ALittleRacoon

Great First Novel!

Although this story was generally short, the plot was very straightforward and the brotherhood between the Monarchs was done really well. I especially liked the character of Hector and how he reached for the goal despite his agonizing injuries with the sole thought of helping his comrades. Although there are some parts that can be done better showing than telling, overall, this is a great story, and I look forward to reading the next two. Again, great job on the storytelling!

A horrifyingly beautiful piece of art

Although I was quite confused by the plot of the story, the detailed descriptions make it seem as if I was in that "world", if it can be called one. The style is flowing, feels fast yet relaxing, pushing you onward but only with small nudges, just like the uncertainty that is presented in the story. It feels poetic. An amazing piece of art all in all.

Interesting Start

Although at the point of this review, this story only has five chapters, it's already more than enough to get the characters fleshed out. The mature Alys, reckless Audric, envious Cecily, and the smart Abby, all four siblings, with at least a chapter from their perspective, feels quite realistic and down-to-earth.

Now of course a review needs some nitpicking, and I do have some. I feel the interactions between Audric and Edith (the girl he meets) was a little exaggerated, although given the time period of a few months, it's not over-the-top. The inconsistent spacing was also a minor problem, but I think it has to do with Inkitt's bugs, as I've had that problem myself. I would suggest using the preview function to check the spacing, and if it's off, add an extra space between.

Overall a humorous, fun start, although I'll be expecting some more serious plot development later. Great job!

A combination of clichés... into something entirely new

The stereotypical depiction of death: a frightening, disgusting, hooded creature. Quite similar to the depiction in the story. The depiction of an angel: a beautiful humanoid being with wings. Just like the story (at least how I imagine it). A story about a girl meeting a guy and gradually falling for him... the entire story should've been a dumpster fire of clichés... right?

No. The story, although SHOULD be riddled with clichés, is not, thanks to the internal conflict and the first-person POV that the author presents. When we see the mind of the protagonist (quite vividly as well), we sympathize with her and try to cheer her on. The fact that she was "forced" to be a Grim Reaper of sorts while still retaining her human consciousness is also very refreshing. The character of Mochta is also very well-written, being kind of like the "ray of hope" for Shina. The plot at first was a bit confusing (since it's from first-person), but it slowly was woven into something very intricate and beautiful, raising many questions after every chapter.

Altogether, I look forward to each new chapter, and the surprisingly amazing combination of what should've been clichés.

Simply...

Amazing. The kind of subtle yet detailed artistic expression of just a few colors is really masterful and awesome. Black, White, and Red is a beautiful poetry collection that one should read in their free time. In fact, it can be used in English classes in its use of various literary elements. Just wow.

Great Beginning!

Even though this is a fairly new story with only one chapter so far, I feel there is already a sense of building up in it. The story overall in the first chapter was interesting as to set the pace and place for the readers to pick up. It was really easy to grasp the pace, and it's actually kinda chilling to think of a mini-purge by a killer.

For improvements/ideas, I think a stronger focus on horror would be nice since it so far surrounds the main character trying to avenge his friend. Maybe a plot twist? The Grim Reaper's identity? Cliffhanger end?

Very, very good beginning. Looking forward to the updates!

Review on the exposition

When I first read the teaser, I was immediately hooked since I'm a HUGE WWII fan and found the first chapter quite interesting. However, some parts were a bit too short, and I wonder if it could go a bit longer.