Chapter 1
“If suspense and menace didn’t defeat reason, there would be very little drama.”
- Raymond Chandler
Most people are easy to make unhappy. A needling inconvenience, a surly, immature co-worker, a string of bad luck – small things are usually all it takes. Hell, in some cases all you have to do to make someone miserable is to give them what they think they want. I had another agent tell me about one girl in Reseda that had every reason to be happy. Young, bright, good-looking, she had her whole future planned out; college, husband, kids. All that had to be done to make her unhappy (and I mean pure, abject, sustained misery) was to give it to her. Sure, it was a long-term project, but when that blossom bloomed, the Confluence was pulling high-octane energy off her for decades.But the surest way to make someone unhappy is to give them an “other,” to setup an outside force, organization, person, or god they can blame for their troubles, that can take away the perceived power to affect their own lives. That’s what they did to me.
The first time I got arrested was coming up I-35 from Mexico. There were three of us: Miguel, our translator, friend, and fellow grad student, was in the passenger seat, making jokes to pass the time. Gavin, despite barely knowing any Spanish, was driving, and spoke with his usual easy confidence even with the trunk filled with illegal pharmaceuticals. I lay in the back seat of the car alternately smoking cigarettes or trying to nap. We planned to get through the sea of people and custom officers at the border looking like exactly what we were – two over-privileged white boys and their Aztlan friend coming back from a good time in Coahuila. Even though it was a bit of a rite of passage for Texas boys to go into Mexico for a few days looking for cheap liquor, whores, and adventure, getting back in could still be unpleasant. While the number of people coming into the States had dropped to a trickle in comparison to earlier years, it was still an interminable wait, sitting on concrete that baked in the sun until you could see the heat waves rising off of it, each car only moving forward an inch at a time.
“We will personally be responsible for every boner in the great state of Texas for the next quarter, gentleman,” Miguel quipped. I laughed at that, choking a bit on my smoke. What had started as a drunken run into Mexico, blowing off classes for a binge, had become a black market enterprise fueled by cheap cocaine and tequila. One of us (most likely Gavin) over late night beers had cracked open the idea of loading up the trunk of my hand-me-down Mercedes with drugs from less than reputable pharmacies. While Viagra was among the stuff we bought, most of the items in the trunk were bound to be sold as study aids – items like Concerta and Adderall and whatever psycho-stimulants were popular with the student body that year. They’d turnover quick and put a nice little sum in our pockets. But while the enthusiasm for the idea had carried us to the pill joints the next day, it hadn’t allowed for much thought beyond that. The bottles were barely hidden in the trunk and wouldn’t be hard to find if one of the border guards started looking. I kicked back, put my feet up on the seat behind Gavin, and tried to put it out of my mind.
I came to when someone knocked my feet off the seat. I blinked awake to see an angry and intense green-uniformed border guard glaring at me through the driver’s side window. He had reached into the car and was alternatively snapping his fingers at me and curling them towards himself in an irritated gesture for me to give him something. “You want to pay attention son?”
Around the car, I realized, several other guards were circling it with mirrors on extenders, examining the undercarriage. The guard’s pug-like face and the others’ scrambling around suddenly reminded me of my mother’s fleet of tiny, yappy dogs. Waking to the unexpected hostility set my paranoia on edge. As I fumbled for my wallet I hoped my sunglasses covered that.
When I handed the guard my ID he stared at it as if trying to set it on fire with his mind. When that didn’t work he glared at me some more, went back to the ID, then handed it to me while continuing to glare. He then proceeded to examine Gavin’s ID and interrogate him on whether or not we had anything to declare. Despite the load of contraband in the trunk Gavin just smiled that beatific smile of his, calm and serene, and answered all of Mr. Snuggleworth’s questions, adding ’sir’s onto the end of each sentence for good measure. Eventually, when he got tired of looking at us, the guard snapped Gavin’s wallet shut and handed it back to him. “Alright,” he said as if not too happy about it, “pull on through. Welcome back to the United States.”
So we pulled on through, all of us visibly relaxing as if someone had just let all of the air back into the car. No one said anything as we listened to the tires move us across the pavement, faster and faster away from the danger of border crossing.
