Elodie West

Overall Rating
Plot
Writing Style
Grammar Punctuation

Gripping and Original

THAT FIRST PARAGRAPH, THOUGH. I swear to beef, if there's anything that got me hooked about this story, it was that. Like, whoa. Massive kudos.

There were a few grammatical errors ["May I off you a drink" rather than "offer") but honestly, I barely noticed them. I think what I mostly noticed was the dialogue. I wasn't wholly in love with it, it was very simple. But honestly? I feel like it worked. It seemed to suit the quirky and intriguing narrative. It's not often that I read a book like this one, where I'm so completely enraptured with the idea that practically everything else sits on the back-burner.

The plot was, frankly, really neat. I want to read this whole book. So you had better win this contest so I can order it from Inkitt, holy mittens.

I feel the story also could have benefited from a bit more description. I want to know more about the opulence behind the Red Door! I want to know if there are any lacquered vases or Persian carpets or silky tapestries. If there's elaborate dark wallpaper with engraved chair rails. ... Haha, this is all what I pictured! But in the prose, I only ever saw "lavish" or "extravagant." But what? Red-glass table lamps with golden tassels? I want all the deets!

This is random, but I also have a Vi in my story. ... She is not as hot as your Vi, I'm pretty sure. Also, questions in dialogue can end with a "?" like "Were you not aware?" she asked dryly. It was a little weird that they'd be missing a lot.

EDIT: ... ... When it said "he knew what he had to do," I was NOT expecting that. Haha, this read is quite a romp. Do recommend! And good luck in the contest!

Read the story now
Top 10% in Hither Thither

About Us:

Inkitt is the world’s first reader-powered book publisher, offering an online community for talented authors and book lovers. Write captivating stories, read enchanting novels, and we’ll publish the books you love the most based on crowd wisdom.