Fulfilling The Oath
Share with your friends
Customize readability

Fulfilling The Oath

Story Notes

This will take a deep dive into elven psyche.

Summary

Arradwen sets out to heal the scars of the First Age

Status
15d ago
Chapters
15
Rating
n/a
Age Rating
13+

Locating Maglor

January, T.A. 295

The Stranger by the Sea

Arradwen liked gathering herbs in winter.

That surprised most people.

Spring was prettier. Summer was certainly easier. Autumn filled her drying room until the rafters smelled of leaves and roots.

Winter made her look.

That was its value.

A healer wandering through January woods could not simply reach toward an abundance of green and take whatever was convenient. She had to know which roots remained viable beneath frozen earth, which bark could be harvested without killing the tree, which evergreen plants retained their strength, what had been dried previously, and what should simply be left alone.

Arradwen knelt beside a patch of wintergreen.

Her basket rested beside her.

A small knife flashed between her fingers.

“Only what we need,” she murmured.

One of the sparrows bounced through the bare branches above her.

Arradwen smiled.

“Yes, I know. You’ve heard that before.”

She reached toward the plant.

And the forest disappeared.


The knife fell from her fingers.

There was sand beneath her hands.

Arradwen gasped.

No.

Not sand.

She could still feel frozen soil beneath her knees.

But she could see sand.

Dark water stretched toward an iron horizon.

Waves.

A shore.

Wind coming hard off the sea.

And someone sitting alone.

An Elf.

Black hair blew across a face Arradwen could not properly see.

One hand was injured.

Burned, perhaps.

Arradwen’s healer’s attention seized upon that immediately.

The figure sat hunched close to the surf as though the entire immense shoreline belonged to no one else.

Then came the song.

Arradwen froze.

Quenya.

She knew Quenya.

In much the same sense that someone who had studied medicinal texts in another language might claim to know it.

Enough for scholarship.

Enough for names.

Enough to understand fragments when spoken clearly.

This was not spoken clearly.

This was being sung by someone whose command of the language was effortless and ancient.

Arradwen caught pieces.

Noldor.

Valinor.

Blood.

Exile.

Loss.

Fire.

She couldn’t assemble the whole.

But she didn’t need a translation to understand the grief in it.

The vision gave her something language didn’t.

Feeling.

Sorrow struck her so fiercely that Arradwen’s hand flew to her chest.

Not ordinary sorrow.

Centuries of it.

Layer upon layer until grief had ceased being something this stranger carried and had become the landscape in which he lived.

Arradwen’s healer-instinct awakened.

Oh.

Not fear.

Not curiosity.

Not Who are you?

Her first thought was simply:

You are hurt.


Far away, the black-haired Elf stopped singing.

His head lifted.

Arradwen felt it.

Not exactly hearing.

Not exactly thought.

A mind brushing accidentally against hers across whatever strange road foresight had created between them.

Arradwen had encountered frightened minds before.

Horses.

Children.

Dying Men.

People reaching blindly for anything that might make the world less frightening.

So she did what she always did.

She sang.

Not in Quenya.

Absolutely not.

If she attempted this in Quenya she would probably promise the stranger that his grandmother was an unusually medicinal turnip.

Sindarin.

Sindarin she knew.

Arradwen closed her eyes.

And sent the song gently through ósanwë.

Not words designed to question.

Words designed to steady.

Do not fear the coming night.

The stranger went utterly still.

The road is hidden, not lost.

A wave broke against the shore.

Shadow may cover the earth,

but it cannot teach the stars to forget their paths.

The black-haired Elf slowly turned his face toward the empty horizon.

There was nobody there.

Yet the voice continued.

Wake, weary heart.

Hear the wind moving through the silence.

Night is vast,

but night is not forever.

Arradwen’s hand tightened against her chest.

She could feel him listening.

That was enough.

Rest if you must.

Close your eyes if they have become heavy.

But do not mistake darkness for the ending of the world.

Something changed.

So slightly Arradwen almost missed it.

The crushing sorrow didn’t disappear.

Of course not.

No proper healer expected centuries of grief to vanish because someone sang nicely at it.

But the stranger’s breathing slowed.

Arradwen continued.

Morning waits beyond what you can see.

When you have strength, lift your voice to meet it.

Dawn is nearer than despair would have you believe.

Hope has not left you.

And finally:

You are not alone tonight.

Silence.

The waves rolled in.

Rolled away.

The stranger’s lips parted.

Arradwen thought he might answer.

Instead one trembling hand touched the sand.

Then his mind touched hers.

Barely.

A question without words.

Who?

Arradwen almost answered.

Arradwen.

But something in her foresight pulled suddenly sideways.

The beach shattered.


Arradwen came back to herself on her hands and knees.

Her basket had overturned.

Her herbs were scattered over frozen ground.

Every sparrow in the nearby trees was screaming.

Arradwen sucked in a breath.

“I’m all right.”

The birds disagreed vigorously.

“I’m all right.”

She sat back.

Her hands were shaking.

The sadness remained.

Not inside her exactly.

More like an imprint.

She looked west.

She had no idea why.

The stranger had been beside the sea.

Which sea?

Where?

When?

Foresight was infuriating that way.

It showed something important and apparently considered explanation beneath its dignity.

Arradwen retrieved her knife.

Then stopped.

Black hair.

Burned hand.

Ancient Quenya.

A lament she didn’t recognize.

An Elf alone beside the sea.

Arradwen frowned.

She would need someone with significantly better First Age linguistic knowledge.

Fortunately, she happened to live with approximately half a dozen people who qualified.


Back at the House

Elrond knew something had happened before Arradwen said a word.

She walked into his study carrying an untidy basket and wearing the particular expression he had learned to associate with:

I have encountered something medically interesting and am about to make it everyone’s problem.

Elrond lowered his book.

“What happened?”

Arradwen sat opposite him.

“I Saw someone.”

That capital letter was audible.

Elrond became very still.

Foresight.

Not imagination.

His daughter had inherited another troublesome fragment of the family legacy.

“What did you see?”

“An Elf.”

Elrond waited.

“Black hair. Alone on a shore. His hand appeared injured.”

Something changed behind Elrond’s eyes.

Arradwen didn’t notice.

Yet.

“He was singing.”

“What?”

“Quenya.”

Elrond’s attention sharpened.

“I couldn’t follow much of it.”

“Tell me what you remember.”

Arradwen thought.

“Noldor. Exile. Valinor. Blood. There was something about the rebellion, I think. And grief.”

Elrond’s face had gone completely blank.

Arradwen knew her father well enough now to understand that Elrond going blank was considerably more alarming than Elrond looking shocked.

“Ada?”

His voice was very quiet.

“The melody.”

Arradwen blinked.

“What?”

“Can you reproduce the melody?”

“I think so.”

She hummed several measures.

Elrond stopped breathing.

Arradwen stared.

“Ada?”

He stood so abruptly his chair moved backward.

“That isn’t possible.”

Now Arradwen stood too.

“What isn’t possible?”

Elrond looked at her.

Not through her.

At her.

And something ancient had awakened in his face.

Hope.

Terror.

Grief.

The reaction of someone suddenly hearing a voice from his earliest childhood through a door sealed for thousands of years.

Arradwen whispered:

“You know him.”

Elrond’s lips parted.

For a moment he could not speak.

Then:

“I know the song.”

That distinction mattered.

Arradwen waited.

Elrond’s gaze dropped toward the herbs scattered crookedly in her basket.

“The Noldolantë.”

Arradwen searched her memory.

Nothing.

Elrond continued.

“The Fall of the Noldor.”

The surviving lore identifies the Noldolantë as Maglor’s own lament concerning the rebellion, Kinslaying and exile of the Noldor. [tolkiengateway.net]

Arradwen’s healer mind immediately landed on the obvious question.

“Who wrote it?”

Elrond looked at his youngest daughter.

And suddenly he was six years old again.

A frightened little boy.

A voice singing beside him at night.

Someone else’s hands making the world safe after it had burned.

“Maglor.”

Arradwen went still.

She knew that name.

Not personally.

From history.

From whispered family history, where affection and atrocity existed in uncomfortable proximity.

Then she understood something else.

Her father’s expression.

“Ada...”

Elrond slowly sat again.

Arradwen crossed the room and knelt beside him.

“He knew you.”

A long silence.

Finally Elrond looked down at her.

“No, darling.”

His voice nearly broke.

“He raised me.”

Arradwen’s eyes widened.

The beach returned to her memory.

The injured hand.

The black hair.

The unbearable loneliness.

The stranger quietly asking into the darkness:

Who?

Arradwen turned toward the western window.

Every healer’s instinct in her body aligned at once.

Elrond saw it happen.

His eyes closed.

“No.”

Arradwen looked innocent.

“I haven’t said anything.”

“I know that expression.”

Apparently that ran in the family.

“Ada.”

“No.”

“He’s injured.”

“Arradwen.”

“And alone.”

“Arradwen.”

“I could find him.”

Elrond stared at his youngest daughter.

She stared back.

After several seconds, his shoulders dropped.

Fifty years earlier he would have locked the door.

Now he knew better.

“Take your brothers.”

Arradwen smiled.

“Both?”

“Both.”

And somewhere far away, beside a cold and endless sea, Maglor sat listening to the memory of a strange Sindarin voice that had reached him out of nowhere and told him something he had not believed for a very long time:

Morning was still possible.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

January, T.A. 295

For several heartbeats after Elrond said the name Maglor, Arradwen remained utterly still.

Then she stood.

The movement was so sudden Elrond looked up.

“Arradwen.”

