
Realistic Portrayals of Emotional Turmoil
I genuinely loved this short story. It took barely an hour to read, yet the characters and plot stayed with me long afterward. It’s remarkable how much happens in such a short story, particularly with the FMC’s experience of profound, empty depression. Her depression was portrayed so realistically that it felt quiet yet deeply relatable and authentic. Authors sometimes over-dramatize depression to make its impact immediately apparent, so it was refreshing to spend time with a character who is simply surviving—going through the motions and moving through the mundane actions of everyday life. Some parts of the story move quickly, but only in places where lingering longer wouldn’t have added much to the plot or character development. There are also a few open threads left unresolved, but they don’t detract from the ending or prevent the story from reaching a satisfying sense of closure. Overall, this was a well- paced, emotionally resonant story that managed to leave a lasting impression in a surprisingly short amount of time. A few of the open threads are: (*SPOILERS*) Why would no one talk about her father (even her aunt and uncle)? Will she ever see her parents again if they have been judged and moved on? Can Lyra help the lost souls wandering the veiled forest? Assuming a pack healer is a respectable position, why would her first mate reject her on the basis of status? Why are those in positions of authority so neglectful (her alpha) and ignorant of things going on (the royals)? What is a reaper, and why aren't they explained or mentioned once she moves to the veil? Will she just keep having kids for eternity, or was this a one time gift somehow? What were the creatures the sorceress forced to shift?
Read the story nowHilarious Mystery with Surprising Emotional Depth
Any Witch Wolf is a delightful return to the imaginative paranormal desert community introduced in Book 1. Only in Smokethorn could a missing senior wolf lothario — armed with a little black book and an unreasonable amount of charm — become the centerpiece of such a hilarious mystery. Even with scandal and chaos popping up in every chapter, the author still makes room for genuine emotional depth and honest communication between the romantic leads. So when the tension finally crests, the payoff feels tender, vulnerable, and completely deserved. I’m itching to dive straight into Book 3, but there’s no doubt Book 2 is one I’ll happily revisit again.
Read the story nowPowerful, Satisfying, and Imaginative
The elemental magic in this installment is the most vivid and imaginative so far — descriptions of how Betty’s power roots into the desert, pulls through the soil, and tangles with the earths energy are fascinatingly visceral. It feels big, ancient, and alive in a way that’s both beautiful and completely gripping. What I loved most, though, is how many plot threads come full circle. Questions seeded in Books 1 and 2 finally click into place here, and the payoff is super satisfying without feeling rushed. You can tell the author planned this arc from the start. And just when everything settles into the homestretch... boom — very juicy foreshadowing that opens the door to bigger stakes and messier emotions in the best possible way. So, so excited for the next book drop this month!!
Read the story nowHot Mess Express in the absolute best way
HUGE appreciation for the fact that this (new-to-Inkitt) author released a fully completed and polished trilogy right from the start. It’s such a treat to settle into a story knowing you’ll get to experience deep, evolving relationships with both the main and side characters — instead of feeling impatient or half-satisfied by an exciting but unfinished first installment. The author perfectly balances fantastical absurdity with thoughtful, comprehensive descriptions of highly complex concepts (like the bond between earth-elemental witches and the soil itself). The result is a main character who’s delightfully off-kilter, yet deeply relatable. The setting is totally unique (seriously, what late-night brain blast led to a paranormal senior trailer park guarded by magical saguaro-cactus spirits and populated by an 80-year-old retired necromancer, a magical house cat, and a moody, mannerless garden gnome with a penchant for explosives?). Add in sharp, witty dialogue and a heroine who’s broken, lost, and hilariously human — and you’ve got something truly special.
Read the story nowPowerful and Beautiful
The Epilogue (Kaelion’s particularly) BROKE me. Like crazy crying in public, mourning in the best way, characters that felt like they had become a part of me. If I’m honest, there are parts of the magical world that didn’t make complete sense, and perhaps some modifications here and there could elevate the story. But none of it really matters because the wrap up is so beautiful; it’s impossible to be more specific without spoilers, but to anyone considering reading this - 10/10 recommend! PS Morneth is the best character in the whole thing, no one else even comes close ❤️
Read the story nowDelightfully “feel-good”
Unpolished in the editing department but not enough to deter from a very compelling read. Leaves the reader with a “feel good” impression, includes many creative new supernatural elements, and the main character is quite the spunky heroine! Note to Author: Consider you’ve set the characters up really well for Blair and Maddox to be their own stand alone concept like Nancy Drew or Sherlock Holmes, with each book a different mystery/adventure in banishing dark spirits and healing new customers. Blair and Maddox feel like a team who have only just begun to scratch the surface of what good they can bring to the world (with Anastasia, Nate, Jack, Holly, and Melinda of course). Perhaps Maddox’s hotel could even have a portal to his family in Paris, so they can solve mysteries and help people there too?
Read the story nowBinge-Worthy
Practically can’t sleep, on the edge of my seat waiting for updates! One advantage Banished (Book 2) has over Book 1 is the emphasis on pure plot as the more mundane character backgrounds are already established. Really loving all the new characters, the shifting dynamics between previously introduced characters, and the growing depth of those characters forced by precarious decision making. This author has the potential to be exceptional.
Read the story nowCharacters are Forged in Fire
This author appreciates how distracting poor editing can be, resulting in a well-written and grammatically sound manuscript. While it starts fairly brutal and slow, by the time the plot hits its rhythm the reader has been lulled into a false sense of safety with the assumption the book will wrap up neatly before jolting us with a wicked twist! Loved reading this.
Read the story nowExcellent first drop!
This book is everything a rookie book should be - complex without overburdening the reader with too many details to remember, well-paced with hints dropped throughout of both past memories and future actions, and a unique take on the classic werewolf fantasy formula. It’s also a pleasure to read a manuscript that has clearly been edited with care and attention to detail, as the only distractions are minor inconsistencies in 1st/3rd person perspective thoughout. Can’t wait for the next installment!
Read the story nowThe start of something amazing!
This is easily the most original and well designed universe I’ve come across in werewolf canon. The writing builds on the existing accepted rules of shifters without leaving logic gaps in the new rules. The characters are, for the most part, developed with enough complexity to get attached as well as tell them apart without unnecessary plot diversions. I think with a few light updates, this could be the foundation of a very successful paperback series, with further additions focusing on Charlie’s quest to spread goodness in other realms and her future heirs learning to follow closely in their parents footsteps.
Read the story now