The Heart That Chose Twice🌹
Share with your friends
Customize readability

The Heart That Chose Twice🌹

Nayelise

All Rights Reserved ©

Summary

Nineteen‑year‑old Serena Vale has always lived her life quietly — working long shifts, taking classes, and trying to keep her world steady. But everything changes the night she meets Elias Carter, a gentle, thoughtful soul who makes her feel seen in a way she never has before. For the first time, Serena lets herself believe in something soft, something safe, something real. Then Jax Rivera crashes into her life — Elias’s opposite in every way. Loud, magnetic, unpredictable. He makes her laugh, makes her reckless, makes her feel alive. Serena never meant to fall for two men, but hearts don’t follow rules, and hers splits in two before she can stop it. One summer. Two loves. One mistake that changes everything. When Serena discovers she’s pregnant, her world tilts. The timing is impossible. The father is uncertain. And the two men she cares for react in ways she never expected — Elias with heartbreak, Jax with fear. The pressure cracks everything open, and Serena finds herself abandoned, confused, and carrying a life she never planned for. But she refuses to break. Through loneliness, betrayal, and the weight of a future she never imagined, Serena learns to stand on her own. She grows. She fights. She becomes stronger than the girl she used to be. And just when she thinks she’s lost everything, love returns — not perfect, not easy, but real. One of the men comes back wi

Genre
Drama
Author
Nayelise
Status
Complete
Chapters
16
Rating
n/a
Age Rating
16+

✨ CHAPTER ONE — BEFORE THE FALL

Serena Vale had always been good at pretending.

Pretending she wasn’t exhausted. 

Pretending she wasn’t lonely. 

Pretending she wasn’t terrified of wasting her life before it even began.

At nineteen, she worked double shifts at the diner on 8th Street, took community college classes she could barely afford, and lived in a tiny apartment with peeling paint and a window that rattled whenever the wind blew too hard. It wasn’t glamorous, but it was hers. And she was proud of that.

Still, some nights she lay awake staring at the ceiling, wondering if this was all she’d ever be — a girl trying to stay afloat in a world that didn’t care if she sank.

Her best friend, Lila, refused to let her drown in routine.

“You need to live a little,” Lila said one Friday evening, tugging Serena’s arm as they stood outside a downtown building pulsing with music. “Just one night. One party. One breath of air that isn’t work or school.”

Serena sighed. “I have a shift at eight tomorrow.”

“And it’s six now,” Lila said, grinning. “Plenty of time to make one questionable decision.”

Serena rolled her eyes, but she followed her inside anyway.

*

The rooftop was alive.

Music thumped through the floor. Strings of lights glowed overhead. The city stretched out in every direction, glittering like it was dressed up just for them. Serena stood near the railing, letting the wind cool her flushed cheeks.

She didn’t belong here — not with the loud laughter, the expensive shoes, the people who looked like they had never worried about rent in their lives. But for once, she didn’t feel like running home.

“Mind if I stand here?”

The voice was quiet, warm, and unexpectedly gentle.

Serena turned and found herself looking at Elias Carter.

He wasn’t the kind of guy who demanded attention. He didn’t swagger or shout or try to impress anyone. He just stood there, hands in his pockets, eyes soft and steady like he saw more than he said.

“Sure,” Serena replied, moving slightly to the side.

He joined her at the railing, gazing out at the city. “You look like you’re thinking about leaving.”

She huffed a small laugh. “Is it that obvious?”

“A little,” he said, smiling. “But I get it. I’m not really a party person either.”

“Then why are you here?” she asked.

“My friend dragged me,” he said. “Said I needed to ‘touch grass’ or whatever.”

Serena laughed — a real one this time. “Sounds familiar.”

They talked. And talked. And talked.

About school. About work. About the dreams they were both too scared to chase. Elias listened like her words mattered. Like she mattered. And for the first time in a long time, Serena felt something warm bloom in her chest.

Something dangerous. 

Something hopeful.

She didn’t know it then — not on that rooftop, not with the city lights reflecting in Elias’s eyes — but this was the moment everything shifted.

Because two weeks later, she would meet Jax Rivera.

And Jax would be everything Elias wasn’t — wild, magnetic, impossible to ignore.

And Serena’s heart, without permission, without warning, would split itself in two.

But for now, she stood under the glow of string lights, laughing softly with a boy who made her feel seen.

And she had no idea how much she was about to lose… 

or how much she was about to gain.

Let Nayelise know what you thought about this chapter!

Further Recommendations

Mystic Wolf

Teresa: The book is well done, brilliant in fact! Z

Read Now
Bear Shifter Secrets

tatianne Ingrid: Adorei cada capitulo! parabens

Read Now
To Catch a Ghost, Part 1

Wendy Salvo: I really liked this story but now that I’ve read all three I wanted to come back with a thought, the forward on this story talks about a reverse harem and not having to choose, but there isn’t any choice, or thought of a harem until the moment she connects with them, there is only foreshadowing of o...

Read Now
Going For The Goalie

S.TYTECA: I really enjoyed reading this book! The story was engaging and kept me interested throughout. There were a few minor spelling errors here and there, and some parts felt a little drawn out for my personal taste, but that’s purely subjective. Overall, it was a lovely read, and I genuinely enjoyed the ...

Read Now
The Grumpy Next Door

mmurphy1008: This book had my attention from the very first chapter! It has romance and humor and just enough tension to keep it moving along. Can’t wait to read more from this author.

Read Now
The Luna He Threw Away

Danielle_Anderson: Garian’s folded arms and the anger he does not bother to hide from Tria caught my attention more than the rejection itself. He stands near the platform steps like a man watching a preventable disaster, and his insistence that the council has not agreed to exile suggests Delvan’s decree is not as abs...

Read Now
The Contract Wife

waiy: I genuinely loved reading The Contract Wife! The storyline is engaging and keeps you interested, making you want to continue reading and discover what happens next.One of my favourite moments was when she discovered that she was pregnant in Chapter 23. Interestingly, I had already started suspecting...

Read Now
Called by the Alpha

Sandra: Gabi is special and Luca is her mate but, he has to protect her but just maybe she can protect all. Hope to read part 2 soon

Read Now
Half-Claimed

Eniola: It was a good read. I love it ❤️

Read Now