tangledup

@tangledup

Overall Rating
Plot
Writing Style
Grammar & Punctuation

Long-time fan!!

I first read this on Wattpad around 2015-2016. I was still in middle school at the time and I cannot tell you how many times I came back to it to reread over and over. Clearly that much hasn’t changed since I’m back here again lol I remember the old disclaimer at the top, saying to give it some grace; you came up with the initial idea in elementary school, so your names were uncreative. I never thought that though, it was the most clever thing I had the pleasure of reading to little middle school me. I know now that the elemental powers was a pretty common trope, but the first time I’d ever seen it was in your book, so it was totally novel and fascinating!! You were so cool! And I remember you saying that, at the time of writing, you didn’t think to include any diversity in characters or viewpoints (again, you were young and writing from your own perspective lol I don’t fault you for that) and that was the first time I ever even considered diversity in the stories I read. I am not white, but I was so used to never reading about people that looked like me I didn’t realize there was another option, so that was a fun awakening for me too lol. Rereading this again in college was so incredibly nostalgic and I am so happy its still up!! I genuinely still think about it 10 years after reading because it impacted me so much. It feels a bit like you were growing up with me, both when I was reading as it actively updated, and now, looking at it as an adult. Its such a treat to watch your writing shift as you gained perspective and grew. Looking at it now, its pretty clear. (SLIGHT SPOILERS!!) Like the change from the girls Tide was jealous of in Hawaii being called ‘Barbie clones’ to a genuine fleshing out of Kenna as a character beyond a jealousy plot point. It really stood out to me. I mean, it could just be because you were writing it from a jealous teenager’s perspective, but to me it felt like I was learning too, you know? Your characters are so charming and you can see your dialogue and writing improve sooo much since Elemental. The character dynamics and relationships are super fun, and I love that in the sequel, the side characters get a little more individual attention. You’ve got a pretty big cast, but I really enjoyed every single one of their POVs and scenes! I loved getting that insight into their character and what they thought of the rest of the cast, the relationships, and whatever mortal danger they most recently found themselves in. It was fun watching things to get more and more complex, like Coal’s relationships with the newer characters introduced, Kaelum and like everything he’s got going on, Jensen’s deeper thoughts, Tide’s stubbornness addressed as more than just a cute personality trait, etc. I also love, love, love Steel and Owen! I am so glad we got to see a lot more of them here. Also your chapter titles crack me up so bad, that still hasn’t changed. I hope you’re still writing. This really seemed like a passion project for you, and you and other authors I’ve read have really inspired me to pick up writing too!! Not really to publish, but just for my own enjoyment. I really hope you are doing well now, and thank you so much for writing this and keeping it up. I will definitely be back to reread!

Read the story now