What We Were

All Rights Reserved ©

Summary

**What We Were** is my story — the kind of story you don’t tell unless you’re ready to bleed for it. For five years, I loved him. Across time zones, through late-night calls, through the ache of missing someone who felt like home. We made a long-distance relationship feel like something unbreakable. Until one lie — whispered by someone I trusted — made me believe he was cheating, living a life without me, hiding who he really was. So, I left. I didn’t ask questions. I didn’t wait for answers. I just walked away and taught myself how to hate him. A year later, I found out the truth. He never cheated. He never lied. He loved me — through it all. And the one who broke us wasn’t him. It was someone in my own bloodline. Now he’s back, asking if there’s anything left between us worth saving. And I don’t know what scares me more — the love I never really stopped feeling, or the fact that I let someone steal the truth of *what we were.* This isn’t just a love story. It’s a story of betrayal, of silence, of rediscovering who I am after being broken in all the wrong ways. And maybe, just maybe… it’s about learning how to love again — not just him, but myself.

Status
Ongoing
Chapters
2
Rating
n/a
Age Rating
16+

To him

I don’t know where to begin– maybe because I never got the chance to end things properly. Maybe because nothing truly ended, it just unraveled… quietly, painfully, falsely. I spent 1 year mourning the death of something I thought you killed. I carried the weight of your supposed betrayal like a second spine – one that bent me in ways I never knew possible. 

I questioned every memory, every phone call, every time you said you loved me. I hated you. I hated myself for still loving you. And all along the truth was buried in someone else’s lie.

I need you to know this: I grieved you like a ghost, Ryan. And now, here you are – not dead, not dishonest, just misjudged. Stolen from me by a mouth I trusted.

What we were– God, it mattered. Maybe more than I allowed myself to admit. Maybe, more than you ever knew. And now I’m left sitting through ashes that should’ve never burned.

Do I still love you? I think a part of me always will. But that love is different now. It’s cautious. It flinches. It asks questions before it dares to hope again.

And maybe that’s okay. You said you want us back. But what if I don’t even know who I am without the heartbreak? What if I’m still learning how to exist without the lie?

Still… if you’re willing to walk with me– through the hurt, through the healing, through the reckoning– then maybe we could find something new. Not what we were. But something honest.

Sincerely,

The version of me you didn’t deserve back then– but maybe you do now.