prologue: part i - the names we were given
https://youtu.be/XtexqkACIEA?si=vqMlxbkbRKr6mvXm
part i
the names we were given
twenty-seven years earlier
wednesday, july 18th 2001
the baby had stopped crying.
the woman noticed it before anything else. not the ache spreading across her abdomen, or the exhaustion weighing down her arms. not the uncomfortable hospital bed or the pale afternoon light filtering through the curtains.
the silence.
she turned her head towards the bassinet. a tiny hand rested against the blanket, fingers curled into a fist. the baby’s mouth moved in her sleep, and for one terrible second, the woman found herself waiting for the little chest to rise.
it did.
of course it did.
the nurse had checked her only moments earlier.
still, she watched until the blanket moved again.
“she’s all right.”
the voice came from beside her. her husband was sitting in the chair nearest the bed, leaning forward with his elbows resting on his knees. his hair was a mess, his shirt was creased, and there were dark shadows beneath his eyes. he had barely moved from her side since the birth.
“i know,” she whispered.
he followed her gaze towards the bassinet. “you’ve checked about twelve times.”
“seven.”
“at least twelve.”
“i counted.”
he smiled faintly. “of course you did.”
she reached for his hand. he took it immediately.
for a while, neither spoke. the room was quiet except for the distant sounds of the maternity ward. somewhere beyond the door, a telephone rang. a trolley rattled past. someone laughed at something neither of them could hear.
the ordinary sounds of a hospital continuing around them. she found that almost unbearable.
“do you think she’ll have your eyes?” she asked.
he looked towards their daughter. “she hasn’t kept them open long enough for me to decide.”
“she opened them earlier.”
“for approximately three seconds.”
“four.”
“you counted that too?”
he laughed softly. then his expression changed. “i think she’ll have yours.”
“you can’t possibly know that.”
“i can hope.”
“why?”
“because they’re beautiful.”
she rolled her eyes, but her mouth softened. “you’re impossible.”
“you married me.”
“i was clearly experiencing a lapse in judgment.”
he leaned forward and kissed her forehead. “how are you feeling?”
she considered giving him a sensible answer. something about pain, fatigue, or the medication she had been given. instead, she looked at the bassinet.
“i don’t know. i thought i’d feel different.”
“different how?”
“more certain.”
he was quiet.
“we’ve talked about this for months,” she said. “we made the decision together. so why does it feel like we’re doing something terrible?”
his expression tightened. “because it’s terrible to have to make the decision at all.”
she closed her eyes. he moved closer.
“don’t tell me it’s going to be okay,” she said.
“all right.”
“you always try to fix things.”
“occupational hazard.”
“not everything can be fixed.”
“i know.”
he said it without arguing, without offering a solution. she leaned her head against his shoulder, and together they watched their daughter sleep.
the nurse returned a little later. she had kind eyes and the brisk manner of someone who had been working for far too many hours.
“how are we doing in here?”
“depends which one of us you’re asking,” the woman said.
“both, ideally.”
“she’s doing better than i am.”
“that’s generally how babies like to arrange things.”
the nurse checked the chart and glanced towards the bassinet. “would you like to hold her again?”
the woman hesitated. her husband looked at her.
“you don’t have to decide for both of us,” he said gently. “i’d like to.”
something in his voice made her chest ache. she nodded.
“who’s first?” the nurse asked.
“you,” the woman told her husband.
“are you sure?”
“yes.”
the nurse showed him how to support the baby’s head, although he had already watched closely enough to remember. then she placed the little bundle in his arms.
he went completely still.
the woman had known him for years. she knew his concentration, his amusement, his anger, the way he tried to conceal fear. she had never seen this expression before.
he looked down at their daughter as though he couldn’t quite believe she existed.
“hi,” he whispered. “hello, little one.”
the baby shifted.
“yeah, i know. it’s a lot.”
the nurse smiled and left them alone. the man sat beside the bed, still holding the baby.
“look at her.”
“i am.”
“she’s perfect.”
her eyes filled. “don’t say that.”
“why?”
“because i can’t...”
she pressed her lips together. he understood.
for a while, he simply held her. then he glanced at his wife.
“we still need to settle the name.” “we already did.”
“we discussed it. i just wanted to hear it again.”
she took a breath. “sienna.”
he repeated it. “sienna.”
something in his face softened. he looked at their daughter. “what do you think?”
the baby wriggled.
“strong opinion,” he observed.
his wife laughed through her tears. “she gets that from you.”
“absolutely not.”
“you argue with people for a living.”
“so do you.”
“i’m usually right.”
“usually?”
“don’t push it.”
he smiled, then traced one finger gently along the edge of her blanket.
“hello, sienna.”
for one brief moment, they were simply three people in a hospital room. a mother, a father, and their daughter.
the social worker arrived that afternoon. his name was amelio hernandez, and he had spoken with them before the birth. he knew enough not to begin with cheerful reassurances.
“before we discuss anything else, i want to make sure you both understand that we can take this conversation slowly.”
“we’ve talked about it,” the man said.
“i know. but it’s important that you each have the opportunity to ask questions and make your decisions freely.”
the social worker explained the steps that would follow, the legal requirements, and the information that could be preserved. he did not suggest that everything could be completed with one signature. there would be formal steps, time, records, and decisions with consequences.
he wanted to know what medical information their daughter might receive when she was older, whether it could be updated, whether sienna would know they had chosen her name, whether she could ever ask questions about them.
some answers were clear. others were not.