She was already gathering the herbs she had brought into the study.

“I know.”

“You do not even know where he is.”

“Beach. Western coast, most likely. Black sand in places. Rocky shoreline. Cold weather. Sparse vegetation. His hand is injured, possibly chronically.”

Elrond blinked.

Apparently his daughter had been cataloguing details while simultaneously experiencing her first major vision.

“He could be anywhere along hundreds of miles of coastline.”

“Yes.”

Arradwen slung the herb basket over one arm.

“That is why I need trackers.”

Elrond knew exactly what was about to happen.

“Arradwen.”

She stopped at the threshold.

“I’ll take my brothers.”

A pause.

Elrond regarded her suspiciously.

“You agreed remarkably quickly.”

“I learn from experience.”

“You learned because I specifically required this.”

“That too.”

And then her mind reached outward.

Not searching blindly.

Two familiar presences were ridiculously easy to locate after a year under the same roof.

Arradwen touched both simultaneously.

Elladan. Elrohir.


Elsewhere in the Last Homely House, Elladan stopped in the middle of sharpening a blade.

Elrohir looked up from across the room.

Both brothers heard:

Find some of the guard.

A pause.

Then:

Let’s go.

Elladan’s eyebrows shot upward.

Go where?

West.

Elrohir immediately became suspicious.

How far west?

Arradwen considered this.

The sea.

Elladan slowly lowered the whetstone.

Arradwen.

Yes?

You promised Ada one of us would accompany you next time.

Correct.

You have somehow interpreted this as “summon both brothers telepathically and march to the ocean.”

Correct.

Elrohir’s shoulders began shaking.

Elladan glared at him.

And exactly what are we looking for?

Arradwen hesitated.

Then:

An injured Elf.

That changed the atmosphere immediately.

Elrohir stood.

Elladan set aside the whetstone.

How badly injured?

I don’t know.

Threat?

Unknown.

Location?

Unknown.

Elladan closed his eyes.

Of course.

Arradwen added:

Black hair. Probably very old. Quenya-speaking.

A noticeable pause.

And he was singing the Noldolantë.

Neither brother moved.

Then Elrohir asked:

Are you suggesting what I think you’re suggesting?

Arradwen’s answer was simple.

Ada thinks it may be Maglor.

Elladan was out the door before the ósanwë-link ended.


The Household Mobilizes

Arradwen reached the healing rooms and immediately began packing.

Not toddler packing.

Not blanket, cup, kingsfoil and optimism.

Fifty years had dramatically improved her standards.

Clean linen.

Bandages.

Needles.

Thread.

Honey.

Dried medicinal herbs.

Kingsfoil.

Splinting materials.

A small mortar.

Water purification supplies.

Her Dwarven healing stones went into their padded case.

Extra food.

Winter cloak.

Bedroll.

Field journal.

Arradwen was fastening the case when Elladan marched into the room.

“You.”

Arradwen looked up.

“Me.”

“You are not leaving without us.”

“I summoned you.”

“I am aware. I simply wanted that stated aloud.”

Elrohir followed more calmly.

“How certain is Ada?”

“Not certain.”

“What did you actually see?”

Arradwen stopped packing.

“A shore. An injured black-haired Elf. Alone. Singing.”

“And you contacted him?”

“Yes.”

Elladan’s face changed.

“You used ósanwë on someone you don’t know?”

“He was distressed.”

“That wasn’t my question.”

Arradwen met his eyes.

“No. It wasn’t.”

There was the difference between them again.

Elladan saw an unknown ancient Elf and thought potential threat.

Arradwen saw an unknown ancient Elf and thought patient.

Neither instinct was unreasonable.

Which was precisely why Elrond wanted them traveling together.

Elrohir apparently reached the same conclusion.

“What happened when you contacted him?”

“I sang.”

Elladan stared.

“You sang at the potentially dangerous ancient stranger.”

“He calmed down.”

“That is not reassuring.”

“It should be.”

“It profoundly is not.”

Arradwen resumed packing.

Elrohir glanced toward his twin.

“She’s been home less than a year.”

“I know.”

“I understand Ada much better now.”

“So do I.”

Arradwen pointed at them without looking up.

“I can hear you.”

“We know.”


Glorfindel Arrives

“Absolutely not.”

Three heads turned.

Glorfindel stood in the doorway.

Arradwen sighed.

“Not you too.”

“Yes. Me too.”

“I am bringing both brothers.”

“I heard.”

“And guards.”

“I also heard.”

“Then what is the problem?”

Glorfindel stared at her.

“You have just announced that you intend to hunt down one of the Sons of Fëanor.”

“I’m not hunting him.”

She looked genuinely offended.

“I am trying to provide medical care.”

Glorfindel closed his eyes.

Somewhere, surely, Eärendil was laughing.

“Arradwen.”

“He is injured.”

“He also participated in three Kinslayings.”

Arradwen’s hands stilled.

“I know.”

There was no defensiveness in her answer.

That mattered.

She wasn’t romanticizing who Maglor had been.

Neither was she pretending history ceased to exist simply because someone was suffering now.

“I know what the histories say.”

Glorfindel watched her.

Arradwen closed her medicine case.

“But none of that makes an untreated wound less infected.”

That silenced the room.

Very Éothéod.

Very healer.

Glorfindel studied her for several seconds.

Then:

“I am coming.”

Elladan brightened instantly.

“Excellent.”

Arradwen groaned.

“I already have two brothers.”

“And now you have me.”

“Wonderful.”

“And guards.”

“I said that.”

“More guards.”

“Glorfindel.”

“Your father will agree with me.”

From behind him came Elrond’s voice.

“I do.”

Arradwen stared at her father.

Betrayed.

Elrond remained infuriatingly serene.

“You wanted to investigate.”

“Yes.”

“You are investigating.”

“Yes.”

“I have placed no obstacle in your way.”

“You have placed an entire military escort in my way.”

“A small one.”

“Ada.”

Elrond kissed her forehead.

“Humor an old father.”

Arradwen narrowed her eyes.

“You don’t get to use age against me.”

“I am considerably older than you.”

“And I spent fifty years listening to mortal grandmothers. I know every form of emotional manipulation involving age.”

Glorfindel made a choking sound.

Elrond’s mouth twitched.

“I’ll remember that.”


The Map

Within an hour, the group gathered around a map.

This was where Arradwen’s demeanor shifted completely.

No jokes.

No exasperation.

She closed her eyes.

Reconstructed the vision.

“The sea was on his left when he turned toward the horizon.”

Elrohir marked possibilities.

“The beach curved.”

Another mark.

“Rock behind him. Dark. Possibly volcanic, possibly simply wet.”

Glorfindel asked, “Vegetation?”

“Very little immediately beside him.”

“Sun?”

Arradwen frowned.

“Low.”

“Direction?”

“I don’t know.”

“Think.”

She did.

Then:

“Light came across this side of his face.”

Arradwen touched her own cheek.

Glorfindel and Elrond exchanged a glance.

Suddenly this wasn’t merely prophecy.

It was tracking.

Something the Éothéod had taught her very well.

Elladan leaned over the map.

“If we identify the stretch of coast, acquiring reports about a lone Elf should narrow things considerably.”

Elrohir nodded.

“Especially one singing in Quenya.”

Glorfindel muttered:

“For several thousand years.”

Arradwen looked up.

That hit differently.

Several thousand years.

Alone.

Her healer’s expression returned.

“We should leave soon.”

Elrond watched her.

He had seen that same expression on his own face reflected in mirrors for millennia.

The wound exists.

Therefore something must be done.

He couldn’t fault her for inheriting it.


Departure

That afternoon the courtyard filled with horses.

Arradwen’s stallion stamped impatiently.

Elladan checked the guard.

Elrohir checked supplies.

Glorfindel checked everything everybody else had already checked.

Arradwen checked the medical packs.

Elrond approached last.

For one fleeting moment, the sight struck every old wound at once.

His youngest daughter.

Horse.

Traveling cloak.

Saddlebags.

Leaving.

Again.

But this wasn’t T.A. 254.

The door wasn’t locked.

Elrond was standing outside.

His daughter wasn’t fleeing him.

And she wasn’t alone.

Arradwen felt the change in his mind and looked down from the saddle.

Softly, privately:

Ada?

Elrond rested one hand against her boot.

Come home.

Arradwen smiled.

I will.

Then, after a moment:

And if we find him?

Elrond’s eyes moved west.

Maglor.

The person who had taken in two terrified six-year-old boys after their world ended.

The singer Elrond had once trusted enough to sleep beside.

The foster-father who disappeared.

Elrond took a slow breath.

Tell him...

He couldn’t finish.

Arradwen waited.

Finally:

Tell him Elrond remembers the songs.

Arradwen’s expression softened.

I will.

She straightened.

Looked toward her brothers.

Then Glorfindel.

Then the guards.

The healer vanished behind the horsewoman.

“Let’s go.”

The gates opened.

This time when Arradwen rode away from Imladris, her father stood in the courtyard and watched.

He did not hide.

He did not ask her to stay.

And Arradwen looked back.

Not because she feared she would never see him again.

Because now she knew that when she returned,

he would still be there.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Arradwen was already moving.

The vision had left cold sweat beneath her collar and the echo of that ancient lament lingering at the edges of her mind, but the moment Elrond gave her permission to investigate, uncertainty became logistics.

She reached outward through ósanwë.

Elladan. Elrohir.

Both minds answered.

Bring only four guards.

Elladan immediately objected.

Only four?

Four.

We’re looking for Maglor.

Possibly Maglor.

That distinction is not making me feel better.

