Chapter 1: Apartment 4B
The first time Maren Kessler saw Theo Marchetti, he was trying to break down her door at 8:47 PM on a Thursday, and she was late to the most important night of her career. She had exactly eleven minutes to get dressed, find her keys, and convince herself that showing up late to her own gallery opening at the Whitmore Contemporary in Chelsea wasn't a metaphor for her entire life. She was on minute nine, hopping into a boot, when someone knocked on her door like they were trying to break it down.
"I know you're in there," a man's voice called.
"The lease says 4B. This is 4B. Open up."
She yanked the door open, one boot on, one boot in her hand.
"Do I know you?" The man on her threshold was tall, unshaven in a way that looked expensive rather than lazy, and holding a cardboard box labeled KITCHEN in block letters. He looked at her, then at the numbers screwed into her door—the B slightly crooked, she'd been meaning to fix that for two years—then back at her, like she was the one who'd made an error. "This is my apartment," he said. "I signed the lease Tuesday. Rent's due the first. I'd like to start unpacking before I lose my mind standing in this hallway." "This is my apartment. I've lived here two years." Maren crossed her arms, boot still dangling from one hand, which undercut the authority she was going for. "Whoever told you 4B lied to you, or you can't read a mailbox." "I can read a mailbox fine." He set the box down against the wall with the particular care of someone who did not want to be having this conversation either. "Call your landlord." "It's eight PM." "Then I guess we're both stuck, aren't we." She almost laughed, except she didn't have time to almost laugh, she had six minutes now, and somewhere across the Williamsburg Bridge, in a converted warehouse on Wythe Avenue, Priya was already lighting the little votive candles around her paintings and telling people the artist was just running behind, which was generous phrasing for possibly still not wearing both shoes. "Look," Maren said, "I don't have time to sort out a leasing office's incompetence right now. I have somewhere to be. You can sit in the hallway with your kitchen box, or you can come in and wait while I call them, but either way I'm leaving in five minutes and I'm not missing this for a stranger's cardboard." Something shifted in his face—not quite a smile, but the scaffolding of one. "That's an oddly specific threat." "I contain multitudes." She was already moving past him back into the apartment, hunting for her other boot's twin sock, which had apparently evaporated. "There's a folder on the counter with the building's number. Call them. Tell them their mistake, not mine." He followed her in, which she noted and decided not to examine, and picked up the folder like a man handling evidence at a crime scene. "You always let strangers into your apartment during a housing dispute?" "Only the ones who bring their own furniture as an alibi." She found the sock under the couch, sat down hard to pull it on, and glanced up at him properly for the first time since he'd nearly kicked her door down. He had the kind of face that made you want to keep looking, just to figure out what it was doing. "What's your name, 4B?" "Theo." He was already dialing. "You?" "Maren." She stood, grabbed her jacket off the hook by the door, checked her reflection in the dark window and decided it would have to do. "I really do have to go, Theo. There's water in the fridge if the hold music is unbearable, which it will be. Lock the door if you leave before I'm back—it sticks, you have to lift the handle." "You're just going to leave me in your apartment." "You're either a very committed con artist or genuinely displaced by bureaucracy. I'm betting on bureaucracy." She was in the doorway now, keys finally located in the pocket of her jacket where they'd been the whole time, adrenaline doing the work her mascara hadn't had time to. "For what it's worth, I hope you're not a serial killer. Tonight's been a lot." "For what it's worth," Theo said, phone pressed to his ear, hold music already leaking out tinny and thin, "so has mine." She should have left it there. She almost did. But she paused at the door, hand on the frame, the wood smooth under her palm from two years of coming and going, and looked back at him standing in the middle of her apartment holding her landlord's folder like a peace offering neither of them had agreed to. "If it turns out you really do live here," she said, "you owe me for the inconvenience." "If it turns out I really do live here," he said, "you can pick the restaurant." She left before she could decide whether that had been a joke.
