
I loved this!
I truly enjoyed this book! I can't think of a single thing I disliked about it. It was an awesome read and I'm looking forward to reading the others.
Read the story nowGood for a rough draft
So far so good. Just a few grammatical errors to clean up. There is some character and scene build up needed to clear up confusion and add depth to relationships and the characters as people. It will help if the lesser characters connections to the main characters seems less forced or last minute. I would suggest a more detailed introduction of major antagonists and supporting characters like Arron, Remond, Zach and Beth before introducing other players like Anderson and Nikolai into the mix. I would also suggest researching the setting for your story a little more, like US laws, Los Angeles and how schools are typically run over here. For example, kids usually leave high school before they are nineteen in the US. Only those who had late birthdays or were left back for some reason are still there that late. It doesn't seem Venessa falls into the 'left back' category unless she was out for a time during her mother's illness and needed to repeat courses due to failure after excessive absence. Most eighteen year olds are in their final year or 12th grade and most nineteen year olds are in their freshman year of college if they attend school after high school at all. There are some exceptions for early or late birthdays, extremely smart advanced students and left back students, as mentioned before, Only private k-12 (kindergarten through twelfth grade) schools and colleges or universities require scholarships over here, so we have to assume Venessa attends a private school given that it isn't told to us in the beginning. Also, you may want to work on her living situation. It isn't believable from an American's point of view. I'm telling you this as a person that lives here and works for the government. Venessa is eighteen and her mother died three years ago. In the US a child under 19 is a minor. They must be under the care of a legal guardian. She wouldn't be allowed to live alone in her parents old house at fifteen. She would have had to move with her grandmother in Florida or her grandmother would have to move there until she finished high school. If she moved to Florida with her grandmother, she has the option to come back to L.A.. at eighteen for her senior year on scholarship to that private school but her grandmother would have to still provide for her because, you have to be nineteen or older to have a bank account on your own here unless they are married or emancipated. Most states don't let students nineteen and under work more than fifteen to twenty hours a week either and then, it's at almost half our minimum wage rate if they are under eighteen. So, you may need to up her age to nineteen and make her a first year college student for this to work without the grandmother in the house. Those bullies could be people she knew from before her mom died when she lived there before and they all ended up at the same college. Typically, college students are more mature than that though So, either her grandma is in the house with her and travels a lot because she's eighteen now or she's a college student to make this more believable. Anyway, these are just some thoughts and ideas I had and some facts about US laws I thought you might want to keep in mind for your writing. I think your storyline is great though. You just need to develop more details in areas but, definitely don't change the path you're going. Thanks for inviting me to read it.
Read the story nowGood story
I left a few comments. I have a tendency to talk to the characters. I may or may not have done that... Your main character confused me but, you know what? That just made her more realistic. Girls have conflicting feelings over guys! They want more than one guy at the same time. They will do stupid stuff like sleep with two different guys they are attracted to in the span of days. None have the excuse of heat or my wolf wants him not me like she did but, this is more like the conflict some girls go through when they have no control over their hormones or emotions and just do whatever. We all want that perfect story where the heroine doesn't screw up but, this heroine wasn't perfect AT ALL. It made readers uncomfortable but, they still read the story. Good job!
Read the story nowI love this spin off!!!
I am embarrassed to say that I have read so many books in my life as a recluse that I don't even remember the name of the book that Sam, Kyrn, and Chloe were featured in but, I do remember reading it. I didn't even remember which platform I read it on until someone mentioned Kindle in a comment. I know...sad. I spend the majority of my free time buried in books on Wattpad, Inkitt, or Kindle. Anyway, I enjoyed reading how the kids turned out and seeing what happened to the girls from the previous book after the hunter and rogue war. I was sad about Sam's Grandpa though. He was a cool old guy but, he was over ninety so, he had lived a full life. I do think Allison and Gideon need a little more development to get rid of some holes in their relationship history and to build up reader sympathy with the heroine. Some stuff like saying she never had love doesn't make sense when she did have it from her mom before she died. And saying 'all her life' when she has only been without her mom three or four years. She had the love of both her parents before that according to earlier descriptions so, all her life doesn't fit.. I would say that, the drastic change in her father's attitude toward her and the frequent abuse caused her to forget what it felt liked to be loved by him and that she all she had was the memories of her mother before her illness to grasp and hold onto and pull her through. Maybe, not having her mother's love there to make up for her father's abuse and neglect possibly made her feel like she had never been loved in her life? That probably needs to be relayed in the details of the story with her dad to build their storyline a little. I'm just throwing out my random thoughts. I am in no way an expert. I just read a lot. LOL
Read the story nowYou just need to clean up some things..
The plot is ok but, I feel like I'm left hanging at the end with her friends. The flip flopping points of view is confusing and the lack of punctuation and dialogue identifiers is a bit confusing too.
Read the story nowThis should not be the end!
This is a great beginning. I would love to see where this story goes. I wan to know what happened with Caddy after she left. I want to see how things progress with her and Theo. I feel like I'm hanging in limbo now. Good job! I hope you decide to continue this.
Read the story now