Arradwen continued as though he had not spoken.

Experienced riders. People who can track. Nobody who panics easily.

Elrohir’s answer was considerably more useful.

Weapons?

Yes.

Winter provisions?

Enough for several weeks. We don’t know how far north or south we’ll have to search.

Then:

We ride west along the coast.

Elladan sighed directly into the ósanwë-link.

You have been home nine months.

Yes.

And we’re already doing this.

Yes.

Elrohir cut in.

I’ll select the guards.

Arradwen smiled.

Thank you.

Elladan was outraged.

Why does he get thanked?

Because he didn’t complain.

I wasn’t complaining. I was contributing tactical skepticism.

Get your horse, Ell.

The connection closed.


“Wait!”

Arradwen entered her room.

Medical satchel.

She pulled it from its hook.

Kingsfoil.

Bandages.

Needles and thread.

Splinting material.

Her small Dwarven stone case.

Winter cloak.

Field journal.

Travel clothes.

She had started separating medicines into waterproof packets when Arwen hurried through the doorway.

“Arradwen!”

“Yes?”

“What’s happening?”

“I Saw someone.”

Arwen stopped.

That distinction everyone in Elrond’s household understood now.

“Ada thinks it might have been someone he knew in the First Age. He’s injured. My brothers and I are going to investigate.”

Arradwen continued packing.

Arwen watched for several seconds.

Then her gaze traveled across the room.

Her expression brightened.

“Wait! What about your pretty dress?”

Arradwen stopped.

Slowly.

Very slowly.

She looked over her shoulder.

“The what?”

“The dress!”

Arwen gestured toward the elaborate garment she had apparently already laid out.

“I thought you could wear it tonight.”

Arradwen stared at her.

Then at the dress.

Then at her medical supplies.

Then back at Arwen.

“Arwen.”

“Yes?”

“There is an injured person alone somewhere on the western coast.”

“I know, but when you come back—”

“Later, Arwen.”

Arradwen turned back to her packs.

Arwen’s face fell slightly.

“But you’ve barely worn it.”

“I know.”

“I had the sleeves altered.”

“I know.”

“And you’re going to get those clothes filthy again.”

Arradwen stopped packing.

There it was.

Not malice.

Not vanity in any especially ugly sense.

Just...

A completely different universe.

Arradwen faced her sister.

“Arwen.”

Her voice was softer now.

“I like the dress.”

That surprised Arwen.

“You do?”

“Yes.”

Arradwen gave the skirt an affectionate touch as she passed.

“It is beautiful. And I know how much work you’ve put into finding things you think I’ll enjoy.”

Arwen smiled.

“But?”

“But somebody is hurt.”

Arradwen picked up the medical bag.

“And therefore right now I don’t care what I’m wearing.”

Arwen looked at her travel clothes.

Something in her expression told Arradwen that this answer genuinely required processing.


The Two Sisters

That was the difference.

Arwen knew illness existed.

Of course she did.

People became ill in Imladris.

People arrived wounded.

Refugees came through the valley.

Elrond’s healing rooms were hardly decorative.

But Arwen’s experience of sickness had almost always contained a crucial assumption:

Ada is here.

There were established healers.

Clean beds.

Medicine cabinets.

Fresh water.

Food.

Guards.

Shelter.

If someone became ill, skilled people came.

Arradwen had spent fifty years learning the opposite assumption:

You may be the skilled person who has to come.

Sometimes there wasn’t a healing room.

Sometimes there wasn’t even a roof.

Sometimes the patient weighed half a ton and was panicking.

Sometimes someone was bleeding onto frozen ground.

Sometimes the nearest medicine was whatever grew beside the road.

Sometimes nobody else was coming.

And the healer still had to do something.

So when Arwen heard:

Someone is hurt.

Her mind naturally went:

Someone will help them.

Arradwen’s went:

Then why am I still standing here?


Arwen watched Arradwen roll bandages.

“How do you know he needs you?”

“I don’t.”

That startled her.

“You don’t?”

“No.”

Arradwen looked up.

“He may already have help. The injury may be old. He may refuse treatment. The vision may not represent something happening at this exact moment.”

“Then why go?”

“Because I don’t know.”

Arwen frowned.

Arradwen approached her.

“If I investigate and discover that he’s safe, then I’ve wasted some travel time.”

Her expression grew serious.

“If I stay because somebody else might help him and discover later that nobody did...”

She shook her head.

“That is a mistake I cannot undo.”

Something clicked.

Not completely.

But enough.

“Oh.”

Arradwen smiled.

“Yes.”


Arwen picked up the medicinal satchel.

It was heavier than expected.

“This?”

“Please.”

Arwen held it while Arradwen fastened her winter cloak.

Then, unable to resist:

“The blue dress when you come back?”

Arradwen looked heavenward.

“Fine.”

Arwen beamed.

“One evening.”

“Yes.”

“And I’ll braid your hair.”

“No.”

“Arradwen.”

“The Éothéod braids stay.”

“I can work around them.”

Arradwen considered.

“Fine.”

Arwen smiled triumphantly.

Arradwen wagged a warning finger.

“No pearls.”

“One pearl.”

“Arwen.”

“Tiny pearl?”

“Goodbye.”

Arradwen took the satchel.

“ARRADWEN!”

She was laughing now.


Outside

Six horses waited.

Elladan.

Elrohir.

Four guards.

Exactly four.

Arradwen nodded approvingly.

Elladan threw up his hands.

“Yes, yes, I followed instructions.”

“Thank you.”

“Do I receive gratitude now?”

“You do.”

“Excellent.”

Elrohir was studying the sky.

“Snow later.”

“Then let’s make distance while we can.”

Arradwen checked her stallion herself.

Girth.

Packs.

Hooves.

Water.

Medical supplies.

Weapons.

Elladan watched.

“You realize this may be one of the most dangerous Eldar remaining in Middle-earth.”

Arradwen swung into the saddle.

“Yes.”

“And your principal concern is his hand.”

“Currently.”

“Of course it is.”

Arradwen glanced at him.

“That’s why you’re coming.”

Elladan frowned.

“What?”

“You worry about whether he’s dangerous.”

She nodded toward Elrohir.

“Elrohir worries about how we locate him.”

Then she tapped her medicinal satchel.

“I worry about whether he survives.”

A pause.

“That seems a sensible division of labor.”

Elladan stared at her.

Then slowly smiled.

“All right, baby sister.”

Arradwen narrowed her eyes.

“Don’t call me that in front of the guards.”

Every guard abruptly became fascinated with their horses.

Elrohir coughed.

Elladan’s smile widened.

“My apologies, baby sister.”

“I’m leaving you here.”

“No, you’re not. Ada said take your brothers.”

“Tragic.”


From an upper terrace came Arwen’s voice.

“ARRADWEN!”

Arradwen looked up.

Arwen leaned over the railing.

“The dress!”

Arradwen closed her eyes.

“LATER, ARWEN!”

Elladan nearly fell out of the saddle laughing.

Elrohir buried his face in one hand.

Arradwen’s stallion snorted.

Even the guards were losing the battle.

Arradwen pointed west.

“We ride.”

And the little company departed.

Behind them stood Arwen, still thinking about dresses.

Ahead of them waited an ancient Elf singing alone beside the sea.

And Arradwen?

Arradwen was already mentally inventorying how much kingsfoil she had packed.

That was the difference between Elrond’s daughters.

Arwen had been raised inside the sanctuary.

Arradwen had spent fifty years learning how to carry a little piece of that sanctuary to people who could not reach it themselves.

And eventually, that difference doesn’t need to make the sisters enemies. It’s precisely what can make their eventual relationship fascinating: Arwen has to learn that beauty cannot always shield people from the world, while Arradwen eventually has to relearn that usefulness does not have to be the price of allowing herself something beautiful.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

First Night on the Road

January, T.A. 295

They didn’t make spectacular distance.

That was deliberate.

Winter daylight was short, and Arradwen had no intention of exhausting seven horses on the first afternoon because Elladan had inherited whatever part of the family believed urgency meant galloping dramatically toward the horizon.

“Slow down.”

Elladan glanced back.

“We have barely begun.”

“You are riding as though Maglor is sitting approximately behind that hill.”

“He could be.”

Arradwen gave him a look.

Elladan slowed his horse.

Elrohir rode up beside her.

“You’ve become frighteningly good at that.”

“At what?”

“The look.”

“What look?”

“The one Ada gives when someone is being foolish in his healing rooms.”

Arradwen considered.

“Good.”

Elladan groaned ahead of them.

“Stars preserve us. There’s another one.”


They followed the old road westward.

Behind them, the mountains rose dark against the January sky.

Ahead lay Eriador.

And eventually, if they kept following the road far enough, the sea.

A very, very large sea.

Containing a great many beaches.

They established camp before darkness fully settled.

Four guards worked efficiently.

Horses were unsaddled, rubbed down and fed.

A modest fire was built beneath suitable shelter.

Bedrolls came out.

Elladan and Elrohir established watches.

Glorfindel, who had insisted upon accompanying them despite Arradwen’s original request for four guards and her brothers, proved remarkably skilled at looking innocent whenever she reminded him of this.

Arradwen was checking her stallion’s foreleg.

Again.

Glorfindel watched.

“You have examined that leg three times.”

“Twice.”

“Three.”

Arradwen frowned.

“When?”

“Once before leaving Imladris.”

“That doesn’t count.”

“It was today.”

“It was before the journey.”

Glorfindel looked toward the twins.

Elladan shrugged.

“We’ve learned not to argue.”

“You were arguing with me three hours ago.”

“That was different.”

