"null"
- Overall Rating
- Plot
- Writing Style
- Grammar & Punctuation


"null"
"null"
"well i loved this book and i really hope that one day it gets published. the thing is when most people write fan-fiction they do not go along the original story or plot. this was really unique. i honestly got so mad that Colette went along to help Draco "kill" Dumbledore... but that just p[roves its excellent writing! if it wasn't good you wouldn't feel any emotions over it really... and you wouldn't cry or throw your phone. thank you so much for writing this. i believe that you could be a real writer some day."
"null"
"This was not what I expected, but I enjoyed it a lot Malfoy was always one of the characters that I liked a lot, so I like that a lot of this happens between him and Colette. I read the first couple chapters, and I enjoyed your writing style and am excited to see where you take this story. My complaint is with the first chapter. You kind of do an information dump. It works, but I think that it would be better if you just mixed it in with the rest of the story, and this is why. I read the first chapter and got a picture of the main character. Then I read the second chapter and got a totally different picture. The two seemed to clash. I would almost say that you could cut the first chapter and start with the second one, because the characterization in the second chapter is really great. So you are fourteen? That's awesome. I started writing around that age too, and I'm really glad that you had the courage to put your writing out there. You're very good, and this story is too. I just think that if you made a few adjustments, it could go from good to great. I hope this helps. Good luck in the contest!"
"I read the first two chapters and didn't find a 'hook' in the very first paragraph that made me feel I should keep reading. I also did not find a hook at the end of the first chapter that grabbed my attention to keep reading into the following chapter.. When I browse in a bookstore I read the 'blurb' on the inside flap, and the first couple paragraphs of the first chapter. If the blurb AND the first two paragraphs don't REACH OUT TO ME, I put the book back on the shelf. I don't know if this is British English or U.S. English, but the grammar was confusing. Too often a person would make an action, followed by dialog in the same paragraph, but the speaker was not the same person. That generally doesn't follow the protocol for writing dialog. It's important to let the reader know who is speaking; not necessarily every line, but enough to be able to follow along. Each character's dialog should be in a separate paragraph. Learn when to use the comma, and when to leave it out. If you want an international audience, put dialog in quotes."
"null"