumed that description involved at least some wounded academic pride.
She looked toward the door, half expecting Professor Whitmore to follow.
Adam checked the screen, then turned to the room.
“Professor Whitmore is taking leave. I’ll be teaching this course for the remainder of the quarter.”
A low murmur passed through the seats.
Olive sat back.
Ethan had taken a class with him. His account had included an excellent grade, considerable suffering, and a twenty-minute explanation of why the grade should have been higher.
She had seen Adam around campus herself. Usually walking somewhere, usually looking as though stopping him would be a mistake.
Today he wore a black shirt, open at the collar, and black trousers. He rested one hand on the lectern while he explained the revised schedule.
The shirt suited him. She noticed that before she noticed what he was saying about the assignments, which seemed a poor way to begin a class she had voluntarily added to her workload.
She uncapped her pen. Being attractive did not make him less likely to assign forty pages of reading.
His voice carried easily.
Something about it caught her attention. She tried to place it, then lost the thought when he changed the slide.
“Who read the assigned paper?”
Olive raised her hand with most of the room.
“Keep your hand up if you found the conclusion convincing.”
She lowered hers.
Adam looked across the rows.
His gaze stopped on her.
“Why not?”
She set down her pen.
So much for finding out how the class worked before participating. She glanced at the paragraph she had marked on Sunday. She had already spent a perfectly good afternoon arguing with this paper in her head; she might as well get something out of it.
“I thought they ruled out one explanation and treated that as proof of the other.”
“Which explanation?”
“The difference in baseline activity.”
He waited.
She glanced at the article open beside her notebook, found the figure, and looked back up.
“The control helps. I just don’t think it supports everything they say it does.”
“Look at figure four.”
“I did. That’s actually where I got stuck.”
He turned to his laptop and brought the figure onto the screen.
“All right,” he said. “Where?”
Olive leaned forward, studying the enlarged graph.
He seemed willing to wait for a real answer. She liked that. There was nothing especially reassuring about his expression, but he had put the figure up instead of moving on, and now she wanted to know whether he saw the same problem she did.
Adam had seen her on campus often enough to know that she had come to Stanford.
The first time had been outside the library. She had been walking with two other students, laughing at something he couldn’t hear.
He had almost stopped.
After that, he noticed her more easily. In the coffee line. On the steps outside the building. Once, late in the evening, carrying a stack of containers into a lab.
He had never found a reasonable way to introduce himself.
Now she was sitting four rows above him, looking directly at him.
She had no idea.
He had considered this possibility when Whitmore sent him the roster. Seeing her name had been enough to make him put the list down for a moment.
He had still been unprepared for her to walk in.
He had watched her slip out of her jacket, her hair catching briefly beneath the collar. Then she had looked toward the front, and he had discovered that a course roster was very little preparation for having her attention.
“The lower panel,” she said. “They’re averaging across both groups. Wouldn’t that hide the difference they’re trying to measure?”
Adam looked at the screen.
“Yes.”
“Then why—”
“What would you need to see instead?”
She paused, considering it.
He let her.
She looked down at the paper, turning her pen once between her fingers. Several students were looking at the figure now, following the comparison she had raised.
“The individual responses,” she said. “Separated by group.”
He nodded.
“Exactly.”
She looked up. Even from the lectern, he caught the small smile before she returned to her notes.
He wanted her to look at him like that again. An inconvenient thing to want five minutes into a lecture.
He turned back to the laptop.
There were twenty-three other students in the room.
He needed to remember that.
By the end of the hour, Olive had filled four pages of her notebook and drawn a large question mark beside an experiment she had planned for Thursday.
Her project concerned blood-based markers that might help detect pancreatic cancer earlier. At the moment, however, she couldn’t reliably compare measurements collected on different days.
A promising difference meant very little if she couldn’t establish where it came from.
She knew why that mattered. Her mother had died of pancreatic cancer when Olive was fifteen.
For a long time afterward, she had wanted someone to explain how a person could be that sick before anyone knew what was wrong. She had read things she barely understood, looking up terms and following references until the browser tabs stopped fitting across the screen.
Now she understood enough to ask better questions. She also understood how much work stood between an interesting result and something that could help a patient.
She had chosen this research knowing that.
It did not make the spreadsheet waiting in her lab any less frustrating.
Around her, laptops began to close.
Adam looked at the clock.
“For next week, read the two papers I’ll upload this afternoon. Bring a proposed control for each. Be prepared to explain what it tells you.”
A student in the front row raised his hand.
“Is there a length requirement?”
“For the control?”
“For the explanation.”
Adam paused.
“Stop when you’ve explained it.”
Olive bent her head to hide a smile.
Chairs tipped forward as people stood. She checked her phone while slipping her notebook into her bag.
Ethan: Done. Went well.
A second message followed.
Ethan: Very well, actually.
She smiled.
Olive: Congratulations ❤️ Call you in a few?
His reply arrived while she was putting on her jacket.
Ethan: Going to lunch with David and the others. Tonight?
Olive: Tonight.