“How?”

“I was wrong.”

Arradwen blinked.

Elrohir nearly dropped the kettle.

“Mark the date.”

Elladan threw a glove at him.


The Problem With Prophecy

Dinner was simple.

Bread.

Cheese.

Dried meat.

Hot broth.

Arradwen sat wrapped in her cloak, staring into the flames.

Eventually Elrohir spread a map between them.

“Let’s establish what we actually know.”

Arradwen immediately appreciated the phrasing.

Not what they assumed.

What they knew.

“One Elf,” she said.

Elladan nodded.

“Black hair.”

“Injured hand.”

Glorfindel added quietly:

“Apparently singing the Noldolantë.”

That silenced everyone for a moment.

Arradwen continued.

“On a beach.”

Elladan tapped the western edge of the map.

“Which is spectacularly unhelpful.”

“Elrond’s histories say Maglor wandered the shores.”

“Also spectacularly unhelpful,” said Elladan.

Arradwen rested her chin on one hand.

“I could tell that the climate was cold.”

“It is January.”

“Thank you, Elladan.”

“You’re welcome.”

“That wasn’t gratitude.”

“I choose to receive it as such.”

Elrohir interposed before healer and warrior became involved in sibling warfare.

“What about the coastline?”

Arradwen closed her eyes.

She reconstructed it.

Not the emotion.

The place.

This was something the Éothéod had taught her.

A frightened rider remembered the wolf.

A tracker remembered the footprints.

Separate observation from reaction.

“Grey water.”

Glorfindel listened.

“Strong surf.”

Pause.

“Rock behind him.”

“What kind?”

“Dark.”

Elladan smiled faintly.

“Oh, excellent. We’ve narrowed it down to beaches containing rocks.”

Arradwen kicked him underneath the blanket.

“Ow.”

“Be useful.”

“The Healer of Imladris just assaulted me.”

“She assessed you as healthy enough to survive.”

One of the guards coughed suspiciously.


Arradwen closed her eyes again.

“The strand wasn’t broad.”

Elrohir marked that mentally.

“There was rising land behind him.”

“How high?”

“I couldn’t tell.”

“Trees?”

Arradwen hesitated.

“No.”

“None?”

“Not within what I Saw.”

Glorfindel leaned forward.

“Buildings?”

“No.”

“Ships?”

“No.”

“Smoke?”

Arradwen shook her head.

Nothing.

Just one Elf.

One beach.

One lament.

One unbearable ocean of grief.

Arradwen’s investigative concentration faltered.

She remembered what she had felt.

Suddenly finding him seemed much more urgent.

“He was so sad.”

Nobody joked.

Glorfindel watched her carefully.

“You mustn’t carry all of that.”

Arradwen’s gaze moved to him.

“It came through the vision.”

“I know.”

“I’ve felt grief before.”

“Not his.”

Something in Glorfindel’s voice made her pause.

First Age grief.

Arradwen had grown up hearing of it as history.

For Glorfindel, Elrond, Círdan and potentially the stranger himself?

It wasn’t history.

It was memory.


Their Route

Elrohir pointed to the map.

“We continue west.”

“The Road?” one guard asked.

“Yes.”

It was the sensible choice.

The ancient road ran from the western lands toward Rivendell and provided a known route across the northern parts of Eriador.

Elladan traced the line westward.

“To the Havens.”

Arradwen looked toward the map.

“And then?”

“Círdan,” said Glorfindel.

Of course.

Arradwen looked at him.

“He might know?”

“If an ancient Noldo has been wandering the western shores singing laments for thousands of years, the Shipwright has at least a better chance of having heard something than we do.”

Arradwen nodded slowly.

It wasn’t certainty.

But it was intelligence-gathering.

Éothéod Arradwen approved.

“So we don’t search blindly.”

“No.”

“We reach Mithlond, ask what the coastal settlements and travelers know, and work outward from there.”

The Grey Havens stood on the Gulf of Lune and were the longstanding Elven harbour of Lindon, so using them as the expedition’s information base is my AU inference rather than a canon statement that Círdan definitely knows Maglor’s location. [tolkienfile.com]

Elrohir pointed at her.

“Exactly.”

Elladan leaned back.

“Look at that. We have a plan.”

Arradwen frowned.

“We had a plan.”

“We had ‘ride west until there is water.’”

“That was the preliminary plan.”

“That was not a plan. That was a compass direction.”

“It was more information than we had this morning.”

Elladan opened his mouth.

Paused.

“Fair.”

Elrohir looked delighted.

“Twice in one day.”

“Stop counting.”


After Everyone Sleeps

Arradwen took second watch.

The fire had become embers.

Her stallion slept nearby.

Four guards rested.

Her brothers were quiet beneath their bedrolls.

Glorfindel appeared to be asleep.

Arradwen knew better.

She sat beneath the stars and reached carefully outward.

Not strongly.

Not enough to intrude.

Just...

Are you there?

Nothing.

Wind moved through winter branches.

Arradwen waited.

Then something.

Very faint.

So faint she thought she imagined it.

A note.

Not audible.

Remembered.

The same lament.

Arradwen’s breath caught.

Maglor?

The note stopped.

She immediately regretted using the name.

Too much.

Too soon.

So she changed tactics.

He didn’t need interrogation.

He needed something familiar.

She let her mind become quiet.

Warm.

The same way she approached a frightened horse: no sudden movement, no demand for contact, no insistence that trust happen merely because she wanted it.

Then she sent:

You do not have to answer.

Silence.

I only wanted you to know that someone heard you.

Nothing.

Arradwen pulled her cloak more tightly around herself.

I’m looking for you.

A reaction.

Not words.

Fear.

Sharp and instantaneous.

Arradwen immediately backed away.

I won’t harm you.

The connection trembled.

Then vanished.

Arradwen sat absolutely still.

Behind her came Elrohir’s sleepy voice.

“You reached him.”

Not a question.

Arradwen looked around.

Elrohir had pushed himself upright.

“I think so.”

“Did he speak?”

“No.”

“What did you feel?”

Arradwen looked west.

“Fear.”

Elrohir’s expression hardened.

“Of us?”

“I don’t know.”

She thought of the history Glorfindel had reminded her of.

Kinslayer.

Oath.

Silmarils.

Exile.

Thousands of years alone.

“Maybe of being found.”

That was worse.


A bedroll rustled.

Elladan’s muffled voice emerged.

“If we’re having the mysterious ancient Elf conversation, I’d like it noted that I was asleep until approximately thirty seconds ago.”

Arradwen raised an eyebrow.

“You weren’t asleep.”

“No.”

Glorfindel said from the darkness:

“Neither was I.”

Arradwen stared around their supposedly sleeping camp.

“Does anyone here actually sleep?”

One of the guards answered:

“I was trying, my lady.”

Arradwen covered her face.

“My apologies.”

A little laughter moved through camp.

The tension broke.


Eventually the others settled again.

Arradwen remained beneath the stars.

She looked west.

Hundreds of miles away waited a sea she had never seen.

Somewhere along its vast edge might be an Elf her father once loved as family.

She didn’t know which beach.

Didn’t know whether the vision showed the immediate present.

Didn’t know whether he would allow himself to be found.

But she knew one thing.

She had touched that mind twice now.

And underneath the immeasurable sadness there had still been awareness.

Still response.

Still life.

Arradwen pulled the blanket around her shoulders.

Very softly, through ósanwë, she sent one final thought toward the darkness.

Not far enough to demand an answer.

Just far enough that perhaps, somewhere beside the sea, he might hear it.

We are coming.

A pause.

Then Arradwen reconsidered.

That sounded rather ominous.

She added hastily:

To help.

From his bedroll, Elladan muttered:

“Excellent clarification.”

Arradwen threw a pinecone at him.

And far to the west, the sea continued breaking against an unknown shore.

Sources

Continue their journey west(it will take about a week to get to the havens from Rivendell).

Once they commit to the road west, this becomes less a frantic chase and more an information hunt. Arradwen has one prophetic image and one fleeting ósanwë contact. So during the week to the Havens, they are constantly testing possibilities rather than pretending foresight gave them a convenient map marker.

Westward

January, T.A. 295

By dawn on the second morning, frost had silvered the road.

Arradwen woke before her watch ended.

That irritated Elladan.

“You are supposed to be sleeping.”

Arradwen, already pulling on her boots, glanced toward him.

“I slept.”

“For four hours.”

“Four and a half.”

Elladan stared.

“Ah. Entirely different.”

From his bedroll, Elrohir muttered, “Don’t bother.”

“I am her older brother.”

“By twenty years.”

“Precisely.”

Arradwen walked past them toward the horses.

“You’re both adorable.”

There was absolute silence behind her.

Then:

“Did she just call us adorable?”

“Yes.”

“I’m seventy.”

“Apparently adorably.”

Arradwen smiled into her stallion’s mane.

Home had been good for her.


Day Two: The Road West

They settled into a steady traveling rhythm.

Not racing.

Arradwen absolutely forbade that.

She knew horses too well to confuse urgency with abuse.

They would need the animals for days, perhaps weeks, after reaching the sea.

So they rode hard only where the ground permitted, walked periodically, watered whenever possible and stopped well before the horses approached exhaustion.

One of the guards finally commented,

“My lady, you ride like one of the Horse-folk.”

Arradwen looked at him.

“I was one of the Horse-folk for fifty years.”

Elladan supplied from behind:

“Do not compliment the horse skills. We’ll be hearing Éothéod horse philosophy until sunset.”

Arradwen immediately began:

“A rider who cannot feel fatigue beginning beneath the saddle has no business—”

“I WARNED YOU.”

