Yusbram Emendator

@Yusrohemendator3

Bestselling novelist and editor with critically acclaimed novels translated into twelve languages. My work has been featured by The New York Times, Send me a direct message on [email protected] .

Jeffrey Calhoun

9 months ago

Hello, thank you so much for showing interest in 1938! This book might take me around a year to write. As I want it to be of the utmost historical accuracy.

0 Comments
Like
Comment
Please log in or sign up to write a comment.

𝓚𝓪𝓽𝓼𝔂 𝓓𝓪𝔀𝓷𝓮

9 months ago

Hey Yusbram,

Thank you for the time you took to compile such detailed feedback, I truly appreciate it ✨.

However, I must address the breach of confidentiality and professional etiquette first: posting the entire plot of a story or in my case prose poem in a public comment section is generally considered a violation of the private nature of the beta reading process. According to Inkitt’s guidelines, feedback that spoils the story for everyone else or exposes the entire plot arc is not considered "constructive." I personally do not believe you would have appreciated it if someone did the same with the plot on one of your own pieces, so maybe that is something for you to take into consideration when beta reading in the future. I will be removing the comment shortly to preserve the experience, hence why I thought I would reply to you on your wall rather than in the comments of my work.


Regarding your points on style & character:

On 'Accessibility': You noted that the metaphors & scientific framing are 'exhausting.' That is a deliberate choice. This isn't a standard contemporary romance; as it’s not a romance—it’s a betrayal & a soul-destroying heartbreak & a journey back to her own heart 🤷🏼‍♀️ As they say, “ a woman mentally & emotionally detaches before physically leaving.” 😉 The first part is an emotional detachment. Removing the 'metaphor overload' would strip the work of its alchemy. I’m not writing for a standard audience; if I were, I would have written the generic direct response that everyone adapts. I’m writing for those who enjoy the active decoding of the material & I did not write this piece to gain an audience, I wrote it for myself.

On the 'Calculating' Protagonist & the male:
You described her as 'intellectually superior' & a 'robot' as if those are negative traits. In the first part that’s the whole point, & what’s wrong with a woman being intelligent? Her intellect is her survival mechanism—emotional detachment isn't a lack of feeling; it’s a necessity when dealing with a betrayal during a vulnerable, life-threatening medical crisis & in abusive/toxic relationships too.
If you felt her 'contempt' more than her 'pain,' then the writing was successful in conveying the intended emotional shield for that specific chapter! 😂 As for the male character being a 'sketch'—that is entirely intentional. This is a story about her evolution, not his. He is the catalyst, not the focus, and his lack of depth reflects his role in her life. Again this is not a romantic piece & nothing insinuates that it is.

It’s clear my piece wasn't a match for your personal reading taste, which I completely understand & expected. I genuinely appreciate your points & will take them into consideration.

All the best & safe travels to a more linear narrative & your own craft 💫

0 Comments
Like
Comment
Please log in or sign up to write a comment.

Yusbram Emendator

9 months ago

I just unlocked the Page Flipper badge! 🚀

0 Comments
Like
Comment
Please log in or sign up to write a comment.

Yusbram Emendator

9 months ago

I just unlocked the Reviewer-in-Training badge! 🚀

0 Comments
Like
Comment
Please log in or sign up to write a comment.