At the front, two students had approached Adam. Olive waited beside her row, reading the question she had written in the margin.
She could email him.
But the graph was still on the screen, and she was already here.
Also, she wanted to ask while she could still remember how he had explained it. An email would become three paragraphs long before she reached the actual question.
She walked down.
One of the students was asking about a scheduling conflict. The other wanted to know whether the readings required access to a particular journal. Adam answered both without moving from beside the lectern.
When they left, he turned to her.
Up close, he was even taller than she had expected. She stopped a comfortable distance away and took her notebook out again.
His eyes were a different color than she had thought from her seat. Brown, warmer in the light from the side windows.
When he leaned forward to look at her notes, she caught a faint trace of cologne. Something clean and woody.
She liked it.
“I have a question about something you said.”
His eyes moved briefly to the notebook, then back to her.
“All right.”
“When you were talking about repeating the measurements before changing the protocol. Would that still apply if the result was consistent, but only within each batch?”
“What are you measuring?”
“A set of candidate blood-based markers. We’re looking at whether they could help distinguish pancreatic cancer samples from controls.”
He glanced at the diagram she had drawn.
“And the variation is between runs?”
“Yes. Enough that I’m not comfortable comparing them yet.”
“What changes between batches?”
“That’s what I’m trying to figure out.”
He waited.
“The samples are prepared on different days,” she continued. “Same procedure, same equipment. Within a batch, the results look good. Between batches, they move enough that I don’t want to combine them.”
“How much?”
She gave him the approximate range.
“And your supervisor?”
“She wants me to repeat it with fresh reagents. I will. I’m just wondering if there’s something else I should check at the same time.”
“Do you have the data?”
“Not with me.”
“Then I’d be guessing.”
“Okay.” She nodded. “Fair.”
She started to close her notebook.
“Check the preparation logs first.”
Olive looked back up.
“Dates, storage conditions, time between preparation and measurement,” he said. “Include the variables you’re assuming stayed constant.”
She opened the notebook again and wrote that down.
That was worth looking at. She had checked the reagent lots twice and kept returning to the same explanation because she knew how to test it. The timing was already recorded somewhere. She could look this afternoon.
“I have most of those.”
“Most?”
She glanced at him.
“I see why people get nervous around you.”
He said nothing.
She felt a smile coming and let it.
“I’ll check the rest.”
His gaze held hers for a moment.
“You don’t need another experiment to identify information you already have.”
“No. I’d rather find it before I spend three days proving the freezer has a temperature setting.”
Something shifted at the corner of his mouth.
It was gone before she could decide whether it counted as a smile.
Oh. She wanted to see that properly.
The thought was immediate enough to amuse her. Apparently, an almost-smile from a severe man required further investigation. She could leave that particular question unanswered.
She put her notebook away.
“Thank you, Dr. Carlsen.”
She nodded toward the screen.
“I liked the class.”
He looked at her, and for a second the conversation seemed to stop in an odd place.
Then he said, “Good.”
Adam watched her leave through the lower door.
He waited until it closed before disconnecting his laptop.
She had come down to ask him a question. She had listened to the answer, challenged part of it, and smiled at him.
He could manage that.
He had supervised doctoral defenses with fewer internal negotiations.
He could still picture her standing beside the lectern, looking up at him. He had wanted to prolong the conversation and had possessed absolutely no useful question with which to do it.
His phone vibrated.
Holden: Are you finished?
Adam picked up his bag.
Adam: Yes.
Holden: Excellent. I need your eyes on something.
Adam: Email it.
Holden: It’s in your office.
He found Holden sitting in his chair with a document open on his monitor.
“You have your own computer,” Adam said.
“And yet yours was closer.”
Adam set his bag down.
Holden turned the screen slightly.
“Second paragraph. Tell me if I’m promising something impossible.”
Adam read it.
“Yes.”
“How impossible?”
“You don’t have the equipment.”
“I could get access.”
“Then get access before you put it in a proposal.”
Holden sighed and reached for the keyboard.
“This is why I value your friendship. The warmth.”
Adam moved a stack of papers off the other chair and sat.
For several minutes, they worked through the paragraph. Holden revised two sentences, argued about a third, and eventually conceded by deleting it with unnecessary force.
“How was Whitmore’s class?”
“Fine.”
“Did he leave you usable notes?”
“Mostly.”
Holden glanced over.
“You volunteered for the entire quarter?”
“He asked me.”
“He asked several people.”
Adam reached for the proposal.
“Are we finished?”
Holden studied him for another second, then rose.
“With this, yes.”
At the door, he stopped.
“Dinner Thursday?”
“I’ll let you know.”
“You always say that.”
“And you always ask again.”
“An arrangement that has sustained us for years.”
The door shut behind him.
Adam sat still for a moment, then opened the course roster.
He should learn the other names.
Malcolm was at the kitchen table when Olive got home, a journal article spread beside his laptop and a bowl of cereal balanced on a stack of mail.
She hung up her jacket.
“Please tell me you’ve eaten something else today.”
