
Classic love story
I loved the story overall. A couple of things the author could tidy up, e.g. the timeline of Steelclaw events before Link and Lyra meet is inconsistent - sometimes it seems that Link has been Gamma for years, other times that he's only just been appointed. However, in general it is very good. My only proper disappointment is that it's not really a werewolf story: the characters never shift in the whole book and just make passing references to their wolves; it might as well be a story set in a fantasy human culture. On a smaller note, there were matters such as why their societies were so uncritically patriarchal - the main female character was willing to defy expectations, but didn't even consider that she didn't have to be the one to give up her home and family. However, all of that is more just pointers that the author could possibly re-examine before publication, it didn't detract from a very sweet and enjoyable romance. It was well written and a light, easy read.
Read the story nowNice read, different world-building with a classic love story
Nice book: good plot & characters, relatively fast-paced. Diálogos a little clunky (especially since no one uses contractions, which sounds unnatural) and repetitive, but otherwise an excellent story. Generally suitable for different ages (not much sex, and very tame; no profanity; no problematic themes).
Read the story nowSweet story, but unresolved
The author's technical skills are good, so for once I found it an easy read without having to struggle through poor grammar and punctuation (which is too often the case with other books on this platform). In terms of the story itself, it was a sweet, relatively predictable, love story. I would say it was aimed at a tween/young teen audience rather than adults. As an adult reading it, there were a few plot holes and inconsistent character development. Like a big part I didn't understand where the female lead had an encounter with a creature who appeared able to hypnotise/enter her psyche/alter her thoughts, but then this came to nothing and the subsequent events were apparently just her acting alone. The huge problem I have with it is that the ending is just a picture of domestic felicity where everything is ok because the female lead has learned to sew well enough to make coverings to keep them warm, and this is apparently supposed to be a happy ending. However, the whole premise of the book is that they are living under an evil system where people are kidnapped and enslaved (including with physical violence and the threat of sexual coercion), but they do absolutely nothing to even acknowledge this let alone fight it, and so the lead characters walk away whilst leaving others to continue to suffer. But it's alright because they have their own tent, so nothing else matters. Overall, if you want a vanilla man and woman fall in love easy read, then this book is fun enough entertainment. Just don't overthink it!
Read the story nowA great plot but badly written
I really love the plot and the ideas behind the characters, but unfortunately the reading experience is marred by a very choppy writing style: the writer switches between past and present tenses (sometimes multiple times a sentence), mixes up third-person and first-person narratives, and there's typos and missing punctuation which make it hard to tell whose POV you're getting and whether they're speaking or thinking. The characters themselves are not hugely developped, but enough for a fun, light, read. A major plot point is that the female lead has experienced severe sexual, physical, and mental abuse, and yet the only mention of how this has affected her is that she had several months of therapy before the story begins (it's not clear how or where given her age, the timescales, and other background details); she then goes straight into a healthy sexual relationship and friendships with no trauma or any other mention of it except as a plot device. I know this is a fantasy book with some degree of escapism to be expected, but it feels frankly disrespectful to women who have suffered abuse to imply that they should just bounce back and get on with life if only they have some therapy. It's kind of a werewolf-lite story in that the characters are techincally wolves (and the eponymous heroine is, of course, part pixie), but this plays very little part in their day-to-day lives. Apart from the existence of mates, they might as well be humans. In fact, them being humans would explain some inconsistencies like how wolves from different packs in completely different areas go to primary school together. Overall, I am going to persevere with it and finish it because I do enjoy the plot, but I'll be wary of trying this author again because it's not well executed.
Read the story nowA pleasant read
It was a decent story. Some plot holes (like what happened to Marissa?) and inconsistencies, and some bits that sounded like they had been stitched together in the wrong place to repeat earlier plot points. But overall it was a nice read. The one sex scene was a bit disappointing (she deserved so much more on her first time!), but it did mean that the overall book is suitable for an older teen audience as there's nothing else very troubling in terms of violence or adult themes. I wouldn't give it any prizes, but it was an enjoyable enough story overall to make me want to keep coming back and finish it.
