CalvinPeat

Really good writing, and a great character

Steampunk protagonist!

Nina is a great character.

This is really good writing. It keeps you engaged, and there's foreshadowing that you only understand once you've read the whole thing. I didn't see the twist coming at all, but as contrived as it could have been, I think it actually really works.

A few tiny things:

You might want to mention in the summary that there are spoilers for Serenity, just in case people haven't seen it yet.

At the beginning, “new pilot” should be “a new pilot”. And then you could do with a blank line between that paragraph and the next, as with the rest of the script.

In the paragraph before the first page break, there are several dashes. These should really have a space either side, to make it easier to read.

At the end, I don't feel like Mal would put his head in his hands. The rest of the description of Mal there probably works, though.

The name Nina initially made me think of an existing Firefly character, Inara's friend (who's actually called Nandi). My instinctive thought was that the story was about her being the new pilot, which didn't obviously seem like it would work. Also, the summary could do without the cryptic introduction. Just cut out “It's a while before she arrives on Serenity. Or:” from the summary. Thankfully, I read the story anyway, and was pleasantly surprised.

In the summary, it's not “the Serenity”, it's just “Serenity”. An easy mistake to make, but Inara actually makes the point in one of the episodes. :)

A great story, very well written. Congratulations.

Great action writing

This is great action writing. It really captures the pace and intensity of the characters' work.

The ending also is very good, making clever use of the phrase “easy as falling”, calling back to its use in the chapter title and the summary.

The dialogue and character interactions could use some work in order not to be overshadowed by Firefly's terrific writing in this regard. Firefly's dialogue is quite stylised, and this story's dialogue seems, well, relatively prosaic in comparison, though some lines (like “Breaking atmo' in three.”) are better than others. That kind of stylisation is difficult to do, so don't feel bad about it.

Lines like “Do the job, maybe I will trust you more.” and “Suit up Val, this will be the real test to see if you are worth the cash and worthy of being my ship's second in command.” seem a little on-the-nose (stating things too obviously). Perhaps you could rewrite these lines, or even get these ideas across more subtly somewhere else in the story, in order to improve it.

In terms of punctuation, there are some places where additional commas should be used. For instance, “Are you building your own little circus Captain?” should be “Are you building your own little circus, Captain?” (Incidentally, this line is a better example of implying things without being too obvious. It hints that the Captain might be planning for a bigger job sometime down the line, without actually saying it as such.)

You're a talented action writer. If you focus on bringing the other elements of your writing up to the same standard, you'll become an even better and more well-rounded writer. (Perhaps you could study Firefly and other great stories, to gain an even deeper understanding of how they do these things.) Keep writing!

Great concept

This is a great concept, and you've done a largely excellent job of capturing the voice of Mal.

You convey Mal's inner struggle well. Perhaps, though, you could reflect the hope in verses 13-17 of Psalm 90 a bit more. A suggestion: in the current version, Mal seems to be losing hope in the idea of salvation; but maybe instead, his understanding of that word could move from his desire to win the war (which didn't happen) to something more intangible, and perhaps spiritual. Maybe he could ask for forgiveness, and/or decide that he doesn't want God to be mad at him.

I really like the last line, though. It's poetic, and very in keeping with the tone and dialogue of Firefly. “Keep 'em flyin'.”

Just a quick grammatical thing; you've got lots of apostrophes in their right places, but there are a few you might have missed. For instance, a few times it says “aint” when it should be “ain't”, and there are few other words that need apostrophes (e.g. in verse 11, “dont” should be “don't”). Generally, if you do a proofread right at the end of the process of writing a draft of a story, and/or get someone else to proofread it, then you should be able to catch little things like this.

Hope that helps. It might be difficult to rewrite, but as good as it is now, there's even more potential there.