Prologue
I had heard the story a thousand times and just like every other ten-year-old in my neighborhood, I felt a brand-new knot of fear tie up in the pit of my stomach every single time it was told. Everyone knew it wasn’t true, but something about that night made it feel real. Perhaps it was because we all painted a picture in our heads of what he might look like.
It was your typical scary story; one parents tell us kids to keep us from talking to strangers. The story that the big kids told the little ones to scare the pee out of them at camp. The story told was about a man named Rufus Billay. He was a short, pig-faced bald man who kidnapped little girls in the middle of the night. He would take them to an abandoned thrift store and force them to become his wives. Rufus would change everything about them, their hair, their names, their clothes, rumor had it that he would perform plastic surgery to completely alter their appearances and make them unrecognizable.
It got even worse from there because everyone had their own version of what happened next. Some said Rufus would burn them with cigarettes and force them to have his children. Others said he would keep them chained to the wall for months at a time before growing sick of them and skinning them alive. Each story instilled a different type of fear. Kids would refuse to go out in public because they didn’t want to risk getting taken. Eventually, we all grew up and the story became just that. A story.
My friends and I were graduating from high school the next day and wanted to relax and reminisce before we went out in the big world. We got together and decided to tell the story again for no other reason than to have a laugh.
“I remember the first time we ever heard the story of Rufus Billay,” my best friend Sky was chuckling, “Alex was so scared she was rocking in the fetal position for an hour.”
“Mock all you want. I’m still scared of that creep.” Alex was laying on my futon, painting her nails upside down.
"He's not even real Alex." teased her boyfriend Kyle. "Don't be such a baby."
Alex threw him the meanest glare she could along with a balled-up piece of old AP Chemistry homework. Kyle caught the ball with one hand and smirked. Just then, my sister, Trina, came into my room and plopped on the bed beside me.
"Are you guys talking about that guy again?" She asked as I gave her a small squeeze. "What's his name again? Reggie?"
"It's Rufus, Trin." I said, correcting her. "What brings you to this neck of the house?"
"Mom just called. She is going to be stuck at work all night prepping for court. She told me to ask you if you would take me to my soccer tournament this weekend.
"Sure kiddo, is it in town or out?
"It's in Yolksville. First game starts at noon."
"ROAD TRIP TO EGG TOWN!" Felix shouted, finally joining us in the conversation. He had been going through my closet looking for a sweatshirt and was pulling it over his head as he walked out and closed the door behind him. Trina high-fived him as she hopped off the bed. "You know it!"
The next day, I graduated Valedictorian with my best friends, my boyfriend, and my mom and sister in the bleachers. At two-thirty, after the ceremony, as we packed into the car to head to Trina's games, I knew that it would be a day I remember for the rest of my life. What I didn't know, however, was that it would be that same day that I would lose my sister. What I didn't know was that I would spend the rest of the day crying hysterically and talking to cops. What I didn't know, was that I would spend the next six months searching for that twelve -year-old little girl.
There was one thing I knew for sure though. Kyle was wrong when he told Alex Rufus Billay wasn't real. Very wrong. We all figured that out as soon as we hit the first stop light into Yolksville. Another thing I knew for sure.
Rufus Billay took my sister.
And I am going to find her.