Read the story nowNice idea, poorly executed
It's a decent overview for a story (although some of the plot details are not properly explained; the overall story arc is fine), but hampered by being hugely descriptive to the point of lengthy repetitions all over the place. It's described by the author as a slow burn, but it's actually not - the main couple get together fairly quickly and smoothly (compared to the length of the overall book), but what makes it long is just very detailed descriptions of everything, without the plot moving forward. Also, maybe a minor point, but yet another story where a young woman abandons her education and settles down to raise a family (even if it is as a queen). She could at least have returned to graduate from university! I persevered with it to the end because it was readable, and there were no technical problems, but it was a chore.
Read the story nowNice romance
There were some minor plot holes, and some confusing parts (how and when was the abduction planned?; why couldn't they just scent-track her to the other pack to prove where she'd gone?; why were they so impressed that a prisoner flooded her cell? It's the kind of thing regular human prisoners do to protest every day; what did Luca use to kill?; why does she fight in her human form, with a sword, when she'd be so much stronger as a wolf?) and the whole premise at the beginning isn't clear - it isn't spelled out what happened to her mother before she was mated, and what disaster is supposed to befall her if she isn't engaged/mated by the time her heat should hit at the initial ball, except that males will be sexually interested in her and her true mate will be revealed. The other thing is that they barely seemed to be werewolves at all. They were pretty much humans with a hierarchical society, who revere the moon and howl a bit. They only once shifted, and even that was only the two main characters for a few minutes. Their wolves don't have names or personalities or any of the other usual features of a shifter story. I feel like this story would have worked better as a human fantasy set in the past if there was going to be so little use made of the wolf element. Having said that, it was quite an enjoyable story and an easy read. The only thing stylistically annoying was the frequent use of short (2 - 7 word) paragraphs to make a point that would have been better made in normal text. It was fine in terms of grammar and vocabulary, and the overall flow of the plot and characters if you overlook the minor points as above. It wasn't shockingly spicy. There were sex scenes, but nothing kinky or very frequent (beyond the early chapters). It would be 18+ for sure, but I don't think it needed the initial chilli pepper rating.
Read the story nowNot my cup of tea
I do love this author's fantasy works, but this didn't live up to them, in my opinion. There wasn't enough going on to make it interesting, just a constant repetition of drama from his ex, drama from her ex & family but of the same sort and quickly resolved, just to come back and rehash it all again. Also, there were little niggles such as several of the women characters being really young to be marrying & having children (19, 23), why not just let them enjoy their youth?! I know that might feel like nit-picking, but the characters' immaturity was a major impediment to them just getting on with a healthy relationship. The profanity is given a content warning at the beginning. It doesn't offend me, but it doesn't seem to add anything either, it just seems to be there every second sentence or so (sometimes several times a sentence) for the sake of it; and because it's basically only two words, and variants of them, it gets tired pretty quickly. It is still good in terms of grammar, vocabulary etc., but I just felt that the plot was way to light to sustain more than a few pages, and the characters weren't developped enough to overcome that deficiency.
Read the story nowGreat plot, but too rushed
I love the plot line and the characters, and I have read a good few of this author's works on here and really like her style. Grammar and techincal points are good, dialogue decent etc. The one big negative for me is that it is way too short for the amount of plot: there are stories which lend themselves to being short stories, and stories that need a proper novel-length exploration. This is definitely one of the latter. There were no plot holes, but there were loads of points and characters that just weren't developped enough. It's way too short for what it is, so the whole thing feels really rushed.
Read the story nowVery sweet story, but unfinished
It's a lovely story so far. Very sweet and innocent, a nice clean romance (one sex scene) with beautiful descriptive passages. However, beware that it is unfinished and hasn't been updated in a year so it seems that the author may not be coming back to complete it. I know it is marked as a work in progress, but as none of the other reviews mentioned that it was unfinished I thought that maybe the plot was more or less resolved and there would just be some epilogue to add. However, this is not the case and so beware! I hope the writer will come back to finish it, because I've got invested in the characters and plot, but currently it's not a complete story.
Read the story now