A Letter To My Lover
Share with your friends
Customize readability

A Letter To My Lover

This story contains themes of: homophobia, self-harm

All Rights Reserved ©

Story Notes

This story began with a simple question: what if you fell in love with someone’s heart on paper, and sat across from her every day without knowing it?

It is set in Cheltenham between 1884 and 1887, and told in two voices, in letters and in a tearoom. Expect a slow burn, longing, and a love that never says its own name until the end. Theodore is not a villain. Some loneliness has no one to blame.

Cheltenham is real, but the Evening Institute, St. Raphael’s, and the Copper Kettle are invented. I’ve taken small liberties with history in service of the story.

Summary

“To Vee” “To Atha” Neither of them knew the other’s name, and yet each opened her darkest secrets to the other. They didn’t know they kept meeting in the same small café, ordering the same things, and it felt as if the whole world knew, and only they didn’t. Verity Whitmore has a good husband, two healthy sons, and a spotless house. She writes to him, signing with the nickname he no longer uses. She should have no complaint, yet in 1884 Cheltenham she is a lonely woman who has forgotten, or perhaps never knew, what it is to be cared for. She has everything, except what she craves: affection. Agatha Wynter runs on anger, and yet her eyes soften when she sees children. “Miss Atha,” the children call her, Miss Atha, who doesn’t know what it feels like to be taken care of and who doesn’t even trust the kindness of adults. She has seen enough adults leave their children at the gates of St. Raphael’s Home for Orphan Girls. She has seen what men leave behind, and the women who take their own lives. What follows is two women, two nicknames, a post office, and not one “I love you.” Nights pass writing their deepest wounds and desires; days pass with each a myth to the other, existing only in The Cheltenham Chatterbox and in letters. Letters. Longing. A bird stitched into everything Verity makes, and the kiss Agatha leaves in every letter.

Status
2d ago
Chapters
1
Rating
n/a
Age Rating
18+

Chapter 1

Chapter One: The Newsletter


Chatterbox—that's what her husband used to call her too, before she stopped talking at all. Her eyes scanned the newspaper before she handed it to Theodore. “Are you coming home early today?” She asked every day at this point, every day hoping that his answer would be a yes. “No, Verity, I have evening classes around the corner.” She knew what that meant; he would be out till ten in the evening, and Verity only nodded and smiled, that fake smile she gave him for the past four years. Maybe more; she just started to notice from the past four years and where everyone around her relentlessly told her to try, try to be more attractive and sweeter, cook better, complain less and smile more, and that satin nightsuit her mother-in-law bought, and to offer herself up in the dead of night.

But in her case nothing worked. She walked back to the kitchen; the kettle was whistling, and Theodore’s tea was to be ready any moment now. She couldn’t focus, but yet she did her work with perfection; she poured his cinnamon tea in his small favourite cup and again walked back to him. Was he cheating on her? Was she so boring? Well, she had to agree; she actually does nothing more than cater to him and their two sons. "Edwin said you never went to meet his headmaster." She says softly as she handed him the coffee cup and looked up at him. His handsome face no longer made her soul or body tingle; it only made her wonder what she was supposed to do to make him come home more often.

She felt exhausted with her thoughts, and yet she felt that love she had for him pull her heartstrings. She paused right where she was, didn’t move even after she gave him his tea, and then leaned down and kissed his cheek. ‘At least he was a good father,’ she thought, her guilt of asking too much in mind pushing all her lonely thoughts. Theodore looked up and smiled, the same fake smile that she had; they both knew, and yet no one wanted to tamper with this fake settlement. Of course, after that everything was back again the way it usually is; even though her heart was heavy, she ignored the pain and focused on Theodore’s lunch.

The lunch that she would be taking to him – that time was the only time she finally saw him outside of home. Would he be happy to see her? Would he be talking to someone else? She often came at the worst moments, when he was talking to other gentlemen, and for some reason that upset him. Verity was thinking about her husband’s annoyance, and that’s when she burnt her hand. Her distracted thoughts caused her to spill the bits of broth on the back of her hand. She yelped, but she didn’t necessarily feel as much pain as she wanted to; the pain felt soothing, like now she had a reason to want attention from her own husband.