I felt all of the suspense release out of me with a manic laugh, which the other two joined in. Gavin looked at me and Miguel with a wide, bragging grin, “I told you it’d be easy.” The laughter went up an octave and a notch in volume and lasted a good ways along the desert road. I’m sure to an outsider it would have sounded slightly hysterical.
But it’s a long road back to Austin from Laredo and the laughter died somewhere along the way. So did whatever lingering buzz we had come back with. Eventually Gavin got tired enough that we switched out drivers.
Somewhere between the flat scrub land of southern Texas and its central hill country I felt my paranoia sit up and pay attention again. I looked around to see what was setting it off but found nothing – there was no other traffic, no black helicopters, not even a billboard for Johnny Law to hide behind. For some reason, though, that didn’t help and I felt myself sweating through my palms onto the leather of the steering wheel.
It was almost a relief when I saw the state police cruiser break over the horizon behind us. Almost, but it wasn’t. Whatever satisfaction I might have gotten out of knowing my caution wasn’t misplaced was quickly overwhelmed by the a rising hysteria yammering away in my head about all the things I needed to keep an eye on: Check the speed limit, make sure you stay center, don’t jerk around or make any sudden movements. He knows. HE KNOWS. Breathe.
It only became worse as the cruiser slowly closed the distance between us, moving from an abstract if recognizable shape to a growling predator right at our backside. I felt more pinpricks of sweat develop across my forehead and back as I stared into its grill. When it finally turned its red and blues on I felt my system light up with electricity causing my fingers to splay out from where I was holding the wheel. I slowed down and pulled a little onto the shoulder in the hopes that the trooper was only trying to get by us, but the cruiser continued to hover in my rear view.
The crunch of gravel and the change in the cycle of the tires’ sound caused Gavin and Miguel to wake up from their fitful naps. Gavin rubbed sleep from his eyes and asked like he was about to start chewing ass, “What the hell are you stopping for?”
I adjusted the rear view mirror with a touch, suddenly feeling very calm. “Cop,” I said. After having experienced the fear of authority alone for what felt like an eternity I took a certain pleasure in waking up the two of them with the cold water of this news. Covered with the new conductive information, the electric tension jumped from me to them, causing a twisting of limbs and torsos as they looked out the rear window to verify this, then snapped back into position as their own fear told them to try to act normal. After awhile of us sitting on the side of the road, the car getting hotter in the Texas sun, Miguel asked, “What do we do?”
Gavin and I slowly turned to look at the other, our expression confirming the mutual belief in the stupidity of this question. We turned to look back at Miguel. Gavin spoke first. “Nothing. We sit here and do nothing. We wait like the good little citizens we are. Cole will answer all of the officer’s questions and, when he gives us a ticket, which he will, we take it with a smile and wish him a lovely day.”
“Right,” Miguel replied, his tone already leveling out at our friend’s practical advice. Miguel had always seemed nervous around cops while perfectly level-headed in all other aspects of his life. I thought about this and what it might mean to us now, about Miguel and his experiences, about society as a whole, all the while looking at the cruiser in the rear view. It continued to sit there, exuding menace like a beast in the heat, with no cop emerging.
I began to wonder how much of an officer’s sitting in his car after pulling someone over was preliminary procedure and how much of it was intimidation. I imagined that most people, even ones who didn’t have a reason to, tended to sweat while waiting for a cop to get out of the car. From this line of thought the image of a Texas Ranger sitting in the cruiser, laughing behind mirrored glasses, began to emerge. I thought it was ridiculous, but I couldn’t shake the feeling that there was something sinister waiting in the dark interior of the other vehicle.
One of the thousands of semi trucks on its way from Mexico to who knows where blew by, causing the car the rock gently.
Eventually, a perfectly normal state trooper stepped out of the cruiser. Tall and whip thin, I could see his smile through the side-view mirror long before he walked up to the driver’s side window. When he did arrive alongside in his neatly pressed uniform and cowboy hat, his smile contained none of the malice that I was expecting. In fact, it seemed genuinely friendly, as if he were seeing an old friend for the first time in a long while. He did have mirrored sunglasses, though. I could see my own image there: Sandy, unwashed hair, green eyes, my thin nose stretched wider in the convex image. I looked startlingly pale, even more than usual, and for some reason it made me look even younger than I usually did.