The cab smelled like pine air freshener losing a war against cigarette smoke, and Maren spent the whole ride not thinking about apartment 4B, which was its own kind of thinking. The driver took the Williamsburg Bridge, and she watched the Manhattan skyline recede in the side mirror, the Empire State Building lit up purple for some cause she didn't know, the East River dark and patient below. She'd made this crossing a hundred times—to gallery openings, to late nights at Priya's old apartment before she'd moved to the gallery's back office, to first dates that went nowhere and second dates that went worse—but tonight it felt different. Tonight she was the one being waited for. By the time she pushed through the gallery doors on Wythe Avenue—eleven minutes late, one earring slightly crooked, breathless in a way that had nothing to do with running—Priya took one look at her and said, "You're glowing. Did something happen?" "A man broke into my apartment with a box of kitchenware," Maren said, "and I don't currently hate it." Priya blinked, her red lipstick and gold star clips making her look like a general surveying a battlefield. "I need details after this opening." "So do I," Maren said, and went to go pretend, for the next three hours, that she wasn't thinking about whether the door would still be locked when she got home—or whether, this once, she wanted it not to be.
The opening was everything Priya had promised and nothing Maren had prepared for. The Whitmore Contemporary's main room was a converted warehouse space with exposed brick walls and track lighting that made everyone look either beautiful or guilty. Maren's paintings hung in a careful sequence—seven large canvases, each one a study in blue, each one a different hour of the night in New York City. 4 AM on the Manhattan Bridge, a reviewer would later call them, "lonely and luminous and unafraid of the dark," but that night, all Maren could see were the flaws: the way the cobalt in the third panel was slightly too heavy, the way the figure in the fifth looked less like a woman and more like a shadow that had forgotten how to be human. But the room was full. That was the thing she couldn't get over. The room was full, and people were looking at her work with their heads tilted and their wine glasses balanced, and Dana Kowalski was introducing her to a collector from Tribeca who said, "Your use of negative space is really, well, brave," and Maren had to nod like she knew what that meant. Priya materialized at her elbow somewhere around hour two, pressing a fresh glass of wine into her hand and saying, "The guy from the Times is here. Actual critic. He's been standing in front of the second panel for fifteen minutes. I think he might be writing something." "Or he's just very confused," Maren said. "He's not confused. He's moved. There's a difference." Priya's eyes swept the room with satisfaction. "Also, there's a woman who says she flew in from Chicago just for this. Apparently she saw your work at a group show in Pilsen three years ago and has been following you since." "Following me how? Like, in a concerning way?" "Like in a 'I want to buy your paintings' way. Go talk to her." Maren went. She talked to the woman from Chicago, whose name was Elaine and who had kind eyes and a handshake like a yoga instructor. She talked to the Times critic, who was named Marcus and who asked her questions about her process that she answered on autopilot while her mind drifted, traitorously, back to Ludlow Street. Was the door locked? She'd told him to lock it if he left. But what if he was still there? What if he was sitting on her couch right now, drinking her water, waiting for her to come home so they could figure out this impossible puzzle of two people and one address? What if he'd left, and she'd never see him again? The thought hit her with unexpected force, and she had to excuse herself from a conversation with a young couple from Brooklyn Heights to stand near the back wall and breathe. "This is ridiculous," she muttered to herself. "What's ridiculous?" Priya appeared again, a human exclamation point in her red lipstick and star clips. "Your event is a success. Your paintings are selling. That guy from the Times just asked Dana for your contact information. Nothing about this is ridiculous." "I left a stranger in my apartment." "That is ridiculous. Tell me more." So Maren told her: the knock on the door, the kitchen box, the face that made her want to keep looking. The way he'd said you can pick the restaurant like it was a dare. The way she'd wanted to stay, just a little, just long enough to see what happened next. "And now I can't stop thinking about whether he's still there," Maren finished. "Which is insane, because I don't know him, and he might be a serial killer, and also I'm supposed to be focusing on—" "Your career?" Priya supplied. "Your big night? The thing we've been working toward for years?" "Yes. That." Priya studied her for a long moment. Then she reached out and fixed Maren's crooked earring with the tenderness of someone who had been fixing Maren's life in small ways for years. "Here's what I think," she said. "I think you should enjoy the rest of this opening, because you've earned it. And then I think you should go home and see if the maybe-serial-killer is still there, because clearly you won't be able to focus on anything else until you do." "I hate that you know me this well." "I know. It's exhausting." Priya grinned. "Now go talk to the Chicago lady again. She wants to buy the fourth panel, and Dana is trying not to look too excited about it."