Elrohir burst out laughing.


The countryside opened around them.

Winter made everything stark.

Leafless trees.

Brown heathland.

Frozen streams.

Bare hills beneath a pale sky.

The road itself became their lifeline.

And whenever they encountered travelers, Arradwen asked essentially the same questions.

“Have you been west?”

“Have you passed the coast?”

“Have you heard singing?”

That last question produced some remarkable looks.

Elladan eventually modified it.

“An Elf,” he explained to one confused traveler. “Black hair. Traveling alone.”

Arradwen added:

“Possibly injured.”

Glorfindel added nothing.

Because Glorfindel knew something the younger members of the company were slowly discovering.

If Maglor had survived alone this long, strangers might not recognize him as anything but a wandering Elf.

And if he did not wish to be found...

finding him would be difficult.


The Second Night

Arradwen tried ósanwë again.

Nothing.

She sat beneath the stars until Elrohir joined her.

“No answer?”

“No.”

“Is that bad?”

“No.”

She hugged her knees.

“It isn’t anything.”

That frustrated her enormously.

Elrohir recognized it.

“You can’t diagnose silence.”

Arradwen gave him a suspicious look.

“That sounded like Ada.”

“I’ve had seventy years of exposure.”

Arradwen returned her gaze to the west.

“I don’t even know whether the vision was happening now.”

“Foresight.”

“Yes.”

She hated prophecy.

Healing was easier.

A patient presented symptoms.

One identified causes.

One treated what could be treated.

Foresight apparently preferred to hand someone a fragment of tragedy and depart without leaving instructions.

Arradwen muttered,

“Useless gift.”

Glorfindel’s voice came from behind:

“Your father has occasionally expressed similar sentiments.”


Day Three

Snow came.

Not a storm.

Enough to slow them.

Arradwen pulled her hood low and rode with her cloak wrapped tightly around her.

Elladan moved closer.

“You warm?”

“Yes.”

“Hands?”

“Warm.”

“Feet?”

“Warm.”

“Face?”

“Attached.”

Elladan glared.

“You were much easier when you were two.”

“I crossed a mountain without permission when I was two.”

“Fair.”

Arradwen glanced at him.

“You really remember me before I left?”

Elladan went strangely quiet.

“Yes.”

The joking disappeared.

Arradwen waited.

“You used to follow me.”

She frowned.

“Why?”

Elladan looked wounded.

“Because you adored me.”

“I clearly hadn’t developed judgment yet.”

“Arradwen.”

She smiled.

But Elladan continued.

“You would grab my clothes when you walked. Just...” He mimed a tiny fist closing around fabric. “Here.”

Arradwen watched him.

“And if I moved too quickly, you’d yell.”

“What?”

Elladan smiled.

“Ell!”

Her own nickname for him.

Something hurt pleasantly inside her.

She didn’t remember.

That was perhaps the worst part of returning after fifty years.

Everyone had memories of versions of Arradwen that Arradwen herself had lost.

After a minute, she reached sideways.

Elladan instinctively brought his horse closer.

Arradwen squeezed his forearm.

“I’m sorry.”

He immediately shook his head.

“No.”

“I left.”

“You were two.”

Apparently Elrond had made that family doctrine.

Elladan’s expression softened.

“We were supposed to notice before you reached Moria.”

Arradwen stared.

“So perhaps everybody stops apologizing.”

“That sounds suspiciously healthy.”

“I’ve lived with Ada for seventy years.”

“Point taken.”


Day Four

They started seeing more westbound traffic.

This gave them better information.

None about Maglor.

But that itself was useful.

No one described:

a recently injured Elf;a mysterious black-haired traveler;or some haunting Quenya singer wandering openly down the road.

Which suggested their stranger was avoiding settlements.

Arradwen frowned over the map that evening.

“If he’s isolated...”

Elrohir finished:

“He probably isn’t near the Havens themselves.”

Glorfindel nodded.

“But we still go there.”

“For Círdan.”

“Yes.”

Arradwen tapped various points along the imagined coastline.

“We ask fishermen.”

“Precisely.”

“Coastal patrols.”

“Yes.”

“Travelers.”

“Yes.”

“Anyone maintaining isolated settlements.”

Glorfindel nodded.

Arradwen sat back.

Then:

“Birds.”

Six people stared at her.

Elladan slowly said:

“Birds?”

“Coastal birds.”

“What about them?”

Arradwen’s expression suggested this should be obvious.

“They see everything.”

Elladan stared.

Elrohir stared.

Four guards stared.

Glorfindel smiled.

“Your sparrows.”

Arradwen nodded.

“My ósanwë with animals isn’t conversation in words. But impressions can be enough.”

Elladan closed his eyes.

“Of course we’re going to interrogate seagulls.”

“Not interrogate.”

“Interview?”

“Ask.”

“This expedition becomes stranger every day.”

Arradwen pointed at him.

“And when a gull finds Maglor, you are forbidden from taking credit.”


Day Five

The weather cleared.

They made their longest day’s ride.

Arradwen came alive in the saddle.

Her stallion stretched into an easy canter across a long open section, and for several glorious minutes she simply let him run.

Then Elladan appeared beside her.

Then Elrohir.

Sibling rivalry required approximately seven seconds to manifest.

“No racing,” called Glorfindel.

Nobody was racing.

Technically.

They were merely traveling very rapidly beside one another while continuously checking who was ahead.

Glorfindel watched the three Peredhil vanish along the road.

One guard asked:

“Should we stop them?”

“No.”

“Why?”

Glorfindel sighed.

“Because I’m tired.”


They waited farther ahead.

Arradwen was laughing.

Actually laughing.

Hair coming loose from her braids.

Cheeks flushed from the cold.

One hand rubbing her stallion’s neck.

“Good horse.”

Elladan looked at her.

“You still say that.”

She glanced at him.

“Say what?”

“That.”

“What?”

“Good horse.”

Arradwen shrugged.

“He is a good horse.”

Something about the uncomplicated answer made Elladan smile.


That Evening: Contact

Arradwen woke abruptly.

Darkness.

Fire nearly extinguished.

The others sleeping.

And somewhere inside her mind:

Music.

Arradwen sat upright.

Not beside her.

Far away.

Maglor.

She didn’t use the name this time.

She simply listened.

The melody was weak.

Fragmented.

Then pain.

Her healer instincts exploded awake.

Wait.

The distant presence recoiled.

Arradwen softened immediately.

Please.

Nothing.

I’m the person who sang to you.

A pause.

Not recognition exactly.

But awareness.

Arradwen continued carefully.

I am a healer.

Fear.

Again.

Why fear?

I’m not asking you to tell me where you are.

That helped.

Interesting.

But your hand is hurt.

A sudden wall slammed down between them.

Arradwen gasped.

The connection vanished.

Elladan was instantly awake.

“What?”

Arradwen stared west.

“He heard me.”

Her brothers were already sitting up.

“Was it him?”

“I think so.”

“What happened?”

“I mentioned his hand.”

Glorfindel opened his eyes.

And understood before anyone else.

“The Silmaril.”

Silence.

Arradwen slowly looked at him.

Of course.

She knew the histories.

Maglor and Maedhros had eventually seized the remaining Silmarils. Their deeds had made them unworthy to possess them, and the jewels burned them.

Arradwen’s stomach sank.

The wound she Saw might not be a recent injury at all.

It might be ancient.

“He’s still hurting.”

Glorfindel looked toward the dying fire.

“Yes.”

“After all this time?”

Nobody answered.

Arradwen’s jaw tightened.

Healer mode.

“Then I definitely want to see the hand.”

Elladan groaned.

Of course that was her conclusion.


Day Six

Something changed after the contact.

Arradwen became quieter.

More focused.

Occasionally she would tilt her head as though listening to something nobody else heard.

But there was no further connection.

The terrain gradually began to carry hints of what waited ahead.

More westbound travelers.

More people connected with Lindon.

Pieces of information about coastal weather.

Arradwen asked every question she could think of.

Nobody knew their Elf.

But an old traveler gave them their first interesting fragment:

Years earlier, someone had heard singing along an isolated part of the shore.

No name.

No reliable description.

Possibly nothing.

Arradwen wrote it down anyway.

Elladan watched.

“That could have been anyone.”

“Yes.”

“You’re recording it.”

“Yes.”

“Why?”

“Because inaccurate possibilities can be discarded later. Forgotten ones can’t be evaluated.”

Elladan looked toward Elrohir.

“She talks like Ada.”

Elrohir shook his head.

“Worse.”


Day Seven

They smelled the sea before they saw it.

Arradwen stopped her stallion.

“What is that?”

Her brothers looked at her.

Then Elladan realized.

“You’ve never seen the sea.”

Arradwen looked offended.

“Obviously I have seen water.”

“That’s not what I said.”

The air tasted different.

Salt.

Cold.

Immense.

Arradwen rode onward.

The land opened.

And there it was.

The sea.

She stopped.

Completely.

The others continued several paces before noticing.

Arradwen stared toward the horizon.

Something deep inside her shifted.

This wasn’t her grandfather’s sea.

Not exactly.

And yet...

Eärendil.

Elwing.

Elrond.

Maglor.

So much of her family’s history ended at the water.

Arradwen had grown up on grasslands.

Open spaces had always meant earth beneath the horizon.

The sea seemed to continue into forever.

Elladan came alongside.

“Well?”

Arradwen considered.

Then:

“I don’t like it.”

Elladan burst out laughing.

Elrohir nearly doubled over.

Glorfindel smiled.

Arradwen frowned.