“License and registration, please,” he said without introduction, the smile still on his face. His name badge read “John Murphy.”
“Sure thing.” I tried to smile back as I handed him the documents, but I could feel all of the nicotine and God knows what else sticking to my teeth, so it felt like it came across as thin-lipped and insincere.
“Where you boys headed?” he asked as his pen worked its way through the sheet on the clipboard he was carrying.
“Austin.”
“Coming back up from Mexico?”
The question primed my paranoia, hitting it like a reflex hammer, causing a too long pause from me. It caused me to lie, “Just visiting friends in Laredo.” I regretted it instantly. He stopped writing to look from the clipboard to me, his smile broadening a bit as if he might laugh. Then he went back to the clipboard. I turned away from him to look out across the flat pan of the Texas landscape, watching the heat waves dance, hoping he wouldn’t ask me anymore questions.
“Do you know why I stopped you, Mr. Hagan?” For some reason that question put a hook in me. I had never been asked that question by a police officer before, had only seen it asked in movies. Also, I didn’t know why he had stopped me. I had been obeying local traffic laws. I said so.
“I stopped you because you have a taillight out.”
“What?” I was honestly confused and let it show. The Mercedes was my father’s car and, true to his fastidious nature, he demanded it be maintained in perfect condition. Part of me had taken it into our Mexican sojourn in the hopes it would get damaged or stolen.
Officer Murphy looked at me as if I had been struck dumb. He spoke his reply a little slow, with a small enunciation on each word. “You have a taillight out.” I blinked more disbelief at him and he stepped back from the door to say, “Come take a look.”
I popped my seat belt off, continuing to stare at him as I felt the rising tension from Gavin and Miguel. I only thought that this might be an unwise course of action after my foot had already hit the pavement. Completely out of the car, Officer Murphy gestured for me to lead the way back to the rear of the car.
Arriving at the end of that short distance I found that he was right – one of the red rear lights was burning and the other was as dead as night. “But I don’t have my lights on,” I said, more confused than before.
“Probably some electric trouble then. Pop the trunk and we can take a look at the wiring.” I had never had such a friendly turn of phrase cause my blood to run cold.
I shook my head, slowly, trying to play it casual as I dismissed the taillight with a wave of my hand. “Nah, don’t worry about it. I’ll have it fixed up when I get home.”
“Can’t do it, son,” he said. I turned to him, his choice of diminutive rankling me beyond what was reasonable or, in this case, safe. His friendly smile now frozen he continued, “If it’s a wiring issue it could be a safety hazard.”
“C’mon,” I said, feeling my apprehension and irritation wrestle each other into resignation, “I’m sure it’ll be fine.” Looking at him I felt one cold drop of sweat roll its way down my back, lighting up my spine against the heat. In that moment I thought about everything from telling him the trunk was locked to running off into the scrub brush. Instead I said, “Can’t you just give me the ticket? I’d really like to just be on my way.”
Officer Murphy cocked his head, causing my image in his glasses to bend in ways that matched my mental state. “If you don’t mind me saying so, your reluctance has got me all curious now.”
“I don’t...”
“Open the trunk,” he cut me off, his face frozen behind the sunglasses.
Another cold drop of sweat ran down my spine, straightening it. “Don’t you need a warrant for that?”
That maliciousness I had been expecting came into his face then, mixing with a certain amount of glee. “Shit, son, if I was willin’ to put into my report that I thought ya’ll were terrorists I could arrest you and hold you until the cows come home. Now open the damn trunk.”
I watched myself blink in the mirror shades, trying to parse out how much of that sentence was true and the resulting best course of action. I shrugged, trying to maintain the illusion of apathy, and slid my key into the trunk’s lock. My face away from his, I closed my eyes and breathed out what I’m sure was pure concentrated hope that the half-ass job we had done hiding the pill bottles did the trick. I struggled with the trunk lid for a moment, the catch not releasing immediately, before lifting it.
The smell that came out when I opened the trunk was the first sign that something wasn’t right. It was pungent and rancid and so strong that I had to close my eyes and turn away, my hand flying up to my face to cover my mouth. Overcoming the olfactory shock I looked into the trunk to see what was causing the smell. I threw up into my hand.
