Elysium Dating Game 🔞
Share with your friends
Customize readability

Elysium Dating Game 🔞

All Rights Reserved ©

Story Notes

Hi loves!

Inspired by the Judgment of Paris, I crafted a modern mythological romantasy featuring sugar, spice and everything nice.

+ Elysium Dating Game updates Mondays and Fridays @ 7 PM ET.

+ I studied Mythology when I lived in Rome.

+ Features gods from different Pantheons (Greek, Egyptian, Roman, Norse, Orisha).

+Rated R or Mature: Steamy NSFW scenes start at Chapters 9/10 (10 & beyond have very explicit scenes interwoven with the romantic tension). 🌶️

+This was originally written for the "Old Gods, New Feelings" contest.

+Thank you for being here.

Summary

Struggling to pay tuition, Lucy agrees to join a reality dating show—but discovers that the contestants are modern incarnations of gods. Each with divine charm, extraordinary powers, and larger-than-life personalities.

Status
4mo ago
Chapters
56
Rating
5.0 (9 reviews)
Age Rating
18+

The Invitation

Lucy was counting quarters on her dorm room floor when destiny texted.

Not destiny-destiny. Maya-destiny. Her BFF since NYU orientation week.

Her phone buzzed beneath a pile of thrifted sweaters and unread philosophy books—Marcus Aurelius, Sun Tzu, Descartes. Lucy nudged a quarter into a crooked stack and exhaled. Tuition math never got kinder, no matter how many times you asked.

Lucy had done this ritual before. Quarters, dimes, crumpled singles. Tuition had a way of turning abstract numbers into something intimate—something that sat with you on the floor at midnight and refused to leave. She’d always been good at math, but money obeyed different rules. It didn’t care how smart you were. It only cared whether you had it. Scholarships came with conditions. Jobs came with exhaustion. Loans came with futures she didn’t want to imagine. Lucy wasn’t desperate, but she was precise. She knew exactly how much time she had left before “figuring it out” stopped being charming and started being fatal.

Buzz. Buzz.

“Lucy,” Maya’s voice suddenly appeared at the doorway, breathless, eyes wild. “Have you seen this?”

Lucy didn’t look up. “If it’s another group chat arguing about astrology signs, I swear—”

Maya crossed the room and shoved her phone in Lucy’s face.

ELYSIUM: A MODERN LOVE EXPERIMENT. A legendary dating series unlike anything before.

Lucy glanced. Unimpressed. “Oh. That.” She blinked.

Maya froze. “What do you mean that?”

Lucy finally looked up, her expression calm in a way that felt almost rude. She slid a quarter onto the pile, then reached for her coffee like she hadn’t just detonated her best friend’s nervous system.

“Yeah,” she said. “I was already selected.”

There it was. The scream.

The scream that followed should’ve violated several campus noise ordinances.

Lucy winced as Maya flopped backward onto the bed like she’d been struck by divine lightning—which, in hindsight, felt ironic.

“You applied to a dating show?” Maya demanded. “You hate attention. You return emails late. You once ghosted a barista because he remembered your order.”

“They found me,” Lucy said, lifting her coffee. “I needed the money.”

It wasn’t the first strange opportunity she’d been offered. Lucy had learned early that unusual things gravitated toward her—professors who lingered after class, strangers who overshared, doors that cracked open without explanation and then waited. She didn’t chase them. She didn’t romanticize them. She evaluated. This one had come with contracts written in flawless legalese, a stipend deposited before she signed anything, and a tone that suggested refusal was optional, but unwise. Lucy trusted patterns. And this one had weight. Gravitas. Potential.

“You were selected? Lucy, normal people apply to dating shows. With headshots. And trauma essays.”

Maya stopped laughing.

“They’re paying for my tuition,” Lucy added. “And housing. And there’s a stipend.”

Maya sat down hard on the bed. “When do you leave?”

“Tomorrow morning. JFK. First class.” Lucy announced like she’d been knighted.

Maya stared at her like she was looking at a stranger. Or a chosen one. Or possibly both.

That did it.

Maya lunged for Lucy’s phone, scanning the itinerary, the NDA, the logo that shimmered strangely—golden, ancient, alive.

“So, LA, huh,” Maya whispered. “This is real.”

Lucy nodded. “Very real.”

“What kind of men are even on this show?” Maya asked. “Influencers? Tech bros? European princes with unresolved childhoods?”

Lucy hesitated.

She hadn’t planned to say this part out loud yet.

“…They’re not normal.”

Maya looked up slowly. “Define not normal.”

Lucy thought of the casting interviews. The way the producers had smiled like they knew her already. The strange warmth in the room when certain names were mentioned. The way the air itself seemed to lean in.

The questions had been… strange. Not invasive, exactly. No one asked about her childhood or her worst heartbreak. No trauma excavation. Instead, they asked things that felt sideways.

Did she believe chance was real?

Had she ever felt chosen without understanding why?

What did she do when she knew something before she had proof?

