shadowkat

@shadowkat

Overall Rating
Plot
Writing Style
Grammar & Punctuation

Boone!!!

I love your idea of Boone getting a HEA(FN)! This was a firecracker start and really makes me wonder how the rest of the story would go. Can't wait to read the rest!

Read the story now
Overall Rating
Plot
Writing Style
Grammar & Punctuation

Sneak Peek with Shelly and Beau

Great story idea! I just had a few points that didn't work for me; I don't think Beau and Shelly are married and it was weird to see Shelly's point of view outside the therapist office. Otherwise I thought it was an interesting story and very sweet to get a sneak peek into Beau and Shelly's life. Thank you for your idea! Cheers.

Read the story now
Overall Rating
Plot
Writing Style
Grammar & Punctuation

Not SPRU, Read to Chap 6

Only read up to chapter 6. This is an interesting surprise baby story, but doesn't connect with Reid's SPRU as the prompt indicates.

Read the story now
Overall Rating
Plot
Writing Style
Grammar & Punctuation

Short, Sweet, and Steamy

Love the glimpse into Bethany Winston's life and what she might have gotten up to after Darrell. I also like the idea of a firefighter being the rebound and the nearest Winston neighbor. Things that didn't work for me: -Jumping from 1st to 3rd person is disorienting. -It wasn't clear that it was around the holidays so the end chapter was a bit jarring. Also, timeline-wise when did Bethany find out about her diagnosis? -Bethany wants to be in control but then she wants to give it up as a sub; those don't seem to align. Darrell very much seems like he'd be bedroom dominant, but with 5 kids either he raped her a lot or she liked bedroom dominance. Either way that's info she would've already known about herself and not discovered with Dan. Overall a nice peek into Bethany's life. Short, sweet, and steamy! Cheers!

Read the story now
Overall Rating
Plot
Writing Style
Grammar & Punctuation

Fun Fantasy Fanfic

This story has interesting plot ideas. I thought it was pretty good changing the dynamics of the characters and how that would go if they were magical creatures. Fleshing out a bit more about witches and how they cast might be a benefit. Did a witch also create Kip the vampire? How do vampires originate? Having the Winstons cursed was an interesting twist, but I feel like the mind-meld of werewolves didn't pay off in any way except to showcase how in love with their partners they were. Also what happened to Diane? Where did Jennifer's cat come from? Overall it was a bit disjointed and jumping from sibling to sibling meant that there wasn't a plot-driven story. It was mostly reactionary; however the Winstons DO things, they're active in their own lives. I liked the supernatural twist on SPRU, but needs more foundation work. Cheers for the read!

Read the story now
Overall Rating
Plot
Writing Style
Grammar & Punctuation

Short and Feels Unfinished

Fun to see a prequel-ish story! Mistaken identity can definitely lead to interesting situations so I was curious to see how this played out. The ending is a cliffhanger however; I was left feeling anxious about the female character. Side note: it's funny to see Billy introduced as Bill. This story is definitely not within the correct timeline, but interesting idea nonetheless.

Read the story now
Overall Rating
Plot
Writing Style
Grammar & Punctuation

Sexy Short

I totally agree that they would travel for some holidays. That seems accurate. However I think they'd do more local/cultural exploring instead of marathon sex. Jessica wants to see the world and that means being in it. Duane's there for Jessica, sure, but he's ready to be delighted by things too. Also I'm unsure if Duane would try to convince Jessica to do something she didn't want to do. Duane always seemed pretty binary to me, not a lot of grey space. I also expected to end on Duane's POV just because he was the 2nd chapter. Maybe tell the whole thing from Jessica's POV if Duane only gets a quarter of screen time? It was very short; even the sex scenes weren't fleshed out. I liked some of the ideas you have here and wished to hear a bit more about them (dog sledding?!). Cheers!

Read the story now
Overall Rating
Plot
Writing Style
Grammar & Punctuation

Sly, sweet, and short story

Nods to Penny Reid's Smartypants Romance Universe books are everywhere and I loved it. This story has witty characters that stand on their own feet, while making generous use of SPRU characters and keeping them true to form. Delightful romp that blends culture, language, dreams, and attraction. Loved the humor that bled through every page. Wish we could get a sneak peek about the family confrontation and small vignettes of their tour travels. Can't wait to read what Krysta Dearson writes next!

Read the story now