Curled up between the wheel wells was a dead girl. While she may have been beautiful in life, the elongated strain on her face and the dried froth at her mouth took that from her. The soiled purple halter top, black miniskirt and fishnet leggings completed the picture of a Mexican hooker that had been pushed into the trunk to die.
My stomach bent me in half in its race to empty itself, racking me with a pain that forced me to catch the edge of the car with my hand. I issued a series of plaintives to a god I had abandoned in eighth grade parochial class. As I repeatedly called out the Lord’s name Officer Murphy stood by me and let out one sharp short bark to His son.
For an indefinite time the world was only filled with the bronchial noise of my vomiting. Eventually I heard Murphy ask, “Weren’t expecting her to be dead, then?” through the echoes in my head.
Still bowed at the waist I looked up at him. “I didn’t know she was in there!” I couldn’t tell if I was crying out or whispering.
He leaned forward to take a closer look, covering his own face with one hand while producing a pair of handcuffs in a smooth, professional motion with the other. “Maybe so, but you’ll forgive me if I feel a mite safer if you put these on while we finish our chat.”
His turn of phrase made it sound like he was going to ask me to slip on a bracelet. Instead he kicked me in the back of my right leg, sending me to the pavement on my knees. Between the heat frying off the surface and the crush to my kneecaps I was very aware of the situation by the time Murphy had my wrists handcuffed behind my back. I tried to speak but couldn’t, alternately gasping or salivating the vomit out of my mouth.
There on my knees I tried to watch over my shoulder as Murphy drew his gun and walked around the passenger’s side of the car with the pistol leading the way. Miguel must have seen it first because I heard him yell out, followed by what was probably a reprimand from Gavin, then general pandemonium from inside the car. It wasn’t long before I felt Officer Murphy grab me by the chain between the handcuffs and pull me up only to deposit me back on my knees, this time a few feet away in the loose dirt by the side of the road next to Gavin and Miguel. Handcuffs must have been in short supply as the other two had their hands on their heads. For some reason seeing the two of them there made the situation more real. Gavin glared angrily at the ground while Miguel looked terribly sad, as if his grandmother might show up at any moment to chastise him.
Pushing through the soup in my skull I began to realize the state trooper looking through the trunk was very much real. I was overcome with the urge to beg or bargain my way out of this, even as the left side of my brain was desperately trying to figure out how all of this had happened.
One thing is for sure, it told me: We’re going to miss class this week. That thought led further into the future, watching it stretch out like a walkway, now falling into empty space as I saw the university graduate education drop off into expulsion, causing the further extensions of Job and Money and Success fall into the abyss with it. Nothing that replaced these things was good, seeing very little beyond the bars of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice, only accompanied by the disappointed and judgmental stares of the thousand or so friends, neighbors, colleagues, and strangers that would eventually learn of this and disapprove, in that lovingly Southern way that was somehow at once hidden and socially powerful.
I realized that Murphy had been talking to Miguel and Gavin when he stopped and walked back to the trunk. I hadn’t heard a word he had said. He started to root around in trunk as we knelt there. My insides moved around on me. I felt weak and light-headed.
“What are we gonna do?” I heard Miguel whisper. He was speaking to the ground, head bowed, his voice shaking as he tried to keep control of his fear. For a moment I stopped feeling sorry for myself and wished Miguel out of there. This hadn’t been his idea, had only really come along out of a desire for approval and some extra cash. He had worked too hard his entire life to see it all destroyed somewhere on the NAFTA highway for being too stupid to say “No”.
“We’re gonna keep our mouths shut. I don’t know what corpse this crazy shitbag is talking about, but I know you can’t do a search because someone’s taillight is out.” Gavin’s normally ruddy complexion was turning even redder with the sun and his anger. I marveled at him for a moment, realizing it wasn’t some kind of front, that he wasn’t using it to mask fear or panic. I could tell that he was already planning his phone calls to a lawyer or his family or both, and how he was going to fight this tide of bullshit that he found towering over him.
Which brought me back to Miguel. While I might have the access to the same resources that Gavin did, I knew Miguel didn’t. He didn’t have any family north of the border and the money on his balance sheet was all in red from student loans.