The room itself had felt warm, softly lit in golds and creams, like a place designed to make people honest without realizing it. At one point, a producer had smiled—not reassuringly, but knowingly—and said, “You won’t need to compete the way others do.” Lucy hadn’t known why that unsettled her more than it should have.

Maya’s eyes narrowed. “Lucy.”

“There’s a stand-up comedian,” Lucy said. “Loki. Funny in a way that makes people uncomfortable. He smiles like he’s already won.” Lucy had the unsettling sense he was the only one who knew the rules or made his own.

Maya nodded. “Red flag. Continue.”

“A cowboy. Thor. Owns land. Big, calm, storm energy.”

“Of course he does.”

“An MMA fighter. Hercules. Legendary yet scary reputation. Gentle hands.”

Maya blinked. “I hate how hot that sounds.”

“Apollo’s a music producer,” Lucy went on. “High-vibe. Platinum records. He walks into rooms like sunlight follows him.”

Maya exhaled slowly.

“There’s a vineyard owner. Dionysus. Inherited land, expanded it, turned wine into an empire. He laughs like he’s never met a consequence.”

Maya shook her head. “This is not a real show.”

Maya’s excitement faltered, something protective flickering beneath it.

“A pilot,” Lucy said. “Horus. Commercial and private. He’s quiet. Watches everything.”

Maya whispered, “Why is this giving… prophecy?”

“And Eros,” Lucy finished. “Dating app founder. Algorithms. Chemistry. He looks at people like he already knows who they’ll fall in love with.”

Silence stretched.

Then Lucy added, casually, like she was mentioning the weather:

“Oh—and a war vet. Mars.”

Maya’s head snapped up. “Excuse me?”

“Decorated. Special forces. Turned billionaire defense contractor. Owns half the companies the government pretends not to fund.”

Maya stared. “Lucy.”

“He’s… intense,” Lucy admitted. “Very controlled. Like violence is a language he’s fluent in but chooses not to speak unless necessary.”

Maya swallowed.

“And one more,” Lucy said.

She paused.

“Ogun.”

Maya frowned. “Is that… a name or—”

“Heir to multiple metal mines,” Lucy said. “Steel, iron, rare earths. Owns an absurd amount of real estate. Cities, basically. He builds things. Breaks things. Very quiet power.”

Maya looked genuinely pale now.

“…Are you going on a dating show,” she said slowly, “or are you being sacrificed?”

Lucy smiled—small, private, like the universe had already let her in on the joke.

“I think,” she said, standing and finally zipping her suitcase, “I’m about to pay for college.”

“Lucy,” she said more quietly, “promise me they won’t make you small.” She laughed after, like it was a joke, but her eyes didn’t.

Maya had always believed in systems—applications, processes, fairness. Lucy had always believed in thresholds. Moments when the universe stopped asking and started deciding. They loved each other anyway.

Lucy glanced once more at the floor before turning away. The quarters were still stacked, uneven but stable. She considered knocking them over—then didn’t. Some things deserved to remain exactly as they were, even if you were leaving them behind. She slung her bag over her shoulder, lighter than she expected, and felt the strange certainty that she wouldn’t be coming back the same way she’d arrived.

Outside, New York roared—unaware. Inside Lucy’s chest, something old and unreasonably calm settled into place.

And somewhere far away, in Los Angeles, the gods were waiting.

Something magical was about to begin.

Let storiesbyBelle know what you thought about this chapter!

Chapter Notes

And so it begins.

Daphne Loves Simone
Daphne Loves Simone

Can't wait to read more, please keep writing!

9 months

Further Recommendations

No Howling at the Dinner Table!

Christin Hoppe: Geweint,Gelacht,Geliebt🥰

Read Now
In Denial

Diane: Love this story and characters, especially incorporation of plus size female main character, as I am plus sized my self, but working on losing some weight. I have lost quite a bit, but have a bit to go to hopefully reach my goal. Nothing real drastic though.

Read Now
THE FIVE-YEAR GAP

cpet99: Loved it, great characters. Thank you for writing this wonderful story.

Read Now
Running

Bridgette Juric: Just love this. Complaint is that it’s not enough for me!

Read Now
Evareth: Awakening

BlackKat07: A great story, with very 'real' characters. There are a couple of inconsistencies in the plot, but only minor ones. All in all, it's a book I would pay to read.

Read Now
The Omega Who Wasn't Difficult

ZiggyCJ : Love the characters and the plot

Read Now
The Wolf King’s Last Bride

JLW: What a story. A human saving his sister by placing herself for the wolf king. With determination she pave the way to melt the frozen wall of the wolf king but with comes chaos. At end they made their peace and their love for their people secure... thank you 😊

Read Now
XP in Love

redherring: I love it. This gave off a really teenish nerdy vibes who’s into game stuff and i’m loving it. I love that it’s not cringey, but has really given me a vision of soft soft features of each characters. like, these nerds are very softboy coded. 😭😭 like where to find these guys IRL, rytttt . Kudos, au...

Read Now
Offered To The Cursed Alpha

Angela: I love this story and would like to read more . I think they are mates and can't wait to find it.

Read Now