Winld flich

Great, honestly, so emotional.

Okay, I will start off by saying, I absolutely adore this book! I love the cover, the story, the characters, pretty much everything! There are minor grammer mistakes but overall it is well put together. The only thing I have to say is, the book is called 'I love him, He loves her', yet I don't really see much of Max at all. Yes there is that drama about him and her sister, but we never really get an in-depth on his character. It would be nice to get a clearer view of his feelings, thoughts, and actions. I still don't know why Max wears a confused expression whenever he sees Addy and Ben together. Does he know that Addy liked him and is confused about the sudden switch up? He hasn't been present in so long (so many chapters have gone by without him) but isn't he one of the main characters (based on the title and cover). What I'm seeing is Addy and Ben being the two, and only, main characters (Even Emmy and her story don't really feel present here). We need to know and understand more about Emmy and Max.
All that aside, I really love Ben and Addy on their own and together. This book is easily one of my favorites.

Constuctice criticism.

Hmm, I enjoy this book. There are many grammatical errors but it is still enjoyable. There are many mistakes and things I found off about this book and its characters; for one I feel that the character development, dialogue, and overall interactions ( mainly between the female and male lead ) are not as good as they could be. 1.)character development: I have now reached the part in the book where the male lead sees the error in his actions towards the female lead, but it was all to sudden! When did he START to see the error in his past actions? Why does he now feel this way? What exactly pushed him to hate her so much? He changed his mind about her way to quickly without even giving a REALISTIC reason. Now I want to push off into character dialogue, the dialogue between some characters, and some of the thing these characters say is honestly very out of character and cringy+not very realistic. Now that brings me to character personality; I honestly still dont know their personality its so confusing. Its like you(the author) wanted to put multiple character tropes all in one, which is fine, but you didn't know how to blend them! You also didn't know how to develop one character trope from the other. One more question, Why would the antagonist leave a note? Now onto the last thing I have to say (this ties into character development) why does the main female lead like him right from the get go? She literally just saw him and she already has a crush...i minght be missing something but you should have gave her a little more time to observe and 'admire' him before their first interaction. Actually I have one more question, Why in the world would they just let them into the pack without any proper questioning????Not even a sniff or roll of the tummy. I have way to many questions that still have to be answer, why is he not apologizing if he feels guilty? Why did he even say those things there was really no reason that I know or can think of??? Some of the scenes are unnecessary.
I recommend if you like drama and romance between a charming female lead and a male almost-Alpha, itndoes have it own unique sence to it and those of you who like these types of books will sure hopefully enjoy this one :)