She smiled when she was bandaging herself, and thankfully, with no more accidents, she made his lunch: chicken pot pie and a warm cake, a small sweet treat he liked. She was never so fond of chicken, but for him she had been eating it with no complaint for the past fifteen years. The excitement she felt while dressing up, the tight woollen skirt for the outdoors till her ankles, the corset to fit her waist, and the fitted dark lavender buttoned jacket Theodore gave her on her birthday and beautiful flower bonnet.

His lunch was packed in her basket full of flowers, and the butterflies of excitement were dancing in her stomach as she dressed up. Maybe even meeting him for ten minutes with that one hour of walk each way was the only time her marriage felt like fireworks and not like ashes. The ashes she held tight in her palms, and yet they slipped. She didn’t dare wear bright colours; he didn’t like that as well, and she, for one, wished only to be to his liking.

As expected and feared, she did arrive, but fifteen minutes late, and unfortunately he was in the middle of the class when the young gentlemen informed him of her arrival. No wonder he told her to wait and told her that it would take around two hours. The bandaged hand held the basket of food while she stood in his small, cramped office waiting for him. She checked her pocket watch maybe every thirty seconds, and then she stopped.

After the twenty-first minute of her waiting, she started to look around his office, which he usually found very offensive; he always seemed to get irritated with the fact that she knew how to write and read, especially when it was more scholarly books or about neuroscience, her favourite subject when she studied in the evening college at home. But she still read, in secret, maybe but often, and she even wrote letters explaining herself, oftentimes when she would make him upset and he would just walk away with that disappointment in silence.

She would write in those scraps of paper she would secretly find in his study while cleaning. She would apologise or simply reason her thoughts and words and actions that she did that made him displeased. She never had the courage to send him any of those, of course, but yes...she still wrote to him in love. Walking around the large wooden table, she saw the newspaper she gave him this morning, Cheltenham Chatterbox. She silently, in curiosity, read the first article, the large advertisement for the donation to a girls’ orphanage.

Upon that small note it was safe to say that Verity was sensitive; she had two sons of those girls’ age, and she knew about this orphanage. She knew how it was; just two streets over from The Copper Kettle – her regular tearoom. Her brows furrowed, and she looked up from the paper, then she looked around, through glass doors carefully, just to make sure her husband wasn’t coming any time soon. She carefully ripped off that piece of paper and stuffed it in her pocket, where her small watch already sat as well. She wasn’t supposed to, but she had to, and this wasn’t the first time she was doing something like this: charity without her husband knowing, charity in her own name, and no one spoke of it to her husband.

It was mostly for the poor children on the streets and often for the children in the parks with no one to look after, and heavens, she made great stories of where some of their family things went. She smiled to herself, mischievous as she remembered how she gave away one of the parlour cushions and blankets to the twins in the park, and she lied to him that they were torn, and she just threw them out. She earned an earful from Theo, but she was...just simply happy in her own way, to say the least. She knew exactly what to do: to sew a few of her sons’ clothes that they ripped while playing and then send them with the fresh basket of biscuits that she would make by hand. Everything was on that paper, and she...was already smiling and jumping in her boots.

“What has gotten you so happy, my dear?” Verity jumped with her husband’s voice; startled and with eyes widened, she turned around to see her darling, Theodore, standing beside her with confusion but sarcasm and mockery. He didn’t call her “my dear” out of love anymore, that’s for sure. She blinked and shook her head. “I was only confused why a part of your newspaper is ripped off.” The white lie, or call it a complete lie, slipped off her tongue. She dared not let him know that it was her. Theodore came in front of her, his eyes brewing from her composure with a serious look to a relaxed one, like puzzle pieces were setting down in his head. “It must have been the students.” He simply sighed and shook his head as well. He took the paper and stuffed it in the bottom drawer and, with no more words, sat down on his chair and looked at her with a small smile.

“What did you bring for lunch?” Verity smiled back and nodded as she picked up the basket, but what she was actually waiting for was her husband to at least notice her bandaged hand. At least once, and ask. Somewhere deep in her heart, as the minutes passed by in silence, as she served his food to him, all she wished was for him to notice her, that she was not just his wife in front of him but a person too. The person who was currently in pain in and out. “What was the article about, do you recall?” She spoke in the middle of his meal, and he checked his papers too. “Just some advertisement for some donation for a girls’ orphanage,” he spoke, his voice flat as he continued his work after his reply. She pressed her lips and...then bit them. Minutes again passed, and he was close to finishing his meal, so she spoke again, “Do I look pretty today, Theo?”