He looked into the bowl.
“There was a banana involved.”
“Well, that’s reassuring.”
She went to the kitchen and filled a glass of water.
“How was the seminar?” he asked.
“Dr. Whitmore’s taking leave, so Dr. Carlsen’s teaching the seminar now.”
Malcolm looked up properly.
“Oh.”
“Anh already sent me your warning.”
“It wasn’t a warning. It was historical information.”
“From a class you didn’t take.”
“I know people, Olive.”
She drank half the water.
“He was fine.”
“Fine?”
“Good, actually. I have to look at my preparation logs.”
“That sounds like a very Dr. Carlsen outcome.”
She could hear how unconvincing her description was. It had been a good class. She had spent most of it engaged, occasionally irritated, and interested enough to forget to check the time. She wanted more of that from the courses she took.
She pulled out the chair opposite him.
“What are you working on?”
Malcolm turned his laptop toward her.
“My committee meeting. I need to explain why the last six weeks were useful even though the result is that I shouldn’t have done the last six weeks.”
Olive leaned closer to the screen.
“Have you tried calling it optimization?”
“I have used that word four times already.”
“Then you’re ready.”
He nudged her ankle beneath the table.
She smiled and started reading.
Ethan arrived at his apartment twenty minutes after Olive, carrying a paper bag and talking into his phone.
“Yeah, she’s here,” he said, looking at her as he pushed the door closed with his foot. “No, Mom. I’m not making her cook.”
Olive held out her hand.
He passed her the phone.
“Hi.”
“Tell me he’s feeding you.”
“He just got here with dinner, actually. It smells really good.”
Ethan smiled and carried dinner into the kitchen.
She talked to his mother while he unpacked the food. By the time she returned the phone, he had found two plates and poured her a glass of water.
She watched him finish the call, smiling at something his mother said.
There were things she liked about being here that had become so familiar she rarely named them.
His hand settling briefly at her back as he passed. An extra toothbrush in the bathroom. Someone asking how her day had gone and waiting for the answer.
She also liked that he had unbuttoned his collar and pushed his sleeves up again. Later, she intended to get him off his phone for considerably longer than dinner. For now, she took the containers from the bag and found the one she wanted.
He set his phone facedown.
“Okay. Tell me everything.”
“About my day or yours?”
“Mine first.”
She laughed and sat.
He had been waiting to tell her. She could hear it in how quickly he began: the questions, the discussion afterward, the professor who had stayed to talk about an application of his work. She asked him to explain one part again, and he pulled a napkin toward him to draw it.
By the time they started eating, he had relaxed enough to admit where he had stumbled.
“No one noticed,” he said.
“How do you know?”
“Because I recovered beautifully.”
“Of course.”
He grinned.
“What about Whitmore?”
“He wasn’t there. Dr. Carlsen’s taking over.”
Ethan stopped with his fork halfway to his mouth.
“Seriously?”
“For the quarter.”
“Oh, you’re going to work.”
“I went there to work.”
“I know. You’ll like him, then.”
She took a bite.
“I did.”
He looked faintly amused.
“Give it a few weeks.”
“Why?”
“He’s tough.”
“He asked questions. That’s the class.”
“Olive, I took his class.”
“I know.”
“I did well, too.”
“I know, Ethan. You told me what you got.”
He reached across the table and stole a piece of broccoli from her plate.
“I’m providing context.”
She moved the plate out of reach.
She knew he had found the class difficult. She had also listened to the story often enough that she wanted the chance to have her own experience of it before agreeing with his.
“He helped me with the batch problem.”
That caught his attention.
“What did he say?”
“To check the preparation logs before repeating everything.”
“I thought you’d checked those.”
“Some. I need to look at the timing more carefully.”
Ethan nodded and reached for his water.
“Could be worth doing.”
“I think so.”
For a while, they ate.
Then he picked up his phone and opened something.
“Look.”
He slid it across the table.
A hotel in Seattle. Big windows, white bedding, a narrow view of the water between two buildings.
“They cover my room through Friday,” he said. “We could stay another two nights.”
Olive looked through the photographs.
It would be nice to go somewhere with him.
She could picture a Saturday morning without setting an alarm for the lab, Ethan finding somewhere for breakfast, both of them wearing the wrong shoes for the amount of walking he would suggest.
And before breakfast, perhaps an hour in that bed. She enlarged one of the photographs, studying the window rather than giving away exactly where her thoughts had gone.
“What time would you be finished Friday?”
“Probably four.”
She checked the dates again.
“I can’t fly before the afternoon. If I can make it work.”
“Okay.”
“And I need to check tomorrow before you book anything.”
“I haven’t booked.”
“I know. I’m just saying.”
He took the phone back.
“I’d like you there.”
His voice was quieter now.
She reached across the table for his hand.
“I’d like to be there.”
He turned his palm up beneath hers and held on.
Tomorrow, she would open the calendar and see what she could move. Tonight, she let herself want the weekend.
For the moment, it seemed like the same answer.










