Some of Them
He didn’t find our cove.
He rowed into the one before it, and stopped, and hummed. He rowed out again. He came along the black rocks of the point so close I could hear the drip from his oars, and I hung under the water with only my eyes above it, and I didn’t breathe through my gills, because even that felt too loud.
The mouth of our cave was low, and half hidden behind a fallen slab, and from the water it looked like nothing. Only a shadow. Tobias had said so, the first night. You’d have to know.
Hollister didn’t know.
He rowed past it. The note went past it with him. One long thin sound, held and let go, held and let go, and every time it came I felt it in my throat, in the place where he used to point. The place he used to touch with one gloved finger, through the bars of my trough, while the stove ticked and the warm pressed down on me like a hand.
Again, he would say. Again. For me.
The boat went round the far rocks. The note went thinner, and thinner, and then it was only the water slapping, and a gull somewhere, and my own heart going slow and heavy in my chest.
I stayed a long time after it had gone.
Tobias was awake when I came back in.
He was sitting up against the wall with the coat across his knees, and he wasn’t looking at the fire. He was looking at the mouth of the cave. At me, coming through it.
“He’s out there,” he said. It wasn’t a question.
“Rowing. Along the coves. Looking in.” I pulled myself up onto the shelf. My tail dragged on the stone, and the torn place under the bitter weed sang out, and I didn’t let it show on my face. “Humming.”
He didn’t say anything for a moment.
“He’s looking for you,” he said.
“He’s looking for his song.”
Tobias looked at me. Then he nodded slowly, as if that were the truer thing, and the worse one.
Across the ashes, the coat that was Kit sat up.
His hair was flat on one side and standing up on the other, and the bruises on his face had gone darker in the night. Purple and green now, and a yellow edge creeping in. He blinked at the light from the crack in the roof. He blinked at Tobias. Then he blinked at me, and remembered something, and went red.
“Morning,” he said to the fire.
Tobias’s mouth moved at one corner. He let it go.
I had thought about it all night. Under his arm, with his breath in my hair, I had lain awake and thought about it. And out at the mouth of the cave, watching the red ship sit there so deep in the water, I had thought about nothing else.
So I didn’t wait.
“Tonight,” I said.
Tobias didn’t ask what I meant. He didn’t even look surprised. He looked at me the way he had looked at the bay, from the wall, before I came in. As if he had been watching something come toward him for a long time, and now it was here.
“The red ship,” he said.
“There are people in her hold.” I said it to Kit as much as to him, because Kit was staring at me with his mouth a little open. “Ours. Not from the Hollow. From the west. I heard them through the wood. They were humming to each other, so they’d know they were still there. The way Ravna and I did.” My hands had closed. I opened them. “One of them answered me. A girl. She asked who I was. And I told her I’d come back.”
Nobody said anything.
The fire ticked. Outside, far off, a gull.
“So, tonight,” I said again.
Tobias looked down at his hands for a long moment. Then he pushed himself up off the wall, slowly, holding his side, and went to the back of the cave.
I watched him reach up. To the high ledge, far from the water, where the sea couldn’t get it even at the highest tide. He brought down the bundle of old sail and came back and sat beside the ashes and unwrapped it, fold after fold, until it lay in his lap.
Hollister’s little book.
I hadn’t wanted to look at it again. I looked at it now. The soft brown cover, rubbed pale at the corners where his fingers had held it against his chest. Day after day. Note after note.
Tobias opened it. He turned the pages, slowly. Most of them were full of the small, careful marks that humans make, that mean nothing to me and everything to them. Some of them had drawings. I saw a fin, drawn very fine, with the notches marked and numbered. I saw a throat, with lines going in. I looked away.
He stopped near the end.
“Royce bought them in the west,” he said. “Before she ever came north. Hollister went over to her ship to look at them, the night of the post. She wanted to know what she’d paid for.” He turned the book a little toward the fire. “Seven.”
Seven.