That was the one moment that Theodore looked up from his papers, and he squinted his eyes and smiled, a little softer and a little more real than this morning. “Where is this coming from, my love?” He asked softly and, for the moment, left his papers. “It’s nothing; I recently…feel like you have paused from noticing me.” Verity spoke, and she came closer, around his desk, and then carefully she put a hand on his shoulder. He smiled; his eyes didn’t follow her, and instead he nodded. “We can make love when I come home, darling,” he said plainly, with only a faint trace of warmth, and Verity pulled her hand back and sighed deeply as she shook her head. “That’s not what I mean, Theo. I simply wanted you to tell me that I look beautiful.”

Verity’s voice had no anger, just pain as she walked back around the table and in front of him. She put her hand on the table, and the moment she winced, she momentarily looked up, slightly expecting his face to look from anywhere but his papers, but it seemed as if he didn’t even hear her small painful cry. “Of course you look beautiful, Verity; you look like my wife,” Theo replied, and even the small smile on his lips was gone. Verity took a deep breath and just shook her head. “Theo, is there someone else?” She couldn’t stop herself from asking, and whereas she expected Theodore to get up and sound even offended, he didn’t say a word and just shook his head.

“I am not being unfaithful to you, Mrs Whitemore; I am simply busy earning for our children and ourselves. That’s it.” And that was perhaps the last of that conversation. So that night she again sat down at her kitchen table when the whole family was asleep. She sat down and started to write on those scraps of paper she found in his study. That evening, when Theodore came home, he didn’t say a word to her. He didn’t speak about the conversation they had in his study. He was acting so normal, as if it never happened. She knew that Theodore felt bad, or she knew somewhere that Theodore never did what she said he did. But somewhere her pain finally caught up to her chest, and she didn’t know what else to say. That night, Verity wrote a letter to Theodore that she knew she would never be able to send, but she still wrote it. She still wrote the letter. She told him how she felt. “Dear Theodore,” it began.

Dear Theodore,

From where I stand in this deep solitude, I wish you would see it too. I wish you had asked me how I was doing and what happened on my walk to your office. I never expect you to make a certain amount of money but somewhere my heart always aches for the moments that we have lost in this mess of our children, your job and maybe everything. I never meant for more time in bed, just maybe a moment you ask me if I am okay or doing well, if I have eaten or not, or maybe that where our little brass lamps had gone that I bought. I know.... Well, more like I assumed that you didn’t like them, so I shoved them in the back of the dressing cupboard. All I wanted that week was for you to notice that our room looked slightly darker, and that the moon wasn’t just simply enough. Our moon isn’t enough. We make love like routine; we eat, sleep, and talk like two strangers in one room and house. I wish that you would notice how much this pains me.

It’s easy to assume that I am leaving like the multiple times you have said in our arguments, and oh lord what arguments, there are no arguments, just words that were spoken in silence, and flat voices and timid reactions. I don’t wish to leave you, I don’t wish to ever leave you and our sons, but do I not deserve the time of your day?

I miss you Theo, I miss you and the funny fact is that we have never even spent the moments I long for, those moments are non-existent, and yet somewhere they are in my heart. Am I so wrong for dreaming about a night where my husband doesn’t touch me but asks me how I was and what all I did today. Our children even sometimes notice our distance and were you aware that our sons have been bringing me flowers and every night kiss my cheeks, tell me that papa loves you too mama. Ten-year-olds Theodore, ten-year-olds notice this gnawing, sickening distance and you are so blind and are you ignorant to this?!

Do you have an acknowledgement of the pain the guilt the heaviness I feel even when I am complaining to you because you are the best father, a respected man, a man who respects me, maybe somewhere even loves me but...how? How do you not see my pain and everyone else can? What is that you can’t see, but the whole world can? This afternoon when I asked you, did I look pretty? The only thing you said was yes because I am your wife. Am I just your wife for you? Do you not see a woman, a human? A girl who is staring at a boy who she also loves, who she has children with. Even I am just a girl, standing in front of a boy, a boy that she likes and asking for love...

How pathetic it may seem to you, that you have given me everything my home, my soul, my reason to exist and yet the lack of attention and affection makes me so restless it does not let me breathe in our marriage.

I am suffocating in this so-called perfect marriage, and every time I express myself, you turn into this silent porcelain doll that I am so scared to hurt, to even touch. I miss you, my dear, and don’t you miss me too? Don’t you miss the girl who could never cease speaking of Shakespear and who couldn’t shut up about how our brains worked to you. Do you truly enjoy this silence between us? How can it not be suffocating to you?