A hollow rattle announced Officer Murphy’s return to our side of the car as he shook one of the pill bottles, holding it between thumb and forefinger. The gravel of the road’s shoulder ground under his boots as he turned on his heel to face us. “Jesus,” he said again, his tone heavy with disbelief, “It looks like your little chica back there got back into your stash and started chewing on ’em like M&Ms.”
“We have no idea who that girl is,” Gavin snapped angrily. His reply made me worry that he was going to make things worse than they already were. With all of the thoughts vying for space in my head it was just one more I didn’t have room for, giving me a headache that made the heat and sun almost unbearable.
Officer Murphy cut through all that, though, when he said, “Funny thing is, I believe you.”
Even Gavin seemed stunned at that, managing only to utter a flabbergasted, “What?”
“Well, what it looks like,” Murphy went on, popping the top off the pill bottle with a flick of his thumb, “is that you boys went down to Mexico,” pronouncing it Meh-ee-ko, “hit up a bunch of loose pharmacies with less-than-reputable doctors, grabbed a girl who was probably willing to blow one and all of you to get into these United States, then stuffed her and your new stash into the trunk to jump across the border.”
He held up a hand to stop our collective protests then shook out a few pills into his palm. “But somewhere along the way she went crazy with the boredom or heat and started chewing on these little suckers.” He picked up one small pill, holding it up between thumb and forefinger to examine it. “Unfortunately for you, she must have kicked out one of the taillights on the way and here we are.” He flicked the pill away with a casual disdain.
Ignoring the officer’s call for quiet, Gavin and Miguel burst into a cacophony of protest, Gavin angry and Miguel pleading, both of them trying to convince Murphy in their different way that his story is not what happened. I didn’t say anything. I could see how perfectly everything Murphy said laid out, like a map of ruination. Not only were we going to look like addicts or drug smugglers, but we’d look like the worst of human beings, men that traffic in other humans with so little regard for them that we’d let a girl die in the trunk while we sat and laughed in the air-conditioned cab.
“Then I found this on her,” Murphy held up something that looked like a key made of bent wire, a short, sharp instrument that you could use to stab someone or jam up a lock, but for nothing good. “It looks like she used it to jimmy your trunk and climb in.” Miguel and Gavin verbally rushed into the space this reasoning provided, assuring Officer Murphy that he was correct in his deduction, that his intellect stood above that of other men in his ability to see this, but were silenced when he continued with, “I’m pretty sure she didn’t sneak in there with garbage bags full of pills, though.”
“There’s also the fact that she’s still dead,” he added, quieting even Gavin’s ill-advised anger. The wind shifted and brought the over-cooked stench of her corpse to us as another reminder. Murphy coughed into his hand, a wet glob of disgust at catching the scent himself, and wiped it off on the leg of his uniform as he bent at his knees to bring his tall form down to our level. “Now I know you boys were probably just down in Coahuila having a good time and thought you’d make a buck or two out of it.” He bowed his head as he pinched the bridge of his nose, so we couldn’t see his eyes when he lifted up the sunglasses. When he raised his head again we only saw ourselves in his mirror shades. “But somebody’s gonna have to answer for this.”
The silence that followed was so long and absolute that I’m sure a tumbleweed went by somewhere. After a time I heard Gavin ask, “What are you saying?”
Murphy stood up, rocks gnashing underneath his heels. “This may not be your fault, boys, but it’s going to ruin somebody’s life. No use in it bein’ all three of you, but it’ll have to be someone. I’ma gonna go back to the cruiser and phone this in, let ’em know I picked up a single with a truckload of contraband and a dead girl. You figure out who that single’s gonna be.” With that he turned and headed back to the his car.
“What’re we gonna do?” Miguel asked as Gavin followed Murphy back to the cruiser with his gaze. I already knew the answer to that, so I didn’t bother answering.
“This isn’t right,” Gavin said, his tone thick with the beginnings of suspicion, his eyes narrowing as he followed the officer’s disappearance into the confines of the cruiser. “This isn’t right,” he repeated, turning to us. I just stared at him, misunderstanding that he meant the situation wasn’t morally correct. The idea that this state of affairs had ever been ethical in any way stunned me into confusion.