“He gave them numbers,” Tobias said. He didn’t read them out. He ran his thumb down the page instead, slowly, line by line, the way you’d count stones. “How long each one had been in the warm. How much they’d eat. Whether they’d sing.” His thumb stopped. “Two of them, he’s marked.”
“Marked how?”
He was quiet.
“Like this,” he said, and turned the book to me, and put his finger beside a small black sign at the end of a line. Two little strokes, crossed.
I didn’t know the mark. But I knew Hollister. I knew the way he looked at a thing in his trough, tilting his head, deciding how much longer it was worth.
“What does it mean?”
“It means he doesn’t think they’ll last the crossing south.” Tobias closed the book. “He told Royce to take what she could from them first.”
The cave was very quiet.
I thought of the voices through the hull. The way they went up where ours goes down, and turned at the end, every song a question. I had thought there were five, or six. I had thought they were all singing.
Some of them must not have been.
“So we go tonight,” I said. My voice had gone strange. “Before she takes anything. Before she sails. All seven.”
“Neris.”
“I can get under her. I’ve been under her. Nobody watches the water, you said so yourself, nobody ever—”
“Neris.” He said it very low. “Listen to me.”
I stopped.
He set the book down on the sail beside him, carefully. Then he looked at me, and his face was the face from the night of the fever, when he had cut the cloth out of his own wound with his own knife and never once let his hand shake.
“They’ve been in the warm for weeks,” he said. “Longer than you were. You remember what it did to your skin. How it cracked. How it hurt when you went back into the cold.”
I remembered. I remembered sliding off the deck of the red woman’s ship into the black water of the bay, with the rope on my tail, and the cold hitting the cracks in me like a hundred little knives. I had screamed into the water. I had thought the sea itself had turned against me.
“You were strong,” he said. “You were whole, mostly. You’d only been warmed a few days at a time. And it still almost killed you.” He looked at the closed book. “Two of them can’t eat anymore. One of them hasn’t sung in six days. And the west is a long way. Longer than the Hollow. Through open water, with ice coming down, and nothing between here and there to hide in.” He stopped. “Some of them won’t make it.”
“Then I’ll carry them.”
“All of them?”
“Then we take them to the Hollow.” I heard my voice go up and couldn’t stop it. “Sagga would take them. She would. She’d—”
“The Hollow wouldn’t come south for one of their own,” he said quietly. “You told me that. Sitting right there.”
I opened my mouth. Nothing came out.
He was right. I had told him. Sagga’s tired face on the council ledge, and her voice, every word set down like a stone. We don’t have the bodies to lose.
“So we leave them?” I said. “Is that it? We leave them in the dark with Royce and the warm and Hollister’s numbers, and we sit here, and we—”
“I didn’t say leave them.”
“Then what are you saying?”
He didn’t answer straight away. He looked at the ashes of the fire. And for a moment his face went somewhere I couldn’t follow it. Far down, under the ice.
“I opened a hold once,” he said.
The cave went still.
Kit had gone very quiet on the other side of the ashes. He wasn’t looking at either of us anymore. He was looking at Tobias, and his face had changed. As if he had heard something about this, once, below deck, in a low voice, and had never believed it.
“I was younger than Kit,” Tobias said. “My father’s ship. There were four of them in the hold. I waited till the watch was drunk, and I took the keys, and I opened the hatch, and I got them over the side.”
“And?”
He didn’t look at me.
“And I was very proud of myself,” he said. “For about three days.”
I waited for the rest. It didn’t come. He sat there with his scarred hands open on his knees and his eyes on the ashes, and I watched him decide not to say it. I watched him put it away somewhere, carefully, the way he had wrapped the little book. Fold after fold, until no edge of it showed.
“Tobias.”
“Not now.” He said it gently. Not like a door closing. Like a hand on my arm. “I’ll tell you. I will. Not with him out there rowing, and the light coming up. Tonight. By the fire.” He breathed out. “I need you to hear it before we go. Not after.”
“Before we go,” I said.
He looked at me.