“What?”

“You’re Eärendil’s granddaughter.”

“I know.”

“And you don’t like the sea.”

“It doesn’t stay still.”

“That is generally how seas operate.”

“It seems suspicious.”

Elladan was helpless now.

Arradwen pointed at him.

“If anything comes out of it, you’re dealing with it.”


Then the Havens appeared.

White structures.

Ships.

Quays.

The western refuge of the Eldar.

Arradwen’s humor faded.

Somewhere beyond it lay thousands upon thousands of miles of coastline.

And somewhere along that coast, perhaps, sat the lonely singer from her vision.

She touched her stallion’s neck.

“We start here.”

Glorfindel nodded.

“With Círdan.”

“And the sailors.”

Elrohir added:

“Fishermen.”

“Travelers.”

Elladan sighed.

“And apparently gulls.”

Arradwen smiled.

“Especially the gulls.”

They rode onward toward the Havens.

For the first time since Arradwen’s foresight began, the search had reached the sea.

Now they only had to find one Elf...

on the entire western coast of Middle-earth.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The Song That Would Not End

Maglor’s perspective, January T.A. 295

Pain had become a measure of time.

Maglor no longer remembered what it was to wake without it.

There had been a time when pain possessed beginnings and endings. A sword cut, then healed. A bone broke, then knitted. Weariness came after battle and departed after sleep.

This had no ending.

The fire had begun when he touched the Silmaril.

One moment of unbearable white radiance.

One moment in which everything his father had desired, everything his brothers had destroyed themselves pursuing, had finally rested in Maglor’s hand.

And the hallowed jewel had rejected him.

Fire.

He had screamed.

He remembered that.

He remembered the Silmaril falling from his ruined hand into the sea.

Afterward, everything blurred.

Days became months.

Months became years.

Years became centuries.

Centuries became Ages.

And still the hand burned.

Not with the clean fire of that first moment anymore.

This was uglier.

Heat buried beneath scarred flesh. Swelling that came and went. Wounds that opened where they should have closed. Fever sometimes rising until sea and sky folded together and he could no longer remember which Age he inhabited.

He had stopped seeking remedies a very long time ago.

There was no point.

Besides...

He deserved it.

That conviction had become almost as constant as the pain itself.

Perhaps more constant.

You deserve this.

When infection sent fire racing along his arm:

You deserve this.

When fever shook him beneath a winter sky:

You deserve this.

When his fingers spasmed and refused to move:

You deserve this.

When he woke screaming from dreams of Alqualondë:

You deserve this.

When children appeared in his dreams...

Elrond.

Elros.

Small.

Frightened.

Trusting him.

That was always worse.


The harp lay beside him.

Maglor refused to look at it.

He had carried instruments across too many centuries.

Repaired them.

Replaced them.

Guarded them from rain and salt.

Music had been the one thing the Oath had not completely taken.

Until his hand finally did.

He had tried again three winters ago.

Or perhaps thirty.

Time had become unreliable.

He had laid the harp across his knees and placed his fingers against the strings.

The first finger obeyed.

The second trembled.

The third curled uselessly toward his palm.

Pain shot through his wrist.

His hand spasmed.

The resulting sound had been hideous.

Maglor had stared at the strings.

Then tried again.

And again.

Until blood ran along his palm.

Finally he had thrown the instrument aside.

Not hard.

Even broken, he couldn’t bring himself to damage it.

He had laughed instead.

There really was something exquisitely appropriate about it.

The greatest singer among the sons of Fëanor, forbidden by his own body from accompanying his songs.

One final joke from fate.

He could still sing.

So he sang.


That night it was the Noldolantë.

What else?

He no longer remembered why he had begun it.

Perhaps the sea had reminded him of ships.

Perhaps the cold had become Tirion beneath starlight.

Perhaps fever had carried him backward again.

The words came automatically.

He had composed them when the memories were painfully new.

Now the lament was older than entire kingdoms.

Yet the grief remained.

Maglor sang of rebellion.

Exile.

Blood spilled by hands that had once held harps and jewels and children’s fingers.

He sang until his throat hurt.

Until his injured hand throbbed against his chest.

Until the boundaries between memory and present dissolved.

For one terrible instant, he was young again.

His father was alive.

Maedhros stood beside him.

All seven brothers remained.

Nothing irrevocable had happened yet.

Then came fire.

Ships burning.

Screams.

Maglor faltered.

“No.”

The shore was empty.

Of course it was empty.

Everything was gone.

All of them were gone.

His father.

His brothers.

Maedhros.

Elros.

And Elrond...

He did not know what had become of Elrond.

He had stopped asking long ago.

Knowing would hurt.

Not knowing hurt too.

Apparently he had chosen the pain whose shape he already understood.

He drew another breath.

And sang.


Then someone answered.

Maglor stopped.

No.

His fever had risen again.

That was all.

Hallucinations weren’t unusual anymore.

Sometimes he heard Maedhros.

Sometimes his father.

Once he had awakened absolutely convinced that Elros was laughing somewhere farther down the shore.

That one had nearly broken him.

So when the unfamiliar presence touched his mind, Maglor ignored it.

Then came music.

Not Quenya.

Sindarin.

A voice he did not know.

Young.

Gentle.

Do not fear the night.

Maglor’s breath caught.

He stopped singing.

The invisible voice continued.

It did not promise that darkness wasn’t real.

That caught his attention.

It did not promise that suffering would disappear.

It did not tell him everything would somehow become well.

Instead it sang of finding one’s way beneath stars.

Of darkness ending.

Of morning remaining beyond the horizon even while unseen.

Maglor stared toward the sea.

“Who are you?”

No answer came aloud.

Of course not.

There was nobody there.

Still the presence remained.

Calm.

Warm.

Infuriatingly compassionate.

Maglor wanted it gone.

He wanted it to continue forever.

Those two desires tore at each other.

You are not alone tonight.

Maglor’s throat closed.

“That is a lie.”

But the presence did not argue.

Then it vanished.


For several minutes Maglor simply listened to the waves.

He almost convinced himself it had never happened.

Almost.

Then something unfamiliar happened.

His shoulders stopped shaking.

He looked down.

His ruined hand was pressed against his chest.

Still burning.

Still swollen.

Still sick.

Nothing had changed.

And yet...

someone had heard him.

That was intolerable.

Maglor stood too quickly.

The world lurched sideways.

He caught himself against the rock.

Pain shot up his arm.

For several seconds there were two seas.

Then three.

He squeezed his eyes shut.

“You deserve this.”

The old words steadied him.

They always did.

Punishment had structure.

Punishment made sense.

Forgiveness did not.


Several nights later the presence returned.

Tentatively.

Are you there?

Maglor recoiled.

The voice.

The singer.

Real?

He remained silent.

You do not have to answer.

That was...

unexpected.

No demand.

No name.

No command to repent.

No invocation of the Valar.

No judgment.

Just presence.

Then:

Someone heard you.

Maglor’s eyes closed.

Don’t.

I’m looking for you.

Terror ripped through him.

No.

His mind slammed shut instinctively.

His breathing accelerated.

Looking.

Somebody was looking.

Why?

After all this time?

Had Mandos finally grown impatient?

Had someone come to drag a Kinslayer before judgment?

He pushed himself upright.

He needed to move.

South.

North.

Anywhere.

But pain turned his first step into a stumble.

He collapsed onto one knee.

“Leave me alone.”

He did not know whether he spoke aloud or through thought.

Perhaps both.

The presence withdrew immediately.

No pursuit.

No pressure.

That frightened him more.


The next contact came while he was half asleep.

Or unconscious.

The distinction had become academic.

I’m the person who sang to you.

Maglor opened his eyes.

Stars.

Cold.

His harp beside him.

The sea.

I am a healer.

Everything inside him froze.

No.

Absolutely not.

His hand curled instinctively against his body.

Why would a healer seek him?

Healers helped the innocent.

Children.

Warriors wounded protecting others.

People struck by misfortune.

Not creatures who had made vows and broken worlds.

Then came the words he could not bear.

Your hand is hurt.

Maglor slammed every barrier he possessed into place.

The contact vanished.

He lay gasping.

His hand pulsed.

He could almost smell the Silmaril again.

White fire.

The jewel in his palm.

Agony.

The sea swallowing its light.

Maedhros walking toward fire.

“No.”

He crawled toward the water.

Salt touched his fingers.

Pain tore through him.

Good.

Pain was simple.

Pain expected nothing.


But the stranger’s voice remained in his memory.

A healer.

Ridiculous.

No healer could undo this.

No healer should.

He held the wounded hand beneath the freezing water until his arm went numb.

Eventually he dragged himself back onto the shore.

His gaze landed upon the harp.

For some reason he reached for it.

His good hand lifted it.

His injured hand followed more slowly.

One finger touched a string.

A single note rang into the night.

Maglor flinched.

Again.

Another note.

The third attempt sent agony through his palm.

He stopped.

Tears burned his eyes.

Long ago, two children had demanded songs before sleeping.

Elros had always asked first.

Elrond had pretended he was too old to need lullabies considerably earlier than he actually was.

Maglor smiled despite himself.

“Elrond.”

He wondered if the boy had lived.

Of course he wasn’t a boy anymore.

If he had survived...

Maglor tried calculating.

The numbers slipped away from him.

Thousands.

Surely thousands.

He laughed softly.

“You would scold me.”

That image unexpectedly became vivid.

Elrond, solemn little face glaring at the wound.

You should have told someone.

“I know.”

His smile disappeared.

“I couldn’t.”

Because if Elrond had remembered him kindly...