I have tried to reason for your blindness, maybe more than half of the four years of my silence. The year you screamed at me to shut up, the year you once told me to leave the house if I wanted to talk more. Am I that much of a nuisance to you? It feels the only thing you apologized for was because both our parents made you to....

Sometimes, no... oftentimes I wish you would hit me instead. I wish you would slap me and yell at me, sometimes I wish I had bruises on my face so whenever I would...explain or even put words of how I feel to someone, anyone, maybe not you, yes, never you, I would never be able to say all this to you, but I wish if I expressed myself to someone then I had the proof of how battered and beaten up my soul is... Because if I told all this to someone today, they would just feel like I am the bad wife, the bad wife who could not be warm enough for her husband to simply crave for. I try my best, my hardest to be to your accord and to how you would just love me more and more but all I see...is how hard you try not coming home. If you are not cheating on me, if there is no second woman then why the evening college, why when we have more than enough from one of your jobs? I know—I am certain—you did not need it, and sure as heaven you did not want it, for even this week you muttered in your sleep of how exhausting this routine has become. So why? Why would you ever take that up? It was to stay away from home, wasn’t it?

What is it about the home that displeases you, that you don’t approve of Theodore, because as much as I can recall everything is according to you. Only to you. Do I not deserve to run away from a world that is yours and yours alone, where I am merely a floating spirit, catering to you?

Is it not even the slightest unfair to you that I am here waiting and praying for your mood to be light, for you not to be exhausted and you, my love, my darling husband did not even notice the bandage in my hand. To conclude this long letter, let the words that I spoke to you on these scraps of paper that I found in your office while cleaning it in secret, because of course and again it’s yours and only yours. In conclusion to this letter, I would only say, I am in pain Theodore and if you—you who took your vows before God with me ...I request that you heal this pain, because now, I am unable to.

Yours, Vee

The anxiety that she anticipated in the morning wasn’t there; in fact, the whole night’s writing and sewing made her exhausted and numb. She forgot to even breathe, while the children and the snapping, polite orders from her husband made her just...stand in the middle of the kitchen and for a moment...simply let out the deepest sigh her chest could muster. For the first time in forever, she didn’t ask her husband when he would be back, and today she handed him his lunch basket right when he was about to leave for work. “You won’t come around this afternoon, my dear?” he asked Verity, and while Verity was distracted, arranging her second basket full of sewn clothes and biscuits, she shook her head.

“I have someplace else to be,” she said in her normal, small, soft tone. She heard the tapping of his shoes, and she...she didn’t know what came to her, and she quickly pulled out the folded pieces of paper she had since last night meant for him and slipped it in the basket. She didn’t think twice, and neither did she have the time to because in seconds he left, taking that basket with him. ”Get some rest; you look pale, my dear.” These were the last words she heard before he went out, and she was too stunned to speak, hearing his voice softer than usual and hesitation before leaving. Was she hearing him right, or was it just the blurry vision from not sleeping all night?

Let A Writer In The Dark know what you thought about this chapter!

Further Recommendations

Mystic Wolf

Teresa: The book is well done, brilliant in fact! Z

Read Now
My Blacksmith Savior

apolloavr04: I love it. It's a great story.

Read Now
The Full Moon Breeding Club

Susan Morris: This is a fantastic romance story! The writing, the timing, the flow, the characters were all great. I love the story because it involved a “process” I had not read about before in shifter romance and was well thought out and applied to this story. Cheers to the author!

Read Now
PARIS IN THE DARK

starlit_soul: The story was beautifull. I hope that every paris find her julien who heals her.

Read Now
Light at the End of the Track

Sonya: This was a lovely gripping and emotional storywith a brilliant ending

Read Now
Hit and Run

ZaraPearl: I truly love the story, very intersting and lovely.Sebastian is a great character and yoda ..., all of it , though I expected more at the endingi5 would've been great

Read Now
IVAN

Steve Worden: Very good read and extremely well written!

Read Now
Silver's Second Chance

April: Reading this one time was not enough, I love rereading this story. I love how strong and independent silver is. 💗💗

Read Now
Bear Roberts

user-za6B61FpQY: While I felt like this wasn't a realistic situation on meeting someone; I realky like how their relationship develops!

Read Now