The opening ended at eleven, and Maren stayed until the last guest left, because that was what you did when the Times critic was still taking notes and the Chicago collector had already promised to wire the deposit by Monday. She helped Priya blow out the votive candles and stack the leftover wine glasses, and she tried not to check her phone every five minutes, because there was no one who would have texted her about the apartment anyway. "He's probably gone," she said to Priya as they stood outside the gallery, the Brooklyn night air cool and smelling faintly of the river. "He probably called the landlord, figured out it was a mistake, and went back to wherever he came from." "Where do you think he came from?" "I don't know. Somewhere with better furniture, probably." Maren pulled her jacket tighter around her shoulders. "He had that look. Like he'd never had to fight for anything in his life." Priya raised an eyebrow. "That's a lot to infer from a man with a kitchen box." "It's an artist thing. We read people." "You read paintings. It's not the same thing." Priya hailed a cab with the practiced authority of someone who had lived in New York for a decade. "Go home, Maren. Find out if your stranger is still there. And if he is—" "If he is, what?" Priya's grin was wicked. "Then you can pick the restaurant."
The cab ride back to Manhattan was shorter than the ride out, or maybe it just felt that way because Maren spent the whole time rehearsing what she would say if he was still there. Oh, you're still here. That's—fine. That's totally fine. No. Too casual. Did you figure out the lease situation? Because I'd really like my apartment back. No. Too aggressive. I was thinking about you all night, and I don't know why, and I think that might be a problem. No. Too honest. She was still rehearsing when the cab pulled up to her building on Ludlow Street, the familiar fire escape and the faded awning and the bodega on the corner with its neon sign flickering like a heartbeat. She paid the driver and stood on the sidewalk for a long moment, looking up at the fifth-floor windows. The light was on in 4B. He's still there. Or he'd left the light on when he'd gone. That was possible. That was the responsible interpretation. He'd called the landlord, sorted out the mistake, and left with his kitchen box, forgetting to turn off the light in his hurry to escape this whole embarrassing situation. But as Maren climbed the stairs—five flights, the way she'd done a thousand times before, the stairs creaking in all the familiar places—she couldn't quite keep her heart from racing. The hallway smelled like her neighbor's cooking and the faint ghost of a gas leak. The hallway was dark except for the light spilling out from under her door. 4B. The B slightly crooked. She'd been meaning to fix that for two years. Maren lifted the handle, the way she'd told him to, and pushed the door open. Theo was sitting on her couch, her landlord's folder open on the coffee table in front of him, a glass of water in his hand. He looked up when she came in, and for a moment neither of them said anything. "Hi," he said finally. "Hi," she said. "I called the landlord. And the management company. And then the landlord again." He set the glass down with the same careful deliberation with which he'd set down the kitchen box, hours ago. "The short version is that the management company double-listed the unit. My lease says 4B, but the apartment they actually meant to rent me is 4C, which is apparently a studio with a broken radiator and a view of a brick wall." "So you don't live here." "I don't live here." He paused. "But I don't exactly have anywhere else to go tonight, because the movers already dropped my stuff at a storage unit in Long Island City, and my sublet in the East Village ended this morning." Maren closed the door behind her and leaned against it. She should tell him to leave. She should tell him to find a hotel, or call a friend, or do literally anything other than sitting on her couch looking like he belonged there. Instead, she said, "That sounds like a terrible day." "It's been pretty bad," he agreed. "Up until about an hour ago, when I realized the person whose apartment I accidentally invaded had left water in the fridge and a very impressive collection of art books on the shelf." "You went through my books?" "I was bored. And nervous. And trying not to think about the fact that I was sitting in a stranger's apartment like a creep." He ran a hand through his hair, and Maren noticed for the first time that he had good hands, the kind of hands that looked like they knew how to fix things. "I was going to leave, but then I thought—I don't know. I thought I should at least apologize in person. For the door. And the inconvenience. And the part where I implied you couldn't read a mailbox." "You didn't imply that. You just looked at my door like it had personally offended you." "That's just my