Maglor couldn’t have borne seeing what that kindness became when confronted with the truth.

Better for the child to grow.

Better to disappear.

Better to let Elrond think whatever helped him survive.

That was what Maglor had told himself.

He had been telling himself many things for three Ages.


Then, one night, there came another whisper across ósanwë.

We are coming.

Maglor’s eyes flew open.

His entire body went rigid.

We.

Not one.

Others.

He struggled upright.

The harp fell onto the sand.

No.

No, no.

He had to move.

His legs refused.

Fever rolled through him.

He reached blindly for the rock.

Then, almost comically, the distant mind added:

To help.

Maglor stared into darkness.

For several seconds nothing happened.

Then a laugh escaped him.

Small.

Broken.

Unbelieving.

He couldn’t remember the last time he had laughed.

“Whoever you are,” he whispered, “you are very strange.”

The waves answered.

He drew his knees toward his chest.

Held his ruined hand against himself.

And waited for the old certainty.

You deserve this.

It came.

But for the first time in longer than he could remember...

another voice followed it.

Gentle.

Young.

Stubborn.

Hope has not left you.

Maglor shut his eyes.

“No.”

But the strange healer’s words remained.

Morning came slowly over the sea.

And for the first time in three Ages, Maglor found himself watching the eastern horizon.

Waiting for the sun.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The Grey Havens

January, T.A. 295

Arradwen had decided that Mithlond smelled predominantly of salt, tar and fish.

Elladan had laughed when she informed him.

“You say that like you’re disappointed.”

“I expected something more poetic.”

“You’re at the Grey Havens.”

“Yes.”

“Home of Círdan the Shipwright.”

“I know.”

“Haven of the Eldar.”

“I know.”

“Last great harbor of the Elves.”

“Yes, Ell.”

“And you have reduced it to fish.”

Arradwen looked toward a gull that was currently fighting another gull over something unspeakable.

“Yes.”

Elrohir pointed toward the birds.

“They’re your responsibility.”

“Why?”

“You wanted to interview gulls.”

Arradwen glared.


Círdan received them before sunset.

Arradwen had heard stories about him all her life.

She had expected ancient.

She had not quite understood what ancient meant until she was standing before one of the eldest Elves remaining in Middle-earth.

Círdan’s attention passed over the travelers.

Glorfindel.

The twins.

Four guards.

Finally Arradwen.

His gaze paused.

“You are Elrond’s youngest.”

Arradwen inclined her head.

“I am.”

“And Eärendil’s granddaughter.”

There it was again.

Arradwen had spent fifty years being introduced principally as herself.

Apparently returning to Elven society meant repeatedly becoming somebody’s descendant.

“Yes.”

Círdan’s eyes lowered toward the healer’s satchel.

“But you have not come to speak of your grandfather.”

“No.”

She met his gaze.

“I think I Saw Maglor.”

Silence.

Not confusion.

Not surprise.

Recognition.

Glorfindel noticed too.

“You know.”

Círdan looked toward the sea.

“I know that he lives.”

Arradwen’s breath caught.

The twins exchanged a glance.

“Where?” asked Elladan.

Círdan shook his head.

“If I possessed an answer precise enough to satisfy that question, he would not have remained hidden for so long.”

Arradwen leaned forward.

“But you’ve seen him?”

A pause.

“Not recently.”

“How recently?”

Círdan’s expression suggested that recently was a somewhat flexible concept for someone his age.

Arradwen suppressed the urge to demand calendar years.

Barely.


What the Mariners Know

They moved to a chamber overlooking the harbor.

Maps covered one table.

Arradwen immediately went to them.

Círdan watched with faint interest.

“You are accustomed to fieldwork.”

“Fifty years among the Éothéod.”

“That explains the horse.”

Elladan coughed.

Arradwen ignored him.

“Tell me everything.”

Círdan raised an eyebrow.

“Everything?”

“Everything that might help me distinguish him from another traveler.”

That answer seemed to please the Shipwright.

He approached the map.

“There have been stories.”

Arradwen’s attention sharpened.

“What stories?”

“A lone singer.”

Her pulse jumped.

“Where?”

“Many places.”

That was profoundly unhelpful.

Círdan continued.

“Fishermen have spoken, from time to time, of hearing an Elven voice along empty stretches of coast.”

“Have they seen him?”

“Rarely.”

“Why?”

“He withdraws.”

Arradwen’s mind returned instantly to the reaction she had felt through ósanwë.

Fear.

I’m looking for you.

Terror.

That suddenly made much more sense.

“He doesn’t want anyone approaching.”

“No.”

“Does he threaten them?”

“No.”

That mattered.

“Attack?”

“No.”

“Steal?”

“No.”

“Ask for food?”

“Rarely, by the accounts that have reached these Havens.”

Arradwen frowned.

“Then how does he survive?”

Círdan looked at her.

“That is one of the questions we have asked for a very long time.”


Glimpses

Círdan’s finger moved along the coast.

“Sometimes footprints have been found near places where singing was reported.”

“Bare?”

“Sometimes.”

Arradwen’s healer expression appeared immediately.

Elladan recognized it.

“No.”

She looked at him.

“I didn’t say anything.”

“You made the face.”

“What face?”

“The medical outrage face.”

“He walks barefoot in winter!”

“We don’t know that.”

Arradwen pointed at Círdan.

“He just said barefoot prints have been found.”

“Sometimes.”

“That’s worse!”

Círdan watched this exchange.

Then looked at Glorfindel.

“Is she always thus?”

“Yes.”

“I see.”

“She’s actually being restrained.”

“I heard that.”


Círdan continued.

“Food sometimes disappeared from stores maintained for travelers.”

Arradwen relaxed fractionally.

Good.

So Maglor wasn’t necessarily starving.

“Blankets?”

“Occasionally.”

“Medicine?”

Círdan paused.

“No.”

Arradwen’s eyebrows knitted.

“Never?”

“Not to my knowledge.”

That bothered her.

A lot.

“Three thousand years with an untreated wound.”

Glorfindel corrected gently:

“We don’t actually know it has remained continuously infected.”

Arradwen looked at him.

“I felt him.”

Nothing more needed saying.

She remembered the feverish confusion touching her thoughts.

The pain.

The exhaustion.

“He is sick now.”


“Why Didn’t Anyone Help Him?”

Eventually the question came.

Arradwen didn’t mean for it to sound accusatory.

It did anyway.

“If people knew he was here, why has nobody helped him?”

Círdan did not take offense.

“Because help cannot easily be given to someone determined not to receive it.”

That silence was harder.

Arradwen’s gaze lowered.

Exactly.

She knew patients like that.

Not three-thousand-year versions, admittedly.

But she knew the principle.

“You tried?”

“Yes.”

“And?”

“He left.”

“Again?”

“Yes.”

“How many times?”

Círdan regarded the sea.

“Enough.”

Arradwen sighed.

So no dramatic rescue.

No simply finding Maglor, grabbing his hand and fixing everything.

They first had to convince him not to flee.

Possibly literally.

Lovely.


What Círdan Understands

“He believes himself beyond mercy.”

Arradwen looked up.

There.

That was important.

Not location.

Not tracks.

Motivation.

“Because of the Kinslayings.”

“Among other things.”

“The Oath.”

“Yes.”

“The Silmaril.”

Círdan’s expression became grave.

“Yes.”

Arradwen touched her own hand unconsciously.

“The hand I Saw.”

Nobody answered.

She didn’t need an answer.

Her mind rearranged the problem.

She had assumed she was dealing with:

wound → pain → isolation.

Perhaps it was instead:

guilt → refusal of care → untreated wound → pain → further guilt → deeper isolation.

A self-reinforcing cycle thousands of years old.

That was much worse.

And perversely, more treatable.

Not easily.

Certainly not quickly.

But understandable.


Arradwen asked:

“Does he think the pain is punishment?”

Círdan’s eyes settled upon her.

“What makes you ask?”

“The instant I identified myself as a healer, he became uneasy.”

She remembered.

“But when I mentioned his hand specifically, he shut me out completely.”

Glorfindel’s expression darkened.

Círdan was quiet for a long time.

Then:

“I believe you may be correct.”

Arradwen’s jaw tightened.

Three thousand years.

Not merely Nobody helped.

Perhaps:

He wouldn’t allow anyone to help because getting better felt morally forbidden.

As a healer, that made her want to scream.


Then Círdan Gives Her the Useful Clue

“There is one thing.”

Everyone looked at him.

Círdan leaned over the map.

“Reports of the singer have never been evenly scattered.”

Arradwen immediately moved closer.

“Show me.”

And suddenly the mission changed.

Not legend.

Tracking.

Círdan indicated several areas.

Arradwen studied them.

“The more inhabited shorelines have fewer reports.”

“Yes.”

“Remote ones more.”

“Yes.”

“And he moves.”

“Constantly.”

Elrohir leaned over her shoulder.

“To avoid being followed?”

“Possibly.”

Arradwen considered her vision.

Beach.

Dark rock.

No ships.

No buildings.

No smoke.

No other voices.

She looked toward Círdan.

“Do any of these areas have narrow strands with exposed dark stone immediately behind them?”

A very slight change crossed the ancient Elf’s face.

He pointed.

“There.”

Arradwen’s pulse accelerated.

“Recent reports?”

“Recent enough to warrant beginning there.”

Not proof.

But finally...

a direction.


One Last Warning

Círdan folded the map.

“If you find him, do not approach him as though you have come to capture him.”

“I won’t.”

“Do not speak first of forgiveness.”

That surprised Arradwen.

“Why?”

“Because he may hear it as judgment.”