“what if she thinks we didn’t want her?” he asked. “what if she grows up believing that?”
“you can leave information explaining what you want her to know,” the professional said. “i can’t promise when or whether she’ll have access to all of it, but we can discuss how to preserve it appropriately.”
“could we write something?”
“yes.”
“together?”
“of course.”
his wife looked down at their joined hands. she had been so occupied with her own grief that she had almost forgotten he was carrying the same decision. not in the same way, not with the physical exhaustion of giving birth, but he had imagined a future too. teaching their daughter to ride a bicycle. reading her books. buying a rocking chair, they would never use.
“we’d like some paper,” she said.
the first attempt at the letter was a disaster. her husband wrote three sentences and crossed out two. she wrote a paragraph that sounded like a defence in court. they disagreed about what to explain, whether to apologise, and how to tell a child they loved her when they would not be there to show her.
“what if she doesn’t believe us?” she asked.
“then at least she’ll know we said it.”
“that’s not enough.”
“i know.”
“what if she wonders why we didn’t keep her?”
“she probably will.”
she looked away. he reached for her hand.
“we can’t write something that makes every question disappear,” he said. “but we can tell her the truth about how we felt.”
she pulled a fresh sheet of paper towards her.
“how do we start?”
“with her name.”
she began to write.
wednesday, july 18th 2001 to our beautiful sienna,
if you’re reading this, there are probably questions you’ve been carrying for a very long time. questions about where you came from, why things happened the way they did, and whether you were wanted.
we wish we could sit beside you while you read this. we wish we could answer every question ourselves.
the first thing we want you to know is that you were loved.
not because of anything you did, or anything we hoped you might become. we loved you before we knew the colour of your eyes, before we heard you cry, and before we held you for the first time.
we chose your name together.
sienna.
we said it aloud so many times before you were born, wondering whether it would suit you. then you arrived, and somehow, it seemed as though it had always belonged to you.
your father held you close and told you that he hoped you would grow up asking questions, even difficult ones. your mother told you that you never needed to become anything extraordinary to deserve happiness.
we both meant every word.
there are things about our circumstances that we hope you’ll understand one day. but we also know that understanding doesn’t necessarily make something hurt less. you may be angry with us. you may be sad. you may not want to think about us at all.
you are allowed to feel any of those things.
please don’t mistake the decision we made for a judgment about your worth. there was never anything wrong with you. there was never anything you needed to change to make yourself easier to love.
we hope someone reads you stories when you can’t sleep. we hope you find friends who make you laugh until your stomach hurts. we hope someone remembers the little things you like and notices when you’re having a difficult day.
we hope you have a home where you can be entirely yourself.
and if you ever wonder whether we thought about you after that first day, we hope you’ll remember this: loving someone and being able to raise them are not always the same thing.
we cannot ask you to understand our decision or forgive us for it.
we only hope you know that your life matters, that your happiness matters, and that you have always deserved a place in this world.
whatever name you carry, wherever life takes you, you will always be sienna to us.
with all the love we wish we could give you in person,
your mother and father
p.s. if you ever find yourself wondering whether you were worth fighting for, please know that you were never the problem we were trying to solve.
the woman read the final line, then reached for his hand. neither signed their names on the letter itself. their identities would be recorded separately through the appropriate process.
she folded the paper, then unfolded it. “what if she never gets it?”
he looked towards the bassinet. “then at least we wrote it.”
he helped her fold it again. this time, she placed it in the envelope.
the final hours passed too quickly and too slowly. the woman held sienna against her chest. her husband sat beside them, one arm around her shoulders.
“she doesn’t like being wrapped up,” the woman murmured.
“she likes being warm.”
“she likes moving.”
“she’s been alive for less than a day. i don’t think we’ve established her preferences.”
“i have.”
he smiled faintly. “of course you have.”
then the laughter faded. he touched their daughter’s cheek.
“can i hold her again?”
“of course.”
he stood by the window with sienna against his chest.
“hello again,” he whispered. “i don’t know what you’re going to be like when you’re older. maybe you’ll love music. maybe you’ll hate it. maybe you’ll be the sort of person who asks a thousand questions.”
he paused.
“i hope you ask questions. even the difficult ones.”
the baby’s hand moved against his shirt.
“i hope someone listens when you ask them. and i hope you find people who make you feel safe. people who stay.”
for a moment he couldn’t continue. he kissed her forehead.
“i’m sorry i won’t get to be one of them.”
his wife began to cry. he returned to the bed and sat beside her. together they held their daughter.
“we chose your name together,” the woman whispered. “i hope you like it.”
“if you don’t, you can blame your mother,” he said.
she gave a broken laugh. “you loved it.”
“i did. i always will.”
“i hope you’re happy, sweetheart,” she said.
he rested his forehead against hers. “and i hope you know how much we wanted you to be.”
when the nurse returned, neither moved immediately. the nurse waited. he kissed sienna one last time, then passed her to her mother.
“goodbye, sienna,” she whispered, breathing in her newborn scent.
with her husband holding her other hand, she carefully placed their daughter into the nurse’s arms.
“we’ll take good care of her,” the nurse said.
they watched her move towards the door. sienna made a small sound. the man took one involuntary step forward, then stopped. the woman reached for him. he returned to her side.
the door closed.
for a long time, neither of them spoke.