face. I've been told it's very expressive." Maren laughed, and the sound surprised her. She'd been braced for something—for awkwardness, for tension, for the strange disappointment of finding out that the man from the doorway was just a man—but instead she felt something loosen in her chest, something that had been wound tight for hours. "I'm sorry your apartment situation is a mess," she said. "And I'm sorry I left you here with the hold music. That was a specific kind of cruelty." "The hold music was fine. It gave me time to think." "About what?" He looked at her then, really looked at her, and Maren felt it like a physical thing, like someone had turned on a light in a room she'd forgotten was dark. "About whether you'd come back," he said. "About what I'd say if you did. About how a woman with one boot and somewhere better to be managed to make me feel like I'd been missing something all day without knowing what it was." The words hung in the air between them, too big for the small apartment, too honest for two people who'd known each other for four hours. "You should probably go," Maren said, but she didn't move from the door. "Probably," Theo agreed, but he didn't get up from the couch. The radiator clanked in the corner, a familiar sound, the building settling into its bones. Outside, a car alarm went off somewhere on Ludlow Street, and someone shouted something in Spanish, and the city went on being the city, indifferent to the small miracle happening in apartment 4B. "Can I ask you something?" Theo said. "You can ask. I might not answer." "How was the gallery opening?" Maren blinked. Of all the questions she'd expected, that wasn't one of them. "It was—good. It was really good, actually. A critic from the Times came. A woman from Chicago bought one of my paintings. I think—" She stopped, hearing the words come out of her mouth, the shape of them unfamiliar. "I think it might have been a success." "And you still came home." "Of course I came home. It's my apartment." "Is that the only reason?" She could lie. She could say yes, obviously, where else would I go. She could pretend that she hadn't spent the entire cab ride rehearsing what she'd say to him, that she hadn't checked the light in the window from the street below, that her heart hadn't done something complicated and inconvenient when she'd pushed open the door and found him still there. But Maren Kessler had spent her whole life painting the truth in shades of blue, and she was tired of pretending she didn't know what she wanted. "No," she said. "That's not the only reason." Theo stood up from the couch, and for a moment they just looked at each other across the small apartment, two strangers on the edge of becoming something else. "So," he said, "about that restaurant." "What about it?" "I don't actually have a place to live. And you don't actually seem to want me to leave. So maybe we should figure out what we're doing here, and then—" He paused, a smile tugging at the corner of his mouth. "Then you can pick the restaurant." Maren thought about all the things she could say. All the reasons this was a bad idea. All the ways this could go wrong. And then she thought about the light in the window, and the way he'd said you can pick the restaurant, and the fact that for the first time in months, she felt like she was exactly where she was supposed to be. "There's a diner on Rivington," she said. "Open all night. Best pancakes in the city." "It's almost midnight." "I know." She pushed herself off the door and reached for the keys she'd just put down. "But I have a feeling this conversation is going to take a while." Theo grabbed his jacket from the back of the chair where he'd hung it, and Maren watched him move through her apartment like he'd been doing it for years, and she thought, Oh no. This is going to be something. They walked out into the hallway together, and Maren locked the door behind them—lifted the handle, the way she'd told him to—and tried not to think about the fact that for the first time in two years, she was leaving apartment 4B with someone else. The hallway smelled like her neighbor's cooking and the faint ghost of a gas leak. The stairs creaked in all the familiar places. Outside, on Ludlow Street, New York was still awake, still moving, still the only city in the world where a woman with one boot and a stranger with a kitchen box could walk out into the night and find the beginning of something. "Hey, Maren?" Theo said, as they reached the street. "Yeah?" "Thank you. For coming back." She looked at him in the neon glow of the bodega sign, his expensive-looking stubble and his expressive face, and she felt something shift into place. "Thank you," she said, "for still being here." And then they walked east, toward Rivington, toward pancakes and coffee and the long, impossible conversation ahead of them, and Maren Kessler thought, Eleven minutes late, and I'm exactly on time.