Oh.

That was good advice.

Very good advice.

“What should I say?”

Círdan considered.

Then smiled faintly.

“You are the healer.”

Arradwen exhaled.

Fair.

She picked up her medical satchel.

“I’ll start with his name.”

Glorfindel shook his head.

“No.”

She stopped.

“Why?”

“He doesn’t know how you know it.”

Right.

Fear again.

Arradwen revised.

“Then I’ll start with mine.”

Círdan nodded.

Better.

“And if he runs?” asked Elladan.

Arradwen answered immediately.

“We don’t chase.”

Her brothers looked at her.

“We stop.”

She remembered approaching terrified horses on the plains.

“You don’t prove you’re safe by pursuing someone who is afraid of you.”

Elrohir smiled faintly.

“And then?”

“We let him choose whether to come closer.”

Elladan looked skeptical.

“That could take days.”

“Yes.”

“Weeks.”

“Yes.”

“Months.”

“If necessary.”

Arradwen picked up the map.

“I spent fifty years learning to wait for frightened creatures to trust me.”

She looked toward the western sea.

“I can wait for one Elf.”

Círdan’s gaze lingered on Elrond’s youngest daughter.

The child of the House that Maglor himself had once helped preserve.

There was something almost unbearably cyclical about it.

Once, Maglor had taken in a terrified child who had lost his home.

Three Ages later, that child’s daughter had crossed Middle-earth carrying medicines because the frightened person beside the sea...

was Maglor.

And this time, perhaps, someone would finally refuse to leave him there.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Two Seconds Later

Arradwen had barely folded the map.

“We’ll begin with that stretch of coastline. If the reports remain consistent, we can establish a search pat—”

A gull cried outside.

Arradwen stopped.

No one noticed at first.

Círdan did.

The ancient Shipwright’s head turned.

Another gull.

The sound cut through Arradwen like a blade.

Her hand loosened.

The map slipped from her fingers.

Elrohir caught it before it struck the floor.

“Arradwen?”

She couldn’t answer.

Because something had opened inside her.


West.

It wasn’t a thought.

Thoughts could be reasoned with.

This was deeper.

Older.

West.

Arradwen stared through the window.

Beyond the harbor lay the Sea.

Beyond the Sea...

Light.

Home.

Not Imladris.

Something older than any home she consciously remembered.

Her breath caught.

For fifty years she had wandered freely across plains and mountains without ever feeling that anywhere other than Middle-earth was where she belonged.

Now suddenly the horizon seemed unbearable.

There was something beyond it.

Something beautiful.

Something waiting.

Her feet moved.

One step.

Then another.

Elladan frowned.

“Arradwen?”

She didn’t hear him properly.

She reached the doorway.

The smell of salt became stronger.

A gull wheeled overhead.

West.

Her pulse hammered.

And then the longing found the one weapon against which she had absolutely no defense.


Grandfather.

Arradwen froze.

Eärendil.

She had never met him.

But she had grown up with him everywhere.

In Elrond’s stories.

In Glorfindel’s unfinished sentences.

In the moments when her father looked at her face and momentarily saw someone else.

Please don’t run off on me, darling.

She finally understood that thought differently.

Arradwen stared across the water.

If she sailed...

Her grandfather was there.

Eärendil.

The lonely mariner.

The father who had left two little boys behind because somebody had to ask the Powers to save what remained of Middle-earth.

The man Elrond had spent thousands of years missing.

Her grandfather.

I could meet him.

Her heart lurched.

Not someday vaguely.

Not through stories.

Him.

She could hear his voice.

Ask what Elrond had been like as a baby.

Tell him what his son had become.

And if Eärendil was still bound to his celestial voyage in your AU, Arradwen’s imagination immediately supplied the most dangerous thought of all.

He must be lonely.

The healer in her answered.

Then go to him.


She took another step.

Círdan moved.

Not toward her.

Across the doorway.

Not blocking it exactly.

Simply making himself impossible to ignore.

“Arradwen.”

Nothing.

“Child.”

That pierced slightly deeper.

Her eyes focused.

But only slightly.

“I could see my grandfather.”

Círdan’s expression changed.

Ah.

Now he understood exactly how hard the Sea had struck her.

“Yes.”

Her voice became tiny.

“He’s alone.”

Glorfindel closed his eyes.

Of everything the sea-longing could have used...

Of course it had found Eärendil.


Then Arradwen Started Walking Again

Elladan caught her hand.

She pulled away.

Not violently.

Instinctively.

“I need to go.”

Elladan’s stomach dropped.

“Go where?”

She looked at him as though the answer were obvious.

“West.”

Elrohir went pale.

“Now?”

“Yes.”

“Arradwen, we just arrived.”

That meant nothing.

The longing had no interest in calendars.

Or missions.

Or prudence.

There was only the endless horizon.

“Grandfather is there.”

Arradwen took another breath.

“I can go to him.”

She sounded increasingly certain.

“I can tell him Ada is safe.”

Glorfindel’s face crumpled for half a heartbeat.

“I can keep him company.”

There.

That was Arradwen’s weakness.

Not paradise.

Not immortality.

Not golden shores.

Not the Blessed Realm itself.

Someone was lonely.

Therefore Arradwen felt responsible.


Círdan spoke very gently.

“And what of the Elf you came here to find?”

Arradwen stopped.

The Sea pulled.

Hard.

Grandfather.

Then memory answered.

Black hair.

An injured hand.

Fever.

A lonely beach.

A broken song.

Maglor.

Arradwen’s eyes squeezed shut.

Her breathing turned ragged.

The healer on one shore.

The grandfather beyond the other.

For one agonizing instant she wanted both.

Then:

“Ada.”

Elladan’s grip tightened.

Arradwen whispered it again.

“Ada.”

Elrond waiting in the courtyard.

Elrond standing outside his door this time.

Come home.

I will.

Arradwen grabbed the edge of the table.

“No.”

It came out barely audibly.

The Sea whispered west.

Arradwen shook her head.

“No.”

Her fingernails dug into the wood.

“I said I would come home.”

The gulls cried again.

Arradwen nearly folded.

Elrohir moved toward her.

Círdan stopped him with one hand.

“No.”

He understood.

This was a choice she had to make herself.

Arradwen gasped.

Then did something very Éothéod.

She stopped thinking about forever.

Forever was too big.

She reduced the problem.

One decision.

One task.

One patient.

She said aloud:

“Maglor first.”

The Sea pulled.

“Find him.”

Another breath.

“Treat the infection.”

Another.

“Get him somewhere safe.”

Another.

“Go home.”

Her grip loosened slightly.

“See Ada.”

Another breath.

The room came back into focus.

“Then decide anything else.”

Círdan’s mouth curved.

Very faintly.

That was excellent healer logic.

Stabilize first. Major decisions later.


Arradwen Comes Back

She stumbled backward.

Elladan caught her.

This time she let him.

Her forehead hit his shoulder.

“What,” she gasped, “was that?”

Nobody laughed.

Círdan answered.

“The Sea.”

Arradwen glared weakly at the harbor as though Belegaer had deliberately attacked her.

“I dislike it even more now.”

That broke Elrohir.

A startled laugh escaped him.

Even Glorfindel smiled.

Arradwen remained against Elladan.

“I almost left.”

“Yes.”

“I was actually going to get on a ship.”

“Yes.”

“I don’t know how to sail.”

Elladan kissed the top of her head.

“We noticed.”

She groaned.


Then Arradwen looked back toward the horizon.

The longing hadn’t disappeared.

That was the frightening realization.

She had simply learned that she could choose despite it.

The sea-longing was described as persistent or “unquietable” once awakened, rather than merely a momentary fascination.

Her expression softened.

“Someday.”

Círdan heard.

Perhaps someday she would sail.

When her work in Middle-earth was done.

When Elrond was ready.

When Arradwen herself was ready.

And on the other side...

Eärendil.

Grandfather.

Her eyes stung.

“Someday,” she repeated.

Then she picked up her medicinal satchel.

“But not today.”

Her healer’s focus returned.

She looked at the map.

“Today we find Maglor.”

Círdan watched Eärendil’s granddaughter turn her back upon the harbor voluntarily.

And perhaps that was the moment he understood her.

The Sea had offered Arradwen something she desperately wanted.

She had answered:

Someone else needs me first.

Very much Elrond’s daughter.

Very much Eärendil’s granddaughter.

And entirely herself.


Let Catherine know what you thought about this chapter!

Further Recommendations

The Alpha and His Rogue

Mia: Loved to see Colton get a second chance mate

Read Now
The Alpha's Exiled Mate (ON HOLD)

Catherineb83: Story good just would have liked her not to wear a mask

Read Now
Bear Shifter Secrets

tatianne Ingrid: Adorei cada capitulo! parabens

Read Now
THE ALPHA WHO REFUSED TO APOLOGIZE

PansyPotter: I liked that the main female character is written to be a strong and intelligent woman

Read Now
His Forsaken Fate

Marene80: I liked the suspense of not knowing when Zachary and Amara were finally going to get together.

Read Now
Bound to the Bear

Mira: Just waw loved every part of tu

Read Now
The Orc's Pet

Glenda Holmes: Good read!

Read Now
The Cursed Alpha's Fifth Luna

karen cridland: Good character construction and fluid writing style.

Read Now
The Luna He Threw Away

Danielle_Anderson: Garian’s folded arms and the anger he does not bother to hide from Tria caught my attention more than the rejection itself. He stands near the platform steps like a man watching a preventable disaster, and his insistence that the council has not agreed to exile suggests Delvan’s decree is not as abs...

Read Now