I stared at him slack-jawed, so he added, “Something’s not right here. What kind of cop offers to let people he’s cuffed go? Who does a search because a taillight is out? It doesn’t make sense,” he enunciated each word of the last sentence as if trying to communicate to us across a vast distance through some device that wasn’t up to the task.
“So what do we do?” Miguel asked again, head still bowed under his hands, confusion mixing with his fear. The heat and his panic had mixed as well, uniting to squeeze every drop of moisture out of him. He was covered in sweat, the drops coming off his forehead forming a wet halo around the shadow of his head on the ground.
Gavin dropped his hands from his head and I could see the back of his neck had already begun to burn in the sun. “Fuck this guy,” he indicated the cruiser with a jerk of his head as he spoke. “We don’t play whatever game he’s playing. We force him to call for backup or we all go with him or,” Gavin stopped, running up against the wall of logic as each of the ideas he tried to articulate led, clearly, to only very bad places. “Fuck this guy,” he repeated, exasperation frustrating his intent, whatever that might have been.
Miguel stared at him with desperation in his eyes. “You can’t be serious,” he stated, his voice as steady and sound in the exact way the rest of him wasn’t. “You want to have us all get arrested because,” he stopped then, his fear wavering in the face of his disbelief, “because you think this is some sort of hoax? You want us to go to jail because you think we’re on Candid Camera?”
It was time for Gavin to shake his head and lower it. “No, but something isn’t right here.” After a moment he questioned, “How the Hell did she get back there? How did we not smell her?”
I had been listening, letting the heat and the sharp rocks in my knees sweep away the rattle of everything that had been bouncing around in my head since this started. “What does it matter?” I heard myself say. Gavin looked at me with suspicion and Miguel with something like hope.
“What do you mean?” Gavin asked.
I looked up at last, gesturing towards the cruiser with as much of my body as my handcuffed hands would allow. “The guy’s a cop. It doesn’t matter if he’s crazy as a shithouse rat, he’s still a cop. And while we may be able to get out of this because of an illegal search or because we can prove we didn’t have anything to do with that girl, we’re still gonna get arrested. We’re still going to go to jail, probably face a trial, and God and everyone’s going to know about it. Which means we’re done with school. Or it’s done with us. I mean, would you touch us after this?”
There it was, laid out on the line in such a way as to resemble the truth, which could shut even Gavin up. I think that caused all three of us to bow our heads, but I couldn’t be sure. I was too busy staring at the dirt.
After a time I heard Gavin ask, “So who’s it gonna be?”
“Who’s what?” Miguel replied.
“The single,” Gavin’s tone was drained of the spitfire it had held since he’d been pulled from the car.
My tone held the same resignation when I answered, “It’s got to be me.”
I felt both of them turn towards me, but I just kept staring at the ground. I could imagine the desire in Miguel’s face and the survivor’s guilt already breeding in Gavin’s, so I didn’t want to look at them. I just kept going with, “The car’s registered in my dad’s name. If I’m not the one to stay it’ll come back on me anyway.”
I looked up at them then, having to close one eye against the glare of the sun, trying to fix the other eye on them. “You should go.”
After a few moments, Gavin nodded with a cool resignation and started to stand. Miguel looked confused at that and I worried he might decide to do something foolish. I did my best to implore him, “You should get out of here before he comes back. He might change his mind. Start walking now and it shouldn’t be long before you get a signal. You can call someone for a ride back to Austin. If you stay you’re going to get caught up in this mess.”
Miguel stood then too, helped by Gavin pulling at his arm. The weirdness of the situation still hung over both of them as they looked down at me, trying to sketch out some way to say goodbye. They stammered out words while giving shifty looks to the cruiser. Eventually I broke it off with a simple, “Get out of here.” Uncertainty and shame caused them to stay for a few moments longer but when I went back to staring at the dirt they shuffled off into the scrub brush.
I returned to my dread thoughts about the future when Officer Murphy’s shadow fell on me. I looked up at him to see my reflection in his glasses again and they seemed to glow in the desert heat.
“Looks like we’ve got us a lucky winner.”
And that was how it all started.