“We’re going,” he said. “Of course we’re going. You promised her.” Something moved in his face, and it almost hurt to look at. “I just need you to know that we’ll take every one of them out of that hold. And some of them will die anyway. And it won’t be because you didn’t try. It won’t be because you weren’t fast enough, or strong enough, or because you stopped to breathe. It’ll be because of what was done to them before we ever got there.” He held my eyes. “I need you to know that now. Before. So you don’t carry it like it’s yours.”
I didn’t say anything. I couldn’t.
I thought of Eilif, in the dark of Thaddeus’s hold, with Tobias’s hand on her forehead. Of the way her breathing had slowed, and slowed, and stopped. Of what he had said to me after, so quietly. Somebody has to be there. At the end.
I had thought, then, that I understood him.
I looked at his hands. I wasn’t sure I understood anything.
Kit cleared his throat.
We both turned. He went red, of course, but he didn’t look away this time. He sat up straighter under the coat.
“The red ship,” he said. “Her hold’s not like ours. Like Thaddeus’s, I mean.” He swallowed. “I rowed a load of salt over to her, the day we came into the bay. They didn’t let me aboard. But I saw her side when I was tying on. There’s a grating. Low down, just above the waterline, at the back. For air. For the warm.” He held up his hands, a little apart. “About so wide. Iron. Rusty as anything. I remember because I thought, that’s the stupidest place I ever saw to put a grating. One big sea and you’d be bailing for a week.”
Tobias stared at him.
Kit went redder. “I just. Notice things. On ships.”
“I know you do,” said Tobias slowly. “You notice everything.” He looked at me. “Above the waterline.”
“I can reach it,” I said. “From underneath. If I come up under the stern, close to the wood, nobody on deck will see.”
“Rust,” Tobias said. He was thinking now. I could see it, the way it went behind his eyes, quick and quiet, the same as on the walk. “Rust, and a bar, and time. And somebody to keep the watch looking the other way.”
He didn’t say who. I saw him not say it.
“And she’s still here,” he said, half to himself. “Royce. She should have sailed yesterday. Her hold’s full, and she’s got no reason to stay in a bay with my uncle in it.” He frowned at the ashes. “Unless she’s waiting for something.”
“For what?”
He looked at me. He didn’t answer.
He didn’t have to. I had heard him say it two nights ago, kneeling by this fire, with Haldor in the water. Royce has wanted it for ten years. The deep one. The Old Bell. The far, slow call through the ice, that I had answered on the walk without meaning to.
Or me.
Or him. The one who had run from her.
Three things in this bay that Madame Royce had come all the way north for. And all three of them were in this cave, or under it, or calling to it.
I shivered. Tobias saw. He didn’t say anything. He only shifted a little closer, until his shoulder was against mine.
We were quiet after that, for a long time.
The light came up through the crack in the roof, grey and then white. Kit got up and went to look at the wood, and came back with the last of it and built the fire up again, slowly, his tongue between his teeth, and every few moments he looked toward the mouth of the cave, where Tove had gone. Tobias didn’t tease him. I saw him see it, and let it be.
I sat at the edge of the shelf with my tail in the water and tried to think of seven. Of seven faces I had never seen, in the dark, behind the wood. Of two little strokes, crossed.
Of what Tobias would tell me tonight, by the fire.
I didn’t want to know.
I wanted to know more than anything.
Tobias sat beside me with the little book closed on his knees. His thumb was moving on the cover, slowly. Back and forth. He didn’t seem to know he was doing it.
Then his thumb stopped.
I felt it before I heard it. A change in the water. A shiver along the scales of my tail, where it hung down into the sea.
Then I heard it.
Thin, and clear, and very close. Closer than before.
One note. Held, and held.
Let go.
Tobias’s hand went to his belt, to the knife, without a sound. Kit froze with a stick of wood in his hand. And all three of us turned our heads, very slowly, toward the low black mouth of the cave.
Where the drip of oars had stopped.
And the note came again. Softer this time. Patient. Right outside.
As if he knew exactly where to look.










