
Thrilling and Unexpected
I loved the unexpectedness of this story. It kept me guessing and reading each chapter. Cora’s character was believable and real. I would have liked to see her early years of development. To understand more of who she was. But despite that, I felt like her story was a good one. I wished that she and her husband did not choose to walk away from their marriage, for the simple fact that marriage is holy and sacred. For example, if she had merely been betrothed, or promised, and then turned to Adam, I would have appreciated that more. But then the whole part of her children would have been lost, and those were crucial moments. I loved the seafaring aspect of this book. It was well-done with correct terminology, without being unintelligible to the “laymen” to sea terms.
Read the story nowVery enjoyable!
I really enjoyed this story. Felt drawn to Cami as a genuine person. Great characters with funny honest perspective. Many subplots made this continually interesting. I was never bored and thought the overall plot was intriguing. I do wish that some elements had been excluded, such as some extraneous body part descriptions and crude language. I didn't feel that it added anything to the storyline. But overall this was very well done.
Read the story nowGreat tone throughout!
I thoroughly enjoyed every particle of this interesting story!! I really enjoyed the development of the main characters and loved them despite their flaws. The plot was interesting and kept me reading, wanting to find out what would happen next. Great work! There were a few consistent mechanical errors throughout.
Read the story nowStyle on point
I think you've really found your style here. In reading apart 1, there were parts that felt stilted and stiff, like you were feeling your way long (mostly at the beginning) but as it went along, and through the ending, it was like you got warmed up. Well, Part 2 starts warmed up, and stays that way! Wow! I was carried along for the ride, wondering, hoping, sighing, and laughing. Great job! Some editing to do, but overall, just wonderful!
Read the story nowAdjustment
I have to make an adjustment to my previous review. I mentioned complexity of sentences, but on re-reading certain portions I realized that the sentence structure was, for the most part, good. It was the verb tense that threw me off. I realized as I was reading that I was mentally correcting tenses as I went along, and it distracted me from other elements. I know in English class, teachers (myself included) tend to harp on staying in the same tense, but though there is some truth to this, there is also a natural give-and-take that should occur. Just because a paragraph starts in the present tense does not necessarily mean that everything that follows must follow suit. Some deviation is natural, and so if only one tense is written, it can seem contrived, even forced. One element that struck me anew is that your development of Evelyn as a round character is truly great. She is intriguing and has an air of mystery. The hints and suggestions about her past made me want to keep reading to find out more about her. And the way she develops as a person throughout the story keeps her realistic and interesting. Again, I have to say well done!
Read the story now